Insider Pages Reviews for Rocking Horse Cafe

5 Stars: we loved the TIME OUT with the Cafe Corner (by LuxuryNYC)

LuxuryNYC — Tue, 08 Dec 2009 09:00:00 GMT

we loved the TIME OUT with the Cafe Corner

5 Stars: Always a great choice (by tryeverythingonce)

tryeverythingonce — Mon, 02 Mar 2009 09:00:00 GMT

This is my favorite restaurant in the neighborhood. It's cute, the food is a little more gourmet than your typical Mexican, and the duck crepes are one of the best dishes anywhere in the city. Great for takeout too. I highly recommend it!

1 Stars: Worst delivery wait (by Kalbertio)

Kalbertio — Thu, 05 Feb 2009 09:00:00 GMT

Do not ever make a delivery order here. I've been waiting for an hour and a half and my food is still not here. I live in Chelsea

5 Stars: Wow...Wow...Wow Great food and drinks (by CookThis)

CookThis — Sat, 24 Jan 2009 09:00:00 GMT

This place is soooooo good. Drinks are wonderful, I got the frozen mango margarita and loved it. The food is mexican elegance, the combinations are excellent. It is very small so if you dont like sitting very close to your nearby diners, dont go.

4 Stars: Really Terrific Food (by Wendy S.)

Wendy S. — Tue, 02 Dec 2008 13:53:00 GMT

I'm from California, and I'm pretty picky about Mexican food. I've always liked the Rocking Horse Cafe. The salsa and chips are excellent, the guac and handmade tortillas are amazing, and the menu is varied and very fresh. It's not cheap... entrees are in the $20 range, but it's a great place for a fun night out with friends, think birthday, promotion, graduation, etc. Service was good.

4 Stars: perfect for special occasions (by morgann11)

morgann11 — Tue, 25 Nov 2008 09:00:00 GMT

YUM YUM YUM. Had a delicious meal here for my best friend's graduation. I thoroughly enjoyed the experience from start to end. The menu was very thoughtful and the food very very good. The service was also very attentive, but not the in "Hows everything going over here?" every two minuets kind of way. The wait staff was knowledgeable and able to tell us a lot about the menu. I would recommend this place for a special occasion because it is pricey.

5 Stars: awesome (by wadinglove)

wadinglove — Tue, 26 Aug 2008 09:00:00 GMT

great food and service. awesome pineapple mojitos and chicken crepes... even better margaritas and guacamole... fast service... great for lunch or dinner...
we had an overall amazing experience

5 Stars: friendly service:great food (by galaxy123)

galaxy123 — Wed, 13 Aug 2008 09:00:00 GMT

Had the pleasure of dining here with my boyfriend on Mon 8/11 and i must say that i found the staff to be friendly and professional. I had the chicken burritos with bbq sauce and avocado, and my boyfriend had the tuna steak over baby greens and the chicken soup. All food was fresh and top quality. The pureed plantains and flan were awesome! Only complaint is that we were seated in the back (at our request), and i noticed that the walls and framed pictures were very dusty. I would strongly recommend this place for any meal,large or small groups. Cant wait to return!!

1 Stars: Salt, salt, and MORE salt! (by everthere)

everthere — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 09:00:00 GMT

Although the guacamole here is really wonderful, every dish I've ever had at this place is incredibly salty. The attitude of the management is salty too, and leaves A LOT to be desired; some could use serious training in people skills. They seem more concerned with getting diners in and out like cattle, with no respect or professionalism. Very upsetting and disappointing place, as the menu is great in theory, but the dishes are just so over-salted. Between that and the rude management, I'm never going back. And as Anthony Bourdain has said, if you're over-salting your food, you're trying to hide something!!

2 Stars: Disappointing. Do not recommend. (by SashaB)

SashaB — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 09:00:00 GMT

Not crazy about this place. While the menu promises wonderful things, their dishes are VERY salty, bordering on unhealthy. All though the bar, provides tasty and strong drinks. Aside from food, the management is rude to the patrons and unprofessional. Certain people should not be in the service industry. Disappointing.

