Pizza 33

★★★★☆
  • 489 3rd Ave

    New York, NY 10016

    Map & Directions
  • 212-545-9191

About Pizza 33

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Alice's Tea Cup Chapter Ii

156 E 64th St New York, NY

Resultset_next

Arte Cafe

106 W 73rd St New York, NY

4.1944 36
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Pizza 33 was?
Write a Review
.

my experience is just been awesome...

3
★★★★★

my experience is just been awesome...

.

My sister lives in NYC and whenever I go to visit her we have to stop at Pizza 33 late night. They have the best zitti pizza around! I know what you're thinking...zitti on pizza? That's exactly what i thought, but when you have one bite of this thing, you'll fall in love. Its open super late night and are constantly cooking new pizzas so they are always hot out of the oven.

4
★★★★☆

My sister lives in NYC and whenever I go to visit her we have to stop at Pizza 33 late night. They have the best zitti pizza around! I know what you're thinking...zitti on pizza? That's exactly what i thought, but when you have one bite of this thing, you'll fall in love. Its open super late night and are constantly cooking new pizzas so they are always hot out of the oven.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Thi place has very tasty brick-oven pizza, very flavorful and authentic. Try the eggplant parmesan. Getting kind of pricey, but the quality is still holding up.

3
★★★☆☆

Thi place has very tasty brick-oven pizza, very flavorful and authentic. Try the eggplant parmesan. Getting kind of pricey, but the quality is still holding up.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

a friend from work and i went there one evening. there was no waiting for a table which was good. i was really disappointed with the pizza though. it was really greasy and with the prices they charged that surprised me.

2
★★☆☆☆

a friend from work and i went there one evening. there was no waiting for a table which was good. i was really disappointed with the pizza though. it was really greasy and with the prices they charged that surprised me.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

on 33rd and 3rd at 3am this place is bumping and youll run into someone you know -
its the heart of murray hill and never skips a beat

2
★★★★☆

on 33rd and 3rd at 3am this place is bumping and youll run into someone you know -
its the heart of murray hill and never skips a beat

Pros: pizza

Cons: no chinese food

.

you have to try the magherita slice here - the tomatoes are so juicy and the cheese is so fresh! the crust is very thin too which i love (less carbs!) all the specialty slices here are fantastic too

2
★★★★☆

you have to try the magherita slice here - the tomatoes are so juicy and the cheese is so fresh! the crust is very thin too which i love (less carbs!) all the specialty slices here are fantastic too

.

This place is usually very good. They are open late and use very good ingredients. However, the bottom of my pizza has been burnt the last few times. I have heard this problem from friends of mine who eat there too. I hope they fix this issue or I will definitely consider one of the other 10 places in the neighborhood my new "go to" pizza place

1
★★★☆☆

This place is usually very good. They are open late and use very good ingredients. However, the bottom of my pizza has been burnt the last few times. I have heard this problem from friends of mine who eat there too. I hope they fix this issue or I will definitely consider one of the other 10 places in the neighborhood my new "go to" pizza place

Pros: Great Ingeredients/Toppings

Cons: Sometimes the pizza is burnt

.

The pizza is cheap so you get a pizza with cheap quality. There is really nothing much to say about this place. It is one of those restaurants that if you have accidentally been at one time you would surely soon forget.

PROS: Cheap
CONS: The pizza

2
★★☆☆☆

The pizza is cheap so you get a pizza with cheap quality. There is really nothing much to say about this place. It is one of those restaurants that if you have accidentally been at one time you would surely soon forget.

PROS: Cheap
CONS: The pizza

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I used to work for Gourmet magazine exploring the world of food as a taste tester. When I settled down in Manhattan, the one place I go to have an enjoyable slice EVERY SINGLE TIME, is Pizza 33. The staff is wonderful, the pizza is always hot and delicious. The ingredients are always extremely fresh and there is the perfect balance of cheese, tomato sauce, and dough regardless of what type you choose to order, I have never been let down by this pizza joint. In my opinion, the Margarita pizza is the best in New York City. The only place you might be able to get a better slice is in Italy.

