Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant

★★★★★
City Island restaurant with expansive seafood menu, feast platters, children's menu and separate bar--open late.
  • 41 City Island Ave

    Bronx, NY 10464

    Cross street: Rochelle Street

    Map & Directions
  • 718-885-0920

About Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant

Hours
Sun-Thu 11:30am-2am Fri-Sat 11:30am-4am

Food

Food
More choices in Bronx:
Resultset_next

Ice House Cafe & Restaurant

140 Reynolds Ave Bronx, NY

Resultset_next

Umbertos Clam House

2356 Arthur Ave Bronx, NY

4.6686 169
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

On the recommnadation of my daughter'S boyfriend we dined at Sammy's fishbox on City Island last thurdays even.ing .It was the best meal I have had in many a day..The place was very busy and rightfully so..We waited 30 minutes and it was well worth the wait,..you must go AND TRY THIS PLACE..SAMMY WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN ALL MY LIFE.\n

2
★★★★★

On the recommnadation of my daughter'S boyfriend we dined at Sammy's fishbox on City Island last thurdays even.ing .It was the best meal I have had in many a day..The place was very busy and rightfully so..We waited 30 minutes and it was well worth the wait,..you must go AND TRY THIS PLACE..SAMMY WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN ALL MY LIFE.\n

Pros: Best food I eatin in , loved the atmophere, , Love the Cosmo I had

.

What can I say..this is what every restaurant should be like. But few compare to Sammy's. I eat there every week without fail. They know seafood.

2
★★★★★

What can I say..this is what every restaurant should be like. But few compare to Sammy's. I eat there every week without fail. They know seafood.

Pros: 5 Star food, greaT staff, never rushed

Cons: extremely busy

.

I just love This Place..I am a new customer and I shall return ASAP

2
★★★★★

I just love This Place..I am a new customer and I shall return ASAP

Pros: Beautiful design, Fire Place, Booths

Cons: can't think of any

.

sammys is the best at seafood its so kid friendly also i always order the king crab legs and jumbo shrimp combo..worth evey penny. They also give you a big chunk of cornbread,bread,cheese,and gardenia on the house.

2
★★★★☆

sammys is the best at seafood its so kid friendly also i always order the king crab legs and jumbo shrimp combo..worth evey penny. They also give you a big chunk of cornbread,bread,cheese,and gardenia on the house.

Pros: food , service

Cons: it can get loud

.

I am a long time customer. I love going to Sammy's. I love his wife she is a wonderful hostess and makes us always feel at home. I enjoy selectng from the extensive Surf & Turf dishes at Sammy's. My favoraite is Steak & Maine Lobster..We just love Sammy's

2
★★★★★

I am a long time customer. I love going to Sammy's. I love his wife she is a wonderful hostess and makes us always feel at home. I enjoy selectng from the extensive Surf & Turf dishes at Sammy's. My favoraite is Steak & Maine Lobster..We just love Sammy's

Pros: Food, atmosphere, great Pina Coladas

.

I love the food and the staff is extremely friendl..When I think of seafood I think Sammy's ...Wonderful sweet jumbo Maine Lobsters

2
★★★★★

I love the food and the staff is extremely friendl..When I think of seafood I think Sammy's ...Wonderful sweet jumbo Maine Lobsters

Pros: Free parking, Great Seafood, Great steaks

.

I just moved to the Bronx from Boston, so I am used to great seafood. I never expected the Bronx to have a seafood restauarnt better than the great ones in Boston,\nbut they do, Sammy's Fishbox on City Island has the best seafood I have ever eaten. I recently took my parent visting from boston to Sammy's they were blown away by the food.

2
★★★★★

I just moved to the Bronx from Boston, so I am used to great seafood. I never expected the Bronx to have a seafood restauarnt better than the great ones in Boston,\nbut they do, Sammy's Fishbox on City Island has the best seafood I have ever eaten. I recently took my parent visting from boston to Sammy's they were blown away by the food.

Pros: Super fresh Seafood, Great apple Martinis, Loved the fireplace

Cons: lighting to bright

.

