I Love New York Pizza

★★★★☆

About I Love New York Pizza

Hours
Mon. - Thu., Sun. 10am - 11pm;Fri. - Sat. 10am - 3am

Food

Food
More choices in Raleigh:
Resultset_next

Casey's General Store

1005 US Highway 45 N Eldorado, IL

Resultset_next

Mimmo's Pizza

1001 Dewey St Eldorado, IL

3.95 20
Hi! Sign in to let us know how I Love New York Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

Im a former New yorker, love the pizza, taste like home, took my woman here and she's from north carolina and she loves the pizza as well......no complaints so far, sorry that mostly everyone on here had a bad experience............

3
★★★★★

Im a former New yorker, love the pizza, taste like home, took my woman here and she's from north carolina and she loves the pizza as well......no complaints so far, sorry that mostly everyone on here had a bad experience............

.

If you are broke college kid or you happen to work at NCSU than you can make the excuse to eat here(ever once in a while). However, if you don't fall into of those categories then you are fool to spend your money here.\r
\r
I bought 2

3
★★★★★

If you are broke college kid or you happen to work at NCSU than you can make the excuse to eat here(ever once in a while). However, if you don't fall into of those categories then you are fool to spend your money here.\r
\r
I bought 2

.

While I was eating my pizza, a roach crawled right over my foot and ran behind a door.

Not coming back here!

3
★★★★★

While I was eating my pizza, a roach crawled right over my foot and ran behind a door.

Not coming back here!

.

Parked behind Silvi'as to grab a slice. It was late morning and found they had not opened yet. I strolled over to Brugger's for a bagel instead. Went out to my truck and it was gone.

I was towed because the "spotters" saw me go over

3
★★★★★

Parked behind Silvi'as to grab a slice. It was late morning and found they had not opened yet. I strolled over to Brugger's for a bagel instead. Went out to my truck and it was gone.

I was towed because the "spotters" saw me go over

.

This is the best pizza I've tasted from a small restaurant. I'll take it over Pizza Hut and Papa John's any day. The wings are great too!

4
★★★★☆

This is the best pizza I've tasted from a small restaurant. I'll take it over Pizza Hut and Papa John's any day. The wings are great too!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I went inside for a pizza. I stayed about 45 minutes. I went to the parking lot and my car was gone. This pizza store called Atlantic towing and had my car towed while I was inside eating pizza Atalantic Towing towed my car to the Atlantic towing lot. Stay away from this place. These people are theives.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I went inside for a pizza. I stayed about 45 minutes. I went to the parking lot and my car was gone. This pizza store called Atlantic towing and had my car towed while I was inside eating pizza Atalantic Towing towed my car to the Atlantic towing lot. Stay away from this place. These people are theives.

Pros: these gusys are crooks

Cons: Atlantic Towing

.

Pizza's here are really horrible. This is with respect to the vegetarian pizza's. I had been to this place twice, both the times the quality of pizza are really very bad. I have no idea about other pizza types. If you are a vegetarian, this is not a place to have pizza..

2
★★☆☆☆

Pizza's here are really horrible. This is with respect to the vegetarian pizza's. I had been to this place twice, both the times the quality of pizza are really very bad. I have no idea about other pizza types. If you are a vegetarian, this is not a place to have pizza..

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I guess this is one of the busiest places on hills borough . I would say the pizzas are great and are definitely affordable . But service is definitely a problem here and also the atmosphere sometimes gets hot and stuffy .

3
★★★☆☆

I guess this is one of the busiest places on hills borough . I would say the pizzas are great and are definitely affordable . But service is definitely a problem here and also the atmosphere sometimes gets hot and stuffy .

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

It is awesome to find a good Pizza place in Raleigh. Former NY'r here who loves this place.
Mellow is ok but over priced, while I love, gives you good pizza, priced well!
They should check their attitudes though, sometimes I think they are trying to go for the authentic feel....

2
★★★★☆

It is awesome to find a good Pizza place in Raleigh. Former NY'r here who loves this place.
Mellow is ok but over priced, while I love, gives you good pizza, priced well!
They should check their attitudes though, sometimes I think they are trying to go for the authentic feel....

Pros: Really tastes like NY pizza, prices, variety

Cons: parking, staff attitude

.

Really, it wasn't worth going over there. It looks like the real deal but isn't. Not sure if it was just an off night considering the reviews it has received. If you are looking for NY pizza Assiagio's is much better. Take it from a New Yorker. I haven't tried many NY style pizza places in Raleigh, but am continuing to search.

1
★★☆☆☆

Really, it wasn't worth going over there. It looks like the real deal but isn't. Not sure if it was just an off night considering the reviews it has received. If you are looking for NY pizza Assiagio's is much better. Take it from a New Yorker. I haven't tried many NY style pizza places in Raleigh, but am continuing to search.

Pros: across from a college campus if you attend the school

Cons: the pizza

.

Food here is alright I guess, it's just what you're used to everywhere else. Can't really knock them for anything but it's the same thing you get at all the other "NY style" knock off places around the country.

1
★★☆☆☆

Food here is alright I guess, it's just what you're used to everywhere else. Can't really knock them for anything but it's the same thing you get at all the other "NY style" knock off places around the country.

Cons: Parking can be painful

.

First of all, the name says it all NEW YORK pizza. That means it will be thin crust (dough made fresh daily hand flown) and little to no tomato sauce. I would rather not eat pizza than eat bad pizza, this is GREAT pizza!

