Nice Guy Eddie's

★★★★☆
  • 5 Avenue A

    New York, NY 10009

    Cross street: at Houston St.

    Map & Directions
  • 212-253-1666

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Antique Cafe

55 West 26th Street New York, NY

Resultset_next

Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steak House

1221 Avenue Of The Americas New York, NY

3.7059 17
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Nice Guy Eddie's was?
Write a Review
.

This place is a joke. The food is garbage, and the bartenders are incompetent (they wrongfully charged me $40 when my friend paid for the bill). The managers are idiots and wouldn't refund me my money back. Don't waste your time here,

3
★★★★★

This place is a joke. The food is garbage, and the bartenders are incompetent (they wrongfully charged me $40 when my friend paid for the bill). The managers are idiots and wouldn't refund me my money back. Don't waste your time here,

.

I don't know what they do tho their burgers, but eating one is like eating REALLY GREAT PUSSY. A must have during the Super Bowl (GO GIANTS!!!)

3
★★★★★

I don't know what they do tho their burgers, but eating one is like eating REALLY GREAT PUSSY. A must have during the Super Bowl (GO GIANTS!!!)

.

the wings are great, some of the bartenders are fun interesting .but one girl in a cotton blue dress was there all the time. .. she says she is the manager during the day. she also said she cant wait to see me homeless i dont know her .

3
★★★★★

the wings are great, some of the bartenders are fun interesting .but one girl in a cotton blue dress was there all the time. .. she says she is the manager during the day. she also said she cant wait to see me homeless i dont know her .

.

I signed up to answer a couple of other reviews. I have been going to Nice Guy Eddie's for years to watch Oregon and Laker games that were'nt on tv. It's in the neighborhood and they get all the games.l For a few years it got iffy, with

3
★★★★★

I signed up to answer a couple of other reviews. I have been going to Nice Guy Eddie's for years to watch Oregon and Laker games that were'nt on tv. It's in the neighborhood and they get all the games.l For a few years it got iffy, with

.

I went in to Nice Guy Eddies last night cause I had a hankering for some wings. The Bartender was nice, cute and not afraid to toss one back with you. I was basically minding my business when this blond sits next to me and starts rambling about the yankees. Each remark she made to me escalated in tone, very angry, abusive person who should not be allowed within 200 yards of a saloon. I soon realized that she was the manager! OMG. It got worse from there. Every statement had a barb and of course I showed my disinterest in what she was saying. She realized I couldn't stomach hearing her, I wasn't being rude, just disinterested. She in a drunken rage called me a "dick f%ck" because i started looking at her with a dumb founded expression. More nasty comments followed. I have never had a worse experience. The owners should turn themselves in for having a old drunk jerk as a employee much less manager. Avoid this place.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I went in to Nice Guy Eddies last night cause I had a hankering for some wings. The Bartender was nice, cute and not afraid to toss one back with you. I was basically minding my business when this blond sits next to me and starts rambling about the yankees. Each remark she made to me escalated in tone, very angry, abusive person who should not be allowed within 200 yards of a saloon. I soon realized that she was the manager! OMG. It got worse from there. Every statement had a barb and of course I showed my disinterest in what she was saying. She realized I couldn't stomach hearing her, I wasn't being rude, just disinterested. She in a drunken rage called me a "dick f%ck" because i started looking at her with a dumb founded expression. More nasty comments followed. I have never had a worse experience. The owners should turn themselves in for having a old drunk jerk as a employee much less manager. Avoid this place.

Pros: bartender was nice

Cons: Drunken 40 something manager with blond hair is horrible

.

The Bartender and the manager are so busy drinking up and toasting to each other that they forget about thier customers. Happy Hour starts form 5-8 but they are so not into the customer that they forget about the time. It was one of my worst experance in a long time.the only persons that were trying to take care of the customer were two young ladies on the floor but the blond chick and the longhair bartender are total looser. They should be fired!!!!! go at your own risk

0
★☆☆☆☆

The Bartender and the manager are so busy drinking up and toasting to each other that they forget about thier customers. Happy Hour starts form 5-8 but they are so not into the customer that they forget about the time. It was one of my worst experance in a long time.the only persons that were trying to take care of the customer were two young ladies on the floor but the blond chick and the longhair bartender are total looser. They should be fired!!!!! go at your own risk

Pros: NONE NOW

Cons: GO AT YOUR OWN RISK

.

