Seashore Restaurant

★★★☆☆
Unbelievable Seafood. Incredible Water View. Sea Shore on City Island.
  • 591 City Island Ave

    Bronx, NY 10464

    Map & Directions
  • 718-885-0300

About Seashore Restaurant

Hours
We are open after Hurricane Sandy.

Food

Food
More choices in Bronx:
Resultset_next

Monster Sushi

158 W 23rd St New York, NY

Resultset_next

Wasabi Lobby Japanese Rstrnt

1584 2nd Ave. New York, NY

3.25 12
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Seashore Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

La Villa is my go to place for business lunches, and weeknight dinners with my family. I have been going there since it first opened and the food has NEVER let me down. The setting is casual elegant, the waitstaff is young,friendly and energetic and the owner will treat you like family.

2
★★★★☆

La Villa is my go to place for business lunches, and weeknight dinners with my family. I have been going there since it first opened and the food has NEVER let me down. The setting is casual elegant, the waitstaff is young,friendly and energetic and the owner will treat you like family.

.

I was in the Sea Shore last weekend and the food was awsome. The portions were so huge that my friends couldnt believe it when they saw them. we sat on the outside deck which I never knew was there. The service was great, the food was great and the view was great..\r\nIt is a must try, you wont be dissapointed

2
★★★★★

I was in the Sea Shore last weekend and the food was awsome. The portions were so huge that my friends couldnt believe it when they saw them. we sat on the outside deck which I never knew was there. The service was great, the food was great and the view was great..\r\nIt is a must try, you wont be dissapointed

.

Everything was just right. Food, service and overall ambiance of the room. And when they politely asked a young couple to leave when they were unable to control the shrill cries and screams of their child (without charging them for their entrees) I thought: ""Yes, a restaurant management that is committed to respectful, adult dining."" I wish more restaurants were as proactive (and protective) of their clientele. Thank you, Seashore. I'll be back soon!

2
★★★★★

Everything was just right. Food, service and overall ambiance of the room. And when they politely asked a young couple to leave when they were unable to control the shrill cries and screams of their child (without charging them for their entrees) I thought: ""Yes, a restaurant management that is committed to respectful, adult dining."" I wish more restaurants were as proactive (and protective) of their clientele. Thank you, Seashore. I'll be back soon!

Pros: No kids, charming staff, perfect seafood

Cons: Not closer to home

.

OK so we went there yesterday 4/26 about 6 ppl. First of all the menu prices are insane but thats not my problem, so i am not a white guy. So you know where this is going right? We were treated like crap ... Menu clearly states that lunch special comes with fruit juice or fruit plate, coffee and dessert. We were not even asked for any of that. All we got was lunch special and thats it... When we asked the waiter is fruit or juice included he clearly stated NO. At the end I was so pissed we just wanted to get the hell of there. Had a word with manager and that guy was just trying to kiss our ass at the end. But all is all what a bad experience. Will never go back there again.?

0
★☆☆☆☆

OK so we went there yesterday 4/26 about 6 ppl. First of all the menu prices are insane but thats not my problem, so i am not a white guy. So you know where this is going right? We were treated like crap ... Menu clearly states that lunch special comes with fruit juice or fruit plate, coffee and dessert. We were not even asked for any of that. All we got was lunch special and thats it... When we asked the waiter is fruit or juice included he clearly stated NO. At the end I was so pissed we just wanted to get the hell of there. Had a word with manager and that guy was just trying to kiss our ass at the end. But all is all what a bad experience. Will never go back there again.?

Cons: Worst service and very bad management

.

LAWSUIT. I went to this restaurant with my wife and 3 year old son at 5 PM on a Friday night. The restaurant was maybe half full. My son was crying as he couldn't find one of his toys and we were thrown out of the restaurant! The manager didn't even warn us or ask us to take him outside to calm him down. He just ran up to us with a wild look in his eyes and said people are complaining and you have to leave! Do not take a child to this restaurant. Although the overall experience has deteriorated over the years, they think they are too good for babies and are completely unprofessional! You really sank your boat Seashore Restaurant.

0
★☆☆☆☆

LAWSUIT. I went to this restaurant with my wife and 3 year old son at 5 PM on a Friday night. The restaurant was maybe half full. My son was crying as he couldn't find one of his toys and we were thrown out of the restaurant! The manager didn't even warn us or ask us to take him outside to calm him down. He just ran up to us with a wild look in his eyes and said people are complaining and you have to leave! Do not take a child to this restaurant. Although the overall experience has deteriorated over the years, they think they are too good for babies and are completely unprofessional! You really sank your boat Seashore Restaurant.

Pros: Nice location

Cons: Will be sued for rude, frightening and embarassing behavior

.

My family and I have been going to Seashore for over 20 years. Lately I've noticed a HUGE change. On a recent visit, there where flies EVERYWHERE. The service has gooten extremely slow. It took 45 mins for the salad to come out, it was a Sunday afternoon and it was not busy. When it finally did come out, the crotons were stale and the lettuce soggy. The fried seafood combo tasted like it came out of a frozen bag from a bad supermarket. The Ahi tuna sandwich gave me food piosining. After 20 years, my family and I will no longer be going to Seashore.

1
★★☆☆☆

My family and I have been going to Seashore for over 20 years. Lately I've noticed a HUGE change. On a recent visit, there where flies EVERYWHERE. The service has gooten extremely slow. It took 45 mins for the salad to come out, it was a Sunday afternoon and it was not busy. When it finally did come out, the crotons were stale and the lettuce soggy. The fried seafood combo tasted like it came out of a frozen bag from a bad supermarket. The Ahi tuna sandwich gave me food piosining. After 20 years, my family and I will no longer be going to Seashore.