2
★★★★★

I used to work for Gourmet magazine exploring the world of food as a taste tester. When I settled down in Manhattan, the one place I go to have an enjoyable slice EVERY SINGLE TIME, is Pizza 33. The staff is wonderful, the pizza is always hot and delicious. The ingredients are always extremely fresh and there is the perfect balance of cheese, tomato sauce, and dough regardless of what type you choose to order, I have never been let down by this pizza joint. In my opinion, the Margarita pizza is the best in New York City. The only place you might be able to get a better slice is in Italy.

Pros: Food, Staff, Hours

Cons: not open between the hours of 5 am and 10 am

.

I'm no expert on pizza, but I do remember, in my youth, deftly forcing other children to eat my mudpies. Pizza 33 distinctly brings the whole mudpie experience back to the forefront of my mind. If I had enemies, I would recommend them to Pizza 33. We ordered a large plain cheese; we received a large box with a small, rubbery greasespot inside. To make matters worse, our full order including bread and salad was not delivered. The rude management even refused to correct the situation.

Do not order from Pizza 33! Unless you're masochistic, do not put yourself in that situation. Of course, if you have a sadistic streak and really want others to suffer, recommend Pizza 33 to a friend!

0
★☆☆☆☆

I'm no expert on pizza, but I do remember, in my youth, deftly forcing other children to eat my mudpies. Pizza 33 distinctly brings the whole mudpie experience back to the forefront of my mind. If I had enemies, I would recommend them to Pizza 33. We ordered a large plain cheese; we received a large box with a small, rubbery greasespot inside. To make matters worse, our full order including bread and salad was not delivered. The rude management even refused to correct the situation.

Do not order from Pizza 33! Unless you're masochistic, do not put yourself in that situation. Of course, if you have a sadistic streak and really want others to suffer, recommend Pizza 33 to a friend!

.

In a perfect world, I would eat nothing but Cheesy Gordita Crunches from Taco Bell. I would savor one cheesy, sour-creamy bite after another, delighting in the fact that I am eating pure joy. I would wash it down with Mountain Dew Baja Blast, a flavor so ridiculously good that it's available only in Taco Bell. To release it to the masses would be to invite anarchy to our beautiful American society. Unfortunately, it is not a perfect world and, as such, I must from time to time consume things besides the prestigious Cheesy Gordita Crunch. Tonight was one such time when, at work, we ordered the Terra e Mare pizza. A more appropriate name for this catastrophe would be the Terror e Nightmare pizza. The shrimp, which I imagined would be plump and delicious, were tiny. Do you know the feeling you get when you're embarrassed and want to curl into a ball? I expect that the shrimp were so ashamed to be a part of this disaster of a pizza pie that they shrunk into themselves. I can't say I blame them. I, too, would have been ashamed to be a part of that pizza. The mushrooms were also offensively bad. The other intern who ate the pizza said he liked the mushrooms, but he is from Maine, a den of iniquities so profound that I will not discuss them in the detail they require. The analyst whose credit card we used to order was likewise disappointed. He told us that the pizza was depressingly bad and that it reflected poorly on us as interns. He said, rightly, that in a city known for pizza that it was a true feat to discover a place that got every aspect of it wrong. Well done, Pizza 33. Thanks to you I have discovered the ultimate depths of human depravity - infinite. The other person to have reviewed this place is either an out-of-towner so enamored with the idea of new york pizza that he/she convinced himself/herself it was good (despite it not being so, I assure you) or he/she is an employee of this awful excuse for a restaurant.

