Insider Pages Reviews for Pescatore

5 Stars: fGreat Restaurant for a Bridal Shower (by SharonPeiffer)

SharonPeiffer — Mon, 05 May 2008 02:00:00 GMT

I had a bridal shower for my daughter on 5/3/08. Pescatore was truly an amazing place to celebrate this very special occasion. The service, food, drinks, etc. could not have been better. All the guests were so thrilled with their great food and service. The staff was extremely helpful, even helping us load gifts in and out of our vehicle. I highly recommend Pescatore for a private party event. Manager Charlesand staff helped us have a very memorable day! We can't wait to return for another great meal!

5 Stars: Aways the Best! (by Michael A.)

Michael A. — Sat, 09 Feb 2008 12:31:00 GMT

What can I say; it has been a favorite of Jaana and mine for to many years to list. You wont find a more consistent place in NYC. The service, food, and drinks are great. One of the very few places in the city with a steady neighborhood crowd and wait staff that has been on board for years, that says something in a city like New York.
Mangia!

5 Stars: Great food, great little place. (by sweetevita)

sweetevita — Tue, 26 Jun 2007 02:00:00 GMT

I found out about Pescatore about a year ago, and I've been a loyal customer ever since. The servers are very friendly, knowledgeable, and accomodating. I have never had a bad experience here. Their selection of appetizers, pastas, and fish is great and their food is always fresh. Their dishes are very natural and not over-done, with just the right amount of seasonings and garnishings. Granted, this place is not exactly what I would call cheap, but you do get some great food for the price.

Oh, and their tiramisu is heavenly.

5 Stars: Great seafood italian gem (by joshalee)

joshalee — Mon, 04 Sep 2006 02:00:00 GMT

We were planning to go to a sushi place tonight and it was closed. As we walked along 2nd avenue we found Pescatore because of the crowded outdoor seating and interesting seafood menu. We were greeted by a pleasant hostess who surprisngly sat us immediately. The service was prompt and friendly and the food was amazing with great portions and a creative menu. Our entrees included shark fillet and an abundance of fresh seafood such as: Lobster, prawns, swordfish, mussells and scallops. The sorbet dessert was a great way to cap off the meal. The presentation was creative as the mango sorbet was presented in a mango shell. Reasonable prices, attentive friendly staff and a great low key location on 2nd avenue.

4 Stars: Good food, great service (by jdpollaro)

jdpollaro — Sat, 22 Jul 2006 02:00:00 GMT

The food was very good, and our service was even better. We had pasta and seafood dishes, which were very good, but I would not classify them as outstanding. Next time, we will try fish entrees as that is the specialty. Loved the atmosphere as well. We will head back!

5 Stars: Excellent value and service (by jedimarco)

jedimarco — Fri, 02 Jun 2006 02:00:00 GMT

Whenever we are in the city for the day we eat at Pescatore. The service is great and the food is delicious. In the nice weather we love the balcony overlooking second ave and enjoy leisurely lunches. The New Zealand Mussels are our favorite and the ossubucco is tender and melts in your mouth. The newly renovated side of the restaurant was a great idea and the ambience is wonderful. The staff is very attentive and makes you feel like family. We recommend this restaurant highly to all our friends and family and have never been disappointed.

2 Stars: Don't waste your time here (by zinc11)

zinc11 — Sat, 29 Apr 2006 02:00:00 GMT

What an underwhelming way to spend dinner. Wish we would have found somewhere where they know how to cook steak and seafood. The salmon carpaccio was just bland lox over a bed of unseasoned spinich, the NY strip steak was not a good cut of meat, the fish special, snapper, was tough and flavorless, and the key lime pie for dessert tasted like it was from a supermarket. On the upside, the waitstaff were friendly and attentive. We hated to complian at them, so just paid the bill and left, never to return.

