Amish Market Westside

★★★★☆
  • 731 9th Ave 1

    New York, NY 10019

    Map & Directions
  • 212-245-2360

About Amish Market Westside

Hours
7 am-9:30 pm
4.0 8
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Amish Market Westside was?
Write a Review
.

when i am in town, i get my apples and yogurt here.

2
★★★★★

when i am in town, i get my apples and yogurt here.

.

This is one the best places I've been to in NYC. It's clean. The customer service is excellent. Their shelves are stocked with gourmet items. If you're into buying organic, they have packaged items and fruits/vegetable/herbs that are organic as well. They have a butcher section with beautiful cuts of meat displayed. All fresh looking. They also have fresh fish (no smell!).

I bought some fresh fruit from them and thought I had died and gone to Heaven. The peaches were incredible. The vegetables were all great looking. Looked like they were just picked.

They also have hot food and fresh salads. Their pizza is probably better than more than half the pizza places in NYC. The hot buffet looked awesome, although I haven't tried it yet. They also had a grill going next to the pizza station. Not sure what they were cooking there but the smell that was wafting over was making my mouth water.

I'd bet almost anything that the 2 negative reviews are from people that work for Whole Foods or some other store that's in competition with Amish Market.

Oh, and it IS run by Amish people. If you know anything about the way the Amish live their lives you would know that they can't use or touch certain types of machinery and electronics. So, obviously, you are not going to see an Amish person behind the cash register. If you see the butcher grinding meat with an electric grinder he/she is not Amish. They can't man a lot of the positions in the store simply due to their beliefs. But the place is run by the Amish.

2
★★★★★

This is one the best places I've been to in NYC. It's clean. The customer service is excellent. Their shelves are stocked with gourmet items. If you're into buying organic, they have packaged items and fruits/vegetable/herbs that are organic as well. They have a butcher section with beautiful cuts of meat displayed. All fresh looking. They also have fresh fish (no smell!).

I bought some fresh fruit from them and thought I had died and gone to Heaven. The peaches were incredible. The vegetables were all great looking. Looked like they were just picked.

They also have hot food and fresh salads. Their pizza is probably better than more than half the pizza places in NYC. The hot buffet looked awesome, although I haven't tried it yet. They also had a grill going next to the pizza station. Not sure what they were cooking there but the smell that was wafting over was making my mouth water.

I'd bet almost anything that the 2 negative reviews are from people that work for Whole Foods or some other store that's in competition with Amish Market.

Oh, and it IS run by Amish people. If you know anything about the way the Amish live their lives you would know that they can't use or touch certain types of machinery and electronics. So, obviously, you are not going to see an Amish person behind the cash register. If you see the butcher grinding meat with an electric grinder he/she is not Amish. They can't man a lot of the positions in the store simply due to their beliefs. But the place is run by the Amish.

Pros: Selection of hot foods. Fresh fruits and veg. Prices are good considering the quality of goods and location.

Cons: Can get a bit crowded at lunch time.

.

I've been to many Food markets within the city but i havent had a relaxing shopping experience.This place has variety of goods & services. You can always ask a worker for their opinion about a product.Customer service is great. I know that every department has their experience if i had questions.I can go there for hours and just find newer items everyday that i have never seen or heard of before which makes the place very unique. Bakery,Tossed Salad & Pizza fresh everyday and yummy! Deli and fish have variety of fresh ingredients! ohh and the buffet!!! yummy food! mixture of countries but yet simple & tasty!You can go to a store who has the products & no friendly workers or you can go to a store where there are friendly workers but nothing you want! this place AMISH market has everything a customer would want! Talking about it makes me want to get a slice of pizza and ON THE SEEN prepared FRESH SUSHI!!! see you there!

2
★★★★★

I've been to many Food markets within the city but i havent had a relaxing shopping experience.This place has variety of goods & services. You can always ask a worker for their opinion about a product.Customer service is great. I know that every department has their experience if i had questions.I can go there for hours and just find newer items everyday that i have never seen or heard of before which makes the place very unique. Bakery,Tossed Salad & Pizza fresh everyday and yummy! Deli and fish have variety of fresh ingredients! ohh and the buffet!!! yummy food! mixture of countries but yet simple & tasty!You can go to a store who has the products & no friendly workers or you can go to a store where there are friendly workers but nothing you want! this place AMISH market has everything a customer would want! Talking about it makes me want to get a slice of pizza and ON THE SEEN prepared FRESH SUSHI!!! see you there!

