Piece O' Cake

★★★★☆
  • 717 Broad St

    Shrewsbury, NJ 07702

    Map & Directions
  • 732-741-3802

About Piece O' Cake

Categories

Food

Food
More choices in Shrewsbury:
Resultset_next

Vinny T's of Boston-Shrewsbury

7 Boston Tpke Shrewsbury, MA

Resultset_next

Osaka

20 Boston Turnpike Shrewsbury, MA

3.5152 33
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Piece O' Cake was?
Write a Review
.

I would NEVER recommend piece o cake to anyone for any event, especially a wedding! This was a vendor that my hall used and I was disappointed from the very beginning. They made me feel as though my business didn't matter unless I was willing to pay more to upgrade my cake. I made an appointment to go for a cake tasting, and drove 2 hours for the appointment. I called to make sure we would be meeting with someone and they informed me that I was not in their book for a tasting. I had to turn around and go back home. On my next visit, I let them know that I wanted to sit with them for a tasting but they informed me "this isn't the way they do tastings". They packed me a "to go" cake tasting. It again made me feel as though I wasn't worth their time. I wanted a cake that was special and unique and at first they said they were very flexible, but they in fact made me pick from a "wholesale cake list" which had pictures dated back to 2007. I called and emailed numerous times with No response. I asked to speak to the owner numerous times and was told I would be charged $50 to see her. This was the worst experience I have ever had with any business and I really don't know how they are in business at all. I also know that there were other brides that felt the same way. Bride and grooms beware... Unless your willing to spend a lot of money- Piece O Cake will not give you any of their time & will make you feel worthless. I started Out so excited to have my dream wedding cake and ended up hating the entire process. They do not even deserve 1 star!

1
★☆☆☆☆

I would NEVER recommend piece o cake to anyone for any event, especially a wedding! This was a vendor that my hall used and I was disappointed from the very beginning. They made me feel as though my business didn't matter unless I was willing to pay more to upgrade my cake. I made an appointment to go for a cake tasting, and drove 2 hours for the appointment. I called to make sure we would be meeting with someone and they informed me that I was not in their book for a tasting. I had to turn around and go back home. On my next visit, I let them know that I wanted to sit with them for a tasting but they informed me "this isn't the way they do tastings". They packed me a "to go" cake tasting. It again made me feel as though I wasn't worth their time. I wanted a cake that was special and unique and at first they said they were very flexible, but they in fact made me pick from a "wholesale cake list" which had pictures dated back to 2007. I called and emailed numerous times with No response. I asked to speak to the owner numerous times and was told I would be charged $50 to see her. This was the worst experience I have ever had with any business and I really don't know how they are in business at all. I also know that there were other brides that felt the same way. Bride and grooms beware... Unless your willing to spend a lot of money- Piece O Cake will not give you any of their time & will make you feel worthless. I started Out so excited to have my dream wedding cake and ended up hating the entire process. They do not even deserve 1 star!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I would NEVER recommend piece o cake to anyone for any event, especially a wedding! This was a vendor that my hall used and I was disappointed from the very beginning. They made me feel as though my business didn't matter unless I was

3
★★★★★

I would NEVER recommend piece o cake to anyone for any event, especially a wedding! This was a vendor that my hall used and I was disappointed from the very beginning. They made me feel as though my business didn't matter unless I was

.