4 Stars: good seafood & pasta (by sortmon)

sortmon — Fri, 28 Apr 2006 02:00:00 GMT

Six of us came for lunch on the company tab. we were seated on the 2nd floor balcony which was perfect for the sunny day. we started with the crispy bruschetta (piled with tomatoes & onions) & caprese (fresh mozzarella with very fresh tomato) as appetizers. afterwards, i had the grilled tuna ($18) served with bean salad. the huge tuna steak was very fresh and grilled rare according to my specifications. it was simply flavoured with salt, pepper, and lemon juice. the fish came atop a huge pile of bean (assortment of white, red, and string beans) salad marinated in a slightly spicy tomato-based sauce it complimented the steak very well. we sampled a few of the desserts. the homemade cheesecake was especially good (light & airy). the white chocolate mousse cake was pretty awful though very dry and dense. bill came to $220 including tip & drinks.

5 Stars: very good (by nycgirl171)

nycgirl171 — Mon, 03 Apr 2006 02:00:00 GMT

I went here for dinner after reading the reviews for this place. The people were nice and attentive. The menu had a good number of options. The calamari was a good portion and the lobster bisque was amazing. Try the halibut. And the tiramisu is a must. The value is excellent.

3 Stars: Just an Average run of the mill italian place (by jackryan)

jackryan — Tue, 28 Mar 2006 01:00:00 GMT

Nothing really stood out here. The service was good and they were on point with us. The best thing we had here were the New Zealand muscles...it was the special. They were HUGE and came in this tastey spicey sauce.

Meals were average at best.

Dinner bill minus any drinks was around 70 bucks.

3 Stars: Down Hill Slide (by 1martman)

1martman — Sun, 05 Mar 2006 01:00:00 GMT

Recent renovaitons eliminated one of the big draws, the Brick Oven which turned out great pizza and the like has been REMOVED. I went there at least a dozen times per year hosting and or directing parties to pescatore as well. It looks like the place is in going to head down the slippery slope of cutting cost and losing more business. It's a shame and I'm not happy.

5 Stars: Wonderful (by lolli280)

lolli280 — Thu, 23 Feb 2006 01:00:00 GMT

A little pricey, but otherwise the olives were delicious and the lobster bisque wonderful. My mother loved her penne ala vodka. Overall, a wonderful experience.

5 Stars: So Reliable, So Great (by seriouslyletsbehonest)

seriouslyletsbehonest — Thu, 15 Dec 2005 01:00:00 GMT

When I have guests in town, I can always count on there being great food and service at an affordable price here. Decor exudes a traditional warm and cozy vibe. Every dish I've tried there is fantastic.

5 Stars: great italian and seafood (by Kristen W.)

Kristen W. — Sat, 12 Nov 2005 21:39:00 GMT

this place is great. good value for your money, fresh seafood, and delicious pasta dishes. friendly service. can be crowded so reservations suggested.

PROS: fresh fish, excellent lobster bisque, good value
CONS: can be crowded

5 Stars: splendid (by Jaclyn d.)

Jaclyn d. — Wed, 02 Nov 2005 07:28:00 GMT

I went on a date here many years ago, set on teh balcony terrace overlooking 2nd ave. the food awas great, teh atmospehre was romantic adn teh service was terrific. I ahd a past primavera dish in which was it was excellent.

PROS: great dining experience
CONS: A lot of seafood, if your not a big fish eater....

5 Stars: EXCELLENT! (by sarbear77)

sarbear77 — Sun, 07 Aug 2005 02:00:00 GMT

This quaint restaurant has a great staff and the best ravioli I have ever eaten!! And I know ravioli. My friends all enjoyed their meals, as well, and we had a wonderful time. We will definitely go back.

4 Stars: User review by mamapop (by mamapop)

mamapop — Fri, 15 Jul 2005 02:00:00 GMT

This is a great place for lunch during the week. The value at lunch time is great and you have a wide range of things to choose from. My department always has lunch out here when we go out as a group. Very good food. You can chose between Pasta, Chicken, Sandwiches and of course fish. I don't eat fish, but I have heard they have great seafood. They have a monsterous fish dish which takes two people to eat.