0
★☆☆☆☆

In a perfect world, I would eat nothing but Cheesy Gordita Crunches from Taco Bell. I would savor one cheesy, sour-creamy bite after another, delighting in the fact that I am eating pure joy. I would wash it down with Mountain Dew Baja Blast, a flavor so ridiculously good that it's available only in Taco Bell. To release it to the masses would be to invite anarchy to our beautiful American society. Unfortunately, it is not a perfect world and, as such, I must from time to time consume things besides the prestigious Cheesy Gordita Crunch. Tonight was one such time when, at work, we ordered the Terra e Mare pizza. A more appropriate name for this catastrophe would be the Terror e Nightmare pizza. The shrimp, which I imagined would be plump and delicious, were tiny. Do you know the feeling you get when you're embarrassed and want to curl into a ball? I expect that the shrimp were so ashamed to be a part of this disaster of a pizza pie that they shrunk into themselves. I can't say I blame them. I, too, would have been ashamed to be a part of that pizza. The mushrooms were also offensively bad. The other intern who ate the pizza said he liked the mushrooms, but he is from Maine, a den of iniquities so profound that I will not discuss them in the detail they require. The analyst whose credit card we used to order was likewise disappointed. He told us that the pizza was depressingly bad and that it reflected poorly on us as interns. He said, rightly, that in a city known for pizza that it was a true feat to discover a place that got every aspect of it wrong. Well done, Pizza 33. Thanks to you I have discovered the ultimate depths of human depravity - infinite. The other person to have reviewed this place is either an out-of-towner so enamored with the idea of new york pizza that he/she convinced himself/herself it was good (despite it not being so, I assure you) or he/she is an employee of this awful excuse for a restaurant.

Pros: It will soon be digested and out of my body

Cons: Don't even know where to begin

.

Excellent pizza - tip: sometimes faster to call in for delivery than to walk over and wait in line.

2
★★★★★

Excellent pizza - tip: sometimes faster to call in for delivery than to walk over and wait in line.

.

I can promise you that you cannot leave Pizza 33 disappointed. I am torn on whether or not to say it's the best pizza I have ever had, it's THAT good, and obviously good enough to write a review about. Don't hesitate to request a special slice that you don't see out on display, they are more than willing, and will probably taste fresher anyway. Granted the lines are long at 3am, but what pizza place wouldn't be at that time that is within one block of 10 bars. The line moves quite quickly too. It's not a restaurant, it's a regular old pizza place, but it's amazing, a must try if you are ever in the area.

2
★★★★★

I can promise you that you cannot leave Pizza 33 disappointed. I am torn on whether or not to say it's the best pizza I have ever had, it's THAT good, and obviously good enough to write a review about. Don't hesitate to request a special slice that you don't see out on display, they are more than willing, and will probably taste fresher anyway. Granted the lines are long at 3am, but what pizza place wouldn't be at that time that is within one block of 10 bars. The line moves quite quickly too. It's not a restaurant, it's a regular old pizza place, but it's amazing, a must try if you are ever in the area.

Pros: Some of the best pizza you will ever have

Cons: The lines

.

This pizza is very good, tasty, good balance of cheese and sauce. They have both brick oven and regular pizza and I haven't had one bad tasting slice yet. They have good hours too.

2
★★★★☆

This pizza is very good, tasty, good balance of cheese and sauce. They have both brick oven and regular pizza and I haven't had one bad tasting slice yet. They have good hours too.

Pros: Taste, Hours, Clean

Cons: Crowded

.

i know that most people know pizza 33 for being the best place to get amazing pizza at 4 am but pizza 33 has more to offer! try the chicken parm sub or the caesar salad - i promise you won't be disappointed. and if you happen to get an itch to try the pizza one afternoon, you will think it's delicious.

2
★★★★★

i know that most people know pizza 33 for being the best place to get amazing pizza at 4 am but pizza 33 has more to offer! try the chicken parm sub or the caesar salad - i promise you won't be disappointed. and if you happen to get an itch to try the pizza one afternoon, you will think it's delicious.

.