5 Stars: Fresh Mexican Authenic (by Ian K.)

Ian K. — Fri, 16 May 2008 10:30:00 GMT

When you see the woman during the day in the front window handmaking the corn tortillas you know this place is fresh. The best fresh salsa and homemade guacomole and huge tortilla chips. The margaritas here are amazing and the tequilla options are endless. Authentic margaritas with fresh lime no sweet and sour and fresh fruit purees. The food itself was amazing. Mixiote was slow cooked pork with plantain puree - incredible. Pairs well with their wine list as well. I will definitely go back and I highly recommend this restaurant!!! Lunch or dinner.

5 Stars: Best Steak Burrito (by swisscheese)

swisscheese — Sat, 05 Jan 2008 09:00:00 GMT

I am officially obsessed with their steak burrito. I can't recommend anything else on the menu because I refuse to order anything else from them. The restaurant itself is very clean and is larger than it appears from the outside. The staff is very pleasant and I can't give one complaint about them.

5 Stars: One of my favorite mexican places (by evillagefoodie)

evillagefoodie — Sun, 18 Nov 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Really innovative mexican cuisine with a great drink and cocktail menu as well. The beef with mojo sauce is my favorite dish in the world.

3 Stars: OK food but be careful with your reservation... (by cherrybomb23)

cherrybomb23 — Thu, 19 Jul 2007 09:00:00 GMT

This is certainly a cute place and the food was fine - not great (esp. for the prices) - but be careful when you make your reservations! I find it's hard to enjoy any meal when a place can't even get your reservation right, but this situation was especially disappointing. They even went so far as to tell a story that someone by my own name called and changed the reservation. Strange, don't you think? Re: the food - the starter salsa was unexciting and quite bland and the chips were stale. The lobster empanadas were dry and required a lot of soaking in the oily sauce that accomanied them. The guacamole was surprisingly good and there was a lot of it, which was a nice surprise, but I wasn't sure what to do with the soft tortillas and the meek side dishes...make a wrap of some sort? The rest of our entrees -- the salmon: the grilled chayote was a nice addition; the tuna: overdone but the sides had great flavor; braised pork: completely bland with no flavor at all - very disappointing; and the steak: just so-so - nothing to write home about. All in all, way overpriced for what the food was and disappointing off the bat with the reservation mistake. I won't be heading back anytime soon.

4 Stars: Lovely Latin Lounge (by plaztikstar)

plaztikstar — Thu, 17 May 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The Rocking Horse Cafe is a great spot for great food or even just great drinks! Great atmosphere for large groups which makes it difficult to dine without reservations on weekends, and outdoor seating is a cut-throat preference that many will wait for but few are privileged with. Regardless of where you sit, there is friendly service and catchy music, but the only fault I found at the Rocking Horse is the limited vegetarian option. Only two salmon dishes are available, but notheless delicious and recommended! It also wouldn't hurt to mention the handsome waiters and bartenders, as well, would it?

5 Stars: rocking horse rocks (by missfantase)

missfantase — Sat, 12 May 2007 09:00:00 GMT

What a better way to spend an evening out in Manhattan, then with good friends at a great restaurant. The Rocking Horse Cafe has come to be probably my favorite restaurant to take people in New York. There is a great energy in the room, super fun and attentive waitstaff, great cocktails, and if you're looking for a restaurant where no matter what you order you wont be dissapointed, this is it. Some of my favorites include the Quesadilla de Hongos, the Enchiladas de Pollo and the Atun. They've got tons a different margarita flavors, and also an eclectic wine list. Oh yeah, and I suggest taking a look at the dessert menu also. The Tortita de Chocolate is fabulous!

