Four Square Restaurant

★★★★☆
  • 2701 Chapel Hill Rd

    Durham, NC 27707

    Map & Directions
  • 919-401-9877

Food

Food
More choices in Durham:
Resultset_next

Country Waffles

690 Rio Lindo Ave Chico, CA

Resultset_next

Denny's

675 Manzanita Ct Chico, CA

3.9375 32
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Four Square Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

four square needs to have the same camera system that one restaurant has (streams the kitchen activities to the bar for the guests). maybe then every chef in kitchen, including the chef de cuisine, will wash their hands every so often. the food was good but, how safe was it? if the food was all i cared about, sure, it was great. but the thing is, i was ServSafe certified and washing hands when handling food is a must. I mean, seriously, who cares these days if their food is clean if it's good...

1
★★★☆☆

four square needs to have the same camera system that one restaurant has (streams the kitchen activities to the bar for the guests). maybe then every chef in kitchen, including the chef de cuisine, will wash their hands every so often. the food was good but, how safe was it? if the food was all i cared about, sure, it was great. but the thing is, i was ServSafe certified and washing hands when handling food is a must. I mean, seriously, who cares these days if their food is clean if it's good...

.

Chef Ingram is a complete jerk to work for... food is okay but it is over priced. Chef ingram has the biggest ego trip out of any chef i have ever worked with

1
★★☆☆☆

Chef Ingram is a complete jerk to work for... food is okay but it is over priced. Chef ingram has the biggest ego trip out of any chef i have ever worked with

.

I'm a vegetarian and my husband is not (far from it) - so finding a restaurant that we both really love for a nice dinner isn't always easy. We've been to Four Square twice just the two of us - and we liked it so much that we went with our family to celebrate a birthday.
Highly recommended!

2
★★★★★

I'm a vegetarian and my husband is not (far from it) - so finding a restaurant that we both really love for a nice dinner isn't always easy. We've been to Four Square twice just the two of us - and we liked it so much that we went with our family to celebrate a birthday.
Highly recommended!

Pros: Creative, delicious dinners

.

We went to Four Square because it had good ratings so I am writing this to provide you with some balance. Four Square is at most a four star restaurant. The service was very good but the food was just OK. Our dinner was not a good value when comparing it to the many other triangle area restaurants we can choose from. I liked the house's historical features, its structure, and its openness in most places except the bar. If your a man, you may get a brief scare when you discover that your bathroom is the one with pink walls and 2 sit-down type toilets :) Like the bathroom, the artwork hanging on the walls clashes with its location. Thinking about it, Four Square restaurant is an odd mixture of trendy food, misplaced art, and historical house.

1
★★★☆☆

We went to Four Square because it had good ratings so I am writing this to provide you with some balance. Four Square is at most a four star restaurant. The service was very good but the food was just OK. Our dinner was not a good value when comparing it to the many other triangle area restaurants we can choose from. I liked the house's historical features, its structure, and its openness in most places except the bar. If your a man, you may get a brief scare when you discover that your bathroom is the one with pink walls and 2 sit-down type toilets :) Like the bathroom, the artwork hanging on the walls clashes with its location. Thinking about it, Four Square restaurant is an odd mixture of trendy food, misplaced art, and historical house.

Pros: service

Cons: value

.

A wonderful old house is the setting, terrific service.

Shane Ingram and Elizabeth Woodhouse (the owners) are real pros.

The menu changes every month. Near Duke University.

Very highly recommended.

2
★★★★★

A wonderful old house is the setting, terrific service.

Shane Ingram and Elizabeth Woodhouse (the owners) are real pros.

The menu changes every month. Near Duke University.

Very highly recommended.

Pros: Outstanding food - some unusual and interesting entrees

Cons: None

.

For Triangle Restaurant Week in Durham, participating restaurants offer a 3-course meal for $25 with a set menu. Last week, my friends and I downloaded about 10-15 menus from different restaurants around the area, finally settling on Four Square's menu because it sounded the most appealing. We had heard great things about Four Square, and we went ahead and made a reservation.

This afternoon, out of curiosity, we looked at the menu again. The one from last week was now gone, replaced by a not-so-appealing menu with fewer choices. When I called the restaurant, the man who answered the phone said that the menu "may have changed," and that "the chef may have put together something for advertisement purposes." What is the point of "putting together a menu" if you won't even stick to it? The reason we chose the restaurant was because of the menu!