Went around lunchtime with a group. Food was slow. It took half an hour to get cheese fries. Took 45 minutes to get regular fries. Would have left but already paid for food. Food was so-so. Would not recomend.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Went around lunchtime with a group. Food was slow. It took half an hour to get cheese fries. Took 45 minutes to get regular fries. Would have left but already paid for food. Food was so-so. Would not recomend.

Pros: The bartender was cute.

Cons: The food took so long to bring out I could have grown the potatoes myself, peeled them, and cooked it in about the same amount of time.

.

Nothing really remarkable about this place. The food is okay bar food. The most recent time I was there, on a weekday afternoon, I had a cheeseburger which appeared to have been lazily thrown together, and french fries which were soggy and room temperature. Blecch. The bar staff are mostly friendly. The drinks are fairly cheap. The jukebox is pretty terrible. Blecch.

2
★★☆☆☆

Nothing really remarkable about this place. The food is okay bar food. The most recent time I was there, on a weekday afternoon, I had a cheeseburger which appeared to have been lazily thrown together, and french fries which were soggy and room temperature. Blecch. The bar staff are mostly friendly. The drinks are fairly cheap. The jukebox is pretty terrible. Blecch.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The wings at Eddies are the best in the EV. I went in there this past sunday and even though I hadn't been in there for a year the bartender recognized me and made me feel right at home. the happy hour 2 for 1 drinks thing stays in effect all day on sunday. Perfect for watching games.

2
★★★★★

The wings at Eddies are the best in the EV. I went in there this past sunday and even though I hadn't been in there for a year the bartender recognized me and made me feel right at home. the happy hour 2 for 1 drinks thing stays in effect all day on sunday. Perfect for watching games.

Pros: Great wings

.

It?s a relaxed place to deflate from the daily grind equipped with a pool table, game machines and a Duck Hunt Arcade that needs all the props it can get. It doesn?t hurt that it has the best spicy wings EVER!! I've had wings from a few award winners; so far no one has beaten Nice Guys. The only thing is...you need to go on the right night to chill with the right crowd for you. It definitely deserves a peak.

2
★★★★★

It?s a relaxed place to deflate from the daily grind equipped with a pool table, game machines and a Duck Hunt Arcade that needs all the props it can get. It doesn?t hurt that it has the best spicy wings EVER!! I've had wings from a few award winners; so far no one has beaten Nice Guys. The only thing is...you need to go on the right night to chill with the right crowd for you. It definitely deserves a peak.

Pros: Food, Games, Service

Cons: Parking

.

I went here a couple weeks ago on a Thursday night and seriously had the time of my life (which is a lot to say about going to a random bar). I am not from the city but was in town visting, happened to walk by the place and stopped in with a friend of mine to have a drink or two. There were two extremely good looking bartenders with some of the best personalities, they didnt just get your drinks and walk away, they hung out, drank with us and we all had a blast!! We wound up stayin almost until closing and will definately go back on another Thursday when I come back to the city. Trish and Casey, you guys are the best!!

1
★★★☆☆

I went here a couple weeks ago on a Thursday night and seriously had the time of my life (which is a lot to say about going to a random bar). I am not from the city but was in town visting, happened to walk by the place and stopped in with a friend of mine to have a drink or two. There were two extremely good looking bartenders with some of the best personalities, they didnt just get your drinks and walk away, they hung out, drank with us and we all had a blast!! We wound up stayin almost until closing and will definately go back on another Thursday when I come back to the city. Trish and Casey, you guys are the best!!

Pros: Hot bartenders

.

If you need to just hang out, grad a pint, and get some good bar grub, this place is perfect. They have specials to coincide with sporting events like $10 pitchers, so it's very cheap too!

2
★★★★☆

If you need to just hang out, grad a pint, and get some good bar grub, this place is perfect. They have specials to coincide with sporting events like $10 pitchers, so it's very cheap too!

Pros: Bar food is good

Cons: Beer selection

.

