Schermerhorn's Seafood

413-533-9229

224 Westfield Rd Holyoke, MA 01040

Write A Review

Insiders:

Anna L. Lynn B. Cindy S. Claire F. Mike S.
Give us the inside scoop on Schermerhorn's Seafood
Write a review!
Kid Friendly: yes 0 no 0
Bookmark and Share Edit business

Have experience with Schermerhorn's Seafood? Write a review!

Click a star and select a rating:

Minimum required characters left: 100 (max 5000)

Title:

 cancel

Reviews for Schermerhorn's Seafood

Ratings_icons this is the best place for seafood

Anna L.

schermerhorns does have the best seafood in town most of the staff lacks personality and could use a fresher course in this department to improve theirselves

Posted 02/02/08 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons Lynn B

Lynn B. | insider_expert Insider Expert | Rank: 3,363

They have a great little business. The seafood can be eaten there or as take-out. They also have a great selection of fresh seafood to take home and prepare yourself. They also sell ice cream I especially like stopping there in the summer when on a bike ride.

Posted 01/28/08 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons Great Swordfish

Cindy S. | insider_guru Insider Guru | Rank: 298

This is a place that we visit occassionally for fresh seafood. A few months ago we bought swordfish from here. It was excellent, and the service was wonderful . They are open all the time, even late on Sundays. This is a much better choice then going to the supermarket.

Posted 11/14/07 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons Good seafood with fair service

Claire F. | insider_expert Insider Expert | Rank: 4,691

Schermerhorns Seafood is a place I like to visit for occasional seafood that is difficult to find elsewhere. Whether you are stopping by to purchase one of their fried seafood entrees at the restaurant or some fresh seafood to take home, it is a treat. It almost takes you back to the seashore as you sit by the ocean water taking in the smells of fried clams. The food is good but maybe not as good as it used to be a few years ago.
The staff gives adequate service but nothing you would write home about. They basically do their job to serve you and not anything more to make it that special service. Schermerhorns Seafood is a good place to eat for something different. Claire

Posted 11/12/07 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons The Crabs arn't only on Ice

Mike S. | insider_guru Insider Guru | Rank: 1,048

Here is a place that could be so great. It is a well established seafood restaurant and fish market. It used to be you could order a lobster dinner, and they would give you PLASTIC UTENSILS. They now give actual METAL FORKS, but charge you $2 for 'using' their lobster cracker. You get your money back if you don't steal it and run home to put it on the fireplace mantle where you display you vast collection of lobster crackers. The food is usually fine, but don't expect to EVER get a smile or thank you from the high schoolers who wait on you begrudgingly.

Posted 11/08/07 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons restaurant

Anonymous

Schermerhorns is a casual restaurant with good seafood as well as a wide variety of non seafood offerings. The prices are competitive and I've always felt I got good value here.

Posted 11/07/07 | Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

Most reviewed businesses

Schermerhorn Fish Market

3 stars
3 reviews

"My family ate at this restaurant today... I ordered the seafood platter ..."

New England Fish & Chips

4 stars
2 reviews

"When I used to work in Holyoke we would get fish and ..."