Piece O' Cake does not even deserve one star! My fianc & I called the Piece O' Cake to schedule a cake testing for our upcoming wedding. When my fianc called Saturday, Oct 22 the woman on the other line just said Piece O' Cake. There was no how can I help you? He explained we would like to schedule a cake testing. The woman put us on hold for 10 MINUTES. We accidentally hung up on them & we proceed to call back for it to ring & go to voicemail. We tried calling again and spoke to the woman again & I explained that she left my fianc on hold for 10 minutes & we accidentally hung up. She said the phones were acting up there. We were given two options on cake testing: Option 1: Pick up a home cake testing kit & pick a design of the website. Option 2: Meet with Joely for cake testing & work out the design of the cake. We chose Option 2. We were told that late night cake testing are done Wednesday, Thursday, & Friday. We asked if they anything available for the upcoming week & she said yes. I asked if we could do Wednesday Oct 26 @ 6:45 pm. Now the woman is trying to tell us that Joely does not like doing cake testing on Wednesday. Then why offer Wednesday if she does not like it. They offer to keep the appointment & speak with Joely. If they had to reschedule they would call us. Well the day before our appointment we received a phone call that Joely had to cancel our appointment for a meeting that she had to attend on Wednesday. I asked if they had anything available next week the women Audrey or something with an A. I could barely make out her name when she said it. She said Joely was free all next week. I asked if I could do Wednesday Nov 2 @ 6:45 pm. She said YES!! She said she would put us down. My fianc & I left our jobs early so we could make the appointment on time. We did not even have the chance to eat dinner. We when arrive to Piece O' Cake all the lights were off. We went to the front door & said go to the side door. We knocked on the side door a couple of times & of course, no one answered. As we sat in the parking lot, I left a message stating I was here for my caking testing & no one is here. My message was stern because I was very mad. We were rescheduled, put on hold & now no one was here. The next day Audrey called me back because she was confused on what had happen. I told her I had appointment for cake testing but no one was there. I was put on hold and either the phone or Audrey hung up on me. She did call back. She said I did not have you in my notes. You did not reschedule. Whom did you speak to? I said I spoke to you. She did not apologize. She said we could reschedule you for next week. Now really why would I book a cake testing if you rescheduled me the first time & second time are a no show. I could not trust this bakery. I said I would not be rescheduling with you. I do not want to use you after this. I do not know how you run your business let only how you stay in business. Now she is starting to get rude & short with me. Once again no apology. I did not go on & on with her about my complaints because I know she would have hung on me. I knew where I could put my complaints & try to warn people not use them. It is quite funny that I am reading another reviews & most people have complained about the lack of customer service. In this economy, you would think people would want business & give the best customer service. In the end I am glad this ALL happened because after reading the reviews they do not make your cakes to what you discuss, change the prices on you etc. Who wants to work with a company like that? I would GLADLY bring my business elsewhere. I could not trust this bakery to deliver the cake on my wedding day. In addition, I do have girlfriends getting married in the next year or two and would have recommend them but they all know now not to use them. The bakery is lacking customer service. They are disorganized and liars! I would think twice on using this bakery!!!

1
★☆☆☆☆

Piece O' Cake does not even deserve one star! My fianc & I called the Piece O' Cake to schedule a cake testing for our upcoming wedding. When my fianc called Saturday, Oct 22 the woman on the other line just said Piece O' Cake. There was no how can I help you? He explained we would like to schedule a cake testing. The woman put us on hold for 10 MINUTES. We accidentally hung up on them & we proceed to call back for it to ring & go to voicemail. We tried calling again and spoke to the woman again & I explained that she left my fianc on hold for 10 minutes & we accidentally hung up. She said the phones were acting up there. We were given two options on cake testing: Option 1: Pick up a home cake testing kit & pick a design of the website. Option 2: Meet with Joely for cake testing & work out the design of the cake. We chose Option 2. We were told that late night cake testing are done Wednesday, Thursday, & Friday. We asked if they anything available for the upcoming week & she said yes. I asked if we could do Wednesday Oct 26 @ 6:45 pm. Now the woman is trying to tell us that Joely does not like doing cake testing on Wednesday. Then why offer Wednesday if she does not like it. They offer to keep the appointment & speak with Joely. If they had to reschedule they would call us. Well the day before our appointment we received a phone call that Joely had to cancel our appointment for a meeting that she had to attend on Wednesday. I asked if they had anything available next week the women Audrey or something with an A. I could barely make out her name when she said it. She said Joely was free all next week. I asked if I could do Wednesday Nov 2 @ 6:45 pm. She said YES!! She said she would put us down. My fianc & I left our jobs early so we could make the appointment on time. We did not even have the chance to eat dinner. We when arrive to Piece O' Cake all the lights were off. We went to the front door & said go to the side door. We knocked on the side door a couple of times & of course, no one answered. As we sat in the parking lot, I left a message stating I was here for my caking testing & no one is here. My message was stern because I was very mad. We were rescheduled, put on hold & now no one was here. The next day Audrey called me back because she was confused on what had happen. I told her I had appointment for cake testing but no one was there. I was put on hold and either the phone or Audrey hung up on me. She did call back. She said I did not have you in my notes. You did not reschedule. Whom did you speak to? I said I spoke to you. She did not apologize. She said we could reschedule you for next week. Now really why would I book a cake testing if you rescheduled me the first time & second time are a no show. I could not trust this bakery. I said I would not be rescheduling with you. I do not want to use you after this. I do not know how you run your business let only how you stay in business. Now she is starting to get rude & short with me. Once again no apology. I did not go on & on with her about my complaints because I know she would have hung on me. I knew where I could put my complaints & try to warn people not use them. It is quite funny that I am reading another reviews & most people have complained about the lack of customer service. In this economy, you would think people would want business & give the best customer service. In the end I am glad this ALL happened because after reading the reviews they do not make your cakes to what you discuss, change the prices on you etc. Who wants to work with a company like that? I would GLADLY bring my business elsewhere. I could not trust this bakery to deliver the cake on my wedding day. In addition, I do have girlfriends getting married in the next year or two and would have recommend them but they all know now not to use them. The bakery is lacking customer service. They are disorganized and liars! I would think twice on using this bakery!!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

