N.Y. Pizza- Harrison Square

★★★★★
Since 1991, four North Carolina locations serve New York-style pizza made with fresh ingredients. Catering also available.
  • 1831 N Harrison Ave

    Cary, NC 27513

    Map & Directions
  • 919-439-8099

About N.Y. Pizza- Harrison Square

Hours
Mon-Sat 11am-9pm Sun 12pm-8pm

Food

Food
More choices in Cary:
Resultset_next

Georgio's Chicago Pizzeria

75 E Woodstock St Crystal Lake, IA

Resultset_next

Di Piero's Restaurant

17 E Main St Lake Zurich, IL

4.7407 27
Hi! Sign in to let us know how N.Y. Pizza- Harrison Square was?
Write a Review
.

Worst pizza, wings and cheese sticks I have ever ordered. All of the above was burnt and I will never order here again!

3
★★★★★

Worst pizza, wings and cheese sticks I have ever ordered. All of the above was burnt and I will never order here again!

.

Stopped by here on a rainy day after shopping at Carolina Pottery. Getting drenched was worth it. This is the best pizza I've had since leaving Baltimore 6 months ago. The young man at the counter was courteous, the slice was huge, and

3
★★★★★

Stopped by here on a rainy day after shopping at Carolina Pottery. Getting drenched was worth it. This is the best pizza I've had since leaving Baltimore 6 months ago. The young man at the counter was courteous, the slice was huge, and

.

I think you got us confused with one of our copycat competitors, we were never opened till 11:00pm, we never delivered downtown Raleigh and we are definitely still the same family that started this business, furthermore none of my Managers

3
★★★★★

I think you got us confused with one of our copycat competitors, we were never opened till 11:00pm, we never delivered downtown Raleigh and we are definitely still the same family that started this business, furthermore none of my Managers

.

called for a delivery at 8:30, told me they closed at 9, when they were family owned they were open till 11 every night and they would deliver to downtown Raleigh. Wow! Not anymore!! I offered the driver $20 tip to cruise down 540 to

3
★★★★★

called for a delivery at 8:30, told me they closed at 9, when they were family owned they were open till 11 every night and they would deliver to downtown Raleigh. Wow! Not anymore!! I offered the driver $20 tip to cruise down 540 to

.

I am from NY. Hands down, the best pizza since home. Yes, there are teenie boppers working. They do give excellent customer serivce and are very funny. Thank you and I can't wait to get more punches in my card for a free pie

2
★★★★★

I am from NY. Hands down, the best pizza since home. Yes, there are teenie boppers working. They do give excellent customer serivce and are very funny. Thank you and I can't wait to get more punches in my card for a free pie

.

Good pizza, although not as good as their competitor's, Randy's Pizza.

The main issue with this location, as it has been for years, is it is very poorly managed. Whoever the owner/manager is, must really enjoy seeing immature kids act completely unprofessional, chewing gum, using cell phones, being rude and basically half paying attention to customers both when you call in an order or, there, in person. They botched two pizza orders for us, back to back.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Good pizza, although not as good as their competitor's, Randy's Pizza.

The main issue with this location, as it has been for years, is it is very poorly managed. Whoever the owner/manager is, must really enjoy seeing immature kids act completely unprofessional, chewing gum, using cell phones, being rude and basically half paying attention to customers both when you call in an order or, there, in person. They botched two pizza orders for us, back to back.

.

I just ordered some calzones and stromboli and when they got here they were really tiny. I called and the manager on duty was awesome and very pleasant. He took care of me and made me feel better and actually changed my view and I will go back again. Overall I now look forward to my next experience.

2
★★★★☆

I just ordered some calzones and stromboli and when they got here they were really tiny. I called and the manager on duty was awesome and very pleasant. He took care of me and made me feel better and actually changed my view and I will go back again. Overall I now look forward to my next experience.

Pros: Management is Spectacular!!!

Cons: Sizes are small

.

Can't put my finger on it
the cheese taste better,the sauce taste better, the crust better, My family loves it. worth the trip.

2
★★★★★

Can't put my finger on it
the cheese taste better,the sauce taste better, the crust better, My family loves it. worth the trip.

Pros: quality, taste,value and authentic taste

Cons: none

.