5 Stars: Great time, every time.... (by empressgefil)

empressgefil — Wed, 09 May 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Two weekends ago, my friend took me to brunch at Rocking Horse. We sat at the front outdoor patio, and had a great time watching Chelsea cruise by. I had a delicious steak and scrambled eggs wrap with a side of guacamole. The experience was so much fun; I decided to go back two nights later, to see if the restaurant was as god as I thought. I took someone else to dinner, and we also had a great time, although, very different. We sat in the back for a quieter meal, so we could talk. Both seaters, each were friendly and attentive, making sure we were seated according to the meals needs. Dinner was great with a starter salad that was frizzled greens with Calamari and Chorizo in a citrus dressing - delicious! I am a real NY 'Gringo' when it comes to Mexican spices, but the flavors in this meal were not overwhelming, nor too spicy. I had a grilled chicken and vegetable entree, which was wholly satisfying; however my friend had another chicken dish that was set in a bowl over mashed potatoes, which was treated entirely differently, and also very tasty. But the most interesting was the postre, desert flan. It had a coconut caramel sauce, with a hint of lime. It was truly unique, not too filling and worth the going back for. Our brunch waiter was a bit more conversational than the dinner one, but they both gave great service. The busboy/food runners were excellent both times attending to water and such. I enjoyed the decor, which was modern and clean, and I didn't feel like I was paying for the decorator instead of my food, which sometimes turns me off in other establishments. In all a great experience and I'm sure I will be going back again quite soon. Hope to see you there!

5 Stars: I have a crush on the Bartendar!! (by gourdsquasher)

gourdsquasher — Wed, 09 May 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Dinner at The Rocking Horse Cafe was a perfect end to a day in the city. I began my Rocking Horse experience with sweet corn tamales topped with shrimp, chipotle butter and avocado. Not only did this appetizer come out well presented, wrapped in cornhusks, it was also delicious. My entree, Camarones con Papaya, with shrimp, caramelized onions, and roasted vegetables and papaya served in a miniature skillet, with organic spelt tortillas rolled on the side, was amazing. Does anyone know the name of the Rocking Horse Chef? Because when I win the lottery, I plan on hiring him as my personal chef.
Desert was a pleasant as well as imaginative experience. The cinnamon ice cream topping my spiced valrhona chocolate cake was so good I wouldn?t mind bathing in it.
The Rocking Horse mixed drinks are great too! I recommend a passion fruit margarita on the rocks, easy on the limejuice.
Aside from the food and drinks, the waiters and bartenders are HOT HOT HOT and the waitresses are beautiful. In fact, I?m still fantasizing about one of the bartenders. So, if you?re down for great food and enjoy being surrounded by gorgeous people, this is the place for you.
If the weather is nice shoot for outdoor seating. It?s definitely worth the wait!

5 Stars: With a Hot Latin Vibe... (by alicew96)

alicew96 — Mon, 30 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Colorful, inventive food, and festive drinks to match. My pomegranate Margarita was THE best and just the right balance to the homemade chips and Rocking Horse?s unique salsa. The service couldn?t have been better--warm, professional and friendly. The manager, bartender and wait staff made certain we had a great experience.

My choice from an elegantly designed menu, a light, fresh and zesty swordfish, garlic mashed potatoes and the best guacamole, sitting atop the dish like a dollop of whipped cream--divine.

Lively bar scene in a contemporary and very classy setting. The place moves to a Latin rhythm and is definitely an homage to our south of the border neighbors.

5 Stars: Not el restaurante Mexicano de su padre (by geomorin)

geomorin — Fri, 27 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Really an exceptional place that's almost hiding under the scaffolding outside. But the multi-colored logo outside sets you up for the bright and happy atmosphere inside. The best part? The food: Scottish salmon, crunchy caramelized onions, smoked trout, exquisite guacamole, organic beef ? it's all good.

5 Stars: RHC Really Rocks (by bohonk)

bohonk — Thu, 19 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

OMG - went the other night and had their scallop special. Amazing! Fresh crispy sea scallops over the best lemon risotto I ever had. Asparagus and mushrooms accompanied it. I told my waiter that this should be on the menu every night - as I'd order it again and again. Great fresh tasting chips and salsa. Killer margaritas. A definite keeper.

