Insider Pages Reviews for La Palapa Cocina Mexicana

5 Stars: OUR FAVORITE SPOT IN NYC!!!!!! (by NYCfloyd)

NYCfloyd — Tue, 01 Dec 2009 09:00:00 GMT

Best dinner I have had in NYC, the folks who own this place really know how to do Mexican the right way! We stopped in on a Friday night and we were treated to one of the best dinner's I have ever had.... the drinks are great as well.... try LA PALAPA and trust me you wont go wrong!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1 Stars: Not Really Authentic!!!! (by txingon)

txingon — Sun, 13 Sep 2009 09:00:00 GMT

Let's just say my girlfriends and I walked out of the restaurant, halfway through our meal due to a visitor in our table AHHHHH!!!! My friend pointed out that I had a cacaroche (city search bans the true word from reviews... hmmm... conspiracy much?) crawling on me, we screamed to high heaven, and a bus boy came and put it in a napkin and ran to the kitchen. Next thing I knew I was asking for the manager, who was a broad with too much attitude.... she tried to debate with me whether it was a cacaroche or a water roche... like woman, an inch long brown roche was crawling on me... do I really need to debate semantics here??

Anyways who knows if the perp was actually a cacaroche or water roche... either way I'm never going back there!

Just as a note, when we walked out, a woman at the front who had just finished eating said "Oh you guys had a cacaroche by your table too?"

Sorry that place needs to be shut the truck down.

5 Stars: Excellent service! (by ecardwell)

ecardwell — Thu, 20 Aug 2009 09:00:00 GMT

I went to La Palapa on a Thursday night and the bar was low key and inviting. Great staff! All were super upbeat and friendly. My bartender was prompt, fresh, and helpful. She was extremely informative on the bar menu, happy hour, and food menu with a ton of specials. All of which is rare at most NYC restaurants. Essentially, she made me feel comfortable, even when she was busy. Based on her great suggestions, I had the Pato con Mole Negra.....and I never have duck! So delicious! They are so many margarita flavors there! I love the ginger margarita! The waitstaff is also informative and super helpful. Happy Hour is a must at La Palapa...great service and a genuine 2 for 1 deal....it's like tapas and half price drinks...perfect for after work. I will definitely be back next week...who wants to come with me!

Go go go!!!!! Don't hesitate!

3 Stars: Awesome (by TomLynch)

TomLynch — Tue, 28 Jul 2009 09:00:00 GMT

Bad

1 Stars: The worst Mexican food I've ever had (by jackson92nd)

jackson92nd — Tue, 02 Jun 2009 09:00:00 GMT

Anything you order with beef in it will have so little beef you will literally have to tear apart your dish to find what you've paid for. The staff is ignorant, but prompt. Avoid at all cost.

5 Stars: The best quesadillas (by Lewis101)

Lewis101 — Tue, 26 May 2009 09:00:00 GMT

This place was fantastic. I had a seat outside and enjoyed a quesadilla with some friends and a nice margarita. The atmosphere is great especially on a Sunny day. I would recommend this place to anyone.

4 Stars: Impressive!!! even after the "not so friendly" bar experience. (by roz1122)

roz1122 — Thu, 26 Feb 2009 09:00:00 GMT

I ate at La palapa last Thursday with friends. The ambiance and lighting was the first thing that struck me, very chill and romantic. The bar girl seemed rude or annoyed even though I was only one of ten or twelve people there. The margaritas were pretty good. The food was one of the best Mexican meals I have had in new York, loved the duck with mole. And to our relief service at the table Was professional.

3 Stars: OK (by a_commentor)

a_commentor — Sun, 01 Feb 2009 09:00:00 GMT

This place was OK. The food's a little overpriced when taking into account the quanitity and taste. the margaritas were good, especially for the "buy one get one" happy hour, but the mixed drink selection is otherwise limited... According to my friend, the bartender girl has a tendency to be pretty rude.

5 Stars: Great margaritas (by cordmahl)

cordmahl — Wed, 31 Dec 2008 09:00:00 GMT

had a blast at a birthday party. la palapa had great food and great drinks. i especially liked the margarita's!!

1 Stars: terrible (by flode)

flode — Sun, 09 Nov 2008 09:00:00 GMT

the service was poor- we waited about 30 minutes for just about everything including the sodas and the check. the food was decent enough but being charged for salsa at a mexican restaurant seems absurd.

1 Stars: WORST BRUNCH I have ever been to in NYC (by ELShir)

ELShir — Sun, 09 Nov 2008 09:00:00 GMT

Horrible service-- they didn't take drink orders for like ten minutes. Soda was flat. Overpriced guac and chips-- you are charged extra for sour cream and salsa. Overpriced in general for the quality of the food. Would never go back here-- everything was bad. Extremely surprised it is so highly rated.

5 Stars: One of my faves!!! (by NorCal2NYC)

NorCal2NYC — Thu, 24 Apr 2008 09:00:00 GMT

I LOVE this place. There white sangria is sooo good. When you order a glass it actually comes in a little pitcher which will give you about 2.5-3 glasses. The happy hour bar food is yummy and small. But it only cost about $3.00 so just order 2 at a time. The menu is creative enough for the food lover but has good standards that your mother from the suburbs would love. They use real fruit purees for their margaritas, not some nasty corn syrup like other places. They also have brunch specials at good prices. The one thing that I don't like is that you have to pay for your chips and salsa. But when you order it they bring you 3 different types of salsa and good quality chips. Every time someone from out of town comes to visit me I bring them here. And they have all loved it. The other location is just as good. The service has always been great. I have made brunch reservations for a big party here once and we had no problems. People from out of town might consider this place expensive. But for a local New Yorker with the love of food and dining out the prices will seem normal.

