Fox Island Seafood House

★★★☆☆

About Fox Island Seafood House

Categories
  • Restaurants
Reservations
Make A Reservation

Food

Food
More choices in Port Chester:
Resultset_next

Inca & Gaucho Restaurant Inc

173 Westchester Ave Port Chester, NY

Resultset_next

The Willett House

20 Willett Ave Port Chester, NY

2.6667 3
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Fox Island Seafood House was?
Write a Review
.

We paid $140 for 2 people. We both had fish that was over cooked and salads that were pre made and warm. The dessert wasn't good either. The wait staff was not attentative and had mixed our courses up twice. At this price I was expecting a top notch restaurant and I was terribly disappointed. I did leave with some stomach upset and so did my husband. I hope this review helps someone else out.

0
★☆☆☆☆

We paid $140 for 2 people. We both had fish that was over cooked and salads that were pre made and warm. The dessert wasn't good either. The wait staff was not attentative and had mixed our courses up twice. At this price I was expecting a top notch restaurant and I was terribly disappointed. I did leave with some stomach upset and so did my husband. I hope this review helps someone else out.

Pros: Near the water

Cons: Food, service was awful

.

Has almost a 360 degree views on the NY/CT border. Provides a dining deck and two expansive dining rooms. Has the "old-style" fish house feel.

4
★★★★☆

Has almost a 360 degree views on the NY/CT border. Provides a dining deck and two expansive dining rooms. Has the "old-style" fish house feel.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

After a bad first experience, my fiance and I decided to give it a 2nd chance. Our first visit: we sat in the bar, which was a horrible decision. After being seated and waiting for at least 15 minutes, we finally got our own menus. After another 10-15 minutes we finally ordered and I forget how much time passed before the food arrived (we stopped another waitress to ask where it was at one point). Never were we checked upon by our waiter and had to ask other staff in order to get our waiter.

We decided to give FISH another try because we enjoy the food. This second chance was a mixed experience. We were seated on the side deck this time and with menus too! We had to wait a while to order our food, the salad did arrive fairly quickly. We had to wait a while for our main course. Wait time was annoying, the fact that we were never visited by our waiter to see if we needed anything or to explain the wait was VERY annoying. Food was finally delivered, but we were not asked if we wanted anything else. After finally grabbing the attention of a member of the bus staff, our waiter finally came by again about 5 mins later to take a drink order. After we finished the entrees, amazingly, our waiter actually showed up at our table quickly this time. Ordered some dessert and were astonished at what happened next. the dessert all of a sudden was slid on to the table by someone on the fly. We had absolutely no utensils with which to eat the dessert. It's a little hard to eat a blueberry and peach crumb with ice cream without spoons! After several minutesmore minutes another member of the staff walked by and we had to nearly grab him to get his attention. Asked for utensils and a couple of minutes later finally received the spoons.

The food was once again very good, the service remained horrible. A little better this time, but service was still horrible. We really enjoy the food at F.I.S.H., but it is hard to overcome the experience that the staff creates.

1
★★★☆☆

After a bad first experience, my fiance and I decided to give it a 2nd chance. Our first visit: we sat in the bar, which was a horrible decision. After being seated and waiting for at least 15 minutes, we finally got our own menus. After another 10-15 minutes we finally ordered and I forget how much time passed before the food arrived (we stopped another waitress to ask where it was at one point). Never were we checked upon by our waiter and had to ask other staff in order to get our waiter.

We decided to give FISH another try because we enjoy the food. This second chance was a mixed experience. We were seated on the side deck this time and with menus too! We had to wait a while to order our food, the salad did arrive fairly quickly. We had to wait a while for our main course. Wait time was annoying, the fact that we were never visited by our waiter to see if we needed anything or to explain the wait was VERY annoying. Food was finally delivered, but we were not asked if we wanted anything else. After finally grabbing the attention of a member of the bus staff, our waiter finally came by again about 5 mins later to take a drink order. After we finished the entrees, amazingly, our waiter actually showed up at our table quickly this time. Ordered some dessert and were astonished at what happened next. the dessert all of a sudden was slid on to the table by someone on the fly. We had absolutely no utensils with which to eat the dessert. It's a little hard to eat a blueberry and peach crumb with ice cream without spoons! After several minutesmore minutes another member of the staff walked by and we had to nearly grab him to get his attention. Asked for utensils and a couple of minutes later finally received the spoons.

The food was once again very good, the service remained horrible. A little better this time, but service was still horrible. We really enjoy the food at F.I.S.H., but it is hard to overcome the experience that the staff creates.

Pros: Food

Cons: Service, Service, Service

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Fox Island Seafood House, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review