However, all in all, we had a great experience, and the food is really good. Service is excellent.

1
★★★☆☆

For Triangle Restaurant Week in Durham, participating restaurants offer a 3-course meal for $25 with a set menu. Last week, my friends and I downloaded about 10-15 menus from different restaurants around the area, finally settling on Four Square's menu because it sounded the most appealing. We had heard great things about Four Square, and we went ahead and made a reservation.

This afternoon, out of curiosity, we looked at the menu again. The one from last week was now gone, replaced by a not-so-appealing menu with fewer choices. When I called the restaurant, the man who answered the phone said that the menu "may have changed," and that "the chef may have put together something for advertisement purposes." What is the point of "putting together a menu" if you won't even stick to it? The reason we chose the restaurant was because of the menu!

However, all in all, we had a great experience, and the food is really good. Service is excellent.

.

I don't mind dropping money on a fabulous meal. I've dined in some of the better restaurants in NYC, Atlanta, Boston and Chicago and have no problem spending double per person what you will at this restaurant. My opinion is that there are better places to go in the Triangle with a similar price tag.

Bonne Soiree in Chapel Hill, in particular (they will pair courses with different wines per your request). The food here also shows a strong French influence, but it simpler and better executed.

I think Nana's has equally good food to Four Square, if a little less creative. But the atmosphere at Nana's is twice as enjoyable, and the staff more friendly and accommodating.

1
★★★☆☆

I don't mind dropping money on a fabulous meal. I've dined in some of the better restaurants in NYC, Atlanta, Boston and Chicago and have no problem spending double per person what you will at this restaurant. My opinion is that there are better places to go in the Triangle with a similar price tag.

Bonne Soiree in Chapel Hill, in particular (they will pair courses with different wines per your request). The food here also shows a strong French influence, but it simpler and better executed.

I think Nana's has equally good food to Four Square, if a little less creative. But the atmosphere at Nana's is twice as enjoyable, and the staff more friendly and accommodating.

Pros: Good food

Cons: Not worth the money.

.

I had my rehearsal dinner there in 2004, and we've been back every year for our anniversary dinner. Definitely a "special occasion" place for most budgets, but if you have the need, this is definitely the place to make the occasion special! I've never *repeat never* had a meal I didn't like. The menu is always changing, so you can't get bored. If you need a spot for a large group, you also can't go wrong. The menu was great, and everyone was very impressed with the food and atmosphere. The house is gorgeous, too. Be sure to save room for dessert! You won't regret it.

5
★★★★★

I had my rehearsal dinner there in 2004, and we've been back every year for our anniversary dinner. Definitely a "special occasion" place for most budgets, but if you have the need, this is definitely the place to make the occasion special! I've never *repeat never* had a meal I didn't like. The menu is always changing, so you can't get bored. If you need a spot for a large group, you also can't go wrong. The menu was great, and everyone was very impressed with the food and atmosphere. The house is gorgeous, too. Be sure to save room for dessert! You won't regret it.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This is expensive, but it's worth it for a special occasion such a b-day, anniversary, graduation, etc. They have great service and the food is outstanding.

4
★★★★☆

This is expensive, but it's worth it for a special occasion such a b-day, anniversary, graduation, etc. They have great service and the food is outstanding.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

yes, the location is weird BUT it is in a beautiful Victorian house on chapel hill rd. It has to be the best kept secret of durham. I have been to NaNa's which was voted one of the top restaurants in the nation BUT I have to say FOUR SQUARE is better. The only reason it may not be NANA'S is because of the location alone. The food and wait staff is so excellent that if you give it a chance, you WILL want to come back and you forget about the location. For the first course, I has a sweet potato bisqet which was recommended by the staff, For the entree I had the lamb.. the meat was SOOOOOOOOOO tender , the greens that came with was better than my moms seasoned greens ( mind you im a born & raised country boy) and the presentation!!!!- you can tell the chef loves his job. My babes had the pork loin- delicious.. then to end I had the chocolate cake and my babes had the cheesecake. SO THE PLEASANT SURPRISE WAS.. me and my baby been together 2 years and it was our two year anniversary...so when they brought out the dessert they wrote HAPPY ANNIVERSARY in chocolate on my plate. This is important to me because every wait staff that came through were genuine and got to know us- and did I tell you we were a gay couple... didnt bother the wait staff one bit. I need not tell you I gave the waiter an excellent tip.. kinda wish I gave him more.
they change their menu every month, so me and babes going back for my birthday this month.. I m so looking forward to it... I'll NEVER forget FOUR SQUARE! if you are looking for a nice 4 star to take a love one or a business dinner LOOK NO FURTHER! I can honestly say It's worth the money.