5 Stars: great vibe (by mk5000)

mk5000 — Wed, 18 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Margaritas are excellent - and not a rip off like most places! Fun place to go to in Chelsea with great food. Best app was the Quesadilla De Hongos. The Bistec En Recado was great but you must love garlic. I woudl defintiely go again with friends....the front section is a little loud but very festive - thankfully they have a back area with tables that is conducive to conversation.

5 Stars: Chelsea's Rocking Horse Cafe Rocks! (by 1giddyup)

1giddyup — Sun, 15 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Rocking Horse is a Cafe with a PERSONALITY! As in the tradition of crafting a classic rocking horse, each dish is a one-of-a-kind work of art--a recipe with a unique, individual personality. The rocking horse is an enduring symbol of childhood. And, thanks to the creativity and caring of restaurateurs Roe and Marvin and their chef, you can RIDE YOUR IMAGINATION at the Rocking Horse Cafe with refreshingly innovative, classy, high-end Mexican Cuisine. The food will delight your palette as rocking horses delighted you with creative play. Roe and Marvin greet you like old friends, and the welcoming staff brings additional warmth to the candlelit fiesta. The ambiance and scrumptious fare offer a joyful ride, and the flavorful margaritas add a bounce. So, Saddle Up! Chelsea's Rocking Horse Cafe Rocks!

5 Stars: Fun atmosphere, great upscale Mexican and adult size margaritas. (by ecsukas)

ecsukas — Sat, 07 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

It always looks like something special is going on because it's busier than all the other restaurants on 8th Ave, Chelsea. But not too busy to get a table or a spot at the bar. Adult size margaritas and excellent food that's healthy and never a dissappointment. Good size portions too!

3 Stars: great atmosphere, selection of unique cocktails, friendly and inviting (by jimoneill)

jimoneill — Thu, 05 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The Rocking Horse Cafe is an outstanding dining experience. The atmosphere has two distinct zones, the front being the more active and boisterous and the rear being more intimate. They have a very fine selection of tequilas and various domestic and imported beers at the bar. The unique cocktails are worth the trip in themselves. For the main entre the Carne Guisado is a surefire good choice, and the Tortita de Chocolate will have you spinning with its chocolate and cinnamon flavors. Finally the wait staff and service were impecable, friendly, and inviting.

5 Stars: Fun spot, good food and GREAT margaritas!! (by gam13)

gam13 — Wed, 04 Apr 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The Rocking Horse is a great after work place to go with friends. I been several times and have never been disappointed. The drinks are awesome, especially the margaritas, they're a must! Served in BIG glasses nice and cold. If you're sitting at the bar and just want appetizers, i highly recommend the quesadillas with manchego cheese and mushrooms, one of my favorites. The guacamole is always good too. If you decide to sit and have a full meal, the hangar steak is the way to go, cooked to perfection. And if you're craving something sweet for dessert, the tres leches con platano is heavenly. All the cocktails on their menu are delicious. And when the weather gets warmer, the frozen margaritas are the best in town. Overall just a great place, fun atmosphere, not expensive, friendly wait staff and again the margaritas!!! Definitely recommend it for some after work fun.

5 Stars: Highly Recommended (by sanmari)

sanmari — Sat, 31 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

On my third visit to the Rocking Horse I had a tasty and yummy dish, which I strongly recommend if you love seafood. I ordered ?Camarones con Papaya? (shrimp caramelized onions with papaya). The combination of the shrimp, onions and papaya gave this dish an original and delicious flavor. After sipping up my drink I was speechless! the best mojito ever. Our waiter was friendly and responsive. The service was outstanding and the atmosphere was enjoyable.

5 Stars: Favorite Mexican Restaurant (by mariahi)

mariahi — Sat, 31 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I'm a big fan of Mexican food, and after I came to the Rocking Horse this week I made it one my favorite Mexican restaurants. The server was very knowledgeable; after recommending me the salmon with chayote he chose a glass of wine for me that went really well with the dish. My friends also had a great time. I couldn?t stop staring at the exotic drinks they were having. The manager was very cordial and attentive (and handsome). The ambience, in general, made me feel young again.

