Insider Pages Reviews for Maggiano's - Italian Catering & Restaurant

5 Stars: Great Italian Food (by by Phil Hinkle at Citysearch)

by Phil Hinkle at Citysearch — Tue, 18 May 2010 09:00:00 GMT

Being married to an Italian, we took her father. They have a new bread and he said it reminded him of the bread his grandmother made. He is 89 years old. He loved the food and the choices. Being picky about his italian food, we were not sure he would like it as much as we did. He did. He loved it. When he returns to Indy he wants to go back, even if it is a thirty minute drive thru construction traffic.

The food is great, well prepared and hot. Service is very good. Highly recommend Maggiano's.

5 Stars: Best Italian in town! (by by susan1981 at Citysearch)

by susan1981 at Citysearch — Wed, 04 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Maggianos has quickly become my favorite restaurant in town. The atmosphere is great, the food is well worth every penny - I've never had something I didn't like! We have always had great servers - very friendly and attentive without being overbearing. Try the onion strings appetizer - inexpensive, large amount and absolutely delicious!

5 Stars: We LOVE this place!!! (by Tricia H.)

Tricia H. — Sat, 23 Sep 2006 18:59:00 GMT

We love the food, service has always been great and the martini's are the best!!
Our kids are VERY picky eaters and they LOVE to go here! Portions are HUGE, so splitting one meal between 2 people gives you WAY more than enough to eat. Try the pesto ravioli!!!! And the tiramisu, you can't go wrong with anything!!!

PROS:
CONS: LONG waits without reservations.

5 Stars: Great for groups of 4 or more! (by by lindsayny at Citysearch)

by lindsayny at Citysearch — Sat, 21 Jan 2006 09:00:00 GMT

I loved going there for lunch with my family! It was $14 per/person for 2 appetizers, 2 pastas, 2 entrees, AND 2 desserts! All replenishible! Better than a buffet because it was fresh! Definitely the place to try! And I'm an Italian from the east coast!!

5 Stars: Best Italian food in Indiana (by by charlie1101 at Citysearch)

by charlie1101 at Citysearch — Mon, 29 Aug 2005 09:00:00 GMT

Being Italian and from the east coast it usually disappointing to eat Italian food in Indy. Not anymore. The pasta was wonderful, sauces were to die for and the service unbeatable. Losta fun and loatsa pasta!!!

5 Stars: We love the food (by by imsweettea at Citysearch)

by imsweettea at Citysearch — Mon, 25 Jul 2005 09:00:00 GMT

Would recommend this restaurant to anyone. We had my mother's 50th birthday party there with 12 people, we had great service, great food, and all you could eat... Reservations & Vallet parking... We orered 2 appitizers, 2 salads, 3 main courses, and 2 desserts. When the bowl emptied, they were right there to refill. This is a great place to eat...

5 Stars: Best Italian in town (by by clippincannon at Citysearch)

by clippincannon at Citysearch — Wed, 16 Mar 2005 09:00:00 GMT

I have never eaten a bad thing from this place. The food is wonderful and so is the atmosphere. It's kid friendly and affordable. Have had 1-2 poor service experiences.

5 Stars: GREAT Italian Restaurant (by by mjpfrank at Citysearch)

by mjpfrank at Citysearch — Wed, 19 Jan 2005 09:00:00 GMT

If you like Italian, this is a must-eat-at restaurant! It is the best Italian restaurant I've ever eaten at. I try to eat there at least once a month if not more. The portions are HUGE and well worth the cost.

4 Stars: Good Food, Good Service (by by redmull50 at Citysearch)

by redmull50 at Citysearch — Thu, 08 Apr 2004 09:00:00 GMT

I have been to Maggiano's in a few different cities. Atlanta, Chicago and Indy. All are good and all are worth the money. The management at the Indy location were great because at the last minute I had a very important reservation to pull together for a birthday and they helped me out. That is the above and beyond that makes a place great.