It does remind me of good New York pizza. Thin crust, dripping good cheese. Their lunch special is reasonable. I remember once stopping by after a late softball game. Even late, those guys were hustling. I must not be the only one who think of their slices late at night.

4
★★★★☆

It does remind me of good New York pizza. Thin crust, dripping good cheese. Their lunch special is reasonable. I remember once stopping by after a late softball game. Even late, those guys were hustling. I must not be the only one who think of their slices late at night.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I was born and raised in NY and have been in NC for 13 years now. This is the best Pizza I've had outside of NY and definitely the best I've had in NC. We searched for years to find a good pizza place and have settled on NY Pizza. We will occasionally stray and try somewhere else and are always disappointed. During my 13 years here I've been a "regular" at three of the four location (we've moved around the area a few times) and have eaten at all four. They are all very good.

Not every pizza is perfect but even a bad pie from here is better than a good pie from other places.

2
★★★★★

I was born and raised in NY and have been in NC for 13 years now. This is the best Pizza I've had outside of NY and definitely the best I've had in NC. We searched for years to find a good pizza place and have settled on NY Pizza. We will occasionally stray and try somewhere else and are always disappointed. During my 13 years here I've been a "regular" at three of the four location (we've moved around the area a few times) and have eaten at all four. They are all very good.

Not every pizza is perfect but even a bad pie from here is better than a good pie from other places.

Pros: EXCELLENT Pizza. reminds me of the places I ate when I was a kid

.

Awesome Pizza! What a refreshing find! A real pizza shop that delivers. Having grown weary of the chain pizza restaurants, I was beginning tht there was no place to get quality pizza in Cary. I happened upon this place and gave it a try. It is fantastic. Genuine fresh ingredients, VERY reasonable prices and home delivery are exactly what they have. All of the items on their menu are excellent. Delivery times can get a bit long at the dinner hour, but knowing that ahead of time, you can order a bit earlier. The staff is generally courteous and pleasant as I have only had one bad encounter with them when trying to phone in an order. They take pride in their quality. I had a burnt pizza delivered one time and the manager was more than accomodating to make it right. If you want a true NY style pizza, this is your only choice in Cary!

2
★★★★★

Awesome Pizza! What a refreshing find! A real pizza shop that delivers. Having grown weary of the chain pizza restaurants, I was beginning tht there was no place to get quality pizza in Cary. I happened upon this place and gave it a try. It is fantastic. Genuine fresh ingredients, VERY reasonable prices and home delivery are exactly what they have. All of the items on their menu are excellent. Delivery times can get a bit long at the dinner hour, but knowing that ahead of time, you can order a bit earlier. The staff is generally courteous and pleasant as I have only had one bad encounter with them when trying to phone in an order. They take pride in their quality. I had a burnt pizza delivered one time and the manager was more than accomodating to make it right. If you want a true NY style pizza, this is your only choice in Cary!

Pros: Authentic NY Pizza, fresh ingredients, high quality, reasonable prices

Cons: sometimes the delivery times are excessive

.

For those who are from NY and looking for pizzas that tastes like those in NY then you should go to NY Pizza. You will not regret it. Highly highly recommeded for the EASt Coast people.

4
★★★★☆

For those who are from NY and looking for pizzas that tastes like those in NY then you should go to NY Pizza. You will not regret it. Highly highly recommeded for the EASt Coast people.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This is simply GREAT pizza. I've lived in NC all my life, I have no idea how NY pizza should taste, but I do know how THIS pizza tastes and it's simply fabulous. In addition, the folks there help my Boy Scout troop twice a year with excellent discounts when we need to feed a lot of hungry boys in a hurry! I cannot speak highly enough about their excellent pizza and community service back to us. Really a great place. Please give them a try. Five stars is all I could give, but more are appropriate.

2
★★★★★

This is simply GREAT pizza. I've lived in NC all my life, I have no idea how NY pizza should taste, but I do know how THIS pizza tastes and it's simply fabulous. In addition, the folks there help my Boy Scout troop twice a year with excellent discounts when we need to feed a lot of hungry boys in a hurry! I cannot speak highly enough about their excellent pizza and community service back to us. Really a great place. Please give them a try. Five stars is all I could give, but more are appropriate.

Pros: GREAT PIZZA

Cons: None

.