5 Stars: great vibe- fun, young, buzzing, and so much more! (by foodnyfood)

foodnyfood — Sat, 31 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Rocking Horse had a great vibe- fun, young, buzzing
with energy. It wasnt uber cheezy like most mexican
restaurants, i dug the tastefully colorful decor.

our service was prompt and courteous, and our waitress
had a personality. im sick of those femmebot
waitresses who dont even know how to really talk to
someone outside of taking an order.

The drinks were neat, interesting mixtures of less
common upper shelf liquor and fresh juice. They were
strong, even with a full meal.

The appetizers were lovely. The guacomole was zesty!
There were these warm tortillas that came with
different toppings, i never thought id say this, but
the duck skin topping was soooooo good. Nice
presentaion.

The entrees were superb. My favorite was the tuna
dish. The tuna was cooked to perfection, just cooked
enough not to freak me out but not so cooked that it
didnt melt in my mouth (oh did it ever melt!). It came
over this amazing veggie compote, it was divine.

The desserts! The chocolate thing was
ridiculous! I was secretely fighting a very covert war
to get as much of it in my mouth as possible (i was
suposed to be sharing!)

I love this place. You get a lot for your buck,
amazing food, and a really good time!

5 Stars: Best Margaritas Ever! (by seresth)

seresth — Sat, 31 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Dining at the Rocking Horse was a wonderful experience. From the moment when the beautiful hostess welcomed us with a great smile to the second we walked out. The service was excellent; our waiter was educating us about the modern Mexican cuisine that characterizes this restaurant and was being very attentive with all the needs we had. The special scallops that the server recommended was very original and delicious (complement to the Chef!) and the Mezcal margarita that the bartender suggested was thrilling! I?m definitely coming back.

5 Stars: best mexican food (by valushak)

valushak — Fri, 30 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Exellent food and margaritas! Highly recomend to try mixiote(braised pork shoulder) or beef brisket. Lively and fun invironment. Very friendly and knowlegable staff. Me and my family had dinner at rocking horse on saturday evening and had exellent time and will definitely come back!

5 Stars: always great fun, excellent food (by pattyyuen)

pattyyuen — Wed, 28 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I have been to Rocking Horse several times, and it has been great everytime. I have sampled several of their dishes and each are fresh, flavorful, visually appealing, and well-prepared. The restaurant?s upbeat decor sets a great mood to unwind and chat with your fellow diners, and there is always a lively bar scene in the front. The drinks are original and tasty and made with the best ingredients. The manager is ever so attentive. I was drinking a martini, and ate all my olives, and she came over, unsolicited, with a refill toothpick, fully loaded with olives! Can?t top that!

5 Stars: best contemporary mexican (by yuliavt)

yuliavt — Wed, 28 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

We had a lovely dinner this past weekend. The service was excellent, the seafood we ordered was fresh, flavorful and well prepared. Strongly recommend their organic salmon, delicious!The atmosphere was great, lots of young people having a good time. Great place to bring your friends. Lively atmosphere! Look forward to coming back there again.

5 Stars: great overall experience (by joedarko)

joedarko — Tue, 27 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Rocking Horse is not like the typical tacky Mexican restaurant at all (i.e. no sombreros on the walls) yet the decor is festive and classy. The food was always a more gourmet Mexican, yet it has really improved over the years. The owners are clearly always looking to improve this place. There is always a hip crowd munching on the gourmet tortillas and killer guac. The bar offers all types of fancy fresh fruit Margaritas, and a killer selection of Tequila. I have found it easy to make this a regular dining spot and hang out.

