Athenian Garden

★★★★☆
  • 619 S New York Rd

    Galloway, NJ 08205

    Map & Directions
  • 609-748-1818

About Athenian Garden

Hours
Mon. - Sun. 5pm - 10pm

Food

Food
More choices in Galloway:
Resultset_next

Tommy's Diner

914 W Broad St Columbus, AR

Resultset_next

Dan's Drive In

1881 S High St Columbus, AR

4.1111 9
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Athenian Garden was?
Write a Review
.

I expected to have good traditional Greek food...I was disappointed .....the falafel was as hard and overcooked as a "hockey puck" and the salad was quite tasteless...little seasoning. I had to ask for organ...no garlic flavor

3
★★★★★

I expected to have good traditional Greek food...I was disappointed .....the falafel was as hard and overcooked as a "hockey puck" and the salad was quite tasteless...little seasoning. I had to ask for organ...no garlic flavor

.

My husband and I ate here on vacation. It was some of the best Greek food I've ever had. The owners were very nice and hospitable as well.

4
★★★★☆

My husband and I ate here on vacation. It was some of the best Greek food I've ever had. The owners were very nice and hospitable as well.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Very good! Would recommend to anyone having a taste for Greek cuisine. Went there last week with our supper club and was very impressed with the extensive menu. Even had items for one of our members who doesn't venture into foods she isn't familiar with (chicken, chicken, and more chicken!). Two of us shared traditional appetizers - stuffed grapeleaves and spinach/feta in phylo - which were excellent! Main dinner was slow in coming, but after the appetizers we were glad for the break. Well worth waiting for! I had the moussaka and just thinking about is making me yearn for it again! Desserts were wonderful - one friend and I shared a custardy concoction which was not as sweet as the usual baked custard creations elsewhere. Very good! Will definitely revisit!

4
★★★★☆

Very good! Would recommend to anyone having a taste for Greek cuisine. Went there last week with our supper club and was very impressed with the extensive menu. Even had items for one of our members who doesn't venture into foods she isn't familiar with (chicken, chicken, and more chicken!). Two of us shared traditional appetizers - stuffed grapeleaves and spinach/feta in phylo - which were excellent! Main dinner was slow in coming, but after the appetizers we were glad for the break. Well worth waiting for! I had the moussaka and just thinking about is making me yearn for it again! Desserts were wonderful - one friend and I shared a custardy concoction which was not as sweet as the usual baked custard creations elsewhere. Very good! Will definitely revisit!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This place has great Greek food. Their wraps are fantastic. If you like Greek salads, you'll want to try theirs. They have a special Spinach and Feta cheese omelet that's to die for.

4
★★★★☆

This place has great Greek food. Their wraps are fantastic. If you like Greek salads, you'll want to try theirs. They have a special Spinach and Feta cheese omelet that's to die for.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We've been there a few times in the past year, always great food! We usually have the same server, he has always been friendly and helpful with questions about the menu.
My teenager loves it too!

2
★★★★★

We've been there a few times in the past year, always great food! We usually have the same server, he has always been friendly and helpful with questions about the menu.
My teenager loves it too!

Pros: Food - BYO

Cons: Closes fairly early

.

I eat at this restaurant frequently and cannot say I have ever had a bad meal. Everything is fresh and prepared to order. The food is authentic and delicious. The wait staff is both curtious and friendly. I would recommend the restaurant for anyone looking for a good meal. Dinner does take a bit of time, however, your meal is cooked to order and not prepared so it is worth the wait.

2
★★★★★

I eat at this restaurant frequently and cannot say I have ever had a bad meal. Everything is fresh and prepared to order. The food is authentic and delicious. The wait staff is both curtious and friendly. I would recommend the restaurant for anyone looking for a good meal. Dinner does take a bit of time, however, your meal is cooked to order and not prepared so it is worth the wait.

.

Very delicious and authentic Greek food. Better than expected.
The lamb dishes were excellent as was the rabbit stew (stifado)... all made very traditionally.

Service was friendly. Appetizers were served in a timely manner. Entrees could have been served a little faster; however, it's possible that the chosen entrees take more time to prepare such as the braised lamb.

Price was higher than expected. It was pricier than the Greek restaurants of Queens, NY. Other than the price, I would have given this a 5 star.

4
★★★★☆

Very delicious and authentic Greek food. Better than expected.
The lamb dishes were excellent as was the rabbit stew (stifado)... all made very traditionally.

Service was friendly. Appetizers were served in a timely manner. Entrees could have been served a little faster; however, it's possible that the chosen entrees take more time to prepare such as the braised lamb.

Price was higher than expected. It was pricier than the Greek restaurants of Queens, NY. Other than the price, I would have given this a 5 star.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

By reading the first review for this restaurant, it made me decide to go to this restaurant because the review told me this would be a very authentic Greek restaurant with delicious food. Evidently, previous customer must never have been to a Greek restaurant to know what to order. Owners must have thought that they were wasting their time.

The food was made very traditional and very delicious. Entrees are rarely found in other restaurants which makes this restaurant unique in what they prepare.

I must say it was a little pricier than I expected because the prices of the entrees were higher than those in Greek restaurants of Queens, NY.

Another drawback, for some, is that liquor is not served. This could be good since you can bring your own and save money that way and have your favorite wine.

I don't think any of the entrees would appeal to children.

2
★★★★☆

By reading the first review for this restaurant, it made me decide to go to this restaurant because the review told me this would be a very authentic Greek restaurant with delicious food. Evidently, previous customer must never have been to a Greek restaurant to know what to order. Owners must have thought that they were wasting their time.

The food was made very traditional and very delicious. Entrees are rarely found in other restaurants which makes this restaurant unique in what they prepare.

I must say it was a little pricier than I expected because the prices of the entrees were higher than those in Greek restaurants of Queens, NY.

Another drawback, for some, is that liquor is not served. This could be good since you can bring your own and save money that way and have your favorite wine.

I don't think any of the entrees would appeal to children.

Pros: very delicious and unique entrees, which are prepared in traditional Greek homes

Cons: SLIGHTLY high prices on the entrees

.

The Waiter took our order for a $16 appetizer incld extra pita,and received it. As we were asking ?'s about the menu, the waiter was getting aggravated.So he came 2 take our dinner order and we decided that the menu didn't appeal 2 us,nor him,that we will just eat the appetizers.He storms off, and a min. later the mang. comes and says
Rudely:Is this all your going 2 order?We said yes,that we couldn't find anythingelse.She reply's then U should of read the menu 1st,and I'm going 2 have to ask U to move to another table.That people R waiting 4 resv. and we cant sit here.So basically she was telling us to leave so I said we will just take it 2 go,she grabs the dish,the waiter hands the food backwards 2 us going out the door and on top of it charges us a $3 tip on the bill.

0
★☆☆☆☆

The Waiter took our order for a $16 appetizer incld extra pita,and received it. As we were asking ?'s about the menu, the waiter was getting aggravated.So he came 2 take our dinner order and we decided that the menu didn't appeal 2 us,nor him,that we will just eat the appetizers.He storms off, and a min. later the mang. comes and says
Rudely:Is this all your going 2 order?We said yes,that we couldn't find anythingelse.She reply's then U should of read the menu 1st,and I'm going 2 have to ask U to move to another table.That people R waiting 4 resv. and we cant sit here.So basically she was telling us to leave so I said we will just take it 2 go,she grabs the dish,the waiter hands the food backwards 2 us going out the door and on top of it charges us a $3 tip on the bill.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Athenian Garden, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review