Moved from Long Island to Fuquay-Varina a few months back.Looking for anything similiar to ny pizza down here. Found it!!!!! Holly Springs Crossings The Original N.Y. Pizza on Holly Springs Rd.Run don't walk hands down this is exactly like the pizza from up North.We had pepperoni(excellent) Mushroom(to die for) and plain cheese pizza all delicious.We also had bread sticks with melted mozzarella and a great dipping marinara sauce.So if you're from anywhere up North and know what great pizza should taste like you'll find it at The Original New York Pizza.Go and try it you won't be disappointed.We won't go anywhere else because we've found the best ... give it a try.

2
★★★★★

Moved from Long Island to Fuquay-Varina a few months back.Looking for anything similiar to ny pizza down here. Found it!!!!! Holly Springs Crossings The Original N.Y. Pizza on Holly Springs Rd.Run don't walk hands down this is exactly like the pizza from up North.We had pepperoni(excellent) Mushroom(to die for) and plain cheese pizza all delicious.We also had bread sticks with melted mozzarella and a great dipping marinara sauce.So if you're from anywhere up North and know what great pizza should taste like you'll find it at The Original New York Pizza.Go and try it you won't be disappointed.We won't go anywhere else because we've found the best ... give it a try.

Pros: great ny style pizza,plenty of parking

Cons: none

.

Best Pizza in the triangle.
I've searched high and low for great "N.Y. Style" Pizza in Raleigh and surrounding areas and so far there aren't many places that come close to the quality pies that NY Pizza makes. The crust is thin but thicker Sicilian crust pies are available as well. The atmosphere is nice and friendly. Every thing about this place screams NY, from the pictures of the twin towers to the Yankees, NY Pizza sets the tone fore a great dinning experience.

2
★★★★★

Best Pizza in the triangle.
I've searched high and low for great "N.Y. Style" Pizza in Raleigh and surrounding areas and so far there aren't many places that come close to the quality pies that NY Pizza makes. The crust is thin but thicker Sicilian crust pies are available as well. The atmosphere is nice and friendly. Every thing about this place screams NY, from the pictures of the twin towers to the Yankees, NY Pizza sets the tone fore a great dinning experience.

.

The pizza was mediocre at best. No way is this NY pizza or a NY pizzeria atmosphere. First of all the dough is so very thin as plastic like, over cooked! Where are the specialty pies on display? Eggplant parm, buffalo chicken pizza, salad pizza, Marsala? How can you call this NY pizza when not one person in the place is Italian or speak Italian? Prices....1.99 for a slice of pizza? The most I have ever paid in NY was 1.75. This was a first and last time at this place. No good no good.

1
★★★☆☆

The pizza was mediocre at best. No way is this NY pizza or a NY pizzeria atmosphere. First of all the dough is so very thin as plastic like, over cooked! Where are the specialty pies on display? Eggplant parm, buffalo chicken pizza, salad pizza, Marsala? How can you call this NY pizza when not one person in the place is Italian or speak Italian? Prices....1.99 for a slice of pizza? The most I have ever paid in NY was 1.75. This was a first and last time at this place. No good no good.

Pros: Speeding service. They had good table condiments. Garlic, oregano, hot pepper etc.

Cons: Pizza is supposed to be the breadwinner of a pizza business. Not good pizza.

.

If I can eat only one place in town, it would be NY Pizza.

These guys make the BEST pizza in town.

We don't even compare NY Pizza to other pizza places. My family made a top 10 list of our favorite restaurants. Each of us wrote our list. We all had places like Simpson's, Bloomsbury Bistro, and Nofo on the list, but right at the top of each list was NY Pizza.

If you're judging a restaurant on nothing but the quality and taste of the food, NY Pizza wins.

2
★★★★★

If I can eat only one place in town, it would be NY Pizza.

These guys make the BEST pizza in town.

We don't even compare NY Pizza to other pizza places. My family made a top 10 list of our favorite restaurants. Each of us wrote our list. We all had places like Simpson's, Bloomsbury Bistro, and Nofo on the list, but right at the top of each list was NY Pizza.

If you're judging a restaurant on nothing but the quality and taste of the food, NY Pizza wins.

Pros: Great food.

.

This is te best pizza in Raleigh. I'm from NJ, and true NY style pizza is impossible to find in other areas. This is the only place in Raleigh that has it right on the money! I'm truly impressed. there is no reason to eat pizza anywhere else.