5 Stars: A New York Staple (by dorgan)

dorgan — Thu, 17 Mar 2005 01:00:00 GMT

It is hard to find a restaurant that you can count on for a romantic dinner or a fun lively time with some friends or a great party setting with such reliable service and continually fabulous food. Maybe that is why there are so many regulars at Pescatore. The food is consistently delicious, always go for the fish special! or the osso buco and don't forget the chopped salad. The wine list is good, there is always a nice Chianti available and the staff is friendly and competent. I'm there every couple of weeks and from all the friendly faces I now recognize, so are a lot of other New Yorkers. Thanks Pescatore.......

5 Stars: Great for groups! (by jessicanatlo)

jessicanatlo — Wed, 16 Mar 2005 01:00:00 GMT

Pescatore is an overall wonderful restaurant! Great place to dine with a few friends or to have company parties. Pescatore has been more than generous in arranging and hosting many parties for Memorial Sloan Kettering. The staff is extremely attentive, helpful and kind! The atmosphere is inviting, cozy and romantic. Most importantly, the food is delicious!!!

5 Stars: What A Fabulous Night. (by amyrosefarmer)

amyrosefarmer — Wed, 16 Mar 2005 01:00:00 GMT

What a night. MSKCC nurses went out for an extraordinary dinner!! We had a beautiful private room with a nice big wide table. Great for talking to the whole group. The food was amazing, the service was superior and the atmosphere was beautiful with very unique and fabulous paintings on the walls! We will be back.

5 Stars: How did I not find this place sooner??! (by noiebird)

noiebird — Wed, 16 Mar 2005 01:00:00 GMT

When a friend recently told me about this great restaurant on second ave, I was a bit skeptical bc her enthusiasm was over the top. She was not wrong to be excited about finding it. Pescatore has such a great warm atmosphere and delicious food. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THE BABY LAMB CHOPS! I could almost make a meal from the olives and bread that they serve before your meal arrives (but make sure you save room for dessert - delicious cheesecake). The staff was extremely friendly and accomodating. Besides the great food, my boyfriend loved the big flat screen TV they have over the bar area.

5 Stars: what a fabulous night! (by amyrosefarmer199)

amyrosefarmer199 — Mon, 14 Mar 2005 01:00:00 GMT

I am writing to rave about the fabulous night!! We had a going away party in a beautiful private room at Pescatore. What a great table we had, what a delicious dinner, superior service. I cannot thank you enough for treating our group so well. The table worked out great for our big group. It was perfect to talk to everyone! I could not think of a better dinner! We will definitely be back!!

5 Stars: Excellent Food!, Excellent Service! (by wozob)

wozob — Mon, 07 Mar 2005 01:00:00 GMT

Food and Service of the same high quality elsewhere in NY
would have been twice the cost.
Highly recommended!!!

5 Stars: What's not to like?!?!?! (by kkleisch)

kkleisch — Thu, 24 Feb 2005 01:00:00 GMT

We had a wonderful dinner here before the theatre. It was walking distance from our hotel (2 blocks). The ambience was warm and friendly. The food was incredible!! We would recommend "Linguini Pescatore" very highly. All the seafood in it was prepared perfectly -- Not overcooked! Be prepared for LARGE portions. Loved the olives!

5 Stars: I love it (by dan0426)

dan0426 — Mon, 20 Sep 2004 02:00:00 GMT

To sum it up, had a wedding shower there. Excellent service, good food, a pleasant experience. Planned a surprise bday party for my girlfriend, the management helped to make sure it went flawlessly. Amazing service, and how many follow up phone calls did i get? just for dining there? I love it!

3 Stars: Been there, done that! (by aznfoodsnob)

aznfoodsnob — Mon, 30 Aug 2004 02:00:00 GMT

With so many choices available to us in the city, may I suggest you venture elsewhere to satisfy your craving for fine Italian cuisine? I was there recently with a group of friends which gave me the opportunity to sample the menu. There was nothing that offended the senses, but there was also nothing notable to speak of. Instead the place manages to offer average fare, served by an inexperienced wait staff.

