Matt's Pizza

★★★★☆

About Matt's Pizza

Hours
Mon - Thu, 11am - 9pm; Fri, Sat, 11am - 10pm; Sun, 11am - 8pm

Food

Food
More choices in ST JAMES:
Resultset_next

Nicky J's Pizzeria

230 Lake Ave # 2 ST JAMES, NY

Resultset_next

Mozzarella's Pizza

1957 Jericho Tpke East Northport, NY

3.875 8
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Matt's Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

Been a loyal customer for years but it is time to venture out and try others.

My last 2 experiences were not good. Last week I ordered a pie, showed up ontime and my pie wasn't ready. I saw the guy behind the counter take a cold precooked pie off the shelf and put it in the oven for 2min and then box it for me. I was essentially given a reheated pizza.

Today I received a poorly cut sauce pie with little cheese.

2
★★☆☆☆

Been a loyal customer for years but it is time to venture out and try others.

My last 2 experiences were not good. Last week I ordered a pie, showed up ontime and my pie wasn't ready. I saw the guy behind the counter take a cold precooked pie off the shelf and put it in the oven for 2min and then box it for me. I was essentially given a reheated pizza.

Today I received a poorly cut sauce pie with little cheese.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

GREAT CRUST! Absolutely mouth watering pizza. Prices are moderate but the taste can't be beat!

We always order pizzas on Friday or Saturday nights and it's never more then a 20 minute wait.

5
★★★★★

GREAT CRUST! Absolutely mouth watering pizza. Prices are moderate but the taste can't be beat!

We always order pizzas on Friday or Saturday nights and it's never more then a 20 minute wait.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Truthfully; I have to say Matt's has the pizza in Saint James on lock-down. They have competitive prices and great, crunchy pizza. And as for the owner, I used to see him all the time at my job and he is just a quiet, semi-grouchy imitation of the Honey I Shrunk the Kids guy, Ha. He isn't so bad and for sure not bad enough to avoid the pizza party!

4
★★★★☆

Truthfully; I have to say Matt's has the pizza in Saint James on lock-down. They have competitive prices and great, crunchy pizza. And as for the owner, I used to see him all the time at my job and he is just a quiet, semi-grouchy imitation of the Honey I Shrunk the Kids guy, Ha. He isn't so bad and for sure not bad enough to avoid the pizza party!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Consistently good pizza with friendly employees. The pizza is a little more expensive than other places, but the fresh taste is worth it. Parking stinks, the decor needs to be totally redone, and the bathrooms are a mess, so I would not recommend eating there. Park in the back. I do recommend calling and placing an order ahead of time, especially during Lent, Weekends, or holidays. They do tend to get very busy and you could find yourself waiting a bit.

2
★★★★☆

Consistently good pizza with friendly employees. The pizza is a little more expensive than other places, but the fresh taste is worth it. Parking stinks, the decor needs to be totally redone, and the bathrooms are a mess, so I would not recommend eating there. Park in the back. I do recommend calling and placing an order ahead of time, especially during Lent, Weekends, or holidays. They do tend to get very busy and you could find yourself waiting a bit.

Pros: Great food, friendly employees, fresh ingredients

Cons: Bathrooms and dining area need to be torn out and built up from scratch

.

There are many other pizza places around in the area and Matt's really is one of the best. They have a great crispy crust and there pizza is not too greasy. They know how to make a good pizza.

5
★★★★★

There are many other pizza places around in the area and Matt's really is one of the best. They have a great crispy crust and there pizza is not too greasy. They know how to make a good pizza.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Off the list. Too many good pizza places around town to put up with an owner who doesn't know the meaning of 'Hello" and "Thank You" He's a social misfit. After many many times eating at Matt's, my hard earning money is now going elsewhere.

3
★★★☆☆

Off the list. Too many good pizza places around town to put up with an owner who doesn't know the meaning of 'Hello" and "Thank You" He's a social misfit. After many many times eating at Matt's, my hard earning money is now going elsewhere.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

In a place where there is a pizza restaurant on every corner and in every strip mall, this place falls right in the middle when it comes to quality and taste. Matt's Pizza, though, is kind of a chain because this is not their only location. Their peperoni is pretty spicy, so if you're not into feeling as if your mouth is on fire, I'd go with the cheese. The square slices are also pretty good.

4
★★★★☆

In a place where there is a pizza restaurant on every corner and in every strip mall, this place falls right in the middle when it comes to quality and taste. Matt's Pizza, though, is kind of a chain because this is not their only location. Their peperoni is pretty spicy, so if you're not into feeling as if your mouth is on fire, I'd go with the cheese. The square slices are also pretty good.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Matt's Pizza makes a really good pizza, but their crust is even better. It's breaded and tastes delicious! Their pastas and salads are excellent too! The store isn't that big, so it is hard to sit down and eat there but you should take-out.

PROS: Great Pizza, Crust, Salads, And Pasta!
CONS: Small store, hard parking

4
★★★★☆

Matt's Pizza makes a really good pizza, but their crust is even better. It's breaded and tastes delicious! Their pastas and salads are excellent too! The store isn't that big, so it is hard to sit down and eat there but you should take-out.

PROS: Great Pizza, Crust, Salads, And Pasta!
CONS: Small store, hard parking

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Matt's Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review