**this is in response to a recent post by the owner of Piece O' Cake, Joely, who was inappropriately complaining about the post by Joseph M titled "Piece O' Nothing". The post has been removed but the comments below are still very valid**

Most people consider the word 'disgusting' to be synonymous with poor, rude and unprofessional customer service, NOT the freedom to speak out your opinions online if you have a bad experience with a business! If you're the owner of a business (and we, the customers, are not giving extra pity if you're a 'small' business...your practices have to be up to par with large businesses just the same!), and you want your business to thrive, it's simple. The formula is something that goes like this for a thriving business:

1. treat your customers as you'd like to be treated

2. attend to your customers, who are about to pay you a lot of money, in a timely manner

3. do not put off answering your customers' opinions, concerns, etc just because you're too 'busy' (sorry, that's no excuse to disregard a customer, and if you're so busy that you can't see a customer, then you shouldn't be taking more than you can handle)

4. do not change the price of your product once you give one

5. treat all customers the same, the ones that you have given service for many years and those that are first timers (otherwise, those first timers will never come back and your recurrent customer pool will decrease...inevitably!)

and last but not least at all:

6. please do not slander the opinions of others who have gotten your service. if you feel unsatisfied with what others are writing about you, your service, your store, etc...you should also take a look at what you are doing. It's hard to self-evaluate but if there are SO many bad reviews for Piece O' Cake, you should definitely start changing a few things around to please your customers better. It is true that everyone should be fair when posting a review. Fair enough. I call everyone to be fair here (that's not a question). But let's also be fair to listen critically to your unsatisfied customers. That's how a good business runs.

Best of luck!

1
★☆☆☆☆

**this is in response to a recent post by the owner of Piece O' Cake, Joely, who was inappropriately complaining about the post by Joseph M titled "Piece O' Nothing". The post has been removed but the comments below are still very valid**

Most people consider the word 'disgusting' to be synonymous with poor, rude and unprofessional customer service, NOT the freedom to speak out your opinions online if you have a bad experience with a business! If you're the owner of a business (and we, the customers, are not giving extra pity if you're a 'small' business...your practices have to be up to par with large businesses just the same!), and you want your business to thrive, it's simple. The formula is something that goes like this for a thriving business:

1. treat your customers as you'd like to be treated

2. attend to your customers, who are about to pay you a lot of money, in a timely manner

3. do not put off answering your customers' opinions, concerns, etc just because you're too 'busy' (sorry, that's no excuse to disregard a customer, and if you're so busy that you can't see a customer, then you shouldn't be taking more than you can handle)

4. do not change the price of your product once you give one

5. treat all customers the same, the ones that you have given service for many years and those that are first timers (otherwise, those first timers will never come back and your recurrent customer pool will decrease...inevitably!)

and last but not least at all:

6. please do not slander the opinions of others who have gotten your service. if you feel unsatisfied with what others are writing about you, your service, your store, etc...you should also take a look at what you are doing. It's hard to self-evaluate but if there are SO many bad reviews for Piece O' Cake, you should definitely start changing a few things around to please your customers better. It is true that everyone should be fair when posting a review. Fair enough. I call everyone to be fair here (that's not a question). But let's also be fair to listen critically to your unsatisfied customers. That's how a good business runs.

Best of luck!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Disguised by the adorable and quaint looking pink exterior on Shrewsbury Avenue in Central New Jersey is a bakeshop owned by Joely Carasia and headed by her husband and baker, Anthony. This delightful faade is simply just, as my visit to this cake shop has been THE worst customer service experience I have had by far. Countless unanswered or returned phone calls and emails, rude staff, inaccurate pricing from a former staff member and shotty-looking decorative work are only few of the deplorable practices of this HORRIBLE business.

For my daughter??s baptism, I had gone in to explain precisely what I had wanted. Yessed to death, I had a cake designer sketch my design and make notes on my preferences. The staff member was rude, absolutely offensive, and talked to me as if I knew all baking and decorating terms assuring me that she fully understood my vision. I was then provided with a quote and was told to later bring in a drawing that I had put together myself.

Upon bringing in the sketch, I was told that the cake would cost twice as much. When I had referred to the cake ??designer? (and I use that term loosely) and her quote already provided, I learned that she was no longer with the bakery. Unwilling to accommodate and make up for their former employee??s mistakes, the owner decided she would not work on keeping to the quoted price for my cake. Their was no compromise whatsoever for her former employee??s miscommunication and she didn??t even leave her office to have the decency in having a conversation with me. I immediately decided to leave and swore to myself that I would share this atrocious experience to all potential and new customers.