2 Stars: Good Ambience but not good food (by kharrenski)

kharrenski — Sun, 29 Aug 2004 02:00:00 GMT

I went to Pescatore on a Thursday. Excellent ambience, service was good but so dissapointed w/ the food. We ordered fried calamari for appetizer and it was gummy, linguini with clam sauce was dry. My friend ordered ravioli it was nothing special. You only pay for the ambience though.

5 Stars: Just great (by jihoffman)

jihoffman — Fri, 02 Apr 2004 01:00:00 GMT

Had a very enjoyable dinner here. The food was great and the service was attentive (but not overbearing). Very relaxed, but classy. Highly recommended.

5 Stars: EXCELLENT (by witchblade)

witchblade — Fri, 27 Feb 2004 01:00:00 GMT

I have been dining at Pescatore for the past 3 years and absolutely love it, the service is always fantastic and the food delicious. Even on Valentine's day last year the service was impeccable, how many restaurants can you say that about in NYC!

5 Stars: Happy Anniversary (by jbscott11)

jbscott11 — Sun, 26 Oct 2003 01:00:00 GMT

The food melts in your mouth, the service is great and you'll definitely want to go back here and enjoy another great tasting dinner.

4 Stars: 1 of 4 favorites in area (by nycritic00)

nycritic00 — Fri, 19 Sep 2003 02:00:00 GMT

Sushi Rose, Murphy's Pub, Oriental Noodle & Pescatore are my 4 frequented spots in this area - diverse yet all very good. appetizers were good, mixed greens & calamari & veal francese were my favorite orders. bread little hard but dipped in olive oil & balsamic was good. svc could be better. a little tight for table of 3-4. nice to sit by balcony except during hot humid weather. SUM IT: give this a try, a little pricey for this area but it's good food.

1 Stars: One Big Dissapointment! (by donaldport)

donaldport — Fri, 25 Jul 2003 02:00:00 GMT

What it seems to be a nice restaurant from the outside could turn into a very mediocre experience while sitting down. Our apetizers took quite a while to be served, in fact, while all the other tables that sat way after us were being served I asked the waiter what happened to our appetizers, the calamari was tough; The entrees were tasteless and really!, one have to be really bad to mess a simple pasta dish. Pitty!

5 Stars: Nice place. (by ctac)

ctac — Thu, 03 Jul 2003 02:00:00 GMT

I looked this place here, on citysearch, and decided to try it. Went there with my friends, one of them was an editor for Departure magazine (luxury travel, food and wine). He used to dining at the best restaurants and he was surprised how great this place was. Food, service and atmosphere were way above your regular restaurant. Try it and see for yourself.

1 Stars: How tacky! (by mishyde)

mishyde — Fri, 06 Jun 2003 02:00:00 GMT

Our meal was very nice and the service - eh, nothing to rave about. The waitress took us as tourists and hand wrote a message about tipping 20%. After paying she returned and demanded a higher tip.

5 Stars: Food and Company (by Jason)

Jason — Tue, 22 Apr 2003 02:00:00 GMT

Thank you for the fantastic meal. My girlfriend and I went for a romantic dinner and came away satisfied. Strongly recommend the seafood pocket complimented with a nice bottle of California white wine.

5 Stars: A great restaurant (by konajeanne)

konajeanne — Tue, 04 Mar 2003 01:00:00 GMT

Pescatore is one of THE great restaurants in Manhattan. The service is great, the food is reasonably priced and it is delicious! In good weather the outdoor dining is the place to be.

5 Stars: Best Birthday (by Ife)

Ife — Wed, 26 Feb 2003 01:00:00 GMT

This resturant was good with a big group. I was searching diligently for an Italian resturant that was good with groups and had good food. They greeted me with a big Happy Birthday when we came in the door. We had 11 people the staff was friendly, the food was excellent, and they gave us a room upstairs away from the crowd and noise, with the radio tuned to whatever we wanted. And most of all we were comfortable. Beside the fact that there was one food slip up, this resturant was GREAT!!!

