I have only ever gotten pizza by the slice usually between classes or after the bar, but the pizza has always been okay and the slices are large. I like the white pizza or the spinach and mushroom, but neither of which are anything to write home about. Beware of the after bar rush though because the place will get packed and you could end up waiting a while for your pie.
Having been to New York and indulged in their wonderful thin-crusted pizza, New York Pizza Depot is the closest your going to get to New York style pizza in the Mid-west. I don't know if they import their water from New York, but I sure can not tell the difference between them and Ray's in New York. Great selection of toppings (love the mushroom variety toppings) and great sandwhiches.
Pros: Wonderful New York style pizza, diverse toppings
NYPD is my favorite eattery in Michigan. Don't be fooled by the casual ambiance. If you are watching carbs, you should know that their pizza crust is paper thin. I also think they make the best salads in town because they are huge and have tons of stuff in them. I had a hot sandwich there last time that was loaded up with chicken, sauce and cheese. it was great too! they also just expanded, so that means more room to sit and eat.
Pros: fresh, delicious, wide vaiety
Born and raised in New York, I have found many pizza places in Michigan that look like New York Pizza, but none that tase like it. NYPD looks and taste like authentic New York Pizza. Not only do they have a plain cheese slice, but also have BBQ Chicken and other types. I usully just ask what is fresh out of the oven. Last where can you find a Pizza place open to 4:00 am outside of Chicago or New York. NYPD is worth the drive.
Pros: Cheap Eats, Super Tasty
Cons: No Parking