2
★★★★★

First of all, the name says it all NEW YORK pizza. That means it will be thin crust (dough made fresh daily hand flown) and little to no tomato sauce. I would rather not eat pizza than eat bad pizza, this is GREAT pizza!

Pros: great pizza

Cons: "clinical" ambiance

.

If you want authentic NY style pizza this is the place to go! I have been to this location and the Wilmington, NC location both are great!

2
★★★★★

If you want authentic NY style pizza this is the place to go! I have been to this location and the Wilmington, NC location both are great!

Pros: Awesome Pizza

Cons: Parking

.

I LOVE THIS PIZZA!!! My niece attends Peace College and she kept raving about it. I finally drove the 30 minutes to get there and it was absolutely fantastic. Authentic NY pizza! I took my husband there two days later. We are hooked. If you are looking for REAL NY pizza, this is your place. We are from Philly and if only I could find an authentic cheesesteak locally.

2
★★★★★

I LOVE THIS PIZZA!!! My niece attends Peace College and she kept raving about it. I finally drove the 30 minutes to get there and it was absolutely fantastic. Authentic NY pizza! I took my husband there two days later. We are hooked. If you are looking for REAL NY pizza, this is your place. We are from Philly and if only I could find an authentic cheesesteak locally.

Pros: outstanding pizza

Cons: college crowd - felt kinda out of place but pizza worth it!!

.

I have been to hundreds of pizzerias in NY, CA, MA, and NC. This is among the best pizza I have eaten in all of north carolina. It is truly authentic new york style pizza and it is delicious. Highly recommended!

2
★★★★★

I have been to hundreds of pizzerias in NY, CA, MA, and NC. This is among the best pizza I have eaten in all of north carolina. It is truly authentic new york style pizza and it is delicious. Highly recommended!

Pros: Pizza

.

generally the prices here are higher than its counterparts elsewhere, but the taste of pizzas are ok. still, one or two tries you'd feel it ok, but more, you wouldn't.

2
★★☆☆☆

generally the prices here are higher than its counterparts elsewhere, but the taste of pizzas are ok. still, one or two tries you'd feel it ok, but more, you wouldn't.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Horrible pizza. I ordered an XL to go, got it home, it had no pizza sauce on it, so I fed the "cheese bread" to my dogs, and gave the rest to my friend to feed to her dogs. I called the store immediately, was told the manager wasn't there, would be back in 30 minutes and they'd have him return my call. Long story short..I received a bad pizza, and after that, the worst customer service on the planet.
I would NEVER recommend this place for any occasion. It was horrible in every way.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Horrible pizza. I ordered an XL to go, got it home, it had no pizza sauce on it, so I fed the "cheese bread" to my dogs, and gave the rest to my friend to feed to her dogs. I called the store immediately, was told the manager wasn't there, would be back in 30 minutes and they'd have him return my call. Long story short..I received a bad pizza, and after that, the worst customer service on the planet.
I would NEVER recommend this place for any occasion. It was horrible in every way.

Pros: none, none, none

Cons: pizza is bad, horrible customer svc, bad karma

.

I love NY Pizza is one of the best "southern" pizza places that we've tasted so far! It's terribly difficult to reproduce the TRUE NY Style pizzas, but they do a fantastic job! (and this coming from NY Metro area natives who are pretty darned picky about Pizza!)

The prices are reasonable for a HUMONGOUS pizza that tastes delicious. The spices were a bit too much for younglings, but for adults, it was just perfect!

There is a self-serve drink area, and a "fast-food" type atmosphere that is larger for a decent amount of people to sit in there. They could use more seating, but it was nice to have extra room to walk around tables.

Service was with a smile, and very kind-- pizza arrived SUPER FAST and was made to perfection

PROS: excellent pizza for a great price-- convenient location
CONS: Could have a "homier" atmosphere for a more enjoyable time

4
★★★★☆

I love NY Pizza is one of the best "southern" pizza places that we've tasted so far! It's terribly difficult to reproduce the TRUE NY Style pizzas, but they do a fantastic job! (and this coming from NY Metro area natives who are pretty darned picky about Pizza!)

The prices are reasonable for a HUMONGOUS pizza that tastes delicious. The spices were a bit too much for younglings, but for adults, it was just perfect!

There is a self-serve drink area, and a "fast-food" type atmosphere that is larger for a decent amount of people to sit in there. They could use more seating, but it was nice to have extra room to walk around tables.

Service was with a smile, and very kind-- pizza arrived SUPER FAST and was made to perfection

PROS: excellent pizza for a great price-- convenient location
CONS: Could have a "homier" atmosphere for a more enjoyable time

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

this pizza place is the best in raleigh ....its even better than the pizza in New York. They are always busy which basically explains how good the pizza is and also theyre special is great..I really do LOVE NY PIZZA!

2
★★★★★

this pizza place is the best in raleigh ....its even better than the pizza in New York. They are always busy which basically explains how good the pizza is and also theyre special is great..I really do LOVE NY PIZZA!

Pros: Inexpensive, very good pizza, plenty of parking

.

This is TRUE NY style pizza. The slices are big, thin and come with great toppings. I have tried a lot of so-called NY style pizza place around here and nothing compares.

2
★★★★★

This is TRUE NY style pizza. The slices are big, thin and come with great toppings. I have tried a lot of so-called NY style pizza place around here and nothing compares.

Pros: GREAT PIZZA!

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used I Love New York Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review