Have enjoyed chef Bill's pizza (small or large) for past 20 years. Best pizza in Colts Neck. Most any topping you like, and hot from the oven, for you to pick up in the back of the restaurant/bar.
Friendly folks, family business. Price is right.
Living in Colts Neck myself, I found Maryanns to be a pretty well kept secret. The pizza is more than worthwhile, and despite being in Colts Neck, it's reasonably priced. Not much variety wise though.4