Angus' Cafe Bistro

★★★★★
Broadway's most popular hangout for Lunch and Dinner
  • 258 W 44th St

    New York, NY 10036

    Map & Directions
  • 212-221-9222

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

The Sea Grill

19 W 49th St New York, NY

Resultset_next

Blue Ribbon Bakery & Cafe

35 Downing St New York, NY

5 19
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Angus' Cafe Bistro was?
Write a Review
.

Smack dab in the middle of the theatre district. We had a private party on their 3rd floor with excellent heavy hors d'oevres.

4
★★★★☆

Smack dab in the middle of the theatre district. We had a private party on their 3rd floor with excellent heavy hors d'oevres.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This is a charming restaurant perfect for theater and dining out. Excellent food and reasonable specials make this a great pick. The staff is friendly and they do nott rush you. Fine dining and a show--can't be beat!

5
★★★★★

This is a charming restaurant perfect for theater and dining out. Excellent food and reasonable specials make this a great pick. The staff is friendly and they do nott rush you. Fine dining and a show--can't be beat!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Went for lunch pre-theatre today and had a wonderful meal. The wild mushroom lasagna is fantastic as is the calamari appetizer. Service was excellent. We'll be going back. Love this place.

3
★★★★★

Went for lunch pre-theatre today and had a wonderful meal. The wild mushroom lasagna is fantastic as is the calamari appetizer. Service was excellent. We'll be going back. Love this place.

Pros: Food, Service, Parking

.

Split the Porterhouse steak with a buddy of mine post theatre and the meal was outstanding. The atmosphere was really alive, as well. We were able to choose from one of their three floors and settled on the third floor because of the

3
★★★★★

Split the Porterhouse steak with a buddy of mine post theatre and the meal was outstanding. The atmosphere was really alive, as well. We were able to choose from one of their three floors and settled on the third floor because of the

Pros: Food, ambience

.

At first I was wondering if I ate at the same Angus McIndoe Restaruant as these other people. Then it dawned on me. All these reviews read kind of the same..."new chef", "really cool waitstaff", "best at 8pm", "Great mushroom lasagna

3
★★★★★

At first I was wondering if I ate at the same Angus McIndoe Restaruant as these other people. Then it dawned on me. All these reviews read kind of the same..."new chef", "really cool waitstaff", "best at 8pm", "Great mushroom lasagna

Pros: convenient midtown location

Cons: the food and the service

.

So, this place is totally the pre/post threatre hangout of the minute, but worth it anytime. The staff are mostly actors ( so what else is new?), except they are the kind of actors that listen to cool music (more than likely, one of their

3
★★★★★

So, this place is totally the pre/post threatre hangout of the minute, but worth it anytime. The staff are mostly actors ( so what else is new?), except they are the kind of actors that listen to cool music (more than likely, one of their

Pros: Service, food, celebrity-watch

Cons: busy at pre-theatre

.

Had an amazing brunch here last weekend and the waiter mentioned a house specialty offered after 8pm of a porterhouse steak for 2 which is served with unlimited house wine. We had friends visiting so decided to go back and give it a try.

3
★★★★★

Had an amazing brunch here last weekend and the waiter mentioned a house specialty offered after 8pm of a porterhouse steak for 2 which is served with unlimited house wine. We had friends visiting so decided to go back and give it a try.

Pros: service, eclectic menu

.

I recently went to Angus's on a weeknight around maybe 8:30. I hadn't been there since late February or so and WOW what a difference. I loved the food before but now (and apparently the new chef David just got started a few months ago)

3
★★★★★

I recently went to Angus's on a weeknight around maybe 8:30. I hadn't been there since late February or so and WOW what a difference. I loved the food before but now (and apparently the new chef David just got started a few months ago)

.

I agree with a lot of the other reviews here. The restaurant itself was classic and lovely. On a beautiful summer evening, we sat by the open doors looking out at the theaters opposite. Our waiter was knowledgeable, helpful, and

3
★★★★★

I agree with a lot of the other reviews here. The restaurant itself was classic and lovely. On a beautiful summer evening, we sat by the open doors looking out at the theaters opposite. Our waiter was knowledgeable, helpful, and

.

I see all of these wonderful reviews and wonder what went wrong with mine.

Our server was friendly enough, but he never brought any bread after he offered it and I had to catch him so I could get a drink refill as it sat empty all

3
★★★★★

I see all of these wonderful reviews and wonder what went wrong with mine.

