Andrea's Brick Oven

★★★★☆

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Ribot

780 3rd Ave New York, NY

Resultset_next

Casa Mono

52 Irving Place New York, NY

3.9 10
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Andrea's Brick Oven was?
Write a Review
.

best pizza in gramercy. I come here all the time. the owner and mangaers and staff are awesome. great time when you are with a group of people. I come here and order delivery all the time. good pizza and also a big menu to chose from.

2
★★★★★

best pizza in gramercy. I come here all the time. the owner and mangaers and staff are awesome. great time when you are with a group of people. I come here and order delivery all the time. good pizza and also a big menu to chose from.

Pros: great time with groups

Cons: cant think of anything

.

Not sure what wotiluv's problem is but this is really great pizza. It is made in a brick oven and taste fantastic. I recomend coming here if you want to eat real pizza....

2
★★★★★

Not sure what wotiluv's problem is but this is really great pizza. It is made in a brick oven and taste fantastic. I recomend coming here if you want to eat real pizza....

Pros: great pizza

Cons: none

.

A group of us were looking for some good pizza deals in gramercy. Lucky that we found this place. The owner and staff were very nice. I always order from here and go when i can. very good pizza and have a lot to chose from on the menu.

2
★★★★★

A group of us were looking for some good pizza deals in gramercy. Lucky that we found this place. The owner and staff were very nice. I always order from here and go when i can. very good pizza and have a lot to chose from on the menu.

Pros: good people and food

Cons: cant think of any

.

this is the worse pizza in the hood- stay away from from here they claim it's thin crust over the phone and it is not and the taste is nasty like bad slices you can pick off the street It was so gross had to throw it away.

0
★☆☆☆☆

this is the worse pizza in the hood- stay away from from here they claim it's thin crust over the phone and it is not and the taste is nasty like bad slices you can pick off the street It was so gross had to throw it away.

Pros: Neary

Cons: the worse pizza ever

.

I was really surprised to see the two reviews below because we had nothing but good things to say about this place. We almost didn't go in because it was empty at 8:30 pm (albeit, on a Monday night) but so glad we did. We wanted a simple, low-key, average-priced quiet dinner and that's exactly what we wanted. Decently-priced, fair-quality wines by the glass and bottle. Salads were pretty uninspiring. The entrees were really great though - I had grilled sea bass (special that day) and my bf had veal marsala, both of which came in really tasty sauces and with roasted veggies that I thought were very well done. We enjoyed some tasty dessert martinis as well - the waiter made me a special one that wasn't on the menu but that was so good I had to order a second.

Overall we were really satisfied. This is not the place for first dates or for fancy dinners with high expectations. It's just a simple meal when you want a quiet night with good food, without a wait, trendy crowd, snooty maitre d's, and all the other BS that goes along with a decent meal in this town.

2
★★★★☆

I was really surprised to see the two reviews below because we had nothing but good things to say about this place. We almost didn't go in because it was empty at 8:30 pm (albeit, on a Monday night) but so glad we did. We wanted a simple, low-key, average-priced quiet dinner and that's exactly what we wanted. Decently-priced, fair-quality wines by the glass and bottle. Salads were pretty uninspiring. The entrees were really great though - I had grilled sea bass (special that day) and my bf had veal marsala, both of which came in really tasty sauces and with roasted veggies that I thought were very well done. We enjoyed some tasty dessert martinis as well - the waiter made me a special one that wasn't on the menu but that was so good I had to order a second.

Overall we were really satisfied. This is not the place for first dates or for fancy dinners with high expectations. It's just a simple meal when you want a quiet night with good food, without a wait, trendy crowd, snooty maitre d's, and all the other BS that goes along with a decent meal in this town.

Pros: Quiet, quick and good service, good entrees

Cons: Appetizers and salads - boring

.

Always a reliable meal in comfortable surroundings....all the typical Italian fare together with terrific thin-crust pizza....the brick oven gives most dishes an extra depth of flavor. Be sure to sample the homemade potato chips served at the bar....and the garlic rolls served at the tables.......However, the waitstaff changes often and most of them, while pleasant, are amateurish. Be aware that Andreas is cash only.

2
★★★★☆

Always a reliable meal in comfortable surroundings....all the typical Italian fare together with terrific thin-crust pizza....the brick oven gives most dishes an extra depth of flavor. Be sure to sample the homemade potato chips served at the bar....and the garlic rolls served at the tables.......However, the waitstaff changes often and most of them, while pleasant, are amateurish. Be aware that Andreas is cash only.

Pros: brick oven gives depth of flavor

Cons: amateurish service....cash only

.

It's a little expensive and the food does not have much taste to it. It looks like it would be good, but when you put it in your mouth, it's very plain. The martinis are good. Maybe just to go have a drink, it's a cute nice place to go after work.

3
★★★☆☆

It's a little expensive and the food does not have much taste to it. It looks like it would be good, but when you put it in your mouth, it's very plain. The martinis are good. Maybe just to go have a drink, it's a cute nice place to go after work.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Best pizza in town!!! I've traveled the world and Andrea's pizza taste like real Italian pizza (the crust, sauce, cheese), not like the American slices you get at corner pizza places! Try it once and you will come back again and again. The pizza tastes like homemade pizza. The sauce is incredible! The restaurant is very cozy, dim light, and very clean. Service is very friendly and quick. There are TVs on the walls so you can watch sports with your friends. Just remember to bring cash.

2
★★★★★

Best pizza in town!!! I've traveled the world and Andrea's pizza taste like real Italian pizza (the crust, sauce, cheese), not like the American slices you get at corner pizza places! Try it once and you will come back again and again. The pizza tastes like homemade pizza. The sauce is incredible! The restaurant is very cozy, dim light, and very clean. Service is very friendly and quick. There are TVs on the walls so you can watch sports with your friends. Just remember to bring cash.

Pros: The pizza!!! The service!

Cons: They don't take credit cards - cash only!!!

.

Cash Only! No credit cards accepted, weird. Food was pretty average. Caesar salad makes your tongue tingle, not in a good way! Recommend penne vodka. If you like lots of fake flowers this is the place for you!

1
★★★☆☆

Cash Only! No credit cards accepted, weird. Food was pretty average. Caesar salad makes your tongue tingle, not in a good way! Recommend penne vodka. If you like lots of fake flowers this is the place for you!

.

The bread is amazing. The pizza was really good. Service was very friendly and accomodating.

2
★★★★☆

The bread is amazing. The pizza was really good. Service was very friendly and accomodating.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Andrea's Brick Oven, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review