Philip Marie

After hearing some friends rave about the great food and moderate prices, my husband and I could not resist. Sadly we were so extremely disappointed. The restaurant was not all it was cracked up to be in fact I would venture to say that it was nothing short of a glorified diner. The silver wear was not clean, and there was an overpowering stench coming from an undetermined place. The food was defiantly unremarkable. I would NOT recommend eating at this establishment in the future, and I am shocked to hear that it has been open for quite a few years who let that one slip?! Diners be ware.

Pros: thumbs down

Cons: we will never recomend this place EVER

Posted 11/02/06

Amazing atmosphere and featuring incredible tastes and attention to detail. I always have great service and fine cusine. In addition to the fabulous menu, there are always innovative specials making it so hard to decide what to select.

It is definitely a great place, and one you will keep going back!

Pros: Food, atmosphere, service

Posted 10/29/06

I dont know what that person was talking about. Maybe she or he was having a bad day. I LOVE the brunch, its great food, affordable and i think the jazz band was fantastic. Where else can you get sweet potato pancakes?!?!?! Its a bit crowded, but welcome to NYC BRUNCH!!!!! I say go there and find out for yourself. My wife and I simply love it!!

Pros: affordable and cozy

Cons: a little crowded

Posted 10/26/06

I specifically made a reservation here for brunch because Citysearch recommended it as one of the 10 best (!?) brunch spots. I will never trust a Citysearch recommendation again, because this place offered an utterly mediocre brunch. Not even mediocre, but just plain BAD. The quality of food was identical to what I would get at my local diner, and the presentation was just as unlovely. The service was poor. My blueberry pancakes tasted like baking powder, my friend's scrambled eggs looked as if they were just scraped off a cafeteria grill and slid onto her plate, the waitress forgot our orange juice and maple syrup and had to be reminded to go get them. I can't believe I actually went out of my way to go to brunch here, and I was actually embarrassed that I had offered to treat my friend to brunch and THIS was what I treated her to. I am convinced that this restaurant has enlisted friends of the owners to concoct positive reviews for Citysearch in order to bring in business---which wouldn't even be such a bad thing if the food and service lived up in any way to the "hype." Don't be fooled by the jazz band either--although I enjoyed the music, the restaurant is rather too small for a loud jazz band, and it hardly makes up for the utterly lackluster food and service.

Pros: The Maitre D', the jazz band

Cons: The Food, the Service, the tight space

Posted 10/25/06

What an adorable restaurant. For those of you who don't enjoy the cozy ambience of a 200 seat dining room, Philip Marie offers an intimate setting which, in my humble opinion, serves as the perfect spot for a date. The food and wine were superb, with service to match. If you are looking for a romantic, cozy restaurant with great food and stellar service, you have to give this place a serious look.

Posted 09/10/06

I was a bit suckered by the fabulous reviews...thinking this was a well kept secret. Living in Ct and traveling to the city work and fun.....always want to try something new. To spite my less than glowing review (food quite nice if a little boring, very stinky sidewalk aroma, wobbly table, bad champagne...nothing really remarkable) I understand WHY new yorkers would love this place. It is low key, food is homestylish & it is affordable. I admit, I was looking for a little more excitement...but the kind hostess & waiter sent us down the street to EO, and the evening was finished with the scene and energy we crave in NY. I give it a 7.

Posted 08/31/06

My friend and I went here after she ran the half marathon last weekend and we were starving. The food was served quickly and it was DELICIOUS!! The brunch menu was fantastic, and the mimosa (sat.) and bloody mary (sun.) brunch specials are an incredible bargain. I can't believe the prices are so reasonable for such fantastic food. The jazz music was the perfect touch for relaxing and you can rarely find such a charming and spacious area in the city - for once I didn't feel like I was slammed up against another person next to me. The manager was very helpful and came to check on our meals, and they have great weekly specials. Looking forward to my next visit!

Pros: great price, delicious food

Cons: waitress was flaky but nice

Posted 08/30/06

My husband and I foudn Philip Marie in the fall of 1999. For lunch we shared a sandwich and salad, with an amazing hazelnut chocolate cake (don't think they serve this anymore). Perfect. We returned for dinner a few weeks later and we continue to eat there as often as possible. The private room for 2 was our anniversary present to ourselves after the birth of our son. AMAZING!!! The service and food and wine pairings were amazing. Brunch is also fabulous. Kids are easily accomodated too.