1 Stars: Avoid on Saturday nights (by gibby07)

gibby07 — Fri, 15 Feb 2008 09:00:00 GMT

I went with a group of 6 people to La Palapa last Saturday night. We waited over an hour and a half for our main courses and half the table received their meals 30 minutes before the rest of the table. When we finally received our dinners the food was cold and way over salted. The server was nice but SLOW. I have been to La Palapa during the week and it is much better. Definately avoid on Saturday nights.

4 Stars: Good food, good service, but very crowded (by oforer)

oforer — Sun, 06 Jan 2008 09:00:00 GMT

While this was better than average Mexican food, and the service pretty decent, it was awkward to get comfortable in this awfully noisy, crowded restaurant with very little room to move.

2 Stars: Still waiting to be seated (by parisforme)

parisforme — Wed, 12 Dec 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I can't tell you about the food at La Palapa because my friends and I never actually got the chance to eat there.

I made a reservation for a friend's birthday at La Palapa and knowing how popular and atmospheric the restaurant is, did so well in advance. The reservations were for 6 people on a Friday night. The reservationist was polite and friendly over the phone, and noted that this reservation was for the special occasion of a birthday.

We arrived promptly a few minutes before our reservation time. Because it was Friday, and the place was clearly busy, we still expected to wait a reasonable amount of time. At around 9:20 we approached the hostess to remind her that our party was complete and to ask her how much longer it would be. She told us at least 20 more minutes (40 minutes after our original reservation). By 9:45 we were still not seated, and more annoyingly, no one had told us anything more about when that might happen. I tried to approach the hostess to get more information. I could see she was busy, so I waited patiently for a few minutes in an attempt to get her attention. I could see her avoiding eye contact with me while she buzzed around, refusing to acknowledge the fact that I was obviously waiting to speak with her. I was frustrated with their lack of planning for not honoring or reservation, but was far more frustrated with the lack of communication as to why it was taking so long, or how much longer we would be kept waiting. At about 10:00 we decided we had been ignored long enough and went to a less trendy place, Paquito's, down the street where we were seated immediately. The atmosphere was definitely not as trendy and warm as La Palapa, but the food, service and prices were far better. I still wonder how long we would have been made to stand there to have actually been seated, or even spoken to. For me, no atmosphere or cuisine can make up for that standard of service.

2 Stars: malo (by paramo13)

paramo13 — Thu, 06 Dec 2007 09:00:00 GMT

This place should be called Guaca-palapa. Every dish that we ordered came with a side of guacamole. Sad thing is we ordered a guacamole as one of our appetizers. That shows you that they can't even come up with sides for thier dishes. We also ordered some chicken cactus empanadas that were horrible. Lamb barbacoa is an all around atrocity. Does anybody taste the food at this place? Also noticed that of entrees on the menu, 5 of them (yes five) were shrimp. Not to mention the queso fundido which was like a stone. Basically they dump the plate on the salamander and bring it out to you. They dont even notice that after 30 seconds the cheese becomes cement. Sangria was awfull. Needed alcohol and sugar and I think I tasted tropicana juice in there. Again anybody tastes anything in this place?Then there was a failled skateboarder kid really badly dressed that appeared to be the manager and was not even paying attention when we tried to signal to him that we needed help in our table. Ohh well. I used to like this place, it just went down the tubes. Feliz Navidad!!

5 Stars: tasty tacos (by emilyswriter)

emilyswriter — Wed, 31 Oct 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Went to my friends bachelorette party there last week. What a blast! The margaritas were strong and so fresh we had a great time. The server was also so nice and we had a champagne toast on the house which really made the evening end on a happy surprise!

5 Stars: home sweet home (by richblack)

richblack — Wed, 31 Oct 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I grew up in Mexico so coming to this place made me feel right at home. I loved their three salsas especially the spiciest serrano one which was great with their steak entree that reminded me of the steaks you have in Mexico City. The waiter said that the ingredients are from Mexico and I believe it -- he really new the menu and I had a lot of questions. Second favorite after the steak were the salsa verde Enchiladas -- wow!

1 Stars: Just Plain Bad (by mikeymouse)

mikeymouse — Sat, 06 Oct 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Went for a friend's birthday (group of 12). We ordered guacamole for the table..TERRIBLE!....i've had better at the pizza place around the corner from me......and it tasted like garlic....garlic in guacamole!!??

Most of the people couldn't eat their entrees because they were either TOO GREASY or too spicy....and we like spicy food!! On a specific note, the camarones (shrimp) tacos were miniscule and extremely greasy and the tilapia tacos entree was just plain bad.

The sangria was tasty but had very little alcohol in it. Good service and good (but very loud) atmosphere though. I like to think posively of restaurant experiences but just can't do it for this place.

3 Stars: Good Food, Good Ambience, but Bad Service (by sk81)

sk81 — Sat, 22 Sep 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The location is great - at the heart of the East Village. The ambience looks great from outside that made me go in with a friend. The menue is extensive with a short but selective wine list. However, the service was much below our expectation from an average restaurant in the area. There was a huge disconnect between the waitor and the bus boy's communication. We wanted some extra guacamole with our remaining chips which didn't come for about 10 minutes. Then the bus boy came to serve our second course, and decided to take away our chips without replenishing the guacamole and also took away one of our napkins! It took another ten minutes to get the situation straightened out. Would recommend this place for the food and th casual/friendy ambience - but be prepared for the poor service!