I went to Sammy's last week and I couldn't believe it they actually had giant lobsters\n6,8,10, 12 pounders. I ordered a 10lb lobster, which was something I have always wanted to do, The loster was only 10 dollars a pound. It was succulent and worth ever penny. My wife and I shared it, it was more than enough for both of us.. We also had a great drink called the Killer Bee..It was great and lef our heads buzzing. Grewart restauarnt it is a real happening..

2
★★★★★

I went to Sammy's last week and I couldn't believe it they actually had giant lobsters\n6,8,10, 12 pounders. I ordered a 10lb lobster, which was something I have always wanted to do, The loster was only 10 dollars a pound. It was succulent and worth ever penny. My wife and I shared it, it was more than enough for both of us.. We also had a great drink called the Killer Bee..It was great and lef our heads buzzing. Grewart restauarnt it is a real happening..

Pros: Giant lobster, wonderful service, great drinks

Cons: always busy

.

I love Sammy's I have been a customer for 15 years and have eaten there over 100 times, I have never had a bad meal in all of those visits. I would rather eat at Sammy's than any other restauarnt bar none. The food is not only great, but the portions are very large.

2
★★★★★

I love Sammy's I have been a customer for 15 years and have eaten there over 100 times, I have never had a bad meal in all of those visits. I would rather eat at Sammy's than any other restauarnt bar none. The food is not only great, but the portions are very large.

Pros: Great for big groups, Special for Holidays

Cons: Long wait on weekends

.

My best friend asked me to join her at Sammy's last saturady night. I really ddidn't want to go up toCity Island, but I am glad I did. I had the best apple martini I ever had and the food was a 10plus. Tnak you sammy's for the best evening I had in a very long time. ""Great people, great food and drinks.

2
★★★★★

My best friend asked me to join her at Sammy's last saturady night. I really ddidn't want to go up toCity Island, but I am glad I did. I had the best apple martini I ever had and the food was a 10plus. Tnak you sammy's for the best evening I had in a very long time. ""Great people, great food and drinks.

Pros: Food was outstanding, Love fireplace, Great bar

.

Hi: I am a pilot and travel all over the world. I have eaten in hundreds of Restaurants throughout the world. I have never found a seafood that compares to Sammy's. The first thing I do when I come home from a trip is go to Sammy's for a great meal. My favorite is his extra big Alaskan King Crab legs.. My wife loves the baby back ribs and Jumbo Shrimp combo..

2
★★★★★

Hi: I am a pilot and travel all over the world. I have eaten in hundreds of Restaurants throughout the world. I have never found a seafood that compares to Sammy's. The first thing I do when I come home from a trip is go to Sammy's for a great meal. My favorite is his extra big Alaskan King Crab legs.. My wife loves the baby back ribs and Jumbo Shrimp combo..

Pros: Warm & Cozy, Love Fireplace, Great staff

.

I use to live in the Bronx and would go to Sammy's almost every week. Now I live in Florida and miss it so much, When I visit my family in NY I always insist they take me to\nSammy's the best restauarnt in NY..

2
★★★★★

I use to live in the Bronx and would go to Sammy's almost every week. Now I live in Florida and miss it so much, When I visit my family in NY I always insist they take me to\nSammy's the best restauarnt in NY..

Pros: Free Parking, Great Bar, Jumbo Lobster are the

.

This is the best seafood experience I've ever had! Generous portions and quality food is what will bring me back to Sammy's again! You must try the bbq'd beef ribs as an appetizer, they are fork-tender, fallin off the bone good! Fresh Alaskan crab and lobster completed a terrific meal...\n\n

2
★★★★★

This is the best seafood experience I've ever had! Generous portions and quality food is what will bring me back to Sammy's again! You must try the bbq'd beef ribs as an appetizer, they are fork-tender, fallin off the bone good! Fresh Alaskan crab and lobster completed a terrific meal...\n\n

Pros: Fresh Seafood, Service, Valet Parking

.

my boyfriend and i decided to go out for dinner late on a sat night. we wanted sea food, but FRESH seafood. no red lobster over here... not that night anyway.. lol. i've always wanted 2 go 2 city island, so off we went. i picked a restaurant out just from driving around and i couldn't of picked a better one. sammy's fish box had great food, great service, great drinks and was over all pleasure to eat @. the food was fresh and plentiful. i am with out a doubt going back. on a scale of 1-10, i would give it a 9...

