Mister Pizza

★★★★☆
  • 1065 Elmwood Ave

    Buffalo, NY 14222

    Map & Directions
  • 716-882-6500

About Mister Pizza

Hours
Sun-Thu 10am-12am, Fri-Sat 10am-1am

Food

Food
More choices in Buffalo:
Resultset_next

Happy Joe's Pizza & Ice Cream

1414 W Locust St Davenport, CA

Resultset_next

Antonella's Ristorante & Pizza

112 W 3rd St Davenport, CA

4.2222 18
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Mister Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

This use to be my favorite pizza place but in the last 6 months the food and service has slipped. the last 5-10 times i ordered for delivery... it comes very late and the food is ice cold and the drivers should be cleaner. I always have to

3
★★★★★

This use to be my favorite pizza place but in the last 6 months the food and service has slipped. the last 5-10 times i ordered for delivery... it comes very late and the food is ice cold and the drivers should be cleaner. I always have to

.

Every time I order from Mister Pizza the food is fantastic! I cannot complain about the quality of the food at all. However, the staff is rather rude. They are always rushing me off the phone. No hello's, please, thank you. Last time I went to pick up my order there were about four or five guys working. Each one of them walked past me several times before I was eventually acknowledged. Good food, but they need to have more polite staff. Bad service leaves a sour taste in the mouth.

3
★★★☆☆

Every time I order from Mister Pizza the food is fantastic! I cannot complain about the quality of the food at all. However, the staff is rather rude. They are always rushing me off the phone. No hello's, please, thank you. Last time I went to pick up my order there were about four or five guys working. Each one of them walked past me several times before I was eventually acknowledged. Good food, but they need to have more polite staff. Bad service leaves a sour taste in the mouth.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

i have been ordering mister pizza for a few years and never had a bad experience with the staff or a "special" order. i have had some inconsistencies in the past with the way certain pizzas are made - specifically the broccoli and ricotta pizza - which when initially ordered was perfect and addicting, but upon 2 other recent tries (new staff?) it was soggy and made with entirely too much ricotta. but previous experience dictates that the staff is patient, delivery prompt, and orders correct.

2
★★★★★

i have been ordering mister pizza for a few years and never had a bad experience with the staff or a "special" order. i have had some inconsistencies in the past with the way certain pizzas are made - specifically the broccoli and ricotta pizza - which when initially ordered was perfect and addicting, but upon 2 other recent tries (new staff?) it was soggy and made with entirely too much ricotta. but previous experience dictates that the staff is patient, delivery prompt, and orders correct.

Pros: good prices, food and service

Cons: some inconsistency

.

listen they dont tell anyone this but they rather take a bum off the street instead of a person that has experiance.listen mr pizza i worked for lanovas and there pizza and wings beat u and just pizza food u guys take forever to deliver and when the food get there the food is always cold and sloppy.i tried working for u guys but u guys said that i have to many years of exoperiance and that i woukld put your staff to shame.sorry for u guys thats why you guys will never be like lanovas.lanovas food is always goos and hot when it gets deliver and our customers love us your customers come to lanovas and they are always satified.last but least our dining room is better than any dining room i've seen we have tv's for our customers and we take pride in opur customers.our customers are our family.lanovas are number 1.the reat are number 10.lol

0
★☆☆☆☆

listen they dont tell anyone this but they rather take a bum off the street instead of a person that has experiance.listen mr pizza i worked for lanovas and there pizza and wings beat u and just pizza food u guys take forever to deliver and when the food get there the food is always cold and sloppy.i tried working for u guys but u guys said that i have to many years of exoperiance and that i woukld put your staff to shame.sorry for u guys thats why you guys will never be like lanovas.lanovas food is always goos and hot when it gets deliver and our customers love us your customers come to lanovas and they are always satified.last but least our dining room is better than any dining room i've seen we have tv's for our customers and we take pride in opur customers.our customers are our family.lanovas are number 1.the reat are number 10.lol

Pros: there food stinks and there staff stinks also

Cons: there sauce comes from a can

.

Mr.Pizza is good but not that good. First if you get delivery expect to get that order no earlier than a hour and a half. The price of there food doesnt match the quality. Ever since they moved to elmwood from hampshire the quality has declined. If you get a order delivered and it comes wrong expect another hour and a half at least before you see a replacement. Also the wings are good sometimes and sometimes there just cooked enough not crispy, soggy, Other times there perfect. But when you pay $30 for a large pizza and wings delivered it should be good every single time. When I am in the neighborhood I usually walk in a get a slice to go, because for some reason there pizza they sell for slices are always better than what you would order.

1
★★★☆☆

Mr.Pizza is good but not that good. First if you get delivery expect to get that order no earlier than a hour and a half. The price of there food doesnt match the quality. Ever since they moved to elmwood from hampshire the quality has declined. If you get a order delivered and it comes wrong expect another hour and a half at least before you see a replacement. Also the wings are good sometimes and sometimes there just cooked enough not crispy, soggy, Other times there perfect. But when you pay $30 for a large pizza and wings delivered it should be good every single time. When I am in the neighborhood I usually walk in a get a slice to go, because for some reason there pizza they sell for slices are always better than what you would order.

Pros: Good food sometimes

Cons: delivery takes way to long

.

Mister Pizza has consistently good food .When I am in the Elmwood area I always make sure to stop in for a pizza or wings to take home. Parking is easy .

