Insider Pages Reviews for Kinchley's Tavern Inc

5 Stars: Kinchley's Tavern Inc is Awesome (by Maria M.)

Maria M. — Mon, 05 Oct 2009 13:42:00 GMT

I am 42 years old and have memories of this great pizza from a very early age. I was an infant when my parents began bringing me there. Although i moved away 17 years ago, i am only 2 hours and go back every few months just for this pizza! Hasn't changed!!!

4 Stars: Pizza to Enoy! (by Mary F.)

Mary F. — Tue, 19 Aug 2008 13:49:00 GMT

Enjoy eating the lightest Pizza imaginable- thin crust- I can eat a whole pizza and not even feel full! Taste is sublime! Quaint atmosphere and reasonable prices- For Heaven sakes, if you never went there-
Today is the Day!

5 Stars: A family tradition (by Charleen B.)

Charleen B. — Thu, 05 Jun 2008 15:32:00 GMT

For over 30 years now Kinchleys has been a special place for my entire family. When those out of town come to visit, Kinchleys has to be one of the nights out. We take two tables in the center of the restaurant and have a blast. I moved here from St.Louis all those years ago, and my favorite pizza place, Mr.Louigis had pizza like this. Back then, no one in N.Y. knew what thin crust pizza was, it was almost UN New York to even think of. When I went here, with my sister and her family I was hooked. It is the best and now my own boys are hooked . I am leaving work in a few minutes, ordering me two pizzas to go, stop to fill up my car , then go home and have the best pizza in Rockland!

5 Stars: Kinchley's (by erica m.)

erica m. — Thu, 13 Mar 2008 16:00:00 GMT

Love this place!! The pizza is the one of the best thin crust pizza I've ever had. Frequently go for lunch. Prices are reasonable. Everything on the menu is delicious. Little small for the amount of customers they receive. Would recommend calling to make a reservation if going on a weekend, seeing as thats probably the busiest time of the week.

4 Stars: You'll really like it (by Jennifer B.)

Jennifer B. — Mon, 28 Jan 2008 17:50:00 GMT

Kinchley's Tavern is most famous for its pizza. It is s very thin crust pizza so it just seems to melt in your mouth. The pizza is not cheap and they are small as pizza goes but they definitly worth an occasional visit. Make sure you bring cash - they do not accept credit cards.

4 Stars: crowded but good (by Sharon R.)

Sharon R. — Sun, 30 Jul 2006 12:01:00 GMT

The pizza is well known. The thin crust pizza seems to melt in your mouth. You have no idea how the table of four just devoured the pie in about 2 minutes. You'll need to order at least two large pies if you have 3 people with decent appetites. Only problem with this place is: no credit cards accepted & crowded. The price to pay for this highly rated pizza. Hey, I usually hate thin crust pizza, but I like Kinchley's

PROS: famous thin crust pizza
CONS: no Credit cards & crowded- get take out!

4 Stars: good food, good service (by anita g.)

anita g. — Sun, 23 Oct 2005 10:34:00 GMT

This place offers great pizzas that you will be telling many people about. They have a nice atmosphere and are located just off Rt 17 for easy access.

PROS: location, parking, food, environment
CONS:

4 Stars: Great Old Style Atmosphere (by Jaclyn J.)

Jaclyn J. — Sun, 16 Oct 2005 07:40:00 GMT

My husband & I visited Kinchley's not too long ago & we're greeted with VERY friendly service. The food was delicious & very afforadable. Great menu too!

4 Stars: Great pizza (by Andrea S.)

Andrea S. — Wed, 31 Aug 2005 13:10:00 GMT

The thin-crust pizza at Kinchley's is wonderful. If you plan to eat there, make sure to arrive early as it fills up very quickly even on weeknights. It is worth the wait though. Also make sure to bring cash as they don't accept credit cards (they have an ATM on-site).