All kidding aside, this is the most delightful pizza in NYC, in the US, in North America. The sauce is delicious, the crust is the perfect size, the toppings inventive... Love it at 3am or Noon

2
★★★★★

All kidding aside, this is the most delightful pizza in NYC, in the US, in North America. The sauce is delicious, the crust is the perfect size, the toppings inventive... Love it at 3am or Noon

Pros: PIZZA

.

Simply amazing, the sauce is on the sweet side but incredibly unique. This is one of the best in NYC

2
★★★★★

Simply amazing, the sauce is on the sweet side but incredibly unique. This is one of the best in NYC

.

Granted I go to this place anytime of day or night, but always the most fun stumbling home from the bars at 4am at which time you can see minor celebs from the Hill area doing the exact same thing. Great minds think alike.

2
★★★★★

Granted I go to this place anytime of day or night, but always the most fun stumbling home from the bars at 4am at which time you can see minor celebs from the Hill area doing the exact same thing. Great minds think alike.

.

During the blackout, Pizza 33 was charging $24 for a soggy plain pie.
I wonder how much of that markup found its way into the workers pockets as I wouldn't have minded tipping the guys working there, it was hot as hell.

Way to support your community, Pizza 33!

Anyway, the pizza is ok at Pizza 33, I prefer Patsy's though.

2
★★★★☆

During the blackout, Pizza 33 was charging $24 for a soggy plain pie.
I wonder how much of that markup found its way into the workers pockets as I wouldn't have minded tipping the guys working there, it was hot as hell.

Way to support your community, Pizza 33!

Anyway, the pizza is ok at Pizza 33, I prefer Patsy's though.

.

I love the fact that the pizza tastes so good and is so cheap. It's only $1.95 for a regular slice and $4.00 for a slice with a mushroom, not mushrooms. Nothing better than buying a snapple for $3.25 too. A great way to make some money is to buy a case of snapple from Costco and sell it right outside for only $2.50. It's a steal! The pizza is good though.

2
★★★★☆

I love the fact that the pizza tastes so good and is so cheap. It's only $1.95 for a regular slice and $4.00 for a slice with a mushroom, not mushrooms. Nothing better than buying a snapple for $3.25 too. A great way to make some money is to buy a case of snapple from Costco and sell it right outside for only $2.50. It's a steal! The pizza is good though.

.

This place is awesome , open late especially on the weekends and the pizza is delicious c'mon who doesn't like pizza. check this place out yourself and tell me if brick oven doesn't make the difference.

2
★★★★★

This place is awesome , open late especially on the weekends and the pizza is delicious c'mon who doesn't like pizza. check this place out yourself and tell me if brick oven doesn't make the difference.

Pros: great service, excellent pizza, open late

.

This place never closes........when do they sleep.
Better Yet, who makes that delicious pizza.....
We all Love Pizza 33

2
★★★★★

This place never closes........when do they sleep.
Better Yet, who makes that delicious pizza.....
We all Love Pizza 33

Pros: Hot, Tasty, Clean

.

Awsome Pizza especially the Margheritta slice. Always busy but fast moving. Great atmoshere and worth every bit. Open late (well as late as I ever got there and I'm a night person)

2
★★★★★

Awsome Pizza especially the Margheritta slice. Always busy but fast moving. Great atmoshere and worth every bit. Open late (well as late as I ever got there and I'm a night person)

Pros: Delicious, Quick, Filling

Cons: always busy

.

the best pizza in the 5 boros.....i come from staten island to have a slice,you know its good

2
★★★★★

the best pizza in the 5 boros.....i come from staten island to have a slice,you know its good

Pros: very nice staff, exellent service, very clean

.

PIZZA 33 HAS THE BEST PIZZA IN ALL OF NEW YORK!!

2
★★★★★

PIZZA 33 HAS THE BEST PIZZA IN ALL OF NEW YORK!!

Pros: GOOD FOOD, GOOD SERVICE, CLEAN

.