5 Stars: Great take on the Mexican theme (by whmjr)

whmjr — Mon, 26 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The first thing that hits you when you enter the Rocking Horse is the great atmosphere. There is good music playing, the lights are not too bright or too dim, and your appetite quickly gets reved up by the savory aromas coming from the kitchen (which you can actually watch work in the cellar). The wait to be seated was not terribly long considering it was a Saturday night, and the unique cocktails imbibed at the bar made the time pass smoothly. The various top shelf tequila helped with the layover. There is a distinct difference between the front and back of the house, the back being much quieter and intimate. I am glad we sat there although I can see how being up front would have its advantages. Especially when it is summer and they open the front garage style door. The menu was simple in the best way possible in that each description gave a very good idea of what the dish would be like. The shrimp dish was superb, and I was able to taste the beef dish and another dish my partners ordered. Overall the food was excellent and presented in a easy and elegant way that reflected the atmosphere as a whole. Finally, the service was some of the best I have encountered. The staff was friendly and accommodating and hardly as stressed out on a busy Saturday night as I would have expected. Go there now.

5 Stars: Chelsea's Best Kept Secret (by masterbeck)

masterbeck — Mon, 26 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

It always amazes me when I speak to NYkers who haven't been to the Rocking Horse Cafe before. I've been coming here since the early 90's and enjoying the great decor, food and service. Two things amaze me about the Horse. First, quite frankly, that they have managed to stay open for so long.
How many New York restaurants can you name that have been in businees 20 years? Which brings me to my second point.
I can honestly say that the food keeps on getting better and better. Which now that I think of it would explain the longevity...but I digress.
A customer since the early 90's I feel compelled to give thanks and wholeheartedly recommend the Rocking Horse Cafe to all who are tired of the same old Mexican food so common here in NYC. They have an ever-changing and creative menu. It pays homage to Mexican classics but at the same time infuses the standbys with creative sauces, delicious spices and decorative plating.
The drinks have always been and remain spectacular. I'm a traditionalist so I tend to go with Margaritas and Daquiris and I must say the Horse has the best around....not to mention that the bartenders pour their libations with a generous and customercentric hand...if you get my drift.
The atmosphere is warm, inviting and lively and when I have visiting guests it is always at the top of my list of places to visit.
Ok, I'm done praising the Horse. If I speak any more effusively I may no longer be able to get a table.

3 Stars: awesome dining experience (by jenniferm3)

jenniferm3 — Sun, 25 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

My favorite artist is Frida Kahlo, so eating at this restaurant was more than just another dinner out in nyc. I had the Frida Pomita - at the bar (a tasty pomgranate margarita with Frida tequila), ate some yummy homemade tortillas while listening to funky music. The warm colors on the walls, glowing lights, and mexican feel matched the delicate richness of the food. I truly appreciated the natural/free range entres which were affordable as well. The manager, bartender and waitstaff took care of us from the minute we walked in to the moment we left - which is rare in a packed New York restaurant. The main dish was scrumptuous, fresh, and had wonderful texture (mixiote slow cooked pork with mashed plantains and collard greens). It was my birthday, so they brought out an incredible chocolate desert topped with cinnamon ice-cream - the perfect ending to an awesome dining experience.

5 Stars: Great atmosphere and quality mexican fare (by mark55)

mark55 — Sun, 25 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

We love Rocking Horse for a great lively atmosphere and high quality artistic Mexican fare. The chips and salsa are amazing and can't have enough of the pomegranite enchilada's. I'm writing this because of the supurb exceptional experience we recently had. They were out of strawberry margarita's, but when the manager, Alfonso, found out, he went and bought fresh strawberry's so our friend coul have his strawberry margarita!!! wow.

5 Stars: GREAT FOOD, GREAT SERVICE (by kiwi07093)

kiwi07093 — Thu, 22 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I went on a Thursday night and the place was packed! When I asked how long for a table I was told 10-15 minutes which I had no problem with so my partner and I went to the bar and had 2 margaritas which were great, here's where the pickyness in me comes out, I wanted salt with mine and didn't get it , I should have asked I guess, usually the request is for no salt but whatever because this is the only complaint I had, and honestly, complaint is really the wrong word, but if I didn't mention this then you more than likely wouldn't believe me, you would probably think that management wrote this review, yes people, it's a glowing review! We were sat in 10 minutes which was great as we've all been told wait times before and waited an eternity, not here. I really did not think that this place would be as great as it is. The food is amazing, I am not that up on Mexican food, I imagined burritos and tacos and was so surprised with how good it was. I went for the staple guacamole and was very happy, usually it has so much cilantro to over power it but here they know to control it, SUPERB!!! For my entree I had the hangar steak, PERFECT. I loved my meal!!!! All anyone can ask for is tasty food and this place delivers. I also have to say a big thanks to our server Kristin, she was always there, but never obtrusive, she is fantastic, I recommend you ask for her personally, she rocks!!!! So after rambling on, I really recommend this place, great food, great service, VERY WELL DONE!!!