Pros: the changing specials menu (my husband loves the game entrees)

Cons: none

Posted 08/18/06

The entrees there are extremely unique. They are not plates that you would expect in every other American restaurant. There are also exquisite names for most of the dishes, such as "Dancing Shrimp." I've been there 5 times with my boyfriend now and it has became "our" restaurant. Despite my love for this Philip Marie, the food is falling slightly below my initial impression of it. Service quality depends on the waiter. There was also a recent incident in which my boyfriend's mother got a deep cut on her finger while closing the bathroom door. Overall, Philip Marie is a great place for a nice dinner. I will definitely go back for a 6th time, but I will stay away from the bathroom and any cranky waiters.

Pros: FOOD!

Cons: may be difficult to find

Posted 08/16/06

always something special to eat. great food in general with the best prices around. the staff is friendly and prompt. i love the outside seats in the summer. you can eat, have cheap beers at happy hour and watch the "show" walk by. the inside window seats are beautiful too.

Pros: food and ambiance.

Cons: closed on mondays.

Posted 07/28/06

great fare, with fantastic specials. the outside seating is lot of fun. i could eat their every day. and they have a great brunch on the weekends.

Pros: food and service

Cons: no parking

Posted 07/28/06

I'm an old man for crying out loud and have lived and eaten in over a hundred countries in this world and all over this country.

Let me tell you that there isn't a place on this earth where I have experienced, in my not-so-humble opinion, consistently superb food and excellent service.

John Greco is a genius (I should know).

One afternoon Mel Brooks was at the next table and telling John's wife how much he enjoyed the food. So I interrupted and asked, "It is really fantastic, isn't it?" He chimed back, "And the price is right, I'll tell ya!" And that is an additional perk, and comes directly from Mel and me!

So listen to me. Go to Philip Marie. Tell them I sent you. Ask for Herb, but don't believe a thing he says about me -- I'm a very nice person. And if you don't believe me, ask John Greco. Did i mention the guy is a genius? He's got a way with a spatula that's spectacula!

Posted 07/28/06

Last night I went on a date at Philip Marie. Can I say it was fantastic. The food was possibly the best that we have ever ate. We started with an amazing warm mozzarella salad(to die for). We then shared the Lobster spring roll (the freshest that I have ever had). For our entrees we had a most tender wild boar and the most melt in your mouth lamb shank. The server that we had was so professional. He knew exactly what wines to pair with each course. I highly recommend this establishment to anyone who has never been. I also must say to make a reservation because the place does fill up. My sincere compliments to the chef and staff for a wonderful evening.

Pros: The food, the service, the ambiance

Cons: nothing that I can think of.

Posted 07/28/06

I just had to wright something.It was great . Went there 3 times IT JUST GOT BETTER AND BETTER.......The food is five stars .Its a must try place...tues thay have clambake very cool .

Pros: THE FOOD

Cons: NONE

Posted 07/28/06

Just when we thought there was nothing better, Philip Marie outdid itself. We love the Tuesday Clambake and weekend brunchs. We brought friends to brag about our find, only to be wowed again. The chef created specials that blew us away. We plan on attending their next wine tasting dinner in October. The last one was amazing!
We can't wait to enjoy the private room for 2 for our anniversay. Thanks to the great staff for always making us feel at home...and then some.

Pros: everything you could want in a great dining experience

Cons: none

Posted 07/26/06

A spectacular place! The staff is great and the food is wonderful. A must go on their special celebration days. Mardi Gras was unbelievable.

Pros: A menu with a flair and flavor like no other restaurant in NYC

Cons: none

Posted 07/24/06

There's never an issue when you're taking people into the city for a wonderful meal because you know that this restaurant always delivers with their food and service, they consistently receive high marks. They also make you feel as if you're home with good friends and this was true even on our first visit. Highly recommend......

Pros: Consistency

Cons: None

Posted 07/23/06

Philip Marie has a great atmosphere. It is a nice needed change from the busy streets of NYC. It's relaxed, with soothing music...very romantic. Perfect for dinners with family and friends, or the ideal restaurant for a date.