.

Another City Island restaurant with great views but not much else. Nicely decorated in kitsch but average food at better than average prices. Not sure we'd return.

3
★★★☆☆

Another City Island restaurant with great views but not much else. Nicely decorated in kitsch but average food at better than average prices. Not sure we'd return.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Bar is great and atmosphere as well. Eventhough I can't eat seafood there is a wide variety of selection of other dishes. Food is great, service is good, prices are reasonable. Bar is great to hang out on a Friday night and have a drink!!!

4
★★★★☆

Bar is great and atmosphere as well. Eventhough I can't eat seafood there is a wide variety of selection of other dishes. Food is great, service is good, prices are reasonable. Bar is great to hang out on a Friday night and have a drink!!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Me and my friends went to this restaurant; it had pretty good reviews. The reviews must have come from the \r\nstaff! This restaurant had the worst service I have ever experienced. To start off; we had no silverware, we had to go and get it ourselves from the storage. Every time we asked the waiter for something; it would take him 15-20 minutes turnaround, IF he even brought it. Everyone around us was complaining to the manager; the poor guy was getting grief. We saw a lot of people sit down and then get up and leave - because nobody came to wait on them. We had considered leaving a few times as well. We had repeatedly complained to our waiter about this; still it took 55 minutes for our food to come after we FINISHED our appetizers. The appetizers were ok, Long John Silvers serves better! The main course when it finally came was just ""OK"". They apologized for their tardiness by giving us a huge plate of mixed vegatibles (like the frozen kind you buy at Shop-Rite for 50cents). The bill was around $225 for 4 people; but was not worth $75 in reality. Too boot, my girlfriend got a terrible stomach ache and I didn't feel to well either. \r\n\r\nI would not recommend this restaurant to anybody, not even my enemies!

0
★☆☆☆☆

Me and my friends went to this restaurant; it had pretty good reviews. The reviews must have come from the \r\nstaff! This restaurant had the worst service I have ever experienced. To start off; we had no silverware, we had to go and get it ourselves from the storage. Every time we asked the waiter for something; it would take him 15-20 minutes turnaround, IF he even brought it. Everyone around us was complaining to the manager; the poor guy was getting grief. We saw a lot of people sit down and then get up and leave - because nobody came to wait on them. We had considered leaving a few times as well. We had repeatedly complained to our waiter about this; still it took 55 minutes for our food to come after we FINISHED our appetizers. The appetizers were ok, Long John Silvers serves better! The main course when it finally came was just ""OK"". They apologized for their tardiness by giving us a huge plate of mixed vegatibles (like the frozen kind you buy at Shop-Rite for 50cents). The bill was around $225 for 4 people; but was not worth $75 in reality. Too boot, my girlfriend got a terrible stomach ache and I didn't feel to well either. \r\n\r\nI would not recommend this restaurant to anybody, not even my enemies!

Pros: Nice location and view

Cons: Food, service and value doesnt add up to the actual cost! Worst Service ever!

.

Living in the city, the ""Sea Shore"" has the ambiance of Old City Island. Great Sea Food. The ""One Of a Kind Sea Shore Dinner"" Is a dream come true. Great wait staff. I find it better on Non Rushed Holidays. Great Evening dining, or a Nice lunch.\n With Attended parking. The Restaurant overlooks the water. Nice & Romantic in the evening.\n Lenny Waller\n BX, NY

2
★★★★★

Living in the city, the ""Sea Shore"" has the ambiance of Old City Island. Great Sea Food. The ""One Of a Kind Sea Shore Dinner"" Is a dream come true. Great wait staff. I find it better on Non Rushed Holidays. Great Evening dining, or a Nice lunch.\n With Attended parking. The Restaurant overlooks the water. Nice & Romantic in the evening.\n Lenny Waller\n BX, NY

Pros: Food, Service, Atmosphire

.

If you want a large helping of seafood, then this is the right place for you. I was there with some friends and I had the rib eye and lobster tail. The lobster tail was good, but I thought the rib eye was better. I had some friends order the Seafood platter for 2 and it'd probably feed 3-4 really. Came out to about $50 per person with entree, (comes with side order and salad), drinks and an appetizer. It was pretty good overall. I'd recommend it.

2
★★★★☆

If you want a large helping of seafood, then this is the right place for you. I was there with some friends and I had the rib eye and lobster tail. The lobster tail was good, but I thought the rib eye was better. I had some friends order the Seafood platter for 2 and it'd probably feed 3-4 really. Came out to about $50 per person with entree, (comes with side order and salad), drinks and an appetizer. It was pretty good overall. I'd recommend it.

.

The food was good and plentiful,and I do mean plentiful. The prices are very steep. I ordered the Shell Fish Feast for two. This dish included: 2 half lobsters, baby tails, shrimp, baked clams and king crab legs. Bring a huge appetite. If you have this dish have them broil it, it tastes much better than the steamed version.

2
★★★★☆

The food was good and plentiful,and I do mean plentiful. The prices are very steep. I ordered the Shell Fish Feast for two. This dish included: 2 half lobsters, baby tails, shrimp, baked clams and king crab legs. Bring a huge appetite. If you have this dish have them broil it, it tastes much better than the steamed version.

Pros: Hot food, Plentiful, Good Service

Cons: Over-priced, Hard to get to

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Seashore Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review