2
★★★★★

yes, the location is weird BUT it is in a beautiful Victorian house on chapel hill rd. It has to be the best kept secret of durham. I have been to NaNa's which was voted one of the top restaurants in the nation BUT I have to say FOUR SQUARE is better. The only reason it may not be NANA'S is because of the location alone. The food and wait staff is so excellent that if you give it a chance, you WILL want to come back and you forget about the location. For the first course, I has a sweet potato bisqet which was recommended by the staff, For the entree I had the lamb.. the meat was SOOOOOOOOOO tender , the greens that came with was better than my moms seasoned greens ( mind you im a born & raised country boy) and the presentation!!!!- you can tell the chef loves his job. My babes had the pork loin- delicious.. then to end I had the chocolate cake and my babes had the cheesecake. SO THE PLEASANT SURPRISE WAS.. me and my baby been together 2 years and it was our two year anniversary...so when they brought out the dessert they wrote HAPPY ANNIVERSARY in chocolate on my plate. This is important to me because every wait staff that came through were genuine and got to know us- and did I tell you we were a gay couple... didnt bother the wait staff one bit. I need not tell you I gave the waiter an excellent tip.. kinda wish I gave him more.
they change their menu every month, so me and babes going back for my birthday this month.. I m so looking forward to it... I'll NEVER forget FOUR SQUARE! if you are looking for a nice 4 star to take a love one or a business dinner LOOK NO FURTHER! I can honestly say It's worth the money.

Pros: FOOD! FOOD! FOOD!

Cons: nothing to look at out the window, after service & food that will not matter!

.

There is NO such thing as a bad meal at Four Square. Having been there well over three times, it's never ever disappointed me. Set in a converted Victorian House, each meal at Four Square is always a delight. With a rotating menu that changes monthly, make sure to take a risk with at least one of your courses--I guarantee it will be the highlight of a truly special dinner.

5
★★★★★

There is NO such thing as a bad meal at Four Square. Having been there well over three times, it's never ever disappointed me. Set in a converted Victorian House, each meal at Four Square is always a delight. With a rotating menu that changes monthly, make sure to take a risk with at least one of your courses--I guarantee it will be the highlight of a truly special dinner.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The food itself was actually very good and nicely presented. That's the good news.

Location is actually quite sketchy, if you eventually find it. Passed through a few "kids lock the doors" type neighborhoods to get there. Nice view of the giant plastic cow on top of the Mexican joint across the street.

Student/waiters didn't seem to want to be there. But to be fair, the place was packed, so it's apparently pretty popular by Durham standards.

If you are looking for a lovely dinner in an old Victorian home in this price range, stick with Second Empire. I know I will.

1
★★☆☆☆

The food itself was actually very good and nicely presented. That's the good news.

Location is actually quite sketchy, if you eventually find it. Passed through a few "kids lock the doors" type neighborhoods to get there. Nice view of the giant plastic cow on top of the Mexican joint across the street.

Student/waiters didn't seem to want to be there. But to be fair, the place was packed, so it's apparently pretty popular by Durham standards.

If you are looking for a lovely dinner in an old Victorian home in this price range, stick with Second Empire. I know I will.

.

Hands down, the best meal I have eaten since I moved to the area. Nice atmosphere; polite, attentive service. Portions were perfectly sized and every item fresh and well-seasoned. Stay for dessert - banana & coconut bombe was amazing!

2
★★★★★

Hands down, the best meal I have eaten since I moved to the area. Nice atmosphere; polite, attentive service. Portions were perfectly sized and every item fresh and well-seasoned. Stay for dessert - banana & coconut bombe was amazing!

Pros: food, atmosphere, wine, service

Cons: none

.