In closing, DO NOT head to Piece O?? Cake?their cakes, staff and experience had left nothing but a bad taste in my mouth.

1
★☆☆☆☆

Disguised by the adorable and quaint looking pink exterior on Shrewsbury Avenue in Central New Jersey is a bakeshop owned by Joely Carasia and headed by her husband and baker, Anthony. This delightful faade is simply just, as my visit to this cake shop has been THE worst customer service experience I have had by far. Countless unanswered or returned phone calls and emails, rude staff, inaccurate pricing from a former staff member and shotty-looking decorative work are only few of the deplorable practices of this HORRIBLE business.

For my daughter??s baptism, I had gone in to explain precisely what I had wanted. Yessed to death, I had a cake designer sketch my design and make notes on my preferences. The staff member was rude, absolutely offensive, and talked to me as if I knew all baking and decorating terms assuring me that she fully understood my vision. I was then provided with a quote and was told to later bring in a drawing that I had put together myself.

Upon bringing in the sketch, I was told that the cake would cost twice as much. When I had referred to the cake ??designer? (and I use that term loosely) and her quote already provided, I learned that she was no longer with the bakery. Unwilling to accommodate and make up for their former employee??s mistakes, the owner decided she would not work on keeping to the quoted price for my cake. Their was no compromise whatsoever for her former employee??s miscommunication and she didn??t even leave her office to have the decency in having a conversation with me. I immediately decided to leave and swore to myself that I would share this atrocious experience to all potential and new customers.

In closing, DO NOT head to Piece O?? Cake?their cakes, staff and experience had left nothing but a bad taste in my mouth.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

.

We had Piece O' Cake make our daughters sweet 16. joely was awesome, the cakes were delicious and so gorgeous that it was the hit of the party. My daughter was so amazed and delighted! A must must must have!

5
★★★★★

We had Piece O' Cake make our daughters sweet 16. joely was awesome, the cakes were delicious and so gorgeous that it was the hit of the party. My daughter was so amazed and delighted! A must must must have!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

.

I had heard a few good things about Piece O' Cake. I went to their website a few days before my sons 1st birthday party (FANTASTIC website by the way) to see their designs. I found exactly what I was looking for. I called them and they said they could make the cake with just the few days short notice that I gave them and they emailed me with pricing that evening. I picked up the cake the morning of my sons party and it was the cutest duck cake I've ever seen! We got so many compliments on it. It was absolutely delicious too!!! Highly recommend POC and well worth the money.

5
★★★★★

I had heard a few good things about Piece O' Cake. I went to their website a few days before my sons 1st birthday party (FANTASTIC website by the way) to see their designs. I found exactly what I was looking for. I called them and they said they could make the cake with just the few days short notice that I gave them and they emailed me with pricing that evening. I picked up the cake the morning of my sons party and it was the cutest duck cake I've ever seen! We got so many compliments on it. It was absolutely delicious too!!! Highly recommend POC and well worth the money.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I came upon this website to write a review on Piece o Cake for the absolutely awesome job they had done on our wedding cake. Funny my cake seems somewhat similar to the previous review...and did have to pay an upcharge for..the cake was spectactular! Our cake had a Chinese temple theme to it and was gorgeous. Red fondant with gold accent and cherry blossoms on vines. It was beautiful and delicious. We could not have been happier with the cake and the service! We will be back for any occasion we have!

5
★★★★★

I came upon this website to write a review on Piece o Cake for the absolutely awesome job they had done on our wedding cake. Funny my cake seems somewhat similar to the previous review...and did have to pay an upcharge for..the cake was spectactular! Our cake had a Chinese temple theme to it and was gorgeous. Red fondant with gold accent and cherry blossoms on vines. It was beautiful and delicious. We could not have been happier with the cake and the service! We will be back for any occasion we have!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

I got married at Mcloone's Pier Village and they include the wedding cake in the bridal package. They referred me to POC and I can say I was less than impressed.
The woman was overall unpleasant and in the end more concerned about profit than presentation.
I had a smaller wedding of 60 people and only requiring 3 tiers. I also wanted a design with fondant and some bands at the bases of the tiers with sporadic cherry blossoms. She tried to tell me only buttercream or some other icing was included but not fondant, I would have to pay extra. I also was informed I would have to pay extra for cannoli filling and for the cherry blossom flowers since she hasn't done them. I kept hearing all these buts and cha chings every second so I became fed up and spoke with Mcloones who stated they would pay the difference as I had a couple not be able to attend after.we had all ready reserved them a spot and paid.
The day of the wedding it was raining and my cake showed wet.spots and if you have ever seen fondant sprinkled with water you know it dries darker in spots. The flowers were also very obviously boughten and I had actually seen them listed online for nothing. The bands were also.carelessly placed on the cake so they jaggedly encircled the tiers. The cake itself was no better as I had asked for one layer of chocolate then filling and bottom layer white. The cake was dry and a very thin application of cannoli filling.