1 Stars: Bad (by slipknotnyc)

slipknotnyc — Tue, 21 Aug 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The Sangria was horrible; weak, watery, no taste and definitely no alcohol. We had to order 3 pitchers (very very small) just to yield everyone two very small glasses. I ordered three soft tacos which were totally small and came with nothing. The acoustics are horrendous so don't think you're going to be able to talk to anyone near you. Pricey too.

5 Stars: Hard to Lose! (by krystyna03)

krystyna03 — Tue, 26 Jun 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I used to live down the block and I was very excited when I discovered such good Mexican right in my neighborhood. I usually go for dinner, but the brunch is very good as well. I would recommend anything with the chorizo, which is always the perfect amount of spicy. I?m also a big fan of the tacos, but they are very little so you have to order many of them. The good part is, that means you get to try many different varieties ? I recommend the pork.

Also, a very big perk is the margaritas. Note that all margaritas are served in pitchers so it is the perfect place to share several drinks. Also, there are many many options so you will likely find some flavors you don?t usually find elsewhere ? i.e. blueberry or bloodorange. Even better, they will make any of the fruit varieties on the rocks, so you don?t have to deal with the brain freeze associated with the blended version. They also have a really good tequila list, so if you haven?t overdone it on the ?ritas save room for a shot at the end, the tequila is so good it will be a sipping shot. La Palapa is the perfect place to satisfy your Mexican cravings at a reasonable price.

3 Stars: Top 5 worst dining experiences in Manhattan (by jaypetrina)

jaypetrina — Sun, 27 May 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I wanted to show my girlfriend the St. Marks hood so we headed down there and walked around and picked La Palapa b/c there was a table near the outside that was open and there seemed to be a good vibe. Our margaritas were basically non-alcoholic and it took 35 minutes for them to serve us our appetizers of a quesadilla and a few soft tacos. Moreover, the tacos had no taste. The only saving grace ironically was I cut my thumb on a broken water glass so they covered the cost of our watery margaritas so the total fare didn't break the bank. Lastly, you know it was a bad dining experience and you pass an Uno's on the way home and you both agree you would have enjoyed a Chicago style pizza from there rather than an "authentic" mexican dining experience at La Palapa. Oh..and we are now enjoying a PB&J sandwich.

5 Stars: Pricey, but the best Mexican I've had in Manhattan (by steorra)

steorra — Sat, 21 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

La Palapa has been my best Mexican food experience since I moved to Manhattan. The environment is chill -- dimly lit and romantic enough for dates, but also appropriate for an evening out with friends. Just make sure you make a reservation! The food is without comparison; everything tastes fresh and made-to-order. I can't even begin to make recommendations because everything is so delicious. There is only one downside to La Palapa (other than having to wait for a table if you don't have a reservation), and that's the price. Save this one for payday.

5 Stars: Great Mexican food, lunch is good time, nice for dates (by peril)

peril — Thu, 05 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I've been there a couple of times and it never seems to fail my expectations. Their appetizing nachos taste like they are fresh out the oven. The sauces that are provided with them can be a bit spicy but Im not afraid of a little spice. The food is delicious and if you don't bring a big appetite then a dish can be shared for two it's that big. Its enviroment is delightful at night, everyone seems to not have a care in the world. Another nice treat would be the Margaritas, I feel like Im back in Mexico. Prices are cheaper than Rosa Mexicano but equal in taste.

5 Stars: Wonderful! (by mac1382)

mac1382 — Thu, 15 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

If you are looking for great traditional Mexican food, look no further. I absolutely love this place! The food was delicious, the service can't get any better and the place is lovely. Our waitress was so sweet and attentive, and she was right about every suggestion. We had a beautiful, romantic evening and couldn't stop commenting on the food. The leg of lamb was extraordinary, the quesadillas and tacos were right on point and dessert was delicious. We dine out a lot, and Mexican is one of our favorite foods, and we both agreed that this place is now at the top of our list.

5 Stars: CHEAP HAPPY HOUR & DELICIOUS FRESH MARGARITAS! (by gngr)

gngr — Mon, 15 Jan 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I went for happy hour last week and the atmosphere was really great for after work. The frozen margaritas are very fresh and delicious. There are tons of great fruit flavors. I tried the pomogranate and the orange. The appetizers are cheap and small enough to try several. And you HAVE to get the chocolate dessert- "The Queen" I believe it's called.

5 Stars: My favorite happy hour (by hodela)

hodela — Sun, 13 Aug 2006 09:00:00 GMT

I have only been here during their happy hour, but I LOVE this place!! The staff is so friendly! You can't beat the margaritas and tapas menu. I also suggest the spicy salsa - it has a vinagarette flavor with kick - delicious! The atmosphere, food, and service have always been great. I would definitely recommend this place.

4 Stars: Good upmarket Mexican (by toskeroskerus)

toskeroskerus — Sun, 16 Apr 2006 09:00:00 GMT

This is way above your aveage burrito place but isn't insanely expensive. It has creative Mexican food without seeming totally divorced from standard Mexican cuisine. We were seated promptly, the decor and atmosphere were appropriate without being forced , and our server really was great- friendly and helpful in a real way. Plus, they have a million flavors of genuinely fresh margaritas (real fruit pieces!). Also, they're open late-ish. Portions aren't huge but by no means shabby.

