Emilios Pizzeria & Ristorante

★★★★☆
40.8425 -73.2882
Map and Directions to Emilio's Restaurant & Pizza

631-462-6267

2201 Jericho Tpke

Commack, NY

11725

Get Directions

About Emilios Pizzeria & Ristorante

Food

Food
More choices in Commack:
Resultset_next

Original Brooklyn Pizza Incorporated

100 Jericho Tpke Commack, NY

Resultset_next

Little Vincent's Pizza Restaurant

324 Smithtown Blvd Lake Ronkonkoma, NY

4.2727 11
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Emilios Pizzeria & Ristorante was?
Write a Review
Reviews 1 - 11 of 11.
.

They overcharged my credit card by $2 even though I wrote out the final total. When I called in to politely resolve the issue they offered to let me come in and get the overcharge refunded. I said this wouldn't work because I live so far away that I wouldn't make any money driving in to pick it up. They then rudely asked me if I was "trying to make money off them".

Apparently they couldn't understand the fact that driving 50 miles round trip over 2 hours to pick up $2 does not make financial sense, and instead assumed I was attempting to form an elaborate con artist attack over the phone to get a measly $2 back from a $50+ meal that I paid them for in person.

When I asked to be contacted by a manager they never called me back. In over fifty days.

Unless you like having your money stolen from you and being treated like a thief and ignored for pointing it out, I'd suggest taking your business elsewhere.

1
★☆☆☆☆

They overcharged my credit card by $2 even though I wrote out the final total. When I called in to politely resolve the issue they offered to let me come in and get the overcharge refunded. I said this wouldn't work because I live so far away that I wouldn't make any money driving in to pick it up. They then rudely asked me if I was "trying to make money off them".

Apparently they couldn't understand the fact that driving 50 miles round trip over 2 hours to pick up $2 does not make financial sense, and instead assumed I was attempting to form an elaborate con artist attack over the phone to get a measly $2 back from a $50+ meal that I paid them for in person.

When I asked to be contacted by a manager they never called me back. In over fifty days.

Unless you like having your money stolen from you and being treated like a thief and ignored for pointing it out, I'd suggest taking your business elsewhere.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This is one of the islands better italian restaurants. Nice size portions and great food. Service is good and fast. Never disappointed with meal. The meals are resonably priced.

5
★★★★★

This is one of the islands better italian restaurants. Nice size portions and great food. Service is good and fast. Never disappointed with meal. The meals are resonably priced.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Gourmet pizza that never fails to please. This place is always packed for good reason. Try the salad slice and the marinara slice although everything is fantastic.

5
★★★★★

Gourmet pizza that never fails to please. This place is always packed for good reason. Try the salad slice and the marinara slice although everything is fantastic.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Whoever wrote the first review must have had a bad day. The place is crowded most of the time because the food and the selection is very good. The staff is moving quick, and maybe they don't always have the time to kiss your feet or offer a back rub. BUT if you want great tasting Italian food at a very reasonable price in the Commack area, here it is. Try the rice balls! Your grandmother can't make them this good!

5
★★★★★

Whoever wrote the first review must have had a bad day. The place is crowded most of the time because the food and the selection is very good. The staff is moving quick, and maybe they don't always have the time to kiss your feet or offer a back rub. BUT if you want great tasting Italian food at a very reasonable price in the Commack area, here it is. Try the rice balls! Your grandmother can't make them this good!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Very rude, terrible reputation for the rudest wait staff in Commack. Food is not that good and the environment is dirty! I was not impressed with this place at all.

5
★★★★★

Very rude, terrible reputation for the rudest wait staff in Commack. Food is not that good and the environment is dirty! I was not impressed with this place at all.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

Latest reviews from Citysearch.

.

They overcharged my credit card by $2 even though I wrote out the final total. When I called in to politely resolve the issue they offered to let me come in and get the overcharge refunded. I said this wouldn't work because I live so far

6
★★★★★

They overcharged my credit card by $2 even though I wrote out the final total. When I called in to politely resolve the issue they offered to let me come in and get the overcharge refunded. I said this wouldn't work because I live so far

.

They use peanut oil in their square pizzas and on their focaccia bread! my daughter had a bad allergic reaction to the focaccia bread. there is no signage and nothing written on the menu.

if you or your kids have peanut allergies,

6
★★★★★

They use peanut oil in their square pizzas and on their focaccia bread! my daughter had a bad allergic reaction to the focaccia bread. there is no signage and nothing written on the menu.

if you or your kids have peanut allergies,

.

