Little Pie Co Ltd

★★★★☆
  • 424 W 43rd St

    New York, NY 10036

    Map & Directions
  • 212-736-4780

About Little Pie Co Ltd

Details
Hours
Monday To Wednesday From 08:00 AM To 08:00 PM Thursday To Saturday From 08:00 AM To 09:00 PM Sunday From 11:00 AM To 07:00 PM

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Katra

217 Bowery New York, NY

Resultset_next

Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steak House

1221 Avenue Of The Americas New York, NY

4.2857 7
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Little Pie Co Ltd was?
Write a Review
.

Little Pie Company has some of the best Apple pies I have tried. I bought the sour cream Apple Pie and it was crumby, sweet and sour. All the amazing combination you want for apple pies are inside!

It comes with a hefty price though. One tiny palm size pie is $7.5!!!! I just got their oatmeal cookie and it is buttery and crunchy too.

I think the smell of pies is still lingering in my nose....yum!

2
★★★★☆

Little Pie Company has some of the best Apple pies I have tried. I bought the sour cream Apple Pie and it was crumby, sweet and sour. All the amazing combination you want for apple pies are inside!

It comes with a hefty price though. One tiny palm size pie is $7.5!!!! I just got their oatmeal cookie and it is buttery and crunchy too.

I think the smell of pies is still lingering in my nose....yum!

Pros: Great pies and desserts

Cons: pricey

.

We were on our way to catch a sightseeing boat and just happened to pass the Little Pie Company..

Now I am a fool when it comes to pies, sometimes I think I could live on them as my only food source, so of course we had to enter this bakery..I thought I had died and gone to heaven..Pies of every type and size were displayed in the most tastefully delicous manner..What a concept I thought when I saw the individually sized pies, just perfect for on the go. There were berry pies, custard pies, fruit pies and and my favorite mini Lemon Merengue, all calling my name..We had to choose in a hurry so a blueberry and Lemon Merengue were first to go into the box we were going to take on the boat. As an after thought we quickly added an apple as well..

They were as fresh and good tasting as they looked and not too expensive I might add.

There is another location in the Grand Central Station marketplace where we went to during the next few days to try a few other varieties..We never had a pie we didn't like!

PROS: A dream come true for any pie lover
CONS: none

4
★★★★☆

We were on our way to catch a sightseeing boat and just happened to pass the Little Pie Company..

Now I am a fool when it comes to pies, sometimes I think I could live on them as my only food source, so of course we had to enter this bakery..I thought I had died and gone to heaven..Pies of every type and size were displayed in the most tastefully delicous manner..What a concept I thought when I saw the individually sized pies, just perfect for on the go. There were berry pies, custard pies, fruit pies and and my favorite mini Lemon Merengue, all calling my name..We had to choose in a hurry so a blueberry and Lemon Merengue were first to go into the box we were going to take on the boat. As an after thought we quickly added an apple as well..

They were as fresh and good tasting as they looked and not too expensive I might add.

There is another location in the Grand Central Station marketplace where we went to during the next few days to try a few other varieties..We never had a pie we didn't like!

PROS: A dream come true for any pie lover
CONS: none

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The pies here are out of this world! The make the best chocolate, custard, creme pies and whatever you can think of. The staff can be rude sometimes. But if you can get past their attitudes the pies, cakes and cookies more than make up for it. These snack can cost a pretty penny. They do offer decent discounts if you work for a company and buy more than one cake or pie.

4
★★★★☆

The pies here are out of this world! The make the best chocolate, custard, creme pies and whatever you can think of. The staff can be rude sometimes. But if you can get past their attitudes the pies, cakes and cookies more than make up for it. These snack can cost a pretty penny. They do offer decent discounts if you work for a company and buy more than one cake or pie.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Wonderful Mississippi Mud pie. Apple sourdough pie, and orange cake are good, as is the bundt cake with a rich chocolaty filling and the cupcakes. Decent but not memorable banana cream pie. Key lime pie was nothing special. They used to have decent ginger cookies but these were conspicously absent during our last visits. They do have a very wide selection of cakes and pies to take home. The chocolate muffins are good too.

2
★★★★☆

Wonderful Mississippi Mud pie. Apple sourdough pie, and orange cake are good, as is the bundt cake with a rich chocolaty filling and the cupcakes. Decent but not memorable banana cream pie. Key lime pie was nothing special. They used to have decent ginger cookies but these were conspicously absent during our last visits. They do have a very wide selection of cakes and pies to take home. The chocolate muffins are good too.

.

Want to taste the most delicious pecan pie this side of New Orleans? I have been a loyal customer here for 10 years and it gets better with great additions (danish), the pies and cakes, (german chocolate, old-fashioned yellow and chocolate, YUM) and they have great indoor or outdoor seating! If you want to pick up a great dessert or just sit and have a cup of coffee and something really delicious, Little Pie Company is the place to go! This place is not cheap, but worth the extra $$$

2
★★★★★

Want to taste the most delicious pecan pie this side of New Orleans? I have been a loyal customer here for 10 years and it gets better with great additions (danish), the pies and cakes, (german chocolate, old-fashioned yellow and chocolate, YUM) and they have great indoor or outdoor seating! If you want to pick up a great dessert or just sit and have a cup of coffee and something really delicious, Little Pie Company is the place to go! This place is not cheap, but worth the extra $$$

Pros: best quality, great service, indoor/outdoor seats

Cons: very crowded, very busy

.

The Little Pie Company's Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie is like a slice of heaven on a plate. Unless you have had this, you simply can not understand how absolutely delicious this pie is. They have been in business since 1985 for a reason. I'd love to try their other pies, but I can't get beyond the S.C. Apple Walnut. It's not cheap, but then again what quality food is?

2
★★★★★

The Little Pie Company's Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie is like a slice of heaven on a plate. Unless you have had this, you simply can not understand how absolutely delicious this pie is. They have been in business since 1985 for a reason. I'd love to try their other pies, but I can't get beyond the S.C. Apple Walnut. It's not cheap, but then again what quality food is?

Pros: Best Pie in the world, Good Variety

Cons: Service a bit slow, A bit expensive

.

This is some of the most delicious pies you've ever tasted! Not too sweet and with just the right amount of ingredients and fillings. Try the Banana Creme Pie or the Chocolate Creme Pie: they're both "to die for!"

2
★★★★☆

This is some of the most delicious pies you've ever tasted! Not too sweet and with just the right amount of ingredients and fillings. Try the Banana Creme Pie or the Chocolate Creme Pie: they're both "to die for!"

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Little Pie Co Ltd, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review