Valley Inn Restaurant

★★★★☆
  • 71 E Buffalo St

    Warsaw, NY 14569

    Map & Directions
  • 585-786-3820

About Valley Inn Restaurant

Hours
Mon., Sun. CLOSED;Tue. - Fri. 11am - 2pm;Sat. 4:30pm - 8pm
3.6667 3
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Valley Inn Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

The Valley Inn occupies a Civil War era home built in 1861. It was constructed as a wedding gift by Theron Main for his son James and his new wife. The restaurant is on the first floor. I have dinned at the Valley Inn for both lunch and dinners over the past few years. The Dinners in my opinion seem to be better then the lunches but the lunches are still very good. This review is about out most recent dinning experience at the Valley Inn - Saturday evening. December 27, 2008. This was one of our most enjoyable dinning experiences in years. The holiday deco was wonderful and unique with a Victorian flare. The service, wine and food selection was exceptional. I had the slow roasted pork shank with Quinoa stuffed quail dish and my wife had the Beef Wellington. The Wellington is only available on Friday and Saturday nights. The Pork/Quail has a maple glaze that perfectly complements both flavors. The pork was fall off the bone tender. The Beef Wellington was done perfectly. Both dishes had an excellent presentation. The prices for the quality of food are quite reasonable. I highly recommend reservations for the weekends. In my opinion, you can?t go wrong dining at the Valley Inn. I am already looking forward to our next visit. Enjoy. DS

2
★★★★☆

The Valley Inn occupies a Civil War era home built in 1861. It was constructed as a wedding gift by Theron Main for his son James and his new wife. The restaurant is on the first floor. I have dinned at the Valley Inn for both lunch and dinners over the past few years. The Dinners in my opinion seem to be better then the lunches but the lunches are still very good. This review is about out most recent dinning experience at the Valley Inn - Saturday evening. December 27, 2008. This was one of our most enjoyable dinning experiences in years. The holiday deco was wonderful and unique with a Victorian flare. The service, wine and food selection was exceptional. I had the slow roasted pork shank with Quinoa stuffed quail dish and my wife had the Beef Wellington. The Wellington is only available on Friday and Saturday nights. The Pork/Quail has a maple glaze that perfectly complements both flavors. The pork was fall off the bone tender. The Beef Wellington was done perfectly. Both dishes had an excellent presentation. The prices for the quality of food are quite reasonable. I highly recommend reservations for the weekends. In my opinion, you can?t go wrong dining at the Valley Inn. I am already looking forward to our next visit. Enjoy. DS

Pros: nice fresh food.

Cons: stone parking lot

.

The quality has gone down over the years. This used to be my favorite place to eat. I would drive out from Buffalo, just to eat here. I have since moved out near Batavia and have had a chance to go to the Valley Inn more often.

However, it seems like the owner, Buzz, isn't as involved anymore. The other chefs on the staff, are not as good as Buzz. Lately the herbs and spices have been heavy handed and overpowered the food.

My new favorite restaurant is: Hillside Inn, 890 E Bethany Rd., Wyoming, NY 14591 - it isn't far from Warsaw and the food has consistently been of better quality.

1
★★★☆☆

The quality has gone down over the years. This used to be my favorite place to eat. I would drive out from Buffalo, just to eat here. I have since moved out near Batavia and have had a chance to go to the Valley Inn more often.

However, it seems like the owner, Buzz, isn't as involved anymore. The other chefs on the staff, are not as good as Buzz. Lately the herbs and spices have been heavy handed and overpowered the food.

My new favorite restaurant is: Hillside Inn, 890 E Bethany Rd., Wyoming, NY 14591 - it isn't far from Warsaw and the food has consistently been of better quality.

.

A nice little out of the way place to eat. It's on a side street but still close enough to walk to downtown Warsaw. The food is good and the prices aren't bad.

4
★★★★☆

A nice little out of the way place to eat. It's on a side street but still close enough to walk to downtown Warsaw. The food is good and the prices aren't bad.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Valley Inn Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review