Star Tavern & Pizzeria

★★★★★
  • 400 High St

    Orange, NJ 07050

    Map & Directions
  • 973-675-3336

About Star Tavern & Pizzeria

Hours
Fri-Sat: 11am-12am, Sun: 12pm-10pm, Mon-Thu: 11am-11pm

Arts & Entertainment

Arts & Entertainment
More choices in Orange:
Resultset_next

Extreme Bar & Grill

1535 W Chapman Ave Orange, CA

Resultset_next

Danny K's Cafe & Billiards

1096 N Main St Orange, CA

4.6154 13
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Star Tavern & Pizzeria was?
Write a Review
.

I would not recommend going here for dinner. I had the most terrible experience ever! First time for my husband, daughter and I. To start this off there was no host/hostess to sit us. So since all the booths were taken at the moment. We

3
★★★★★

I would not recommend going here for dinner. I had the most terrible experience ever! First time for my husband, daughter and I. To start this off there was no host/hostess to sit us. So since all the booths were taken at the moment. We

.

I went to Star Tavern last nite 12/10/11 around 7:30pm my wife and I with the expectation of enjoying a good meal and much wanted r&r. But when we arrived we waited on there little rickety chairs and was seated in an awkward place near

3
★★★★★

I went to Star Tavern last nite 12/10/11 around 7:30pm my wife and I with the expectation of enjoying a good meal and much wanted r&r. But when we arrived we waited on there little rickety chairs and was seated in an awkward place near

.

Always loved Star for thin crust, lots of tomato sauce, just enough cheese for deliciousness BUT last two times (mid Sept 2010) the pizza had been greasy and loaded with gooey cheese just like every other crappy pizza round. What happened?????

2
★★☆☆☆

Always loved Star for thin crust, lots of tomato sauce, just enough cheese for deliciousness BUT last two times (mid Sept 2010) the pizza had been greasy and loaded with gooey cheese just like every other crappy pizza round. What happened?????

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Good pizza. Not worth a 3 hour drive though. The thin crust is different but to me this is just a lazy chef's way to make a pie, simply roll it out with a rolling pin. Again, good pie, not the best ever.

3
★★★☆☆

Good pizza. Not worth a 3 hour drive though. The thin crust is different but to me this is just a lazy chef's way to make a pie, simply roll it out with a rolling pin. Again, good pie, not the best ever.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I moved from West Orange, NJ to Fl in 1977. To this day I have never tasted a pizza that comes close to the Star. Also, their eggplant sandwiches were to die for. Yeah they are the BEST PIZZA EVER. Do you deliver to Fl ? LOL

5
★★★★★

I moved from West Orange, NJ to Fl in 1977. To this day I have never tasted a pizza that comes close to the Star. Also, their eggplant sandwiches were to die for. Yeah they are the BEST PIZZA EVER. Do you deliver to Fl ? LOL

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Thin, crisp, fresh and flavorful. Great taste! My Thai wife refused to eat pizza until we went to the Star. Now we make an hour long drive each weekend for an eggplant pie and the greatest wings around. The food is addictive.

2
★★★★★

Thin, crisp, fresh and flavorful. Great taste! My Thai wife refused to eat pizza until we went to the Star. Now we make an hour long drive each weekend for an eggplant pie and the greatest wings around. The food is addictive.

.

Before you add toppings, try this pie plain. It is the perfect pizza. The sauce is outstanding, the crust thin and crisp, the cheese fresh. It doesn't need topping but adding them only expands the flavors. It is by far one of the best pizza's I have ever experienced. It's hard to get past the pizza, but the other items are just as good. Mussels, which are a great addition to the pie, are cooked in a sauce that is to die for. I asked if they sold the sauce by itself and unfortunately they don't. Lasagna was great as was the eggplant, but the treat is their pizza. It is well worth the trip.

5
★★★★★

Before you add toppings, try this pie plain. It is the perfect pizza. The sauce is outstanding, the crust thin and crisp, the cheese fresh. It doesn't need topping but adding them only expands the flavors. It is by far one of the best pizza's I have ever experienced. It's hard to get past the pizza, but the other items are just as good. Mussels, which are a great addition to the pie, are cooked in a sauce that is to die for. I asked if they sold the sauce by itself and unfortunately they don't. Lasagna was great as was the eggplant, but the treat is their pizza. It is well worth the trip.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Star Tavern Pizza is the best in the Universe...the best I've ever had, anywhere!!!! I have tried the pizza from New York down to Florida and out to Tennessee and Arkansas and nothing comes close. Hands down Star Tavern has got it, if you are within 10 hours drive time it's worth the drive. Heck, it's worth an overnight stay nearby for the true Pizza lover. There is none better, PERIOD!!!!

5
★★★★★

Star Tavern Pizza is the best in the Universe...the best I've ever had, anywhere!!!! I have tried the pizza from New York down to Florida and out to Tennessee and Arkansas and nothing comes close. Hands down Star Tavern has got it, if you are within 10 hours drive time it's worth the drive. Heck, it's worth an overnight stay nearby for the true Pizza lover. There is none better, PERIOD!!!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Star Tavern has great thin crust pizza. Its a great place to hang out with friends, and has a bar-like atmosphere. The only downside is that its not in the greatest neighborhood.

4
★★★★☆

Star Tavern has great thin crust pizza. Its a great place to hang out with friends, and has a bar-like atmosphere. The only downside is that its not in the greatest neighborhood.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I'm from NYC and if someone knows pizza that's me. My father in-law who's the Director at the NJ transit garage close by recommended for us to try it. I have to say that Star Tavern is like having pizza at my grandma's house!!! made from scratch, fresh ingredients, and most important it does not break your bank.

5
★★★★★

I'm from NYC and if someone knows pizza that's me. My father in-law who's the Director at the NJ transit garage close by recommended for us to try it. I have to say that Star Tavern is like having pizza at my grandma's house!!! made from scratch, fresh ingredients, and most important it does not break your bank.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

i drove about 3 hours for this pizza, and let me tell you, it was worth it. Usually my family and I take a drive to NJ every month to visit my grandmother but this time we decided to go to a pizza place on the way up that was recomended near the area. So we went to Star Tavern and it was awesome and the pizza was delicous. We will go here for years to come.

4
★★★★☆

i drove about 3 hours for this pizza, and let me tell you, it was worth it. Usually my family and I take a drive to NJ every month to visit my grandmother but this time we decided to go to a pizza place on the way up that was recomended near the area. So we went to Star Tavern and it was awesome and the pizza was delicous. We will go here for years to come.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I drive over a half an hour each way to go to this restaraunt. The pizza is out of this world! It is one big smoky room but it is worth it for pizza this good.

PROS: Pizza
CONS: atmoshpere

5
★★★★★

I drive over a half an hour each way to go to this restaraunt. The pizza is out of this world! It is one big smoky room but it is worth it for pizza this good.

PROS: Pizza
CONS: atmoshpere

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Star has a long history of being the best pizza on planet earth. The pizza is made very thin and the toppings cimpliment the crust. Everyone who is anyone has been to the Star as we all fondly refer to it. They may not deliver but with the products they sell, they dont need to deliver.

5
★★★★★

Star has a long history of being the best pizza on planet earth. The pizza is made very thin and the toppings cimpliment the crust. Everyone who is anyone has been to the Star as we all fondly refer to it. They may not deliver but with the products they sell, they dont need to deliver.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Star Tavern & Pizzeria, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review