4 Stars: Loads of Potential (by risen_feenix)

risen_feenix — Mon, 24 Feb 2003 01:00:00 GMT

The food at Pescetore had the potential to be great, but only made it to "pretty good".

First, my appetizer of "fresh" mozzarella, tomato and peppers was "fresh" in the sense that was not "polly-o". It may have been fresh three or four days ago, but what I had was hard and bland. Either get a new supplier, or stop serving old fresh mozzarella. The catfish special was perfectly cooked, but brutally over-seasoned. When you have a great piece of fish (as they had), subtle seasoning is all that is required (and desired). I actually experienced physical pain while eating, there was so much pepper on the fish.

Decor was nice, quiet music in the background, and the staff was friendly and attentive. Pescetore could definitely be a great with the right chef (or properly instructed cooks). For now, it stays in the list of "could have beens".

5 Stars: heavenly and devine!! (by farmer303)

farmer303 — Mon, 03 Feb 2003 01:00:00 GMT

what an unbelievably yummy and fantastic place to go. this is truly a neighbood secret slowly being let out of the bag. this swimmingly fab food goes so well with the tremendous wine list offered.. the sleek surroundings and casual atmosphere allow for romance or a fun group setting. what an enjoyable array of paintings and photos placed so uniquely on the walls. but, the staff has to be the ultimate draw to this fine establishment. the waiters always know what to deliver and the best things to recommend!! another place that belongs in heaven!!

5 Stars: City Top 10-- (by jclee79)

jclee79 — Tue, 21 Jan 2003 01:00:00 GMT

The food and decor was excellent. If you are looking for a nice small restuarant, with great service and excellent food, look no further. My girlfriend and I had a great time. The black linguine was so good. But really the best part of the meal was the delicious homemade tiramisu

4 Stars: I would go there again!.. (by soogah)

soogah — Sat, 18 Jan 2003 01:00:00 GMT

The food was good here and the service was excellent!The waiter gave excellent service he was very attentive to our every needs during dinner and extreamly polite.(something I am truely picky on.) The bill was very reasonably priced considering in new york city standards and I would definatly go back there again! The only con was that the place was too noisy and parking around that area sucks.

5 Stars: Worth Another Visit (by kubswfan)

kubswfan — Wed, 01 Jan 2003 01:00:00 GMT

This place was packed, so reservations ahead of time are a must! With Reservations, our party waited 25 minutes for a table. The menu provided a vast selection, and the appetizers themselves were large portions and delicious. The entree is a heavenly delight for seafood lovers--so much to choose from, this is deserving of additional visits. I regret we didn't have room for dessert. The only mildly negative is in regard to the service--it's so busy, you'll definitely need to flag down the wait staff; rarely will be come over and ask you about the food.

5 Stars: Potential disaster avoided (by writa)

writa — Fri, 13 Dec 2002 01:00:00 GMT

Rest. lost our reservation. It was a Saturday night. What's a party of 8 to do? Not to worry. The host found a table for us, and a great waiter. Food was wonderful.

4 Stars: Good food, Great service (by jaiunmouton)

jaiunmouton — Mon, 25 Nov 2002 01:00:00 GMT

This place was great: the food was delicious (especially the desserts --the cheesecake was amazing), the waiters were really friendly and nice. I don't think you can go wrong with this place - whether you're on a date or with a group of friends.

5 Stars: Great food, good service (by hocampo)

hocampo — Thu, 31 Oct 2002 01:00:00 GMT

A very good option for a nice dinner in a comfortable setting. The menu is quite varied, with fish, meat, and pasta entries. The specials are always good. As the specialty is fish, most of their fish dishes are fantastic. Great date restaurant, if a bit on the noisy side.