4 Stars: Reservations? What a joke! (by ma_belle)

ma_belle — Fri, 03 Feb 2006 09:00:00 GMT

I've been to La Palapa a couple and each time I have mixed feelings about my dining experience. I suggest going during the week day at a time when it's less crowded. We went on a Saturday night and it was very packed, so I understood mind the 30 minute wait. We had excellent food (love the spicy yellow & blue corn chips) and okay service. We figured next time we'll make reservations and head over at an earlier time another weekend. Well, we did just that and still waited for 20 minutes with reservations (!!!) and you can see lots of empty(party of two) tables around. Very odd. I HIGHLY recommend the frozen strawberry margaritas!!! Muy excellente!

1 Stars: Problematic with potential (by daalig)

daalig — Sun, 13 Nov 2005 09:00:00 GMT

A friend and I walked into La Palapa off the street. The ambience and smell of food enticed in the doors. However, the experience quickly went downhill. First, our silverware was dirty, and our waiter scoffed at replacing it. Second, our table was wobbly. Our server, after two askings, fixed the table temporarily and finally gave us a menu after ten minutes. However, the table quickly wobbled again and spilled coffee all over us. We asked to be moved, which subsided the problems for a little while. Finally, the largest, inexcusable mistake occured with the check. We asked one server for change, and she gave our check with a credit card to our waiter. Who then brought us another check and forgot to give the credit back. In the end, we had to confront him about the missing credit card....all in all....a disaster!

5 Stars: Best Mexican in NYC (by hollys821)

hollys821 — Thu, 08 Sep 2005 09:00:00 GMT

I LOVE THIS PLACE!! I have been here several times, and enjoyed every vegetarian-friendly item on the menu. The waitstaff is prompt and courteous, the food is phenomenal, and the prices are reasonable. Try my personal favorite dessert, the tres leches cake.

5 Stars: Great food (by thinkbh)

thinkbh — Sat, 30 Jul 2005 09:00:00 GMT

This is a great place to take out-of-towners. Perfect margaritas made with real lime juice, not a pre-mix concoction of sweet and sour mix. I'm surprised that one reviewer would actually complain about a soft taco costing $4.95. Um, you are at a restaurant. Not Taco Bell. And, is that really breaking the bank? I don't think so. Service has always been pleasant and helpful. We always sit as soon as our entire party gets there.

1 Stars: What a waste of money (by inagaddadavida_loca)

inagaddadavida_loca — Fri, 17 Jun 2005 09:00:00 GMT

I went w/a Mexicana from Chicago. It didn't start off on a good note because there was no complimentary chips and salsa - a bad sign! And I ain't payin' $5 for that, ya dig? We had a decent appetizer, but I spent $20 on this combo plate that just didn't move me. My date had a soft taco, which cost $4.95(!) If that was not bad enough, a side of sour cream was $2! In total, bill with drinks and dessert was $69. I've never felt so ripped off in my life. For that kind of money, I could have gone to a nice steakhouse and been treated like a king (and queen). This city still leaves me cold for Mexican - why can't NYC get it right? Why aren't there any good hippie food burrito places around? A big deep six from me!

5 Stars: Very Good (by natamaria)

natamaria — Mon, 13 Jun 2005 09:00:00 GMT

Once you go inside this restaurant, yuo are automaticly welcomed. The service is very warm and attentive. They will always offer you a smile. In addition the food is delicious. I have gone to many other restaurants but none as perfect as this one.

5 Stars: HIBISCUS HEAVEN (by addiebower)

addiebower — Fri, 20 May 2005 09:00:00 GMT

There is one reason alone to visit this restaurant: The Hibiscus Margarita. It's so good it DESERVES to be capitalized. On the plane ride home, I was tapping my veins for the sweet nectar of the gods, for which I knew I'd have to wait years before I had it again. God, the corn is tasty as well. I live in North Carolina; it's been too long since my last moments at La Palapa. All I have for consolation is a postcard I shamelessly took with me to post on my refrigerator in memories of my H.M. and suitcases I had to lug in with me on my way to the airport. (tears...)

4 Stars: Saturday Brunch (by reigningcattle)

reigningcattle — Sat, 05 Feb 2005 09:00:00 GMT

Stopped in on a Saturday at around 4. Pretty empty, but hey, that's late for brunch. Hostess waved myself and girlfriend to sit wherever we liked. Menus and water right away; no bread, chips, etc, but a trio of salsas set down with water. GF had Mexican rendition of french toast, which was huge, quite crisp on the outside, verging on melted on the inside, w/ cinnamon syrup and sliced banana. I had good (but overpriced at 5) pork taco, side of astounding Mexican cornbread, and lovely cafe de olla. Not bad for 20.

4 Stars: Absolutely Delicious (by apricotdelight)

apricotdelight — Sun, 10 Oct 2004 09:00:00 GMT

No sure why CitySearch has this classified as Italian, because it's Mexican at its best. We stopped in one Saturday for brunch and it was such a pleasant surprise. I had their version of Huevos Rancheros and it really was one of the best things I have ever tasted. The service was friendly and attentive and the room was very cute. My only minor complaint is the traditional Mexican music. Why do they think people want to hear that? It actually detracts from an otherwise sophisticated yet warm vibe. Definitely check it out.

4 Stars: No Sweet & Sour Mix here!! : ) (by deannaip)

deannaip — Sun, 29 Aug 2004 09:00:00 GMT

Loved it! The margaritas were strong, made with fresh lime. No sweet & sour or powder in the drinks. Just wonderful. The salsas were flavorful and spicy.

