Joe Michael's Steakhouse

★★☆☆☆
  • 262 Deer Park Ave 1

    Babylon, NY 11702

    Map & Directions
  • 631-321-5580

About Joe Michael's Steakhouse

Hours
Daily, 4:30pm - 11pm
2.2 5
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Joe Michael's Steakhouse was?
Write a Review
.

Joe Michaels Steak House served my party of four the worst meals we had ever paid for. This was one of the worst experiences in a restaurant I've ever had. The 'Steak House' in the name is a bold faced lie; this is a bar that serves low quality steak.

The waitress was a phantom, despite only three or four other tables having customers. When we did see her she was surly and spoke as though she was annoyed that we had dared to dine. The appetizer ribs were decent, but the other appetizers were frozen-microwave quality. They were out of baked clams on a Saturday night; foresight they have not. The steaks were extremely fatty and tough. My medium rare shell steak came out so rare that the center of the meat was still cold. I sent it back to be cooked through and it came back clearly microwaved. Trying to eat this was nearly impossible. My girlfriend had to get a slice of pizza afterwards, her steak was so fatty there was barely any meat for her. After 2.5 hours and a large check, you should be full and satisfied with your evening.

Avoid this dump.

1
★☆☆☆☆

Joe Michaels Steak House served my party of four the worst meals we had ever paid for. This was one of the worst experiences in a restaurant I've ever had. The 'Steak House' in the name is a bold faced lie; this is a bar that serves low quality steak.

The waitress was a phantom, despite only three or four other tables having customers. When we did see her she was surly and spoke as though she was annoyed that we had dared to dine. The appetizer ribs were decent, but the other appetizers were frozen-microwave quality. They were out of baked clams on a Saturday night; foresight they have not. The steaks were extremely fatty and tough. My medium rare shell steak came out so rare that the center of the meat was still cold. I sent it back to be cooked through and it came back clearly microwaved. Trying to eat this was nearly impossible. My girlfriend had to get a slice of pizza afterwards, her steak was so fatty there was barely any meat for her. After 2.5 hours and a large check, you should be full and satisfied with your evening.

Avoid this dump.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Enjoyed it from start to finish. Took the kids. Great choices for them. I had a marinated rib eye. It was delicious! The brownie sundae at the end was the best.

4
★★★★☆

Enjoyed it from start to finish. Took the kids. Great choices for them. I had a marinated rib eye. It was delicious! The brownie sundae at the end was the best.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We found the restaurant in the enterainment book. We had dinner on a Saturday night. The restaurant was cold and we had to keep our coats on. We ordered appetizers that took approximately 1/2 hour before we received them. I ordered a salad minus walnuts and the waitress came out with the salad with walnuts on it. The steaks we ordered came out warm.

1
★☆☆☆☆

We found the restaurant in the enterainment book. We had dinner on a Saturday night. The restaurant was cold and we had to keep our coats on. We ordered appetizers that took approximately 1/2 hour before we received them. I ordered a salad minus walnuts and the waitress came out with the salad with walnuts on it. The steaks we ordered came out warm.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This is definitely a deceiving place. It is a typical looking bar from the outside. Once inside there is an area around this small wall that serves the most delicious steak we have ever had. More pricey that Outback but worth every penny.

4
★★★★☆

This is definitely a deceiving place. It is a typical looking bar from the outside. Once inside there is an area around this small wall that serves the most delicious steak we have ever had. More pricey that Outback but worth every penny.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We ordered the filet mignon and after several attempts to saw through it, I gave up trying. The meat was tough and fatty and I couldn't believe this was supposed to be their best cut! The baked potato had skin like leather and I was told upon ordering that to switch potato style would cost extra! Our waittress must have entered the witness protection program after bringing the food, but finally she appeared. This was on a Saturday night, and we should have known something was wrong because it wasn't that crowded. No visit from any manager/owner proved that this dive survives on a nucleus of regulars who hang out at the bar.

0
★☆☆☆☆

We ordered the filet mignon and after several attempts to saw through it, I gave up trying. The meat was tough and fatty and I couldn't believe this was supposed to be their best cut! The baked potato had skin like leather and I was told upon ordering that to switch potato style would cost extra! Our waittress must have entered the witness protection program after bringing the food, but finally she appeared. This was on a Saturday night, and we should have known something was wrong because it wasn't that crowded. No visit from any manager/owner proved that this dive survives on a nucleus of regulars who hang out at the bar.

Pros: Big screen tv at the bar

Cons: everything else

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Joe Michael's Steakhouse, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review