5 Stars: delicious!!! (by oi812)

oi812 — Fri, 25 Oct 2002 02:00:00 GMT

I was here a couple of weeks ago with a party of eight. We were seated in the upstairs room right away. The food was delicious! The wine was just right and the service was attentive but not in your face. Everybody walked away from dinner very happy. The best part was that we didn't have to break the bank to have such a great meal. I highly recommend Pescatore to anyone. Whether you are a dining snob or just looking for a great dinner you will like Pescatore.

4 Stars: quick full meal (by sunchef182)

sunchef182 — Fri, 25 Oct 2002 02:00:00 GMT

I thought everyone was very friendly but felt rushed. Food was good but no timing between coarses. I work in the Food and beverage industry and I can tell my fish sat in the window while I finished my salad. Overall was a good experience. wouldn't recommend for relax dining. good for dinner before going out on the town. Waitstaff very friendly.

5 Stars: birthday party success! (by bisonification)

bisonification — Wed, 18 Sep 2002 02:00:00 GMT

i threw a birthday dinner for my roommate here and it turned out to be a great success. we had about 20 people and we were seated right away. the staff was very courteous and delightful. we were seated in an upstairs room which was very private and cozy, providing an intimate environment which is hard to find for such a large group outing. the food was excellent! the prices were even more excellent. i had the black linguine with rock shrimp, lobster meat, prosciutto and fresh plum tomatoes. it was oh so delicious! this restaurant is a keeper!

5 Stars: Excellent Food, Excellent Service (by pernell74)

pernell74 — Sat, 07 Sep 2002 02:00:00 GMT

Initially I was skeptical as I had never relied on internet reviews for a restuarant , but the reviews were well deserved.
The Presentation of the food was not only Fantastic, but the Food, from the appetizers(I'd recommend the Seafood Purse) to the entrees and desert, was also scrumptous!
I would highly recommend this restaurant for small or large parties(3-4).
This is my new favorite restaurant.

4 Stars: constant (by ricochan)

ricochan — Fri, 06 Sep 2002 02:00:00 GMT

It's been more than a year since I first visited Pescatore, but the food and service is constant. When it's warmer, I take balcony seats upstairs. One of the best steamed mussles in town.

4 Stars: Nice Place (by dkui)

dkui — Mon, 29 Jul 2002 02:00:00 GMT

second time in about two weeks that i've been there and this place is slowly becoming a favorite for me. Fish specials are good, chicken fettucine is excellent. service could have been a little better but all in all great food and great value. menu has a good selection of italian and seafood. nice comfortable dining atmosphere.

5 Stars: Amazing!!! (by keren090)

keren090 — Wed, 17 Jul 2002 02:00:00 GMT

Food was amazing! Service was so nice and prompt. Got a table right away. Recommend to everyone!

5 Stars: Perfect! Thanks to all!! (by wheresmysocks)

wheresmysocks — Mon, 24 Jun 2002 02:00:00 GMT

Excellent choice for a special occassion! I had a surprise evening planned for my wife on our 15th wedding anniversary (a new ring). I called and spoke with Bret (Mgr) a few days before our arrival in New York. He was absolutely in tune with my surprise and what I was trying to accomplish! He was extremely helpful and told me that everyone would be ready! He was right! Our waiter Carlos had been made aware of the event and was discretly playing along. The surprise desert (ring) was a huge hit! Thanks Carlos and thanks to Charles (Mgr) and all of the staff! The food, service and the staff's knowledge of the surprise helped me to pull off a perfect evening and a perfect memory! Thanks Pescatore!! I'll be back.

5 Stars: Fabulous (by JenniferKlein)

JenniferKlein — Mon, 20 May 2002 02:00:00 GMT

Tops with everything!! The service here is outstanding!! Extremely courteous and accomadating staff! The pizza is a must! Linguini nere is filled with flavor. Other great dishes were the Salmon and the chicken paillard! Everyone loved the meal!! If you like your sweets the chocolate mud cake was outstanding! The food, the service and lets not forget the candle lit surroundings were ALL A HIT!!!!!!