Our food was delicious! Great service. What's not to love? Definitely one of my favorite places in the city! I highly recommend it for your next meal out!

A+++

Pros: Service, Atmosphere, Food...

Posted 07/19/06

Don't get confused by the name. It is not a French restaurant. The cuisine is based on basic, familiar American ingredients.

Pros: location

Posted 07/16/06

What a special place. We got engaged here and it was amazing. Everything was top notch; the food, service, atmosphere and hospitality. We look forward to returning soon as husband and wife and maybe even beforehand.

Pros: Great food, beautiful atmosphere, amazing service

Cons: none

Posted 07/15/06

Have been back to PM many times, both in the main room and the private wine cellar for special occasions. The food is always wonderful, inventive, different (wild boar anyone?) and delicious. The service never fails, from the moment you step in, until your completely sated departure. The space is beautiful, romantic, welcoming. I've turned on countless friends to PM and all have had the same experiences. Toques off to John Greco, Herb Westphalen & staff.

Pros: Inventive, delicious food, beautiful space (Check out intimate wine cellar)

Cons: None

Posted 07/10/06

We are clowns in Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade and after a nap on Thanksgiving Day, we always have our holiday dinner at Phillip Marie's. This is one restaurant where the holiday meals are as good as other days. You even get a turkey dinner to take home regardless of what you order! The presentation, food, and friendly yet professional service are always excellent and the restaurant charming. Delightful in the warm weather when you can eat outside and do some great people watching while you enjoy delicious meals. A great find in a great neighborhood.

Pros: Excellent knowlewdgeable staff, great menu choice

Cons: tables are a bit close

Posted 07/08/06

We found PM when we purchased a Wine Cellar Dinner for Two that John had donated to a Cancer Care Auction. After having a couple of great lunches and a fabulous Australian wine tasting dinner, we finally tried the private dinner in the wine cellar - WOW! Personal server, excellent food and service with matching wines. We just gave a certificate for the same kind of evening to our newly engaged daughter. We cannot wait to do it again; dozens of friends we have sent there have only raved.

Go Philip Marie and your great manager-Herb. Thanks for enjoyable times...
Your faithful Patrons - David and Sharon

Pros: see our review - all great

Cons: Nada

Posted 07/07/06

My husband brought me to Phillip Marie on our first date. Three years later we got engaged in the romantic and charming wine room where the service is outstanding and the food absolutely delicious. We even had our engagment dinner here where our entire family raved about the unique dinner choices, excellent wine, and family atmosphere. Our favorites are the Wild Boar and Fried Green tomatos!

The Martino's

Posted 07/07/06

This place is a fantastic little gem for all to enjoy. The hosts/owners are very friendly and they instill that quality in their servers. The food is a unique mix of cajun, american, and even some french flavors. Try the singing scallops if you are lucky enough to be there on a night where they aren't sold out or out of season. There is a private dining room in the basement, where the old colonial kitchen used to be, really a very comfortable spot. The best tables are at or near the front windows, but the whole place has "comfortable" quality to it. I have eaten there quite a few times and have never been disappointed. Bon appetit!

Pros: Ambience, value, service

Cons: parking

Posted 07/06/06

Dining at Philip Marie is an experience that everyone deserves. The moment you walk in, you're embraced with an "at home" feeling. John, Herb and the staff really know how to make each experience unique. The food is DIVINE!!! The food coupled with the service . . . you can't go wrong . . . hey, and the price is right!!!! Cudos to John and his staff!

Posted 07/06/06

We dine out here frequently. We love the attentive, friendly wait staff and interesting menu. The food is delicious and the atmosphere comforting.

Pros: Location and Ambience

Cons: Not recomended for children under 5

Posted 07/06/06

We visit NYC at least twice a year and always try to have dinner at PM at least once during our visit. The service is always professional yet friendly which creates a comfortable, relaxing dining experience. I find the food to be inventive and at the same time very satisfying with an emphasis on fresh ingredients. All in all, an experience worth repeating even though we only visit a few times a year.