5 Stars: Great food, great space, great time (by kae222)

kae222 — Sun, 18 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

We went on a Friday night, the cafe was very busy but even so the service was fantastic.
We had great drinks, the salads were wonderful and our meals were cooked perfectly.
The atmosphere was just what we wanted, up beat, lively and friendly. Will definitely go back many times.

5 Stars: Definitely the least bland mexican food i've ever had. (by ahadro)

ahadro — Fri, 16 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

This place has a very trendy and cozy atmosphere. The service was ridiculously fast, and always friendly.

Don't even get me started on the drinks, the bartenders make everything well and then make sure you are happy.

The tortilla chips are authentic and delicious, the only problem is eating too many and not being able to enjoy the incredible entrees. Every dish is unique in some way and does not give in to the stereotypes of mexican food.

Delicious.

Its easy to find and get to as well!

5 Stars: One word: Margarita!!!! (by cohenj11215)

cohenj11215 — Fri, 16 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

You never thought Mexican food can do THAT. Bold, bright and unusual flavors dominate every dish I tried here. Standard Mexican fare like guacamole is accompanied by three relishes that make it transcend its origins, while more sophisticated plates, like the beautiful crusted tuna, are all modern, but with a Mexcian kick. Service was fast, friendly and knowledgeable.

5 Stars: Great Food....Great Atmosphere (by jennylou8702)

jennylou8702 — Wed, 14 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

It was my first evening in NYC and we wanted to grab a bite to eat. The friends that I was staying with took us to Rocking Horse Cafe as it was one of their favorite spots. Alfonso greeted us on our arrival and we felt immediately at home. The Margaritas are great. The bloodorange was my favorite. The food was exceptional, traditional Mexican with a twist. The carnitas were awesome as was the guacamole appetizer. We were in New York for 6 days and Rocking Horse Cafe was such a pleasant way to start to our trip that we went back on our last night to enjoy it all again. I will definitely come back the next time I am in New York.

3 Stars: Rocking Horse Cafe (by sueac1)

sueac1 — Tue, 13 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Singing for my own supper has become a way of life, so anytime I'm treated to a meal by a friend is something of an event, regardless of the restaurant or its offerings. But my recent meal at Rocking Horse Cafe was an unexpected pleasure. The space is casual cool, and staff are knowlegeable and exceedingly welcoming. While clearly in the category of upscale Mexican, ingredients, flavors, and compositions honor the menu's pre-Columbian roots, and nothing feels fusion-silly. A salad of warm, grilled corn kernals over greens napped with lime vinegrette was perfect. Carnivores and foodies alike will appreciate entrees featuring free range chicken, organic salmon, and Niman Ranch pork. The Carne Guisado, - slow-cooked brisket with garlic mashed potatoes in chile-lime sauce - was fine and mellow. Deserts are also surprisingly good, and include a sharable Valrohan chocolate tortita and a lucious coconut flan. Although I'm not a tequila fan, the bottles lining the wall behind the bar impressed my companion, who sees himself as something of an expert in this area. Given the increasing numbers of fancified, overhyped, and overpriced south of the border joints popping up around town, I was expecting the same from Rocking Horse. Wrong. It's worth the trip, no matter who's buying.

5 Stars: Great customer service and food (by dbrewer308)

dbrewer308 — Sun, 11 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

From the minute I walked in I was treated beautifully. I got a great table and had a drink in front of me in less than 3 minutes. The wild mushroom quesadilla appetizer was tremendous. The entree great and dessert excellent. I would go back in a minute. The entire experience was wonderful.