Really good experience overall. The restaurant is in a lovely Victorian house on the outskirts of Durham. The inside has a lived-in feel that is very relaxing. Service was good -- attentive but not overbearing. The food was very good. Interesting but not overly fussy. Portion sizes were just about right. We arrived at 9.30 and they could not have been more accomodating. The wine list was good but the wines were too young. We had a 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon from Western Australia and an 05 or 04 Ridge Zinfandel with high levels of alcohol that were a bit overwhelming. Overall though it was a very positive experience and the food was very good.

2
★★★★★

Really good experience overall. The restaurant is in a lovely Victorian house on the outskirts of Durham. The inside has a lived-in feel that is very relaxing. Service was good -- attentive but not overbearing. The food was very good. Interesting but not overly fussy. Portion sizes were just about right. We arrived at 9.30 and they could not have been more accomodating. The wine list was good but the wines were too young. We had a 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon from Western Australia and an 05 or 04 Ridge Zinfandel with high levels of alcohol that were a bit overwhelming. Overall though it was a very positive experience and the food was very good.

Pros: Nice atmosphere, good service, good food

Cons: young wines

.

This is arguably one of the finest restuarants in the Triangle. The service is always professional and attentive, and the wine list is quite extensive and offered at a reasonable price. While the cost is a bit high, it is worth every cent if you appreciate fine food and excellent cooking. The chef is inventive and there is a new menu every month. Do try Four Square for a special occasion, you won't be disappointed!

2
★★★★★

This is arguably one of the finest restuarants in the Triangle. The service is always professional and attentive, and the wine list is quite extensive and offered at a reasonable price. While the cost is a bit high, it is worth every cent if you appreciate fine food and excellent cooking. The chef is inventive and there is a new menu every month. Do try Four Square for a special occasion, you won't be disappointed!

Pros: Fine food, great service, beautiful old building

Cons: None

.

We went to Four Square to try out their Thanksgiving Prix Fixe menu. It is housed in a historic Victorian in Durham, with an inviting porch and warm lighting glinting from the windows. We started out in the bar, where I had an underwhelming Sangriatini. The bar was cozy though lacking music, and its brown walls are luscious enough to make me reconsider completely writing off the ugly brown paint on the walls of our bathroom at home.

For the dinner, we were led to a small chilly room that would have been improved had a fire been lit in the fireplace. The walls were sparsely decorated and the house definitely shows some wear and tear, especially in the restroom.

Bread service was by the slice, which is helpful for people like us who are trying to control our portions. Their home-baked sourdough was quite good and that?s coming from a California snob.

My husband and I shared a frisee and baby red onion salad and a seafood crepe for the first course. The crepe was groovy on my palate and the salad was pleasant as well.

For the main course, my husband went traditional and chose the turkey offering. The sugar peas were not completely cooked and as a result, tasted bland. The turkey and mashed potatoes were good but nothing exceptional. I had the duck confit with expertly prepared brussel sprouts, a sweet berry sauce, and stuffing of Stove Top caliber, which is high praise from me.

For dessert, I had the Bourbon Pecan Pie. I couldn?t taste any bourbon but it was tasty and the piecrust was to die for. My husband?s Rum Raisin Bread Pudding was more like a muffin. It had a great chocolaty flavor but both rum and raisin were missing as far as we could tell.

A satisfying meal but we aren?t necessarily coming back again.

1
★★★☆☆

We went to Four Square to try out their Thanksgiving Prix Fixe menu. It is housed in a historic Victorian in Durham, with an inviting porch and warm lighting glinting from the windows. We started out in the bar, where I had an underwhelming Sangriatini. The bar was cozy though lacking music, and its brown walls are luscious enough to make me reconsider completely writing off the ugly brown paint on the walls of our bathroom at home.

For the dinner, we were led to a small chilly room that would have been improved had a fire been lit in the fireplace. The walls were sparsely decorated and the house definitely shows some wear and tear, especially in the restroom.

Bread service was by the slice, which is helpful for people like us who are trying to control our portions. Their home-baked sourdough was quite good and that?s coming from a California snob.

My husband and I shared a frisee and baby red onion salad and a seafood crepe for the first course. The crepe was groovy on my palate and the salad was pleasant as well.

For the main course, my husband went traditional and chose the turkey offering. The sugar peas were not completely cooked and as a result, tasted bland. The turkey and mashed potatoes were good but nothing exceptional. I had the duck confit with expertly prepared brussel sprouts, a sweet berry sauce, and stuffing of Stove Top caliber, which is high praise from me.