1 Stars: such a disappointment (by furixx)

furixx — Sat, 26 Jun 2004 09:00:00 GMT

crap food, the worst margarita i have ever had (choked on the fumes) inattentive service, overpriced, pretentious yuppies. what more could you ask for?

5 Stars: Don't believe the naysayers.... (by mononokehime)

mononokehime — Thu, 20 May 2004 09:00:00 GMT

I'm perplexed by the bad reviews here and wonder if perhaps the chefs are inconsistent. I think it has the best Mexican-REAL Mexican- food I've had in New York, leagues beyond Dos Caminos (overhyped), Miracle Grill (bland and Southwestern, not Mexican) or Veracruz(bland and overpriced), all places that have similar ratings on this site. The decor is stylish with traditional elements. The margaritas were large and delicious, and the salsas and guacamole perfect. My entree-a vegetarian plate with beans, cactus paddle and potato filled taquitos-was perfectly spiced and inventive; the portions were smaller than the obscene amounts of food served elsewhere, but it was still more than I could eat in one sitting. It may be more expensive than your corner burrito joint, but you get a lot of quality and flavor for those extra dollars.

1 Stars: Should be nominated as Worst (by robjack)

robjack — Fri, 07 May 2004 09:00:00 GMT

The food is horrible. Bulk made and aged ceviche - you'd think they might get the hint when there's a barely touched dish at nearly every table. Chorizo is 50% oil and I wouldn't want to guess what the other 50% is. If this place was any good, it certainly isn't anymore. Plus you get to pay plenty of the privilege.

5 Stars: Go if you know Mexican food (by gnhoratio)

gnhoratio — Fri, 31 Oct 2003 09:00:00 GMT

We've been, several times, to the newer branch on sixth avenue. DON'T go if you want enchiladas and tacos - that's not what this place is about. It's about authentic, real MEXICAN food, not Tex-Mex, and it's some of the best we've ever had. Cactus paddles, Veracruz fish, etc. And the menu changes regularly, so you have to go back again and again. Don't understand the comments about skimpy portions. We've never been able to finish. And Matt is a great server.

2 Stars: Good drinks, bad food (by id1978)

id1978 — Wed, 01 Oct 2003 09:00:00 GMT

This is certainly not the worst restaurant that I have eaten at. But, it is certainly not the best. The drinks are acutally pretty good & I can not complain about the service either. The problem is the food. My salad was made of some substance that had the texture of leather & by the taste of it, I would imagine that leather would tase like this salad. The chicken had the same problem very tough & small portions.

3 Stars: so so (by merrik)

merrik — Wed, 10 Sep 2003 09:00:00 GMT

Been walking by for months now and meaning to try La Palapa. The design is inviting and the atmosphere inside is casual/pleasant. Service was efficient and knowledgable.

Appetizers were good. We had the quesadillas and chilupas plus two frozen margaritas. margaritas were strong and well made, but maybe a touch too sour.

Entree was the duck with mole, swiss chard and rice and unfortunately verged on tasteless. the glass of house shiraz I had with it was quite good though. Strong hints of coffee bean made it a great way to finish the meal.

Prices are slightly inflated. Not absurd, but high enough not to think of the space as a good value. I found myself thinking of Esperanto on Avenue C a lot while we were at La Palapa and kind of wishing I had gone there.

4 Stars: Es Bueno (by pennpal05)

pennpal05 — Mon, 08 Sep 2003 09:00:00 GMT

Overall enjoyed the place but there was nothing that stood out against other similar places. Service was a little on the slow side since we had to flag down our waitress all evening just to get her attention. Bonus points for the complimentary champagne toasts for bday celebrations

2 Stars: Don't Go! (by meaniepluel)

meaniepluel — Thu, 28 Aug 2003 09:00:00 GMT

We had reservations and were seated 5 minutes late (I'M NOT COMPLAINING). The service was horrible, they didn't take our order for a half an hour. After waiting for an hour our dinner finally came out. All 3 steaks were cooked wrong. Then when we ordered desert, one of the two items ordered never came. When confronted about the service aftering sitting in the restaurant for two hours. The manager didn't believe us, and thought we were trying to scam them. We weren't trying to get a free meal, but an apology would have been nice.

2 Stars: Big Disapointment (by eyalkattan)

eyalkattan — Mon, 21 Jul 2003 09:00:00 GMT

Service:
We ordered a few apetizers and asked the waiter to bring the guacamole and chips first. it came about 15 minutes later with the rest of the apetizers.

Food:
Personaly I didn't like the food. Although it had mexican ingredients, nothing there had any flavor. just a big salad of items swimming in the same souce as the apetizers. The cod fish was overcooked and I am willing to bet that it was not even fresh. The frozen margaritas were week and too sour.

Price:
Way Over Priced!!! BIG DISAPOINTMENT!

5 Stars: A Breath of Fresh Air (by donnickolson)

donnickolson — Sat, 12 Jul 2003 09:00:00 GMT

If you are looking for great authentic Mexican food, helpful friendly service and atmosphere which makes you feel as though you are in the Heart of Mexico City, run, not walk, to La Palapa. Terrific Margaritas! Don't forget to save room for dessert. You will not be disappointed.

4 Stars: Great Find (by WineLover2000)

WineLover2000 — Fri, 09 May 2003 09:00:00 GMT

La Palapa is a wonderful jewel in the East Village! I recommend a reservation because the wait can be long. The front part of the restaurant is loud, but the garden is wonderful, quiet and warm. The mango margarita is heavenly. I went with a party of four and no one was disapointed with their meal. They import the veggies from Mexico so it's authentic! This is a must go.

