Cascarelli's Pizza

★★★★☆
  • 103 E Main St

    Homer, MI 49245

    Map & Directions
  • 517-568-3502

About Cascarelli's Pizza

Hours
Mon. - Thu. 9:30am - 10pm;Fri. - Sat. 9:30am - 11pm;Sun. 4:30pm - 9pm

Food

Food
More choices in Homer:
Resultset_next

Fritz Creek Pizza

Mi 8.2 E End Rd Homer, AK

Resultset_next

Save-U-More

3611 Greatland St Homer, AK

4.4 5
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Cascarelli's Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

Cascarelli's is an institution in the area. For those of us who have moved to other areas and states it is a must do when we get to Michigan. The pizza is the BEST I have eaten in the country. I lived on both coasts and have traveled extensively. There is one restaurant in Jupiter, FL that has a very similar product but the sauce isn't quite as good and they don't use as much cheese. Can't quite duplicate the real deal! Well worth the travel time to Homer....I sent a acquaintance from CA to Cascarelli's and he came back with rave reviews. Three generations of Cascarelli's and the establishment is still going strong. The proof is in the PIZZA!!

5
★★★★★

Cascarelli's is an institution in the area. For those of us who have moved to other areas and states it is a must do when we get to Michigan. The pizza is the BEST I have eaten in the country. I lived on both coasts and have traveled extensively. There is one restaurant in Jupiter, FL that has a very similar product but the sauce isn't quite as good and they don't use as much cheese. Can't quite duplicate the real deal! Well worth the travel time to Homer....I sent a acquaintance from CA to Cascarelli's and he came back with rave reviews. Three generations of Cascarelli's and the establishment is still going strong. The proof is in the PIZZA!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I have gone to Cascarelli's in Homer several times. The pizza is delicious and they have something for everyone. Their specialty pizzas can come with steak, (even w/bbq sauce) feta, olive oil, you name it! The pizzas are reasonably priced and worth it. They have around 16 beers on draft and offer several microbrews. Homer is a little town with nothing going on, but Cascarelli's makes it worth visiting!

4
★★★★☆

I have gone to Cascarelli's in Homer several times. The pizza is delicious and they have something for everyone. Their specialty pizzas can come with steak, (even w/bbq sauce) feta, olive oil, you name it! The pizzas are reasonably priced and worth it. They have around 16 beers on draft and offer several microbrews. Homer is a little town with nothing going on, but Cascarelli's makes it worth visiting!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I was introduced to Cascarelli's by our friends a few years ago. Homer is little town a driving distance from everywhere. It's about 90 minutes for us.

But Cascarelli's is worth it. The pizza is one of the best I've ever had ... and I've had a lot ... ask my waistline and my wife. Thin crunchy crust, delicious sauce and any topping you can think of. Combos are interesting and you can create your own.

The last time we went with another couple, we each got a small with different toppings and shared. Got a bottle of wine and had a great time. That was their first visit and they loved it. We're planning to introduce another couple to this place next week.

Wine list is short but pretty good. And the beer selection is great.

The previous reviewer sited the atmosphere - there isn't much. and that the pizza being no better than Pizza. (I happen to like Pizza Hut thin crust). Got that wrong, too. Everyone's entitled to an opinion but it makes me wonder if that reviewer even went to Cascarelli's.

If want a straight forward tavern in a small town and Pizza that won't disappoint, go to Cascarelli's. Just be prepared for a long drive.

5
★★★★★

I was introduced to Cascarelli's by our friends a few years ago. Homer is little town a driving distance from everywhere. It's about 90 minutes for us.

But Cascarelli's is worth it. The pizza is one of the best I've ever had ... and I've had a lot ... ask my waistline and my wife. Thin crunchy crust, delicious sauce and any topping you can think of. Combos are interesting and you can create your own.

The last time we went with another couple, we each got a small with different toppings and shared. Got a bottle of wine and had a great time. That was their first visit and they loved it. We're planning to introduce another couple to this place next week.

Wine list is short but pretty good. And the beer selection is great.

The previous reviewer sited the atmosphere - there isn't much. and that the pizza being no better than Pizza. (I happen to like Pizza Hut thin crust). Got that wrong, too. Everyone's entitled to an opinion but it makes me wonder if that reviewer even went to Cascarelli's.

If want a straight forward tavern in a small town and Pizza that won't disappoint, go to Cascarelli's. Just be prepared for a long drive.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Cascarelli's of Homer is good pizza, but not THE BEST around. it's very expensive, and your basically paying for the atmosphere, not the quality of pizza. If your looking for good pizza, save your money and just go to Pizza Hut.

3
★★★☆☆

Cascarelli's of Homer is good pizza, but not THE BEST around. it's very expensive, and your basically paying for the atmosphere, not the quality of pizza. If your looking for good pizza, save your money and just go to Pizza Hut.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

during my time in the area, I found this place to be a hidden gem. An excellent beer selection and the best pizzas in the area. I used to go here both on dates and with friends. Weekends are always filled with families too.

2
★★★★★

during my time in the area, I found this place to be a hidden gem. An excellent beer selection and the best pizzas in the area. I used to go here both on dates and with friends. Weekends are always filled with families too.

Pros: Great Pizza, Good Beer, Nice atmosphere

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Cascarelli's Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review