For dessert, I had the Bourbon Pecan Pie. I couldn?t taste any bourbon but it was tasty and the piecrust was to die for. My husband?s Rum Raisin Bread Pudding was more like a muffin. It had a great chocolaty flavor but both rum and raisin were missing as far as we could tell.

A satisfying meal but we aren?t necessarily coming back again.

Pros: Plenty of parking, nice price for a prix fixe meal

Cons: The house and menu needs some updating.

.

I wish I had read this before I visited this restaurant. We decided to try it after seeing a profile on a UNC program. All of the negative things outlined here- cold interior, unappealling exterior, costly "interesting" food and unbelievably slow, snobbish service. I did not particularly care for the food. It was not bad, but not anything special and when the server refilled my wine she looked around over our heads as though there were someplace else she'd rather be. We were checked on frequently, almost invasively, yet when we needed things, everyone was silently, officiously avoiding our gaze, as though our limit of service had been reached. I thought it might be racism, but evidently from these reviews that is the way customers are treated! I would not recommend this place.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I wish I had read this before I visited this restaurant. We decided to try it after seeing a profile on a UNC program. All of the negative things outlined here- cold interior, unappealling exterior, costly "interesting" food and unbelievably slow, snobbish service. I did not particularly care for the food. It was not bad, but not anything special and when the server refilled my wine she looked around over our heads as though there were someplace else she'd rather be. We were checked on frequently, almost invasively, yet when we needed things, everyone was silently, officiously avoiding our gaze, as though our limit of service had been reached. I thought it might be racism, but evidently from these reviews that is the way customers are treated! I would not recommend this place.

.

I've been living here in the triangle for a couple of years now, and I've eaten at the vast majority of the notable restaurants - new and established - in the area. I've suffered through unbelievable snobbery, less-than-memorable food and lousy service at many. One restaurant, however, stands above the crowd. I've dined at Four Square Restaurant in Durham 5 or 6 times now, and each experience has been outstanding. Four Square has that magical combination of fantastic and innovative food, highly professional, knowledgeable and friendly service, and beautiful atmosphere. The last time I was there, the maitre d' actually greeted me by name when he opened the door for me upon my arrival. At the end of our meal, the chef came out to the table to greet us and see how we enjoyed everything. This is a place that cares about what they do and about their diners' experience. If you haven't been yet, GO!

2
★★★★★

I've been living here in the triangle for a couple of years now, and I've eaten at the vast majority of the notable restaurants - new and established - in the area. I've suffered through unbelievable snobbery, less-than-memorable food and lousy service at many. One restaurant, however, stands above the crowd. I've dined at Four Square Restaurant in Durham 5 or 6 times now, and each experience has been outstanding. Four Square has that magical combination of fantastic and innovative food, highly professional, knowledgeable and friendly service, and beautiful atmosphere. The last time I was there, the maitre d' actually greeted me by name when he opened the door for me upon my arrival. At the end of our meal, the chef came out to the table to greet us and see how we enjoyed everything. This is a place that cares about what they do and about their diners' experience. If you haven't been yet, GO!

Pros: food, service, ambiance, and the little "extras"

Cons: get good directions - Durham can be confusing

.

It is disconcerting how anyone can write anything they want on this site and there is no opportunity for the restaurant to respond. I happen to work at Four Square, and the "World Traveler" below was an old woman whose credit card was declined. Yes, it took a while to process her payment because we had to call her bank to get authorization to charge her card. Maybe she should spend more time balancing her checkbook and less time writing untruthful reviews of a very nice restaurant.

2
★★★★★

It is disconcerting how anyone can write anything they want on this site and there is no opportunity for the restaurant to respond. I happen to work at Four Square, and the "World Traveler" below was an old woman whose credit card was declined. Yes, it took a while to process her payment because we had to call her bank to get authorization to charge her card. Maybe she should spend more time balancing her checkbook and less time writing untruthful reviews of a very nice restaurant.

.