2
★★★★★

my boyfriend and i decided to go out for dinner late on a sat night. we wanted sea food, but FRESH seafood. no red lobster over here... not that night anyway.. lol. i've always wanted 2 go 2 city island, so off we went. i picked a restaurant out just from driving around and i couldn't of picked a better one. sammy's fish box had great food, great service, great drinks and was over all pleasure to eat @. the food was fresh and plentiful. i am with out a doubt going back. on a scale of 1-10, i would give it a 9...

.

I have lived on City Island where Sammy's is located but until recentlly, never tried it.\nI was astonished by the food. It was so good. I started with the best New England chowder I ever had and finished with a Giant piece of Key Lime pie also great. If you can believe it the in between was ever better.. Great fried Shrimp and the Steak surf & Turf I had were mouth watering.I highly recommend this restaurant for me it was the best seafood dinner I can ever remember eating..

2
★★★★★

I have lived on City Island where Sammy's is located but until recentlly, never tried it.\nI was astonished by the food. It was so good. I started with the best New England chowder I ever had and finished with a Giant piece of Key Lime pie also great. If you can believe it the in between was ever better.. Great fried Shrimp and the Steak surf & Turf I had were mouth watering.I highly recommend this restaurant for me it was the best seafood dinner I can ever remember eating..

Pros: But worth the wait

Cons: Long wait for table

.

I visited Sammy's for the first time last Saturady night on a recommendation of my girlfriend. I was astonished how beautiful and romantic the restuarant was. We started with fantastic apple martini's and then proceeded to split a 4 lbs stuffed lobster that was the best I ever had. The meal came with so many extra at no cost its was amazing.\nI can't wait to go back next week and try some of the other items.

2
★★★★★

I visited Sammy's for the first time last Saturady night on a recommendation of my girlfriend. I was astonished how beautiful and romantic the restuarant was. We started with fantastic apple martini's and then proceeded to split a 4 lbs stuffed lobster that was the best I ever had. The meal came with so many extra at no cost its was amazing.\nI can't wait to go back next week and try some of the other items.

Pros: Beautiful decor, great food, real fireplace

.

I am originally from San Francisco where great seafood is king. But I have to admitt that Sammy's fishbox on City Island was absolutely the best King Crab I have ever eaten. My party of 8 had a seafood feast sampling Sammy's menu and we couldn't believe how great the food was.. After leaving the restauarnt I called my mother in San Francisco who runs our family restauarnt and told her I just had the world best Seafood..I salute Sammy's fishbox .

2
★★★★★

I am originally from San Francisco where great seafood is king. But I have to admitt that Sammy's fishbox on City Island was absolutely the best King Crab I have ever eaten. My party of 8 had a seafood feast sampling Sammy's menu and we couldn't believe how great the food was.. After leaving the restauarnt I called my mother in San Francisco who runs our family restauarnt and told her I just had the world best Seafood..I salute Sammy's fishbox .

Pros: Beautiful decor, large parking lot, friendly staff

.

great food good amount and nice ambiance\n\nI enjoy going here i think the food is wonderful and they accomidate your needs. the serving portions are your moneys worth so take the family out and in joy \nI also has valet parking free of charge!!!!!

2
★★★★★

great food good amount and nice ambiance\n\nI enjoy going here i think the food is wonderful and they accomidate your needs. the serving portions are your moneys worth so take the family out and in joy \nI also has valet parking free of charge!!!!!

Pros: amount of food

.

I've been to Sammy's a few times and the food is always marvelous. I highly recommend Sammy's to anyone who wants great seafood especially lobster and can't get to Maine.

2
★★★★★

I've been to Sammy's a few times and the food is always marvelous. I highly recommend Sammy's to anyone who wants great seafood especially lobster and can't get to Maine.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Sammy's Fishbox Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review