Posted 07/06/06

We stopped here on the way to another restaurant because they had 2 for 1 drinks and thought we'd try it out. The bartender could not have been nicer (or cuter) and gave us 2 coupons for a free bottle of wine for next time. After trying to get into every Mexican place to celebrate Cinco de Mayo we decided to use our coupon at Philip Marie and couldn't have been happier. We sat outside on a beautiful night, the staff was so friendly, the food was great, and the wine was wonderful. I got the dancing shrimp and the next time I think I'll get them again and get the singing scallops to accompany them. : ) Can't wait to try the brunch.

Pros: Food, Location, Service

Posted 05/06/06

Philip Marie is always great. You can always count on excellent service, excellent food, a nice variety of food, a wonderful jazz brunch, a comfortable open-airy atmosphere, really nice people and staff, and just an overalll fresh invigorating experience. The tasting room downstairs looks like a great place for an event. The food is fantastic. Try the white chocolate french toast or the farmers omlette....

Posted 04/14/06

This place has it all.......Great food, great wine, romantic ambience, and good value for a village restaurant. The service is good and the atmosphere is great. Good place to sit on their patio for dinner in the summer.

Pros: food, service, romantic

Posted 04/04/06

My boyfriend come here a lot in the summer when we can sit outside. For lunch we often split the BLT (the best BLT I have ever had) and a fruit plate. For dinner we love the muscles, the scallops and the wild boar. The service is hit-or-miss and sometimes just bizarre, but the food is always excellent. I am pleased to have this restaurant in our neighborhood.

Pros: food

Cons: service

Posted 01/29/06

This was my second visit and I could not get back here fast enough!! It is a NY MUST while the neighbor has sky rocketed in prices & attitude and the over abundance of 'so so' food, Philip Marie has shined with its excellence if Food Service and Ambiance unlike anything else in the Village.
The old world style and professionalism makes this a definate NY GEM!

Pros: FOOD, FOOD, SERVICE

Posted 12/02/05

We've lived in New York for 10 years and haven't had a brunch experience as bad as this one. The coffee came cold, our waitress was in her sweats (eating a pear no less!), the staff spent most of the time eating breakfast at a separate table and neglecting customers, and the food was just god awful. Anything interesting on the menu? Sorry, they were out of it. Never again.

Pros: when it was over

Cons: food was awful, service stunk, it's not French

Posted 10/29/05

As a native new yorker I 1) know a deal when I see one and 2) know when food is as it should be. This restaurant blows me away everytime I go there. I live in the neighborhood, go at least once a week, and am never disappointed. From the courteous staff to the amazing food, I am never disappointed. If you haven't been here you are really missing out. They also have two awesome private dining rooms they I am dying to try. Enjoy!!

Posted 06/03/05

i had never been to this restaurant before, and my decision was based solely on the reviews. i was kinda nervous, cause i was meeting 5 other people there. but they did live up to their fame. it was a really fun experiance. the unlimited mimosa bruch was great ! they kept filling up our glasses... didnt ever see the bottom of my glass ! food was good with generous portions. i left full and happy. would definately recommend this place for a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, a family event, mother's day ... anything ! just go...you'll like it !

Pros: unlimited mimosa, good service, good food

Posted 05/14/05

A great "comfort food" type menu served much more elegantly. Delicious menu, excellent presentation, and great service. A cozy bar area to meet someone for a casual drink to boot!

Posted 04/21/05

My husband and I dine hear at least twice a month. The food is exceptional, the atmosphere lovely, and the service very attentive. The decor is a little cheesy (gotta get rid of the murals, tree branches, and tapestry drapes), but the place feels warm and inviting. Be sure to check out the private dining areas downstairs - lovely table for two in the wine vault and the private party room toward the front of the property. Just delightful! (I'd like to recommend the squid ink lobster-filled ravioli in tomato cream sause - my favorite!!)

Posted 04/10/05

This place was amazing! After a terrible appetizer/drinks experience a few blocks away, we stumbled upon this oasis of welcoming staff, great service, awesome martinis and to-die-for desserts. The dining room looks cozy and romantic with candle lamps at every table, but our raucous party of 10 was welcomed with open arms and made to feel right at home. The staff - even those who had no expectation of receiving a tip - were attentive, friendly and solicitous. The biscotti gelato and carrot cake were amazing. I can't wait to try the jazz brunch.
Definitely the best kept secret in the Village!