I do not know if the person was resentful as I had gotten annoyed at the upcharges for everything for an extremely simple cake or just lack of care about their product.

I do not recommend them to anyone and I recently went elsewhere for my baby shower cake who replicated the chocolate, cannoli, and white cake but it got rave reviews and I was extremely satisfied with the cost, presentation, and taste.

1
★☆☆☆☆

I got married at Mcloone's Pier Village and they include the wedding cake in the bridal package. They referred me to POC and I can say I was less than impressed.
The woman was overall unpleasant and in the end more concerned about profit than presentation.
I had a smaller wedding of 60 people and only requiring 3 tiers. I also wanted a design with fondant and some bands at the bases of the tiers with sporadic cherry blossoms. She tried to tell me only buttercream or some other icing was included but not fondant, I would have to pay extra. I also was informed I would have to pay extra for cannoli filling and for the cherry blossom flowers since she hasn't done them. I kept hearing all these buts and cha chings every second so I became fed up and spoke with Mcloones who stated they would pay the difference as I had a couple not be able to attend after.we had all ready reserved them a spot and paid.
The day of the wedding it was raining and my cake showed wet.spots and if you have ever seen fondant sprinkled with water you know it dries darker in spots. The flowers were also very obviously boughten and I had actually seen them listed online for nothing. The bands were also.carelessly placed on the cake so they jaggedly encircled the tiers. The cake itself was no better as I had asked for one layer of chocolate then filling and bottom layer white. The cake was dry and a very thin application of cannoli filling.

I do not know if the person was resentful as I had gotten annoyed at the upcharges for everything for an extremely simple cake or just lack of care about their product.

I do not recommend them to anyone and I recently went elsewhere for my baby shower cake who replicated the chocolate, cannoli, and white cake but it got rave reviews and I was extremely satisfied with the cost, presentation, and taste.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

.

What an awesome cake we had for my husband's 65th birthday party! I gave them a vague idea and the cake designer did a fabulous job creating it. In addition to looking wonderful the cake was very delicious! If you need a special cake go to Piece O Cake!

5
★★★★★

What an awesome cake we had for my husband's 65th birthday party! I gave them a vague idea and the cake designer did a fabulous job creating it. In addition to looking wonderful the cake was very delicious! If you need a special cake go to Piece O Cake!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Piece O' Cake made my grandsons birthday cake. A 3 dimensional Cars cake. He absolutely loved it. The service and cake were wonderful. The price was well worth it!

5
★★★★★

Piece O' Cake made my grandsons birthday cake. A 3 dimensional Cars cake. He absolutely loved it. The service and cake were wonderful. The price was well worth it!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I have been buying may cake at Piece O' Cake for 17 years. I have always had a positive experience. They are small business that manages to produce a big business product. The cakes are always beautiful and taste delicious. I think people that write these poor reviews are terrible! I am not know by the establishment personally but would say I have witnessed customers that think their party is the only one there is regardless of anyother customers waiting for help. So the people who write these poor reviews need to think of others sometimes rather than their own little world.
I have always enjoyed the cakes I have purchased from Piece O' Cake and will continue to for many years to come

5
★★★★★

I have been buying may cake at Piece O' Cake for 17 years. I have always had a positive experience. They are small business that manages to produce a big business product. The cakes are always beautiful and taste delicious. I think people that write these poor reviews are terrible! I am not know by the establishment personally but would say I have witnessed customers that think their party is the only one there is regardless of anyother customers waiting for help. So the people who write these poor reviews need to think of others sometimes rather than their own little world.
I have always enjoyed the cakes I have purchased from Piece O' Cake and will continue to for many years to come

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

There appears to be a disconnect between the people taking the orders and the people making the cakes. Ordered a birthday cake for my son and was told that they would contact me the next day to confirm that they could make my special request. They didn't call. I called the next day to make sure that I would have a cake for his birthday and they told me that they had the order and would make the cake. In general the cake tasted good. However, the filling was not what I requested and they spelled my son's name wrong. For what they are charging, they could at least take the time to listen to what the customer tells them when an order is placed. I can't recommend a business that either doesn't really care or is just careless. I am not surprised that they required cash payment and took the money before showing me the cake. Bad business.

