Insider Pages Reviews for Cheesy Charlie's Pizzeria

5 Stars: Cheesy Charlie's Pizzeria is GREAT FOOD and FOLKS (by Jim N.)

Jim N. — Tue, 08 Sep 2009 21:46:00 GMT

As a family, and parts of the family, we've counted on CCs many times over the years -- this summer, we had a family reunion and needed a tray of something at the last minute -- CCs made up a tray of zita and meatballs that EVERYONE raved about (and ours is a picky group sometimes) -- great price, nice banter, good suggestions, terrific food, friendly staff and atmosphere -- can't get any better -- I live in Philadelphia, but Cheesy Charlie's is my NoFo Best -- I envy my sisters' families who have weekly access!

5 Stars: Best Pizza on the North Fork (by William R.)

William R. — Mon, 16 Mar 2009 08:38:00 GMT

Cheesy Charlie's is hands-down the best pizzeria on the North Fork and is as good as Antonio's on Flatbush in Brooklyn. Their specialty pies are delicious as are their soups and prepared meals. But for an outstanding regular slice there is no better place. No contest. No once comes close. And you also have to try the special home-baked goods they sell once in a while (I think the owner's mother in law bakes them so she can go play Bingo at Foxwoods).
So great pizza. Great special pies, delicious soups and amazing prepared dishes. Oh. And they deliver and everyone who works there is super nice. The Best.

5 Stars: Not Just Pizza (by Michael V.)

Michael V. — Mon, 18 Aug 2008 11:23:00 GMT

From a name like Cheesy Charlie's you would not expect the quality of food to be so high. Gourmet style pizzas of every category plus specialties like Greek Quesadillas, Crab Cakes that rival most restaurants, Roasted Vegetable Panini, Soups that would make grandma jealous like Crab and Roasted Pepper Bisque, an amazing Italian Wedding Soup, and even the occasional Lobster Salad Sandwich, Family owned and run, they are more than happy to serve you any of their delightful gourmet surprises. A breath of fresh air in a world of blase pizza joints.

5 Stars: Consistently great food (by laurie m.)

laurie m. — Wed, 13 Aug 2008 16:19:00 GMT

I have to get my pizza fix weekly, and Cheesy Charlie's is my go-to. They always accomodate a request for a thin, well done pie, AND, THEY DELIVER.
We've never been disappointed from anything received by CC.