Pros: Waitstaff, Ambiance, Food/drinks

Posted 03/24/05

I came here with some friends and knew nothing about it other than the owners' middle names were put together to sound french but it was an american restaurant - and I was a little worried. Turns out that was the last thing I needed to be. We sat at this cozy booth by the window and had wonderful food with great service. They were out of a couple of items we ordered so they comped a bottle of wine - very nice gesture on their part.

I hear that there are a couple of nice dining rooms downstairs that also have quite a history - including a tunnel to the White Horse Tavern (dating back to prohibition).

I think this is a good place to bring a date or even the parents. Not too expensive, good food and cozy for being as crowded as it was.

Posted 02/02/05

I went with three others for an early (5pm) dinner on a Saturday. Seated promptly with our reservation, though our waiter seemed pretty unconfident (or was it incompetant?). Luckily the busboys and other servers all pitched in to bring us our dishes and clear the table. Three of us had the red snapper, while the fourth had a sweet chicken dish (all on the menu I believe, not specials). All of us enjoyed our meal, and for the price (~$185, w/ tax&tip, 2 bottles of wine, 1 appetizer each, plus entrees) it was pretty impressive. Ambiance: romantic, plus a cozy feel (and not the "cozy" used to describe small apartments). Would definitely return.

Pros: menu, wine, ambiance

Posted 01/10/05

Excellent food, great service, and a nice restauarant. We picked from the extensive wine list, shared a great escargot appetizer, and then enjoyed the wild boar and the snapper for dinner. Everything was delicious. The service was attentive but relaxed. I was amazed at the low, low price-tag for such a pleasant experience.

Pros: Food, Service, Cost

Posted 08/30/04

Last night my husband and I dined at Philip Marie. A friend of ours had given us a gift certificate to the wine room. It was absolutely beautiful. The chef who is a bundle of personality came to tell us all about the special menu for the wine room. He told us that whatever we wanted could be prepared it was just a matter of deciding. I chose the lobster it was decadent. My husband went for the wild boar. We will definetely be returning and buying gift certificates for the friends who got us hooked.

Pros: Great food, Excellent service, Beautiful atmosphere

Posted 06/05/04

Of the great service, wine list, and the incredible food. The specials are always diverse, and one can find excellent and unique dishes during the weekends. A great place

Posted 06/03/04

The brunch food was good and my Bloody Mary was delicious. They have a few interesting choices on the brunch menu, it's inexpensive, and the portions are quite large. We sat by a huge window with a great view for people watching, and the murals on the walls are also nice. A good choice; I would definitely return.

Pros: food, service, atmosphere

Cons: nothing significant

Posted 07/22/03

After dipping into corner bistro twice to check on the line and deciding that no hamburger is worth 30 minutes in a crowded line I wandered into this place. It's a delightful little "Bistro" style restaurant. The menu looked good as did the price, and they also had a "steak burger" which sounded about my speed. Though the food took a while to arrive is was perfect beyond imagination. A huge chunk of prime usda juicy goodness along with fresh roasted tomatoes on a kind of oversized english muffin along with some very well seasoned crisscross fries, wow; just wow.

Posted 03/15/03

My girlfriend and I dined at Philip Marie Friday night and we were amazed at the experience. A gem in the Village serving incredible and incredibly priced food in a romantic, casual atmosphere. The service was superb and John, the chef/owner was so energetic, personable and made us feel as if we were VIPs. Everything is homemade on the premises and there wasn't anything that we ate that was not satisfying. From the appetizer and soup sampler to the awesome cheesecake and bread pudding, this restauraunt is a true find.

Pros: incredible food, great value, cozy atmosphere

Posted 03/02/03

I've been going back to this place for years, it's fantastic. Over time the quality has gone up and down, but I've really never been too disappointed and sometimes I've been amazed. Wine list needs to be updated, but otherwise great place.

Posted 01/04/03

I found this place online and decided to give it a try. I am so glad that I did. The smoked salmon and aspargus was delilcious, the staff was attentive and never rushed us. The prices were fair as well. It's a wonderful place for two.

Pros: Attentive staff, Delicious food, Well put together

Posted 12/08/02

The cute little place was found through our entertainment book. We've been back 10 times since. The food is good and fair priced. Inside is very romantic. The service was great, freindly and prompt . good value for this atmospher.

Pros: atmospher, food, service

Posted 12/06/02