5 Stars: looking for new places (by LaCerva)

LaCerva — Sat, 03 May 2003 09:00:00 GMT

The food and atmosphere were top notch.The owner was out and about in the diningroom,and that was really refreshing to see.We liked it so much we went back the next day and took 4 of our friends.

5 Stars: best mexican (by margaritte)

margaritte — Sat, 03 May 2003 09:00:00 GMT

dined at la palapa last night and had a homemade chosrizo and cheese stuffed gordita. It was delicious as was the fish special witha guacamole and tomatillo salsa. my hibisicus margarita also outstounding..I could taste the fresh lime... the food, the service and the value all are great. I will return...so will the friends
dined with.

3 Stars: nothing special (by Buttonfly)

Buttonfly — Thu, 24 Apr 2003 09:00:00 GMT

After spending more money than intended, I felt even more disappointed in the food. The southwestern spices were more than overwhelming to the point where you couldn't taste the actual food!

3 Stars: It's Palapatable :-) (by taksa)

taksa — Sun, 06 Apr 2003 09:00:00 GMT

$ of us had a Saturday brunch at La Palapa. I found the atmosphere quite confortable, the restaurant is bright and clean. I wasn't that thrilled with the food, though. I say stay away from the Bloody Marias and stick with the Marys (vodka); somehow tequila, tomato and horseradish make an odd combination. The "Fruit of the Day" offering is a joke - a very tiny portion of slightly oxidized canned pineapple, a sliver of unripe strawberry, why bother? I tried the french toast, also tiny, and way, way too sweet. The coffee was on the verge of being too old (over 20 minutes.) I have heard good things about their lunches and dinners, so I will give them another try.

3 Stars: Fell Off (by divine1002)

divine1002 — Thu, 03 Apr 2003 09:00:00 GMT

I've been to this restaurant 3 or 4 times. The first time was with a group for friend's birthday! It was great, we all felt it was one of the best meals we had. Unfortunately the next few times I went with my boyfriend our meal wasn't all that great. The guacamole was terrible, and the steak dish was too salty. And our bill of $70 (without drinks) was definitely not worth it. Too bad because it was a great option for dining in the village. BEWARE if you decide to change something in your dish like a different mole sauce you will be charged extra.

4 Stars: Great Food + Service (by digital_buffalo)

digital_buffalo — Tue, 04 Mar 2003 09:00:00 GMT

Went on a busy Fri nite and waited to be seated for 20 minutes or so. Other than that I have nothing but positive things to say. The food is tasty and served quickly. The service is prompt and professional. Our table happened to be near the liquor cabinet and when the owner needed to access the cabinet during our meal - which was hardly a major inconvenience - she removed the pitcher of Sangria we were drinking from our bill. An excellent alternative to your usual burrito and fajita Mexican place.

3 Stars: Those hidden extra $$$. (by brucef)

brucef — Sat, 15 Feb 2003 09:00:00 GMT

A small side of rice was $4 and a side of beans was also $4. Have chips and salsa at the bar. The same chips at your table and you'll be paying $5 for them (a NY mexican restaurant custom, it seems). Our waitress explained, "we charge for them because we make the chips and salsa here at the restaurant." The entrees are expensive enough. Don't nickel-and-dime the customer over the chips.

5 Stars: Authentic and delicious! (by snivel6)

snivel6 — Sat, 01 Feb 2003 09:00:00 GMT

Being from Texas and constantly in search of good Mexican food, I have finally found it at La Palapa! The margaritas, especially the frozen pomegranate, are huge and delicious. The chips are dusted with a mild chili powder and pair with the guacamole spectacularly. I have had the mole enchiladas 3 times and have to say that they are just as good as back home--sorry, Grandma! The green chicken enchiladas are mouth watering, as well. I am so glad La Palapa exists and highly recommend it.

5 Stars: Underrated (by rushjc)

rushjc — Wed, 22 Jan 2003 09:00:00 GMT

One of the better authentic Mexican restaurants around. You get a great value for a great meal. Can't go wrong.

5 Stars: Holy Mole!! (by elaineglue)

elaineglue — Mon, 20 Jan 2003 09:00:00 GMT

I have to disagree with that last "rating"...I dined at La Palapa on Sunday night...I had the enchiladas in red mole...not only were they awesome..the serving was gigantic and the mole sauce was rich, thick and tasty..my mouth is watering just thinking of them...they are worth every penny! I also recently dined at Dos Caminos...where the enchiladas were 16.95..you get rice and beans but I would rather have La Palapas Enchiladas anyday!!
Hands Down!!

4 Stars: "Would you also like salsa and chips?" (by RavenmuseNYC)

RavenmuseNYC — Thu, 16 Jan 2003 09:00:00 GMT

...asked my waitress after I placed my order. Of course, she didn't tell me I was going to get charged $3.95 for it. I had the Enchiladas de Pollo Verde, which was good, but not exactly worth $11.95. The chicken was a little dry. They didn't even have the decency to include rice and beans. Too bad. The atmosphere was wonderful, with its Mayan artwork, romantic lighting, and music that's not too loud or soft. The service was warm and friendly. Better to just go for drinks.