4
★★★★☆

Mister Pizza has consistently good food .When I am in the Elmwood area I always make sure to stop in for a pizza or wings to take home. Parking is easy .

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

If you are from the real NY (NYC, eastern NY and even NJ and CT) and are looking for our pizza, don't waste your time or money at Mr. Pizza with the NY style pizza. It tastes like all the other crappy pizza over here. Doughy, saucey, with weird cheese...I'm dying for some real pizza, I got all exicted when i saw they had a NY style one...oh well...If you're looking...so far the best I've had over here is La Rosa's pizza at the mall on Transit...not perfect but closest so far...

0
★☆☆☆☆

If you are from the real NY (NYC, eastern NY and even NJ and CT) and are looking for our pizza, don't waste your time or money at Mr. Pizza with the NY style pizza. It tastes like all the other crappy pizza over here. Doughy, saucey, with weird cheese...I'm dying for some real pizza, I got all exicted when i saw they had a NY style one...oh well...If you're looking...so far the best I've had over here is La Rosa's pizza at the mall on Transit...not perfect but closest so far...

Pros: Pleasant service

Cons: non-NY, NY style pizza

.

Mr Pizza stands out as having a consistently good pizza, It's always fresh and they use great ingrediants. In a city chock full of great pizza, this is always one of the best.

5
★★★★★

Mr Pizza stands out as having a consistently good pizza, It's always fresh and they use great ingrediants. In a city chock full of great pizza, this is always one of the best.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Always a good pie at Mister Pizza. In a town with lots of great Pizza, this is always one of the best.

2
★★★★★

Always a good pie at Mister Pizza. In a town with lots of great Pizza, this is always one of the best.

.

While they are pricey the pizza makes up for it, best pizza in Buffalo in my opinion wheter you get a full pizza or just slices it is wonderful.

2
★★★★★

While they are pricey the pizza makes up for it, best pizza in Buffalo in my opinion wheter you get a full pizza or just slices it is wonderful.

.

The pizza is awesome!!! More expensive than other smaller pie places, but always wonderful and worth your dollars if you have enough. Better service and cheaper that the other 2 large pizza shops in Buffalo.

2
★★★★★

The pizza is awesome!!! More expensive than other smaller pie places, but always wonderful and worth your dollars if you have enough. Better service and cheaper that the other 2 large pizza shops in Buffalo.

Pros: Chicken finger pizza, garlic sesame crust

Cons: Not cheap

.

The great service at MISTER PIZZA is only surpassed by the great food. Pizza's are incredible, wings are very good. BBQ pit wings are the best in town. There are tons of pizzas to choose from, one is better than the next.

2
★★★★★

The great service at MISTER PIZZA is only surpassed by the great food. Pizza's are incredible, wings are very good. BBQ pit wings are the best in town. There are tons of pizzas to choose from, one is better than the next.

Pros: location, service, delivery available

Cons: none

.

The best Pizza ever. Best in Buffalo, Chicago, NC, NYC, Best Pizza period. Great Chicken finger pizza, steak pizza, all are great. You pay a little more, but the quality is the best. Have had the chicken fingers and boneless wings, chicken wings, and several other items. All very good. Subs are average, Pizza is GREAT.

2
★★★★★

The best Pizza ever. Best in Buffalo, Chicago, NC, NYC, Best Pizza period. Great Chicken finger pizza, steak pizza, all are great. You pay a little more, but the quality is the best. Have had the chicken fingers and boneless wings, chicken wings, and several other items. All very good. Subs are average, Pizza is GREAT.

.

i spent 35 out of my 41 yrs in buffalo and visted a few months ago no ones pizza is close to being as good.i live in north carolina now nothing compares.i only have positive things to say about mister pizza,i drive the 900 miles sometimes just to get a good pizza pie and visit

2
★★★★★

i spent 35 out of my 41 yrs in buffalo and visted a few months ago no ones pizza is close to being as good.i live in north carolina now nothing compares.i only have positive things to say about mister pizza,i drive the 900 miles sometimes just to get a good pizza pie and visit

Pros: ingredients, serving portions, taste

.

Execellent recipe, ingredients and the cleanest restaurant in town. If the Sopranos was a sit-com this is what it would be like.

2
★★★★★

Execellent recipe, ingredients and the cleanest restaurant in town. If the Sopranos was a sit-com this is what it would be like.

Pros: Clean, Top ingredients, Great Delivery

Cons: Costly, Busy, order mistakes

.

Mister Pizza has a great selection of pizza. My favorite is the BBQ chicken pizza. Their crust can get a bit crunchy though. Otherwise it is very good pizza.

2
★★★★☆

Mister Pizza has a great selection of pizza. My favorite is the BBQ chicken pizza. Their crust can get a bit crunchy though. Otherwise it is very good pizza.

Pros: Great variety

.

Mister Pizza has the closest pizza to ny pizza. It is so good I wish I could have it everyday. But I don't have that kind of money. If you want good pizza I mean good pizza go to Mister Pizzas

2
★★★★★

Mister Pizza has the closest pizza to ny pizza. It is so good I wish I could have it everyday. But I don't have that kind of money. If you want good pizza I mean good pizza go to Mister Pizzas

Pros: pizza, Subs, gormet pizza

Cons: no dine in

.

they have very good pizza and the delivery service is good.

2
★★★★☆

they have very good pizza and the delivery service is good.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Mister Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review