Very dissapointed...they've gone downhill. I have been going to Emilio's for over 20 years and I always tell everyone its my favorite pizza on LI. However, I was living in New England for 3 years and I've come back and the pizza has been unacceptable each time I have gone there. First time I got my former fav the Marinara slice. The dough was RAW and inedible. 2nd visit back I got Sicilian which used to be great. This time again the dough was severely undercooked and inedible and the sauce was dry. I stayed away for months but then recently I figured I'd give them one more shot. My 3rd trip back I got a plain slice, when I opened the box when I got home, the slice was small enough to fill a cavity (it was literally Half a normal size slice). For $2.50/.25 a slice (with no toppings) they have some nerve skimping, that is NO WAY to run a business. To top it off, the new workers behind the counter are unfriendly and barely speak English.

They've just lost a former loyal customer and I will tell all my friends and family to Stay Away until Emilio's relearns to value its customers and deliver a quality product. I suggest people try out Branchanelli's in Hauppauge, same family, better pizza. Also CIro's in Hauppauge, friendly people, big tasty slices.

1
★☆☆☆☆

Very dissapointed...they've gone downhill. I have been going to Emilio's for over 20 years and I always tell everyone its my favorite pizza on LI. However, I was living in New England for 3 years and I've come back and the pizza has been unacceptable each time I have gone there. First time I got my former fav the Marinara slice. The dough was RAW and inedible. 2nd visit back I got Sicilian which used to be great. This time again the dough was severely undercooked and inedible and the sauce was dry. I stayed away for months but then recently I figured I'd give them one more shot. My 3rd trip back I got a plain slice, when I opened the box when I got home, the slice was small enough to fill a cavity (it was literally Half a normal size slice). For $2.50/.25 a slice (with no toppings) they have some nerve skimping, that is NO WAY to run a business. To top it off, the new workers behind the counter are unfriendly and barely speak English.

They've just lost a former loyal customer and I will tell all my friends and family to Stay Away until Emilio's relearns to value its customers and deliver a quality product. I suggest people try out Branchanelli's in Hauppauge, same family, better pizza. Also CIro's in Hauppauge, friendly people, big tasty slices.

.

I have been to many pizza places both in NC [where I now live] and on LI [where I grew up]. Emilio's has by far the BEST pizza I have ever had. The sauce is superb and very flavorful and they put on just the right amount of cheese without overpowering the pie. The crust even has a great flavor. Unfortunately I came upon this place literally the same week I was moving. The only downside to this restaurant is the space. Your packed in like a sardine so if you are claustrophobic at all this is not the place for you to EAT-IN, GET TAKE OUT. The other thing that's annoying is the service was kinda of lax but everything was made up for by the taste of the pizza. Definitely worth the annoyances.

5
★★★★★

I have been to many pizza places both in NC [where I now live] and on LI [where I grew up]. Emilio's has by far the BEST pizza I have ever had. The sauce is superb and very flavorful and they put on just the right amount of cheese without overpowering the pie. The crust even has a great flavor. Unfortunately I came upon this place literally the same week I was moving. The only downside to this restaurant is the space. Your packed in like a sardine so if you are claustrophobic at all this is not the place for you to EAT-IN, GET TAKE OUT. The other thing that's annoying is the service was kinda of lax but everything was made up for by the taste of the pizza. Definitely worth the annoyances.

Pros: PIZZA PIZZA PIZZA YUM!!!

Cons: Very Cramped, OK service

.

Been here twice to eat in (many times for a slice, or take out). The food is of the highest quality and very good all the time. However, the service was terrible. We received both our appetizers and our entrees cool. The first time we asked that our food be reheated, the second time we were with a large group and didn't want to make a scene.

3
★★★☆☆

Been here twice to eat in (many times for a slice, or take out). The food is of the highest quality and very good all the time. However, the service was terrible. We received both our appetizers and our entrees cool. The first time we asked that our food be reheated, the second time we were with a large group and didn't want to make a scene.

.

The BEST Sicilian we have EVER had!! Sauce is well cooked, perfect crust.......
We have moved to VA, but make it a point to visit every time we go to LI!!!
Keep makin' the BEST pie!! :)

5
★★★★★

The BEST Sicilian we have EVER had!! Sauce is well cooked, perfect crust.......
We have moved to VA, but make it a point to visit every time we go to LI!!!
Keep makin' the BEST pie!! :)

Pros: consitent, sauce, service

Cons: parking, traffic

Similar Nearby

Similar Nearby

  1. 1
    Via Italia
    4% ★★★★☆ 3 reviews
    0.35 mi
  2. 2
    Paradise Pizza
    3% ★★★☆☆ 2 reviews
    0.43 mi
  3. 3
    0.67 mi
  4. 4
    Pizza D'Lusso
    5% ★★★★★ 1 review
    0.81 mi
  5. 5
    Olio Ristorante
    4% ★★★★☆ 2 reviews
    0.97 mi