4 Stars: Insert catchy title (by jblnyc)

jblnyc — Thu, 02 Jan 2003 09:00:00 GMT

This place is strong. I find that Mexican food in the city is generally pretty weak, but I'll go here and be happy. Terrific Verdes sauce and nice margaritas. Service is a little naive, but pleasant enough. The seating is a little odd(I've been there several times and sat in differen sections, but always feel squeezed in and a little in the way

5 Stars: Viva Mexico! (by DBlaya)

DBlaya — Mon, 16 Dec 2002 09:00:00 GMT

Amazing food, friendly service and a spacious dining area. (no bumping elbows and spilling your Tecate!) A great selection of Mexican beers and tequilas, not to mention margaritas in every flavor imaginable, accompany the mouth watering dishes.

5 Stars: Soooo yummy! (by jpfood)

jpfood — Mon, 02 Dec 2002 09:00:00 GMT

I am surprised to see negative comments! I went for dinner this weekend and had a delcious meal. The food was great- not your basic taco/burrito Mexican. The dishes are really interesting and very flavorful. Large portions too! I have been before and have a similar experience. Prices are also very reasonable. My favorite Mexican in NYC!

4 Stars: Fun atmosphere, decent food (by nkranes)

nkranes — Wed, 27 Nov 2002 09:00:00 GMT

Ate there the other night as part of a party of 10. The service was attentive, the atmosphere fun with interesting Mexican-ish decore, and the food was decent. Good margaritas, although I had around 6 and was still standing. We went for a birthday and there just happened to be 2 others in the same evening there.

2 Stars: Great Food, Small Portions (by lshewitt)

lshewitt — Thu, 14 Nov 2002 09:00:00 GMT

The foode was delicious, however, portions are small and prices high. It also seemed as though the waiter was just tolerating us and completely ignored some of our requests.

5 Stars: What a Margarita! (by 38397)

38397 — Wed, 13 Nov 2002 09:00:00 GMT

This place definately deserves to be on the best Mexican list (if not the best). Everytime I've been to La Palapa (10 times) the food and drinks have been fantasic and the service impeccable. I don't know what they'er doning to get it so right but it's working. And what a margarita!! I'm so happy I live right around the corner from this joint ,I'm trying to become a regular at the bar, but I keep sitting at a table to enjoy the food.

5 Stars: THE VERY BEST (by sohophoto)

sohophoto — Mon, 11 Nov 2002 09:00:00 GMT

The food is amazing, the service is prompt and friendly and the ambience keeps me coming back... and the drinks are superb!

5 Stars: Hidden gem in nutty St. Mark's pl. (by Mchelp)

Mchelp — Sat, 12 Oct 2002 09:00:00 GMT

My first experience at La Palapa was disastrous. My blind date was ugly (not restaurant's fault), the beer was warm, and the food was so spicy it numbed my taste buds. However, I loved the ambience, and decided to give it another chance. I'm glad I did so, because all my gripes seemed to have been addressed. I've since been there many more times, and I would probably rate this restaurant as one of the top three Mexicans in the city. To top it all off, getting a table there is never a hassle.

1 Stars: It would earn a 10 on a scale of 100! (by rwl)

rwl — Tue, 08 Oct 2002 09:00:00 GMT

La Palapa makes Burritoville look like Daniel! Here are a few reasons: 1) The margaritas are overpriced, unpleasantly sour and weak. 2) When not otherwise unacceptable - blandness, dryness, etc. - the dishes are generally one-note disasters with the singular note being hotness. 2) The sauces they leave on the table are the same sauces they dump on the food, one of which rendered the enchiladas - which don't earn a positive numerical rating to begin with - bitter, overhot and totally inedible. 3) After biting into a piece of duck, I had to look at the menu again to see if I had, in fact, ordered the "duck jerky special". 4) In general, there is a lack of fundamental skills in the kitchen...culinary sins abound here, folks! La Palapa is a primer for how not to prepare Mexican food. 'Nuff said.

5 Stars: you won't find better (by dahlia_summers)

dahlia_summers — Fri, 04 Oct 2002 09:00:00 GMT

If you are looking for refried beans, go elsewhere. This is modern regional Mexican cuisine. I have been to La Palapa several times with friends and each plate is always excellent. I don't know what other restaurant these folks are complaining about. I've had to push my plate away due to the large portions (the enchiladas are gigantic). Although, I have to admit that the mixed drinks are awful, stick with beer and wine.

1 Stars: Worst Dining Experience Ever (by cindi_jones)

cindi_jones — Wed, 02 Oct 2002 09:00:00 GMT

Having ordered delivery from here, I decided to go and try out the restaurant with six friends. We ordered apps and main courses. 3 apps came 10 minutes into being there, the other 3 came 45 minutes later NO JOKE!...then 5 minutes later they brought out all the entrees. don't know about you--but mexican food is type of meal i need time in between courses. having a full plate of appetizers when the entrees were brought out did not allow me to enjoy my food at all. The waiters were rude, the place was empty (thus no justification for this type of service), and we were treated horribly. Guess that automatic 20% tip on parties of 6 really hinders their desire to give good service. Though the food was good, it is very pricey, and the service is awful. I will NEVER return (nor get takeout) again. Such a shame...

4 Stars: all about the mole (by jaba44)

jaba44 — Wed, 11 Sep 2002 09:00:00 GMT

and the vibe. I had the Mole and a really cute waitress. Scene is a good one. I really dont know why everyone seems to be so nege about this place. kick back and relax!

1 Stars: avoid at all costs (by sal_monella)

sal_monella — Tue, 27 Aug 2002 09:00:00 GMT

La POOPlapa is a more fitting name. Don't bother with this place

2 Stars: 3 (by shady_dave)

shady_dave — Sun, 18 Aug 2002 09:00:00 GMT

This place was a huge disappointment. Starting off with having to pay for chips n salsa (isn't this against Mexican restaurant tradition??) the food was very, very spicy. This is good if you like spicy food, but it was just too much. I even like spicy food but this one was too rough on my stomach. It had a lot of fancy Mexican dishes (those of you looking for the basics, go elsewhere) and it was super loud, hence not very romantic. All in all, it is a great place to go if you like VERY spicy food and you have a large group. Otherwise, I would try a different restaurant. Cheers.