Best Pizza I have had. Cleanest pizza place I have ever been to.

2
★★★★★

Best Pizza I have had. Cleanest pizza place I have ever been to.

Pros: cleanest pizza place, wonderful pizza, understand english

Cons: not cheap, but worth, limited selection

.

I love Pizza 33. The thin crust, a bit of tomato sauce, a slice of cheese and a basil leave ..... spells heaven !!!

2
★★★★★

I love Pizza 33. The thin crust, a bit of tomato sauce, a slice of cheese and a basil leave ..... spells heaven !!!

.

Great for slices, especially the margherita. Cute atmosphere as well.

2
★★★★★

Great for slices, especially the margherita. Cute atmosphere as well.

.

Love Pizza 33.. I will be out with friends and all of a sudden I am hungry and I only crave one thing... their Pizza. I live in the neightborhood and am a regular. It hits the spot every time

2
★★★★★

Love Pizza 33.. I will be out with friends and all of a sudden I am hungry and I only crave one thing... their Pizza. I live in the neightborhood and am a regular. It hits the spot every time

.

I live in the neighborhood and my friends meet me down here not only for the bar scene but also the promise of The Pizza Place at 3am. The owners and employees are friendly and their pizza is fantastic. Everything a NY pizza joint should be. GO HERE. NOW.

2
★★★★★

I live in the neighborhood and my friends meet me down here not only for the bar scene but also the promise of The Pizza Place at 3am. The owners and employees are friendly and their pizza is fantastic. Everything a NY pizza joint should be. GO HERE. NOW.

Pros: Open Late, Cheap & Clean, Great Service

Cons: Crowded

.

It's open late which is really great. It's a clean, place with great food. What esle can you ask for...?

2
★★★★☆

It's open late which is really great. It's a clean, place with great food. What esle can you ask for...?

Pros: open late, clean, fresh

Cons: it's not free, it's not open 24 hrs, it's not free

.

This is a nice pizza place with good selection of thin crust pizza including the Basil slice. Their calzones are horrific, bad, vomit-inducing, YUCK. They smell like they stuff them with old canned vegetables like the spinach mushroom calzone. The counter service is bad. They charge different prices all the time. They're rude at times, and not very friendly. NO PIZZA 33 for me!

0
★☆☆☆☆

This is a nice pizza place with good selection of thin crust pizza including the Basil slice. Their calzones are horrific, bad, vomit-inducing, YUCK. They smell like they stuff them with old canned vegetables like the spinach mushroom calzone. The counter service is bad. They charge different prices all the time. They're rude at times, and not very friendly. NO PIZZA 33 for me!

Pros: good thin crust

Cons: terrible calzones, bad service, rude

.

cant get better late night pizza...a welcome addition to the murray hill area.

2
★★★★★

cant get better late night pizza...a welcome addition to the murray hill area.

Pros: close, imexpensive

Cons: small

.

Perfect in every way. The pizza is amazing and tastes like heaven. It is also not too greasy.

2
★★★★★

Perfect in every way. The pizza is amazing and tastes like heaven. It is also not too greasy.

Pros: amazing taste, delicious, perfect consistency

.

The margherita pizza is great, and some prosciutto and it is excellent. Good for dinner and even better as a late night snack at 1am.

2
★★★★☆

The margherita pizza is great, and some prosciutto and it is excellent. Good for dinner and even better as a late night snack at 1am.

.

The pizza here is, bar none, the best in New York. I LOVE this place, and make multiple pilgrimages a week for the excellent crust & fabulous combination of cheese. All in a very low-key, fast & efficient atmosphere.

2
★★★★★

The pizza here is, bar none, the best in New York. I LOVE this place, and make multiple pilgrimages a week for the excellent crust & fabulous combination of cheese. All in a very low-key, fast & efficient atmosphere.

Pros: pizza, cute atmosphere

Cons: ?

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Pizza 33, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review