The screened porch is too close to the sight & sound of heavy traffic on that busy road, so we moved inside.
to the table nearest the entrance. Ambience? Hardly. There wasn't a picture on the wall or a thing on the tables to relieve the plainess. The food was only adequate. Vaunted organic vegetables were overcooked and the portions tiny. Veddy artsy NOUVELLE though, if you still appreciate that tired concept when it Costs The Earth. And do bring cash. A lot of it. They haven't figured out how to work their credit card machine. It took half a day the following Monday to get the EXTRA charge [nearly doubled!] removed from my account. The experience would be laughable ~ IF it hadn't been my g'daughter's birthday for which they travelled from High Point.... In addition, the delay/mess at the end (after 2 hours) w/the card cost us our orchestra seats at the ADF until intermission. Horrible!

0
★☆☆☆☆

The screened porch is too close to the sight & sound of heavy traffic on that busy road, so we moved inside.
to the table nearest the entrance. Ambience? Hardly. There wasn't a picture on the wall or a thing on the tables to relieve the plainess. The food was only adequate. Vaunted organic vegetables were overcooked and the portions tiny. Veddy artsy NOUVELLE though, if you still appreciate that tired concept when it Costs The Earth. And do bring cash. A lot of it. They haven't figured out how to work their credit card machine. It took half a day the following Monday to get the EXTRA charge [nearly doubled!] removed from my account. The experience would be laughable ~ IF it hadn't been my g'daughter's birthday for which they travelled from High Point.... In addition, the delay/mess at the end (after 2 hours) w/the card cost us our orchestra seats at the ADF until intermission. Horrible!

Cons: Proximity to busy street precludes outside dining; absurdly expensive for too 'haute' everything.

.

My husband and I tried Four Square for the first time for our anniversary. We were exceptionally pleased- the meal was exquisite. On Friday evenings they serve a "wine flight" which I would highly recommend. Ours included three varieties of Spanish wines. I had pork tenderloin and my husband had scallops, both of which were outstanding. The ingredients were fresh and both dishes successfully blended very unique flavors. For dessert I had the chocolate macaroon tart, which I believe was the best dessert I have ever tasted. We will absolutely return to Four Square and would highly recommend it for special occasions.

2
★★★★★

My husband and I tried Four Square for the first time for our anniversary. We were exceptionally pleased- the meal was exquisite. On Friday evenings they serve a "wine flight" which I would highly recommend. Ours included three varieties of Spanish wines. I had pork tenderloin and my husband had scallops, both of which were outstanding. The ingredients were fresh and both dishes successfully blended very unique flavors. For dessert I had the chocolate macaroon tart, which I believe was the best dessert I have ever tasted. We will absolutely return to Four Square and would highly recommend it for special occasions.

Pros: Beautiful setting, unique menu, excellent service

Cons: expensive

.

The setting (historical landmark) is beautiful despite the ugly surroundings.
Seating/service was prompt.

Appretif: Non-vintage champagne is priced correctly (1.8x retail price). Wine selection is one of the
better ones in the area.
Ordered: Ravioli with chocolate/truffle sauce, diver scallops, dessert.

Food was quite good, though some flavor arrangements are "?". I tend to think that there are
too many American-French New Cuisine copies... it's not the ingredients who get the spot-light - and
we are forced to focus on the chef's artistic creativity.

Meal for 2 came to $140 plus tip. This is a special occasion restaurant which could be a once-a-month
restaurant if not ordering higher priced wines.

1
★★★☆☆

The setting (historical landmark) is beautiful despite the ugly surroundings.
Seating/service was prompt.

Appretif: Non-vintage champagne is priced correctly (1.8x retail price). Wine selection is one of the
better ones in the area.
Ordered: Ravioli with chocolate/truffle sauce, diver scallops, dessert.

Food was quite good, though some flavor arrangements are "?". I tend to think that there are
too many American-French New Cuisine copies... it's not the ingredients who get the spot-light - and
we are forced to focus on the chef's artistic creativity.

Meal for 2 came to $140 plus tip. This is a special occasion restaurant which could be a once-a-month
restaurant if not ordering higher priced wines.

Pros: Lovely building, interesting menu, good wine list, nice staff

Cons: Food interpretations could be questionable, at times.

.

I enjoying trying new places and was excited about this little restaurant.

First of all...get GOOD directions because it is not easy to find. The home is charming and the colors warm.

The food, although I enjoyed the fresh veggies from their garden, was as if they were trying too hard. The crab salad for example had so many ingred. that it over powered the delicate crab flavor. The soup was luke warm at best and did not have good flavor. You almost got the feeling that they were trying really hard to be creative and they went overboard. Mixing so many flavors that none of them stood out. Honestly the food was very average. I would not go back.

