Totonno's Of 26 Street

★★★☆☆

About Totonno's Of 26 Street

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Una Pizza Napoletana--CLOSED

349 E 12th St New York, NY

Resultset_next

Arte Cafe

106 W 73rd St New York, NY

2.7143 7
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Totonno's Of 26 Street was?
Write a Review
.

I moved in next door and ordered 3 large pies. It was so nasty I wouldn't even eat this stuff after hauling furniture and appliances all day....and I'm a beast when it comes to eating Pizza.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I moved in next door and ordered 3 large pies. It was so nasty I wouldn't even eat this stuff after hauling furniture and appliances all day....and I'm a beast when it comes to eating Pizza.

Pros: close to my house

Cons: everything else

.

Not only was the server not interested in serving us at all, the food was very underwhelming. The pizza was doughy in the center and just plain wasn't very good. I will not be back. The server sat around and watched the dining room while there were only 5 customers in the entire place. It took me 20 minutes to get a refill of club soda. Bottom line line: overpriced, bad food, and terrible service....ENJOY!

0
★☆☆☆☆

Not only was the server not interested in serving us at all, the food was very underwhelming. The pizza was doughy in the center and just plain wasn't very good. I will not be back. The server sat around and watched the dining room while there were only 5 customers in the entire place. It took me 20 minutes to get a refill of club soda. Bottom line line: overpriced, bad food, and terrible service....ENJOY!

Pros: None.

Cons: Service, food, price

.

a friend and i ordered this pizza after reading insanely good reviews online and on their menu. while the delivery was fast, we found the pizza disappointing at best. the crust was abnormally heavy. it was similar to a bagel in both taste and consistency. the ingredients were fresh-tasting, but nothing could mask that crust. i imagine it would be a good pizza to order if you haven't eaten in years and really need to get full quickly. for everyone else, there are several better alternatives. i find it unlikely that "only god makes better pizza." highly unlikely.

1
★★☆☆☆

a friend and i ordered this pizza after reading insanely good reviews online and on their menu. while the delivery was fast, we found the pizza disappointing at best. the crust was abnormally heavy. it was similar to a bagel in both taste and consistency. the ingredients were fresh-tasting, but nothing could mask that crust. i imagine it would be a good pizza to order if you haven't eaten in years and really need to get full quickly. for everyone else, there are several better alternatives. i find it unlikely that "only god makes better pizza." highly unlikely.

Pros: fresh ingredients, fast delivery

Cons: nasty crust, very heavy

.

I have tried most all notable pizza establishments all over NYC & NJ and this pie is only average & it is extremely overpriced, Grimaldis is better.

1
★★★☆☆

I have tried most all notable pizza establishments all over NYC & NJ and this pie is only average & it is extremely overpriced, Grimaldis is better.

Pros: Good Service

Cons: Expensive

.

Great food, great service. If you're looking for nonstop attention, a 20 page wine list and a waiter who puts your napkin on your lap, this is not the place to go. You get high quality food (definitely top of the NYC pizzas), value for your money and a relaxing environment. Just what you want from a pizza place.

2
★★★★★

Great food, great service. If you're looking for nonstop attention, a 20 page wine list and a waiter who puts your napkin on your lap, this is not the place to go. You get high quality food (definitely top of the NYC pizzas), value for your money and a relaxing environment. Just what you want from a pizza place.

Pros: Pizza, Prompt Service, Inexpensive

Cons: Not close to subway

.

This Totonno's restaurant is not like the Upper East Side version (which is great). At the downtown Totonno's the food is solid, the pizza is good but expensive, and the salads are always good. However the service is atrocious. I had to go up to the bar to get a glass of water for myself the last time I was there. I had to ask several times for a check and that is after locating the waiter. The waiters do not pay any attention to the customers, instead sit at the bar and watch TV. I would consider ordering out but I will never eat there again.

1
★★☆☆☆

This Totonno's restaurant is not like the Upper East Side version (which is great). At the downtown Totonno's the food is solid, the pizza is good but expensive, and the salads are always good. However the service is atrocious. I had to go up to the bar to get a glass of water for myself the last time I was there. I had to ask several times for a check and that is after locating the waiter. The waiters do not pay any attention to the customers, instead sit at the bar and watch TV. I would consider ordering out but I will never eat there again.

Pros: Solid food

Cons: Waiters , Service, Prices

.

This is absolutely the best pizza in the city. Those fortunate to experience this pizza in the outer-boroughs are already well aware of this truth. I recommend delivery.

2
★★★★★

This is absolutely the best pizza in the city. Those fortunate to experience this pizza in the outer-boroughs are already well aware of this truth. I recommend delivery.

Pros: The best pizza

Cons: low income locale

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Totonno's Of 26 Street, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review