Randy's Pizza

★★★★★
Randy's Best New York Style Pizza, Subs and Salads in the Carolinas
  • 4810 Hope Valley Rd

    Durham, NC 27713

    Map & Directions
  • 919-403-6850

About Randy's Pizza

Hours
Mon - Fri 10:30AM - 10:00PM Saturday 11:00AM - 10:00PM Sunday 12:00PM - 10:00PM

Food

Food
More choices in Durham:
Resultset_next

Mountain Mike's Pizza

1105 St W5 Chico, CA

Resultset_next

Papa Murphy's Take 'N' Bake

2485 Notre Dame Blvd 440 Chico, CA

4.5 10
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Randy's Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

Randy's Pizza is by far the best I've had in the triangle area. Great service too!!

3
★★★★★

Randy's Pizza is by far the best I've had in the triangle area. Great service too!!

.

Hard to order take-out if they don't answer the damn phone. This is but a further indication of a real attitude problem at this Randy's location.

3
★★★★★

Hard to order take-out if they don't answer the damn phone. This is but a further indication of a real attitude problem at this Randy's location.

.

This is my favorite pizza place in all of Durham. Being from New York, this is not just New York Pizza. It is BETTER than New York pizza!! The slices are huge and they fold up just like back home. This is a must try for anyone who is looking for real pizza in Durham.

5
★★★★★

This is my favorite pizza place in all of Durham. Being from New York, this is not just New York Pizza. It is BETTER than New York pizza!! The slices are huge and they fold up just like back home. This is a must try for anyone who is looking for real pizza in Durham.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We tried a couple of other pizzeras around the area but none compare to the AWESOME food at Randy's. Trying to find good pizza around Durham is hard to do...until I found Randy's Pizza. The giant slice fresh out of the oven was the best pizza I have had since leaving New York last year. I will never go anywhere else for pizza. Thank you Randy's. I am now home again!!

5
★★★★★

We tried a couple of other pizzeras around the area but none compare to the AWESOME food at Randy's. Trying to find good pizza around Durham is hard to do...until I found Randy's Pizza. The giant slice fresh out of the oven was the best pizza I have had since leaving New York last year. I will never go anywhere else for pizza. Thank you Randy's. I am now home again!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We haven't been to Randy's in a while so thought we would go back. No wonder they are still tops in Durham! The slices are always gigantic, and I could barely finish my one slice. I had to take the other one home. The toppings are fresh, and the pepperoni and italian sausage just taste heavenly. We ordered a "small" salad and it would have fed four people. Be aware when you go to Randy's...you will get hooked! The owner told me that they have won best pizza in Durham by the Herald Sun yet again. I think it is four years in a row, now? Not surpised. Randy's is simply the best pizza, and the friendly helpful staff is an extra bonus...not like the other place nearby who has rude staff. I just LOVE Randy's!!!

2
★★★★★

We haven't been to Randy's in a while so thought we would go back. No wonder they are still tops in Durham! The slices are always gigantic, and I could barely finish my one slice. I had to take the other one home. The toppings are fresh, and the pepperoni and italian sausage just taste heavenly. We ordered a "small" salad and it would have fed four people. Be aware when you go to Randy's...you will get hooked! The owner told me that they have won best pizza in Durham by the Herald Sun yet again. I think it is four years in a row, now? Not surpised. Randy's is simply the best pizza, and the friendly helpful staff is an extra bonus...not like the other place nearby who has rude staff. I just LOVE Randy's!!!

Pros: giant slices, great friendly service

.

Not sure how Randy's got the rep it did; I just don't find anything special about it. There are just too many better pizza options in Durham to tempt me into trying this place again.

2
★★☆☆☆

Not sure how Randy's got the rep it did; I just don't find anything special about it. There are just too many better pizza options in Durham to tempt me into trying this place again.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Being from NY, I always search out pizza in a new town. It was only after my favorite pizza place (I Love NY Pizza on Franklin St.) was sold to another owner and quality was thrown out the window that I tried Randies. Great thin crust, real cheese and a pretty good sauce along with the great owner(s) old and new(Randie and Elia) made me a fan for life! They even know my voice and what I want depending on which day it is I am calling. Living in Kansas City now but will be back in 6 days and will be bringing back my usual 4 XL pizzas when I leave.

2
★★★★★

Being from NY, I always search out pizza in a new town. It was only after my favorite pizza place (I Love NY Pizza on Franklin St.) was sold to another owner and quality was thrown out the window that I tried Randies. Great thin crust, real cheese and a pretty good sauce along with the great owner(s) old and new(Randie and Elia) made me a fan for life! They even know my voice and what I want depending on which day it is I am calling. Living in Kansas City now but will be back in 6 days and will be bringing back my usual 4 XL pizzas when I leave.

Pros: pizza, great owner, real hero bread and garlic knots

Cons: parking

.

We would have been better off buying a frozen pizza at the grocery store. Seriously. I've worked in the restaurant business all my life; several Italian places too. My 4 year-old nephew could have made better pizza with Playdough. I think the sauce was straight up tomato paste; crust was dry and tasteless; and I think we counted about 15 slices of pepperoni on the entire pizza, you got maybe 1 or 2 pieces per slice. It wasn't even quality, thick pepperoni; it was probably just Hormel or Arrezzio. Completely pathetic. Don't bother.

1
★☆☆☆☆

We would have been better off buying a frozen pizza at the grocery store. Seriously. I've worked in the restaurant business all my life; several Italian places too. My 4 year-old nephew could have made better pizza with Playdough. I think the sauce was straight up tomato paste; crust was dry and tasteless; and I think we counted about 15 slices of pepperoni on the entire pizza, you got maybe 1 or 2 pieces per slice. It wasn't even quality, thick pepperoni; it was probably just Hormel or Arrezzio. Completely pathetic. Don't bother.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Took my wife out to dinner here and service was fast, it was clean, pizza was very good, portions are large, and prices are very low.

2
★★★★★

Took my wife out to dinner here and service was fast, it was clean, pizza was very good, portions are large, and prices are very low.

.

This location has great wings and lasagna! You can call in your order and it will be ready when you arrive without having to wait until they complete the order.

5
★★★★★

This location has great wings and lasagna! You can call in your order and it will be ready when you arrive without having to wait until they complete the order.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Randy's Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review