I hope this helps.

1
★★☆☆☆

I enjoying trying new places and was excited about this little restaurant.

First of all...get GOOD directions because it is not easy to find. The home is charming and the colors warm.

The food, although I enjoyed the fresh veggies from their garden, was as if they were trying too hard. The crab salad for example had so many ingred. that it over powered the delicate crab flavor. The soup was luke warm at best and did not have good flavor. You almost got the feeling that they were trying really hard to be creative and they went overboard. Mixing so many flavors that none of them stood out. Honestly the food was very average. I would not go back.

I hope this helps.

Pros: cute house and nice cozy bar

Cons: high price and missed the boat on mixing flavors

.

My wife and I had dinner at Four Square and everything about the experience was top notch. The setting is beautiful (we are looking forward to dining on their screen porch soon!), the food was out of this world, and the service was impeccable.

2
★★★★★

My wife and I had dinner at Four Square and everything about the experience was top notch. The setting is beautiful (we are looking forward to dining on their screen porch soon!), the food was out of this world, and the service was impeccable.

Pros: Beautiful historic home, great food and service

Cons: None

.

After reading rave reviews of Four Square, we booked an early V Day dinner. The hostess, who turned out to be the owner, was extremely rude, hanging up on us on the phone when we called to tell her we ran into traffic and were running a few minutes late. Our tables was given away, and we were seated in a drafty, creaky, extremely bright area upstairs near the bussing station with absolutely no ambiance. Even more upsetting was that the couple who came in 10 seconds ahead of us were seated at a lovely table downstairs. The menu was rather odd that night, food mediocre. Though our server was kind, the owner's rudeness tinged our whole experience, and we will certainly never return to this overpriced, snotty restaurant.

1
★★★☆☆

After reading rave reviews of Four Square, we booked an early V Day dinner. The hostess, who turned out to be the owner, was extremely rude, hanging up on us on the phone when we called to tell her we ran into traffic and were running a few minutes late. Our tables was given away, and we were seated in a drafty, creaky, extremely bright area upstairs near the bussing station with absolutely no ambiance. Even more upsetting was that the couple who came in 10 seconds ahead of us were seated at a lovely table downstairs. The menu was rather odd that night, food mediocre. Though our server was kind, the owner's rudeness tinged our whole experience, and we will certainly never return to this overpriced, snotty restaurant.

.

I greatly enjoyed my meal here at Four Square Restaurant. Our waiter was fantastic as was the meal. I was impressed by the ambience and the wine selection. I will be coming here again!

2
★★★★★

I greatly enjoyed my meal here at Four Square Restaurant. Our waiter was fantastic as was the meal. I was impressed by the ambience and the wine selection. I will be coming here again!

.

We'd heard about this restaurant from friends but had never tried it since we don't get much opportunity for fine dining because of our kids and often it's just not worth it to us to go to the trouble of getting a sitter. I'm happy to report that this place made it all worth it. The staff made us feel at home, and we were able to really relax and enjoy the truly delicious food. If you need a quiet grown up night out away from the kids, this is the place to go.

2
★★★★★

We'd heard about this restaurant from friends but had never tried it since we don't get much opportunity for fine dining because of our kids and often it's just not worth it to us to go to the trouble of getting a sitter. I'm happy to report that this place made it all worth it. The staff made us feel at home, and we were able to really relax and enjoy the truly delicious food. If you need a quiet grown up night out away from the kids, this is the place to go.

Pros: Cuisine, ambience, service

.

I wouldn't recommend this place. The service was extremely slow between courses. The mater d was well, snottie. Our room was very warm.

1
★★★☆☆

I wouldn't recommend this place. The service was extremely slow between courses. The mater d was well, snottie. Our room was very warm.

Pros: variety

Cons: slow service, snottie attitude

.

Shane Ingram, the chef at 4 Square, is wonderful - a food genius. Every meal is a creative exercise, with unusual pairings and fresh ingredients. The service is excellent, and the same staff seem to be there year after year (a good sign). I've eaten their dozens of times, mainly for special family events, and while some of Shane's culinary experiments don't work as well as others, the failures are still interesting. As with Magnolia Grill's Ben Barker, Shane is "not afraid of flavor". Reasonable wine list, standard prices. Nice, quiet atmosphere.