2
★★☆☆☆

There appears to be a disconnect between the people taking the orders and the people making the cakes. Ordered a birthday cake for my son and was told that they would contact me the next day to confirm that they could make my special request. They didn't call. I called the next day to make sure that I would have a cake for his birthday and they told me that they had the order and would make the cake. In general the cake tasted good. However, the filling was not what I requested and they spelled my son's name wrong. For what they are charging, they could at least take the time to listen to what the customer tells them when an order is placed. I can't recommend a business that either doesn't really care or is just careless. I am not surprised that they required cash payment and took the money before showing me the cake. Bad business.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

Wedding: I had a difficult time getting someone from Piece O Cake to talk to me. I called and left them two messages. Then I called and finally spoke to a hurried receptionist who said the lady would call me back between 4 and 5pm. She did not. I then called the next day and spoke with someone who said the lady would call me back between 12 and 1pm that day. She never did. I called again and the girl swore that the lady did in fact call me but wasn't able to get through. She said she that she called both my cell and home number but neither work. I'm sorry but I don't buy that. The girl then said that she would e-mail me. I waited for her e-mail for a week. Finally, after getting in touch with her I was pretty sure that she knew what I wanted. The cupcakes were dry and tasteless. The icing was completely wrong. I was embarrassed to have them served to my wedding guests.

2
★★☆☆☆

Wedding: I had a difficult time getting someone from Piece O Cake to talk to me. I called and left them two messages. Then I called and finally spoke to a hurried receptionist who said the lady would call me back between 4 and 5pm. She did not. I then called the next day and spoke with someone who said the lady would call me back between 12 and 1pm that day. She never did. I called again and the girl swore that the lady did in fact call me but wasn't able to get through. She said she that she called both my cell and home number but neither work. I'm sorry but I don't buy that. The girl then said that she would e-mail me. I waited for her e-mail for a week. Finally, after getting in touch with her I was pretty sure that she knew what I wanted. The cupcakes were dry and tasteless. The icing was completely wrong. I was embarrassed to have them served to my wedding guests.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

I went to Piece O' Cake for my wedding cake and they were wonderful from the first call. They were very accomodating and helpful..and provided us with an amazing cake that people have been asking for more for the last 3 years. We are expecting our first baby and will be there for all our childrens cakes.

5
★★★★★

I went to Piece O' Cake for my wedding cake and they were wonderful from the first call. They were very accomodating and helpful..and provided us with an amazing cake that people have been asking for more for the last 3 years. We are expecting our first baby and will be there for all our childrens cakes.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

I love these cakes, but I'm really old fashioned and enjoy a cake topper as well. If anyone is looking for something to top their anniversary cake with you really should check out www.anniversarygiftideasforu. I really like how the personalized anniversary cake topper can be customized for any year celebrated. : )

5
★★★★★

I love these cakes, but I'm really old fashioned and enjoy a cake topper as well. If anyone is looking for something to top their anniversary cake with you really should check out www.anniversarygiftideasforu. I really like how the personalized anniversary cake topper can be customized for any year celebrated. : )

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

I booked an appointment with Piece O' Cake for my wedding cake..and from the first called realized how great they were. The young girl who answered the phone was polite and helpful. Then we met with the owner for our cake who was awesome and very funny. She helped us feel so sure of our cake. The wedding cake was an amazing hit!

5
★★★★★

I booked an appointment with Piece O' Cake for my wedding cake..and from the first called realized how great they were. The young girl who answered the phone was polite and helpful. Then we met with the owner for our cake who was awesome and very funny. She helped us feel so sure of our cake. The wedding cake was an amazing hit!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Piece O Cake did my wedding in October of 2009..and what a hit! I have never heard so many compliments on a wedding cake in my life. They were a pleasure to work with from the time we made the first call!

5
★★★★★

Piece O Cake did my wedding in October of 2009..and what a hit! I have never heard so many compliments on a wedding cake in my life. They were a pleasure to work with from the time we made the first call!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

They took my money $65 for my 2 year olds special wiggles cake order. They would not take credit cards and out of state checks which should have been my red flag alone that this company has had issues before. They did not deliver as promised and as of today has not responded to my emails or phone calls. It's people like this that give NJ a bad name.

1
★☆☆☆☆

They took my money $65 for my 2 year olds special wiggles cake order. They would not take credit cards and out of state checks which should have been my red flag alone that this company has had issues before. They did not deliver as promised and as of today has not responded to my emails or phone calls. It's people like this that give NJ a bad name.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

.

Piece O' Cake did a fabulous job on our wedding cake. It was beautiful, exactly as represented and tasted good, too! This was a wonderful, stress-free experience, and I recommend these folks without reservation.

