Cafe Amore Pizza Restaurant

★★★☆☆

About Cafe Amore Pizza Restaurant

Hours
Mon. - Sun. 9am - 6pm

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Lombardi's Pizza

32 Spring St A New York, NY

Resultset_next

The Cloister Cafe

238 E 9th Street New York, NY

2.5 4
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Cafe Amore Pizza Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

I have eaten at this place a few times because I live directly across the street and I haven't found any good "by the slice" pizza places right on Union Square. No more. At this point, I would walk across the Brooklyn bridge if it was my only other option. Obscenely rude staff and absurd prices, but if it was half decent pizza it still might be worth it. It's not. The pizza is heavy, tasteless and NOT new york pizza. I've tried several different types out of late night desperation for quick and easy food, and they manage to consistently make them all equally as bad.(and yes, I tried the white pizza.)

Walk a few extra blocks and eat somewhere else.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I have eaten at this place a few times because I live directly across the street and I haven't found any good "by the slice" pizza places right on Union Square. No more. At this point, I would walk across the Brooklyn bridge if it was my only other option. Obscenely rude staff and absurd prices, but if it was half decent pizza it still might be worth it. It's not. The pizza is heavy, tasteless and NOT new york pizza. I've tried several different types out of late night desperation for quick and easy food, and they manage to consistently make them all equally as bad.(and yes, I tried the white pizza.)

Walk a few extra blocks and eat somewhere else.

Pros: it's in New york and not a far walk from decent pizza restaurants

Cons: so many...

.

I absolutely LOVE Amore's, mainly for their white/mushroom pizza, but their other pizzas aren't half-bad either. You won't want to get white pizza anywhere else after going to Amore's. I don't usually dine IN Amore's though - it's a little dingy in the back, and it sometimes smells funny. Pies are only sliced when you order, so depending on who serves you your slice could be gigantic or kind of small. Also, the servers are kind of bad-tempered in that they get annoyed when you walk in and take a while to order. And they're usually reluctant to re-bake a slice for you if you think the crust is underdone (though it's good most of the time!)

2
★★★★☆

I absolutely LOVE Amore's, mainly for their white/mushroom pizza, but their other pizzas aren't half-bad either. You won't want to get white pizza anywhere else after going to Amore's. I don't usually dine IN Amore's though - it's a little dingy in the back, and it sometimes smells funny. Pies are only sliced when you order, so depending on who serves you your slice could be gigantic or kind of small. Also, the servers are kind of bad-tempered in that they get annoyed when you walk in and take a while to order. And they're usually reluctant to re-bake a slice for you if you think the crust is underdone (though it's good most of the time!)

Pros: good food, good drinks

Cons: inconsistent slice sizes, dingy dining area, bad-tempered servers

.

This place has pretty alright pizza, but their prices don't really match up well with the quality of their food. I'd recommend this place if you really were starving, or if you just like paying high prices for food. Bottom line: there are better deals out there.

3
★★★☆☆

This place has pretty alright pizza, but their prices don't really match up well with the quality of their food. I'd recommend this place if you really were starving, or if you just like paying high prices for food. Bottom line: there are better deals out there.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I used to come here everyday for lunch, but I'm sorry I did. Theyve raised the prices everyyear to a now unaffordable level, and the pizza does not justify the high price. the pizza is stale even when its "fresh" out of the oven. There's always too much cheese and its usually burnt. The only thhing going for it is that it's in a good neighborhood where it gets a lot of traffic... unfortunately.

2
★★☆☆☆

I used to come here everyday for lunch, but I'm sorry I did. Theyve raised the prices everyyear to a now unaffordable level, and the pizza does not justify the high price. the pizza is stale even when its "fresh" out of the oven. There's always too much cheese and its usually burnt. The only thhing going for it is that it's in a good neighborhood where it gets a lot of traffic... unfortunately.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Cafe Amore Pizza Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review