2
★★★★★

Shane Ingram, the chef at 4 Square, is wonderful - a food genius. Every meal is a creative exercise, with unusual pairings and fresh ingredients. The service is excellent, and the same staff seem to be there year after year (a good sign). I've eaten their dozens of times, mainly for special family events, and while some of Shane's culinary experiments don't work as well as others, the failures are still interesting. As with Magnolia Grill's Ben Barker, Shane is "not afraid of flavor". Reasonable wine list, standard prices. Nice, quiet atmosphere.

Pros: Great food, Good wine list, Superb service

Cons: Prices match quality

.

This was such a wonderful restaurant. We went on Valentine's night and were very glad that we made reservations because they were extremely busy. It is pricey but we were expecting that. The food was phenomenal! My husband is a picky eater and liked everything we ordered!! I will say that we have been to more 'romantic' places to eat, but the food and service and the house more than made up for it. The tables are kind of close together, especially in the upstairs bedrooms, which is where we ate. We will recommend this restaurant to others. It really made for a great Valentines dinner!

2
★★★★★

This was such a wonderful restaurant. We went on Valentine's night and were very glad that we made reservations because they were extremely busy. It is pricey but we were expecting that. The food was phenomenal! My husband is a picky eater and liked everything we ordered!! I will say that we have been to more 'romantic' places to eat, but the food and service and the house more than made up for it. The tables are kind of close together, especially in the upstairs bedrooms, which is where we ate. We will recommend this restaurant to others. It really made for a great Valentines dinner!

Pros: Food, Service, The House

Cons: tables crowded, not very romantic

.

I only had dinner here once but was very impressed. I started with the turtle soup (spicy) and had the seared tuna dinner; it was incredible. Smokey flavor with melt-in-your-mouth tuna topping creamy spinach and a nutty potato pancake. One of the most memorable meals I have ever had... Then for dessert I had the Citrus Trio, a work of art. Arranged almost like sushi, with three desserts, all tangy and elegant. Really unique flavors. Don't go here for the standard meat-n-potato options, but if you want to try something new and enjoy adventurous food, I'd highly recommend this restaurant.

2
★★★★★

I only had dinner here once but was very impressed. I started with the turtle soup (spicy) and had the seared tuna dinner; it was incredible. Smokey flavor with melt-in-your-mouth tuna topping creamy spinach and a nutty potato pancake. One of the most memorable meals I have ever had... Then for dessert I had the Citrus Trio, a work of art. Arranged almost like sushi, with three desserts, all tangy and elegant. Really unique flavors. Don't go here for the standard meat-n-potato options, but if you want to try something new and enjoy adventurous food, I'd highly recommend this restaurant.

Pros: unique food, good wine list

.

I have been dining at Four Square for around three years now. I was introduced to the restaurant by my colleagues when I moved here from New York City. I was skeptical about the restaurants in North Carolina (you know, I'm a New Yorker and all!), but I was amazed at the unbelievable quality of the food (delicious and creative) and service (polished, but not too formal), not to mention the beautiful setting. I am also writing in response to a couple of reviews I've seen posted here about the owners. I have had the pleasure of getting to know both of them over the years, and I'd be hard pressed to find kinder, more hospitable and passionate people. They really do go out of their way to make you feel like you are in their own home. If you haven't been there yet, you're in for a treat!

2
★★★★★

I have been dining at Four Square for around three years now. I was introduced to the restaurant by my colleagues when I moved here from New York City. I was skeptical about the restaurants in North Carolina (you know, I'm a New Yorker and all!), but I was amazed at the unbelievable quality of the food (delicious and creative) and service (polished, but not too formal), not to mention the beautiful setting. I am also writing in response to a couple of reviews I've seen posted here about the owners. I have had the pleasure of getting to know both of them over the years, and I'd be hard pressed to find kinder, more hospitable and passionate people. They really do go out of their way to make you feel like you are in their own home. If you haven't been there yet, you're in for a treat!

Pros: Great Owners, Great Food, Great Service

Editorial from

Owners Shane Ingram and Elizabeth Woodhouse's joint resume highlights experience at The Inn at Little Washington and Charlie Trotter's in Chicago. A restored Victorian mansion in one of Durham's old neighborhoods, Four Square, their first…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Four Square Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review