631-587-2251

761 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, NY 11704

Write A Review

Insiders:

Jerry Z. Mary G. Sabrina C. stacey w. Ava S.
Give us the inside scoop on Cafe Gio
Write a review!
Kid Friendly: yes 1 no 0
Bookmark and Share Edit business

Reviews for Cafe Gio

Ratings_icons one of the best on south shore

Jerry Z.

Excellent value for the money. The salad dressing is the best too bad they don't bottle it. One of the beat Italian restaurants on the south shore. Service is superb a friendly family atmosphere. Try it you'll like it.

Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons Great food, great specials!

Mary G.

Their pasta specials are great! At $9.95 per person, you get a salad with their delicious house dressing, which I'd like to buy and bring home; delicious pasta, garlic knots or Italian bread, and a dessert!

Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons Gross and overpriced.

Sabrina C.

Once upon a time this was a decent place. Recently it went down the tubes. If you live in New York, you know what good pizza tastes like. This place doesn't even come close to the quality of pizza it should, being located on Long Island. I went a second time recently and I bought a Caesar salad to stay away from the pizza, figuring, "How could they mess that up?" Well, my dressing was watery to the point where I couldn't even eat it, there was barely any chicken, and it was over $14!! That price is outrageous even if it were good. What a waste! Do NOT throw away your money or your appetite at this dump.

Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons not pleased

stacey w.

I wasn't happy with the quality of the food my penne came out cold, the place wasn't even busy, the bread was stiff i couldn't even eat it. If it was an expensive meal, there's no way I'd pay for it.. all i can say is the service was good, other than that i have nothing positive to say about my experience here at this restaurant.

Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons Great Italian Food!!!

Ava S.

This little Italian homestyle restaurant sure hits the spot!!! The service is exceptional especially my two favorite girls Cristal and Kim. They are so friendly and professional, they really gave us something to look foward to other than then the food, which was amazing.

Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons Love this place!

Kate D.

It's unseemingly in a random strip mall just north of Sunrise, but what a find!

We go almost every Monday or Tuesday for their pasta night specials. I truly love the pesto but everything on the menu is great with over 40 selections (for only $10 a person it includes salad, delicious garlic knots, entree, coffee/tea, and dessert)! The house salad dressing is great too, I believe it's unique to Gios. The atmosphere is of a romanticly lit bistro and it is never over crowded so you can have a discussion and hear the other person.

We had them cater my graduation party was well and they gave us substantial portions for the lowest price around (and everyone agreed that the penne a la vodka was amazing!)

Exceeded my expectations and would highly recommend!

Report Abuse

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons cafe GIO its really good

isabella m.

this is a good restaurant, food its excellent and service the best. my favorite waitress its Mary and my favorite waiter its Rosario they are very good and professional people they serve you the best. the hostess its really good but i miss the old hostess guys keep the good work and don't change nothing, food its delicious....

Report Abuse

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons once mama left

kevin m.

once mama (the fonder of the restaurant ) left the food has gone down not the same quality of food and service since she turned it over to the kids ...

Report Abuse

0 out of 2 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons
Ratings_icons A Taste of Good Home Cooking

Caryn H. | insider Insider | Rank: 26,634

This is a family run restaurant . The food is excellent and they give large portions. The staff is very friendly.
They have pasta night on Tuesdays and provide a bread, salad, entree, dessert and coffee.
There menu is priced fairly and have different specials as well.
My favorite is Chicken Marsala over Linguine.

Report Abuse

2 out of 3 people found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful to you?

Ratings_icons Ratings_icons