Stadtmuller Jewelers

★★☆☆☆
  • 18 Main St

    Sayville, NY 11782

    Map & Directions
  • 631-589-3300

About Stadtmuller Jewelers

Categories
Hours
Mon - Thurs, 9:30am - 5pm; Fri, 9:30am - 7pm; Sun, closed

Shopping

Shopping
More choices in Sayville:
Resultset_next

William J O'neill Sales Exch

1 E Main St Patchogue, NY

Resultset_next

Village Silversmith Gallery

149 S Country Rd Bellport, NY

2.3333 3
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Stadtmuller Jewelers was?
Write a Review
.

I recently went to Stadtmuller Jewelers in Sayville, NY, to sell some jewelry. A diamond ring of about 1/2 carats was appraised at $100. Even after the jeweler gave the appraisal, other subordinate workers defended the price by saying they could not find anything in house to compare my ring to. I then took it to another jeweler and found I could, and did get, eight times the value of Stadtmuller's appraisal.The whole store is just a scam for selling jewelry. Thank God I got a second opinion, and stay away from this place.

1
★☆☆☆☆

I recently went to Stadtmuller Jewelers in Sayville, NY, to sell some jewelry. A diamond ring of about 1/2 carats was appraised at $100. Even after the jeweler gave the appraisal, other subordinate workers defended the price by saying they could not find anything in house to compare my ring to. I then took it to another jeweler and found I could, and did get, eight times the value of Stadtmuller's appraisal.The whole store is just a scam for selling jewelry. Thank God I got a second opinion, and stay away from this place.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

So shocked at the poor customer service and complete deception my father received today. Dad wanted to buy Mom a Pandora bracelet, I told him to go to a jewelry store in Sayville that I had bought one at, but I couldn't remember the name. He went to Stadtmuller told them he wanted to buy a Pandora bracelet, the sales woman said fine. He picked out the bracelet, clips, a charm. When she was ringing him up, he noticed a different name, he said that's not Pandora, she said, it's the same. He called me, I said mom wants Pandora. He told her to cancel the sale and asked if she knew a store nearby that sold Pandora, she said no. Turns out a store 6 stores away sells it. Shame on you Stadtmuller! You tried to take advantage of the fact that my Dad is no jewelry expert. This is like a service station that rips off a woman because she doesn't know about cars. We will not be shopping there and will tell others to do the same!

1
★☆☆☆☆

So shocked at the poor customer service and complete deception my father received today. Dad wanted to buy Mom a Pandora bracelet, I told him to go to a jewelry store in Sayville that I had bought one at, but I couldn't remember the name. He went to Stadtmuller told them he wanted to buy a Pandora bracelet, the sales woman said fine. He picked out the bracelet, clips, a charm. When she was ringing him up, he noticed a different name, he said that's not Pandora, she said, it's the same. He called me, I said mom wants Pandora. He told her to cancel the sale and asked if she knew a store nearby that sold Pandora, she said no. Turns out a store 6 stores away sells it. Shame on you Stadtmuller! You tried to take advantage of the fact that my Dad is no jewelry expert. This is like a service station that rips off a woman because she doesn't know about cars. We will not be shopping there and will tell others to do the same!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I took a trip to Sayville this summer and stopped in Stadtmuller Jewelers for a gift. They had the most amazing OPAL Jewelry I have ever seen. I bought 2-Handmade Pendants for the best Prices I have seen. Great Service & Quality. will recommend to all.

PROS: Excellent Service-Price & Quality
CONS:

5
★★★★★

I took a trip to Sayville this summer and stopped in Stadtmuller Jewelers for a gift. They had the most amazing OPAL Jewelry I have ever seen. I bought 2-Handmade Pendants for the best Prices I have seen. Great Service & Quality. will recommend to all.

PROS: Excellent Service-Price & Quality
CONS:

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Stadtmuller Jewelers, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review