3
★★★☆☆

Piece O' Cake did a fabulous job on our wedding cake. It was beautiful, exactly as represented and tasted good, too! This was a wonderful, stress-free experience, and I recommend these folks without reservation.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

A highlight of our daughter's wedding at Windows on the Water was the amazing cake provided by Piece O' Cake. The guests said it was the best they ever tasted at a wedding. It was beautifully decorated with a nautical design and tasted so delicious! They provided a cake tasting prior to ordering, and a free one year anniversary cake!

5
★★★★★

A highlight of our daughter's wedding at Windows on the Water was the amazing cake provided by Piece O' Cake. The guests said it was the best they ever tasted at a wedding. It was beautifully decorated with a nautical design and tasted so delicious! They provided a cake tasting prior to ordering, and a free one year anniversary cake!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

My Wife and I used Piece O Cake for our June 8th wedding. We chose cake #74, a three-tiered chocolate cake with cannoli filing and buttercream icing. It was literally the best cake we've ever had. The presentation was incredibly artistic as well! We would HIGHLY recommend them!

5
★★★★★

My Wife and I used Piece O Cake for our June 8th wedding. We chose cake #74, a three-tiered chocolate cake with cannoli filing and buttercream icing. It was literally the best cake we've ever had. The presentation was incredibly artistic as well! We would HIGHLY recommend them!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I usually make my own cakes, but this time (for a friend's birthday party thrown by me) I wanted something more special and much more professional. I'd heard about Piece O' Cake from a friend who'd used them for a Communion cake. I'm so glad I did it because they did a beautiful job and it was really good cake, too.

2
★★★★★

I usually make my own cakes, but this time (for a friend's birthday party thrown by me) I wanted something more special and much more professional. I'd heard about Piece O' Cake from a friend who'd used them for a Communion cake. I'm so glad I did it because they did a beautiful job and it was really good cake, too.

.

I have used Piece O' Cake for many occasions and many years. I would trust them with any occasion in any season. My daughters wedding cake was absolutely destroyed by the place hosting the wedding. Piece O' Cake was called in to repair the disaster 1 hour before the cocktail hour began. They not only repaired the cake, but my daughter had no idea of the disaster that had occurred b/c of someones negligence. The saved her day, so I can not recommend them enough! They have always come through for our occasions

5
★★★★★

I have used Piece O' Cake for many occasions and many years. I would trust them with any occasion in any season. My daughters wedding cake was absolutely destroyed by the place hosting the wedding. Piece O' Cake was called in to repair the disaster 1 hour before the cocktail hour began. They not only repaired the cake, but my daughter had no idea of the disaster that had occurred b/c of someones negligence. The saved her day, so I can not recommend them enough! They have always come through for our occasions

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

My wife and I used Piece O' Cake for our wedding in 2005. I threw my wife a party this month (March '08) and per her request, we wanted to use them again for the same type of cake - cannoli filling - and they responded well! Granted, they are busy, and Lydia seemed "harried" at times - but all-in-all, she was courteous and helpful. I even expressed concern about some of the other negative reviews that they had received recently - but she informed me that it was due to a person that was no longer there. She assured me that I could count on them - and she was right. I totally recommend them for all occasions.

4
★★★★☆

My wife and I used Piece O' Cake for our wedding in 2005. I threw my wife a party this month (March '08) and per her request, we wanted to use them again for the same type of cake - cannoli filling - and they responded well! Granted, they are busy, and Lydia seemed "harried" at times - but all-in-all, she was courteous and helpful. I even expressed concern about some of the other negative reviews that they had received recently - but she informed me that it was due to a person that was no longer there. She assured me that I could count on them - and she was right. I totally recommend them for all occasions.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I have known the proprietors for years and they have always exceeded my expectations. For anyone who has expressed a legitimate gripe about a poor experience there in the past, it's worth it to go back b/c the source of the problem has been removed!

5
★★★★★

I have known the proprietors for years and they have always exceeded my expectations. For anyone who has expressed a legitimate gripe about a poor experience there in the past, it's worth it to go back b/c the source of the problem has been removed!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I used them for our wedding cake this fall & although they got the filling correct the design we picked out was not correct. She got a portion of it right but not the rest. The top was correct but the details around the rest of the tiers was not. We also picked out 2 different shades of ivory & they created it with one. She was friendly in person but over the phone they are so quick to get you off, so it does not surprise me that they screw things up, they dont pay much attention to detail.