2
★★★★★

This is te best pizza in Raleigh. I'm from NJ, and true NY style pizza is impossible to find in other areas. This is the only place in Raleigh that has it right on the money! I'm truly impressed. there is no reason to eat pizza anywhere else.

Pros: Just like NY/NJ, great price

.

Best NY style pizza in Cary. Great pizza for take out, however if you're looking for a dining experience, this place doesn't offer much beyond great pizza.

2
★★★★★

Best NY style pizza in Cary. Great pizza for take out, however if you're looking for a dining experience, this place doesn't offer much beyond great pizza.

.

Excellent crust, tasty sauce, perfect amount of fresh mozarella cheese. Just as good as getting a slice in NY

2
★★★★★

Excellent crust, tasty sauce, perfect amount of fresh mozarella cheese. Just as good as getting a slice in NY

.

New York pizza offers terrific queens/brooklyn style pizza with a crust that is neither too thick or thin and always done to perfection - their calzones are pretty good too

2
★★★★★

New York pizza offers terrific queens/brooklyn style pizza with a crust that is neither too thick or thin and always done to perfection - their calzones are pretty good too

.

I have lived in the south for many, many years now -- but have never fogotten the pizza of my childhood. I have never found a place down here that made pizza as I remembered it -- until I ate at New York Pizza. This place is the best (and, please, don't compare it to Lilly's Pizza -- they're two entirely different styles!). Always friendly service, but, more importantly -- the greatest pizza around!

2
★★★★★

I have lived in the south for many, many years now -- but have never fogotten the pizza of my childhood. I have never found a place down here that made pizza as I remembered it -- until I ate at New York Pizza. This place is the best (and, please, don't compare it to Lilly's Pizza -- they're two entirely different styles!). Always friendly service, but, more importantly -- the greatest pizza around!

.

Really good pizza! Better than Lilly's! Fast friendy service. Don't be dumb, get you some.

2
★★★★☆

Really good pizza! Better than Lilly's! Fast friendy service. Don't be dumb, get you some.

.

Great Sicilian Pizza- thick delicous crust, with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The big round thin crust pies are probably just above average, although the fresh crust is very good. The best pizza I've found in Cary in the 7 years I've been here. Having moved from a town in the Northeast where there are a lot of great Italian restaurants and pizza joints, it was great to find NY Pizza! The owners of other pizza restaurants in the Triangle need to stop by NY Pizza to find out how to do it right.
Great for take out, as the ambience is typical storee-front pizza store. Easy to find from anywhere in the triangle, just off I-40, the Harrison Ave. exit.

2
★★★★★

Great Sicilian Pizza- thick delicous crust, with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The big round thin crust pies are probably just above average, although the fresh crust is very good. The best pizza I've found in Cary in the 7 years I've been here. Having moved from a town in the Northeast where there are a lot of great Italian restaurants and pizza joints, it was great to find NY Pizza! The owners of other pizza restaurants in the Triangle need to stop by NY Pizza to find out how to do it right.
Great for take out, as the ambience is typical storee-front pizza store. Easy to find from anywhere in the triangle, just off I-40, the Harrison Ave. exit.

Pros: best sicilain pizza, convenient to I-40

.

I haven't had pizza this good since I was in NY. I love this place!!!!

2
★★★★★

I haven't had pizza this good since I was in NY. I love this place!!!!

.

For the best old fashioned NY style pizza, this is the place. I moved to the Triangle from the NY/NJ area last year and this pizza is just like pizza from home.

2
★★★★☆

For the best old fashioned NY style pizza, this is the place. I moved to the Triangle from the NY/NJ area last year and this pizza is just like pizza from home.

.

This pizza is just as good as the pizza you would find in New York City (hence the name, I guess). My entire family is hooked on this pizza--and they are from the North East. I don't live in Cary any longer, but always make it a point to stop by and eat a slice (or the whole pie) when I'm in town.
DON'T MISS THIS PIZZA!

2
★★★★★

This pizza is just as good as the pizza you would find in New York City (hence the name, I guess). My entire family is hooked on this pizza--and they are from the North East. I don't live in Cary any longer, but always make it a point to stop by and eat a slice (or the whole pie) when I'm in town.
DON'T MISS THIS PIZZA!

Pros: Price, Taste, Quality

Cons: Closed Sunday

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used N.Y. Pizza- Harrison Square, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review