Our server was friendly enough, but he never brought any bread after he offered it and I had to catch him so I could get a drink refill as it sat empty all

Cons: Not Handmade Food!

.

I dont another place of this food quality and abidance in the Theatre District let alone in all of NY for the price. Food is great but you better make a reservation. I have been there many times and have never been let down. The best

3
★★★★★

I dont another place of this food quality and abidance in the Theatre District let alone in all of NY for the price. Food is great but you better make a reservation. I have been there many times and have never been let down. The best

.

I have been to this restaurant a total of three times and each time has been better than the last. Most recently I hosted a birthday dinner there and it was fabulous. Requested and received a round table for ten people on the mezzanine

3
★★★★★

I have been to this restaurant a total of three times and each time has been better than the last. Most recently I hosted a birthday dinner there and it was fabulous. Requested and received a round table for ten people on the mezzanine

Pros: Good Food, Excellent Service, Good Value

.

If you're going to see "The Producers" this is the pre-theatre spot ... right next door, literally, to the St. James. Good service, excellent food, and a nice atmosphere. A little crowded but the spirits are good, so who cares? Well

3
★★★★★

If you're going to see "The Producers" this is the pre-theatre spot ... right next door, literally, to the St. James. Good service, excellent food, and a nice atmosphere. A little crowded but the spirits are good, so who cares? Well

Pros: value, service, location

Cons: a little crowded

.

We dined here last weekend before we saw "Avenue Q", one block over. We had such a great experience, we'll definitely be back! The food was delicious, the service spectacular and the prices extremely reasonable, especially for midtown.

3
★★★★★

We dined here last weekend before we saw "Avenue Q", one block over. We had such a great experience, we'll definitely be back! The food was delicious, the service spectacular and the prices extremely reasonable, especially for midtown.

Pros: delicious food, nice waiters, not touristy

Cons: cramped dining area

.

I was disappointed in our trip to this restaurant. Although my food was excellent my dinner partners were somewhat disappointed. With no prix-fixed menu the expense jumped rather quickly as ala carte items(salads and 2 desserts) were

3
★★★★★

I was disappointed in our trip to this restaurant. Although my food was excellent my dinner partners were somewhat disappointed. With no prix-fixed menu the expense jumped rather quickly as ala carte items(salads and 2 desserts) were

Pros: Location, Friendly service

Cons: Crowded, Tables too close, No prix-fixed menue

.

As part of a bus group trip into the city, we chose Angus Mcindoe's based on a recommendation from someone at Joe Allen's. We needed accommodations for 50 people and Angus was able to give us the third floor of his restaurant for our

3
★★★★★

As part of a bus group trip into the city, we chose Angus Mcindoe's based on a recommendation from someone at Joe Allen's. We needed accommodations for 50 people and Angus was able to give us the third floor of his restaurant for our

.

This place is a find within this area, or anywhere for that matter. The service was friendly, the atmosphere was relaxed, and the food was really good. When I think of Times Square I think of gaudy, touristy places. This had me feeling

3
★★★★★

This place is a find within this area, or anywhere for that matter. The service was friendly, the atmosphere was relaxed, and the food was really good. When I think of Times Square I think of gaudy, touristy places. This had me feeling

Pros: good food, location, price

Cons: it's in times square

.

Angus Mcindoe, the former fabulous and friendly manager of Joe Allen's, has opened up his own place, right next to "The Producers" home, and it's really great. The space is terrific, boasting three stories; two for dining and the third is

3
★★★★★

Angus Mcindoe, the former fabulous and friendly manager of Joe Allen's, has opened up his own place, right next to "The Producers" home, and it's really great. The space is terrific, boasting three stories; two for dining and the third is

.

Ate here based on what I read on this site, so thought I'd return the favor. Four of us arrived around 4:30, right after a matinee and we had the place entirely to ourselves. By 5:30 it was packed, so I suggest reservations. The great

3
★★★★★

Ate here based on what I read on this site, so thought I'd return the favor. Four of us arrived around 4:30, right after a matinee and we had the place entirely to ourselves. By 5:30 it was packed, so I suggest reservations. The great

Pros: Great Service, Good meals, Star Watching

Cons: Tight Seating, Grilled Veggies

Editorial from

Right next door to the St. James Theatre, home of The Producers, Angus McIndoe counts the show's original stars (Matthew Broderick and Nathan Lane) as investors. So don't be surprised to find yourself brushing elbows with stage names as…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Angus' Cafe Bistro, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review