Nice Guy Eddie's has a bar in the front and a small room with a stage in the back. Depending on who's playing, it can be a very magical place.

I'm not a big drinker, so I don't have much use for the bar part of the club. The drinks there are cheaper than in most other Manhattan places I've been to, but it's hard for me to tell what the quality of the drinks is. I know their Long Island Iced Tea is very good and does the job of getting you smashed, but they don't have a blender, so they can't make some of the more complicated blended drinks.

That aside, the stage area is great. It's small and cozy, but doesn't have the coffin feel that so many places of that size have. The stage is set low, which makes for a great chance for connection between the performers and the audience. The sound system is surprisingly good for a place that size, with no reverb and a great mix.

PROS: Great stage area, cheap drinks
CONS: No blended drinks, a little out of the way

4
★★★★☆

Nice Guy Eddie's has a bar in the front and a small room with a stage in the back. Depending on who's playing, it can be a very magical place.

I'm not a big drinker, so I don't have much use for the bar part of the club. The drinks there are cheaper than in most other Manhattan places I've been to, but it's hard for me to tell what the quality of the drinks is. I know their Long Island Iced Tea is very good and does the job of getting you smashed, but they don't have a blender, so they can't make some of the more complicated blended drinks.

That aside, the stage area is great. It's small and cozy, but doesn't have the coffin feel that so many places of that size have. The stage is set low, which makes for a great chance for connection between the performers and the audience. The sound system is surprisingly good for a place that size, with no reverb and a great mix.

PROS: Great stage area, cheap drinks
CONS: No blended drinks, a little out of the way

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I thought I was getting a great sports bar with a great atmosphere. Instead, I ended up with a local townie bar and not so great tv's to watch with. The beer isn't as cheap as expected and the atmoshpere isn't as great as expected. The bartenders is are nice though.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I thought I was getting a great sports bar with a great atmosphere. Instead, I ended up with a local townie bar and not so great tv's to watch with. The beer isn't as cheap as expected and the atmoshpere isn't as great as expected. The bartenders is are nice though.

.

I adore the bartenders on Friday nights! Two really pretty girls who are totally unpretentious...a rare find in this neighborhood nowadays. My boyfriend and I have spent many a Friday here, and plan many more.
One word of caution: there's one girl that works there who is really friendly, but not such a great bartender. It was a Saturday night, I think, and the other bartender was doing all of this girl's work, and we were sitting right in front of her, but she was paying attention to some good-looking guy with a lip-ring all night. At one point, the waitress actually came over to us and asked us if she could help us! She'salso there on Tuesdays, during the day - do yourself a favor and stay out if that lipring guy is there - you just won't be able to get her attention.

1
★★★☆☆

I adore the bartenders on Friday nights! Two really pretty girls who are totally unpretentious...a rare find in this neighborhood nowadays. My boyfriend and I have spent many a Friday here, and plan many more.
One word of caution: there's one girl that works there who is really friendly, but not such a great bartender. It was a Saturday night, I think, and the other bartender was doing all of this girl's work, and we were sitting right in front of her, but she was paying attention to some good-looking guy with a lip-ring all night. At one point, the waitress actually came over to us and asked us if she could help us! She'salso there on Tuesdays, during the day - do yourself a favor and stay out if that lipring guy is there - you just won't be able to get her attention.

Pros: great happy hour, awesome wings, Fri bartenders!

.

not only is nice guy eddies a great place to watch a game.The 2 for 1 happy hour and wings can not be beat. The jukebox has also been updated and is NOT only 70's

2
★★★★★

not only is nice guy eddies a great place to watch a game.The 2 for 1 happy hour and wings can not be beat. The jukebox has also been updated and is NOT only 70's

.

my friends and i have been frequenting nice guys for years. it's a great place to start off the night and is conveniently located at the foot of ave. a. go early for the happy hour and try some of the best wings in the city while listening to the super sounds of the 70's.

2
★★★★☆

my friends and i have been frequenting nice guys for years. it's a great place to start off the night and is conveniently located at the foot of ave. a. go early for the happy hour and try some of the best wings in the city while listening to the super sounds of the 70's.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Nice Guy Eddie's, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review