3
★★★☆☆

I used them for our wedding cake this fall & although they got the filling correct the design we picked out was not correct. She got a portion of it right but not the rest. The top was correct but the details around the rest of the tiers was not. We also picked out 2 different shades of ivory & they created it with one. She was friendly in person but over the phone they are so quick to get you off, so it does not surprise me that they screw things up, they dont pay much attention to detail.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We are new in town and planning a anniversary celebration for my in-laws. Per a recommendation, I called to make arrangements to have a cake made. I was rudely told they were to busy to fill my order for a cake that would serve a small crowd (15). When I asked for another recommendation, the woman told me to go to a grocery store & pick one out. Her condescending tone & total lack of professionalism has resolved this new Red Bank resident to never call them again. I'll be sure to share this incident with others.

1
★☆☆☆☆

We are new in town and planning a anniversary celebration for my in-laws. Per a recommendation, I called to make arrangements to have a cake made. I was rudely told they were to busy to fill my order for a cake that would serve a small crowd (15). When I asked for another recommendation, the woman told me to go to a grocery store & pick one out. Her condescending tone & total lack of professionalism has resolved this new Red Bank resident to never call them again. I'll be sure to share this incident with others.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

Piece O' Cake far exceeded our expectations on our wedding cake. The taste and look were absolutely fabulous. I would recommend them to anyone getting married or for any other occasion. Kudos!

5
★★★★★

Piece O' Cake far exceeded our expectations on our wedding cake. The taste and look were absolutely fabulous. I would recommend them to anyone getting married or for any other occasion. Kudos!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I called and ordered a cake and 3 dozen cupcakes and spoke with them 3 different times to verify. On the day of my son's baby blessing, I shown up to pick up my cake and they had NO ORDER!?!? We chatted afew times to go over the blue flowers and balloons on the cake and cupcakes but on saturday the 11th of august not only did they not have my order but could have cared less that they left me high and dry with no cake for the blessing. I gave my number and asked to have someone call me back to discuss but NEVER heard back. VERY poor business practice. I told all my neighbors never to use again and am in the process of contacting better business bureau. TOTAL disgrace!!!

1
★☆☆☆☆

I called and ordered a cake and 3 dozen cupcakes and spoke with them 3 different times to verify. On the day of my son's baby blessing, I shown up to pick up my cake and they had NO ORDER!?!? We chatted afew times to go over the blue flowers and balloons on the cake and cupcakes but on saturday the 11th of august not only did they not have my order but could have cared less that they left me high and dry with no cake for the blessing. I gave my number and asked to have someone call me back to discuss but NEVER heard back. VERY poor business practice. I told all my neighbors never to use again and am in the process of contacting better business bureau. TOTAL disgrace!!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

used POC for our wedding last summer. ordered raspberry mousse, but when we cut into the cake, it was raspberry jelly- which we didnt like nearly as much. Additioanlly, the cake didnt look nearly as attractive as the pics. we were shown.

2
★★☆☆☆

used POC for our wedding last summer. ordered raspberry mousse, but when we cut into the cake, it was raspberry jelly- which we didnt like nearly as much. Additioanlly, the cake didnt look nearly as attractive as the pics. we were shown.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

Totally lacking in phone manners and completely unable to answer basic price and design questions. Even after I told them that I had purchased my wedding cake there, they still weren't gracious or willing to help. I was told to call back in a few weeks! I think I'll just call somebody else.

1
★☆☆☆☆

Totally lacking in phone manners and completely unable to answer basic price and design questions. Even after I told them that I had purchased my wedding cake there, they still weren't gracious or willing to help. I was told to call back in a few weeks! I think I'll just call somebody else.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

This vendor was included in our wedding package at the Old Orchard Manor. About two months before the wedding, we went to the cake shop to pick out the style of cake. They had several books of designs to choose from. I liked different elements of a few cakes and they were able to mix and match to make the cake of my dreams. I had chocolate with chocolate filling- can you tell that I love chocolate! We received many compliments on the cake at the wedding. On our one year anniversary, I called the cake shop to order a replica of the top tier (since we ate ours the day after the wedding) to be delivered as a surprise for my husband. They were so helpful and didn't even charge me for the cake. I would recommend them to anyone

5
★★★★★

This vendor was included in our wedding package at the Old Orchard Manor. About two months before the wedding, we went to the cake shop to pick out the style of cake. They had several books of designs to choose from. I liked different elements of a few cakes and they were able to mix and match to make the cake of my dreams. I had chocolate with chocolate filling- can you tell that I love chocolate! We received many compliments on the cake at the wedding. On our one year anniversary, I called the cake shop to order a replica of the top tier (since we ate ours the day after the wedding) to be delivered as a surprise for my husband. They were so helpful and didn't even charge me for the cake. I would recommend them to anyone

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Piece O' Cake, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review