5 Stars: Yum, yum, yum (by lydia2980)

lydia2980 — Tue, 13 Aug 2002 09:00:00 GMT

All of you people who think that La Palapa is overpriced and not authentic are insane!!!!! They have the best Mexican food I have ever had, full of delicious unique flavors. And everything tastes so fresh! The staff is so friendly and knowledgable, and the owners are so personable, and often come to your table to give you tastes of dishes. Those of you who think it's too expensive: what's so espensive about $5 for a quesadilla, or $12 for an entire brunch. As for small portions, yes, a couple of the appetizers may be small, but I dare anyone to order the chiles rellenos, and tell me that it is a small dish. The ambience is also wonderful - I love the lit wall in the back. I frequent this restaurant, and everyone else should too!

4 Stars: 8 (by dinnerdate)

dinnerdate — Mon, 29 Jul 2002 09:00:00 GMT

upbeat mood and music...I was happy to see the table salsas were like the ones I had in Mexico and really loved the tacos and quesadillas. We tried the Hibiscus Margarita recommended by another ctitsearch reviewer and wow was it great or what!!!?

1 Stars: La Palapa = La Garbage (by culinarycanary)

culinarycanary — Wed, 24 Jul 2002 09:00:00 GMT

This place has a super fancy exterior---too bad
the food quality doesn't match the decor's quality.
The food is bland, served in small portions, and is overpriced. Only someone who likes to be ripped
would love this place. For all its glitz and glam, it
still serves some of the worst Mexican in NY. And
their service is super slow!

4 Stars: La Palapa es guapa (by Hege)

Hege — Thu, 18 Jul 2002 09:00:00 GMT

Great place! The atmosphere is inviting and the waitstaff attentive and knowledgeable. The menu is original with something for everyone--including cheese that is made on the premises. And for the drunken horticulturist in all of us, there's a hibiscus margarita that will keep you planted at the bar for hours.

3 Stars: Why oh Why? (by jujube)

jujube — Wed, 10 Jul 2002 09:00:00 GMT

Why oh why do people love this place. The food is downright yucky sometimes and occassionally decent. Overpriced. The tacos were dry and bland. The enchiladas were a big indecipherable mass. Cocktails are good and will at least keep your spirits up (until you get the bill). Service is OK.

5 Stars: The perfect Mexican experience (by liquidpaper)

liquidpaper — Tue, 02 Jul 2002 09:00:00 GMT

I have been to La Palapa countless times and each time I go, I cannnot bring myself to order anything but the delicious duck mole. It is the best mole dish I have ever had. And this is coming from a proud Mexican who, until now, would scoff at the pretense of creative, unconventional Mexican dishes. The well-concocted spices are expertly paired with simple sides of saffron rice and spinach. My string of dinner companions have also raved about the steak with lime and the chicken tacos. Stay away from the enchiladas. It is the only dish that hasn't received a stellar review from one of my recruits. The service here is always friendly. Their attentiveness leaves a bit to be desired, but the bright and cheerful atmosphere makes it impossible for you to care. Especially if you've had a pitcher of the delicious white sangria ;)

5 Stars: What's with the whining about CHIPS? (by pingpingping)

pingpingping — Fri, 21 Jun 2002 09:00:00 GMT

So what? Its not like an extra few bucks is going to kill you, relax! If charging for chips is what it takes to keep that place consistantly good, I'm all for it. I love it every time I go there. Real mexican (not taco bell/maryanne's style tex mex), good marg's, service is ALWAYS polite, and the atmosphere is fun. I finally branched out from my standard order of the skirt steak with lime, and was not disappointed. Great place. If you can't afford chips, go to burritoville.

5 Stars: 10 (by gwenny)

gwenny — Mon, 17 Jun 2002 09:00:00 GMT

the ambiance is tres cool... kind of lounge-like... not at all pretentious... low lights... funky mexican music... excellent decor. apparently, the place as been feng shuid to the hilt! the food is incredible. if you love margeritas---it's totally worth sampling one here. they use fresh squeezed lime juice---as opposed to bottled---and the taste is evident. also, the quacamole is to die for. it is soooo genuine. i always order two heaping plates of it!!!! and one last thing... the chips are different... they are spiced chips, not just plain chips... and i assure you, they are yummy chips! a most satifying meal awaits you at la palapa.

2 Stars: get out while you still can (by twoEatingPeas)

twoEatingPeas — Mon, 27 May 2002 09:00:00 GMT

lousy:

first we were seated in the garden right up against the super loud air conditioner. so we asked to be moved back inside-- so far, so good. (during our dinner, it appeared that another couple encountered this and also asked to be relocated.)

then we got the infamous "try and taste me" dishes -- we paid for chips to discover they were mostly flavorless except the overspiced salsa. we both practically choked on the spicy salsa.

my frozen margarita was undrinkable -- sour and weak.

the enchilladas were some crappy pieces of chicken wrapped in a tortilla with the same sauces we already got for free and some flavorless cheese.

the chicken with plantains: well, the plantains were good. the chicken was (see enchilladas above).

go somewhere else like any mexican place below 14th street for better food.

(oh, the service was excellent, otherwise!)