Pros: you pay for what you get! high price but worth it cause everything is 100% FRESH!

Cons: everything looks so good that when you to buy 1 item you end up with 10! :D

.

The food was really good. I guess you just don't want it delivered. Who the hell asks Amish people to deliver anyway?

2
★★★★★

The food was really good. I guess you just don't want it delivered. Who the hell asks Amish people to deliver anyway?

.

Delivery guy came to my office and called upstairs about my pizza but left before I got down. I called Amish Market but it took me 15-20 minutes of sitting in the lobby waiting for him to come back. When he came back he had no insulating bag for the pizza. The night was ice cold and so my pizza was too. I called Amish Market and all I got was attitude. It was the worst delivery experience I ever had on Seamless Web or otherwise in Manhattan.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Delivery guy came to my office and called upstairs about my pizza but left before I got down. I called Amish Market but it took me 15-20 minutes of sitting in the lobby waiting for him to come back. When he came back he had no insulating bag for the pizza. The night was ice cold and so my pizza was too. I called Amish Market and all I got was attitude. It was the worst delivery experience I ever had on Seamless Web or otherwise in Manhattan.

Pros: none

Cons: terrible delivery service and worse attitude

.

So it's Christmas day and I had paid for and ordered food for a meal for my family and friends of 12. The Amish Market gladley TOOK my money and never delivered our meal. When I called them they had no record of the order and I checked my bank statement and saw that indeed they had taken money with out providing services promised. Keep in mind I have guests arriving and it's Christrmas day. They were happy to help me out as long as I pay twice for one meal for 12 people. Not only did they lie to me over and over again, steal my money but they run a dishonest business and you should never trust them in any way at all. At this point I am ready to turn them over to the authorities for fraud. Keep in mind if you give them your card you are taking a huge chance. By the way they are not even Amish. Everything about them is a lie.

0
★☆☆☆☆

So it's Christmas day and I had paid for and ordered food for a meal for my family and friends of 12. The Amish Market gladley TOOK my money and never delivered our meal. When I called them they had no record of the order and I checked my bank statement and saw that indeed they had taken money with out providing services promised. Keep in mind I have guests arriving and it's Christrmas day. They were happy to help me out as long as I pay twice for one meal for 12 people. Not only did they lie to me over and over again, steal my money but they run a dishonest business and you should never trust them in any way at all. At this point I am ready to turn them over to the authorities for fraud. Keep in mind if you give them your card you are taking a huge chance. By the way they are not even Amish. Everything about them is a lie.

Pros: None

Cons: lies, cheating

.

Close to the best sandwiches I have ever had. Outstanding customer service. Visit and enjoy!

2
★★★★★

Close to the best sandwiches I have ever had. Outstanding customer service. Visit and enjoy!

.

This place is clean, well-stocked, smells great and has stuff that I don't know if I could find anywhere else. Good stuff for gourmet dinners/parties. Bakery's fantastic, produce is wonderful, and I believe they have every variety of cheese and olive known to man. But it's hard to justify buying staple stuff like ketchup, tuna, etc. here. It's a good 10-20% more expensive than normal places and right next door there's a (somewhat seedy) store where you would feel less like a rube buying dry goods, etc.

2
★★★★★

This place is clean, well-stocked, smells great and has stuff that I don't know if I could find anywhere else. Good stuff for gourmet dinners/parties. Bakery's fantastic, produce is wonderful, and I believe they have every variety of cheese and olive known to man. But it's hard to justify buying staple stuff like ketchup, tuna, etc. here. It's a good 10-20% more expensive than normal places and right next door there's a (somewhat seedy) store where you would feel less like a rube buying dry goods, etc.

Pros: gourmet everything

Cons: overpriced basics

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Amish Market Westside, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review