5 Stars: Returning is a must!!!! (by rockawaymil)

rockawaymil — Sat, 10 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The rosy hue & outre lighting provide a warm, intimate atmosphere at Rocking Horse Cafe. This zesty Chelsea dining spot offers up generous portions of subtly-flavored succulent food. (e.g. pulled pork, long-roasted, tender & yummy) A refreshing eye & palate-pleaser was the rainbow, tropical-flavored sorbet dessert. Kudos to the staff who aimed to please big-time . Returning is a must.

5 Stars: hip romantic place (by joanie11516)

joanie11516 — Sat, 10 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Chelsea's Rocking Horse Cafe manages to have a distinctive, inviting decor and a warm intimate look as well as personalized service offering helpful recommendations to patrons with special needs. Better yet, the food - generously served, interestingly sauced and spiced, cooked exactly as ordered is varied and eye pleasing. Meats and vegetables are tender and delicious and oh! the desserts. All this and a fun-loving young crowd with a sprinkling of hip older folks. Try it, you'll like it.

5 Stars: Margaritas to Die For! (by chris)

chris — Fri, 09 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

People go to The Rocking Horse Cafe for the freshly baked tortilla chips and world class margaritas, they stay for the flavorful and create menu options and they return again for the family-like service. The staff at The Rocking Horse Cafe is friendly and welcoming and dining there is always a guaranteed good time. Lively atmosphere and modern, artsy decor keep the energy up in this Chelsea landmark.

5 Stars: Rock on over to the Rocking Horse Cafe! (by craigbnyc)

craigbnyc — Mon, 05 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Though the Rocking Horse Cafe has become a place to see and be seen (celebrities are ofen just at the next table), it's well-worth the reservation (or drop-in if you're willing to wait) to experience the unique menu. It stands a head above the rest where Mexican cuisine is concerned and is a diamond in Chesea's tiara. From my appetizer of tamales de rajas y queso to the delicious "mixiote" entree, the dining experience was a complete pleasure. Great staff the night I was there! One caveat: if you prefer a quieter evening, plan your visit on Monday through Wednesday. The other nights are rockin' at the ol' Rocking Horse Cafe!

5 Stars: rocking restaurant (by demadiva)

demadiva — Sun, 04 Mar 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The Rocking Horse set the mood for a great evening with friends. The oranges and reds of the interior exude warmth and the music matches the upbeat chatter of the hip dining crowd. The bar serves up cocktails with a lively kick. The deliciously singular bits of mahi mahi swimming in coconut milk, ripe plantains, red onions, jalapenos and cilantro melted in my mouth. And the dashing server was the spitting image of Gael Garcia Bernal as he rode a motorbike up the Argentinian coast. A Chelsea restaurant can't get more festive or flamboyant than this.

3 Stars: Can't Wait to go Back (by josh2102)

josh2102 — Wed, 28 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

My friend and I had dinner for the first time at Rocking Horse the other night and it was fantastic. The entire staff was very knowledgeable of all their entrees and was more than happy to explain several of the dishes to us. Even more impressive than their steak burritos and camarones con papaya are their selection of margaritas. Our waitress surprised us with a White Peach margarita and a Carmen Miranda (made with El Tesoro Silver and pineapple puree). The drinks were so good we had two more rounds! For a fun place with great food, drinks and a wait-staff that?s as hot as their spicy chips and salsa- I recommend Rocking Horse Cafe.

5 Stars: Pleasant for date with friends (by madu1)

madu1 — Fri, 23 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

After not having been back at Rocking Horse in two years, I?m adding it to my list of restaurants to come back to. Last weekend?s dining experience with friends was overall more than satisfactory. The shrimp tamale appetizer was tasty. It was lightly drizzled with a chipotle sauce added a spicy kick to it. I also got the pan-seared tuna steak that was cooked perfectly to the way I asked for it, raw and juicy while crispy on the outside. Accompanied w/ delicious rice and little pieces of chorizo, it was a completely delectable dish. It does get a little loud in the restaurant, but not more than your average bistro. With its charming and friendly staff and delightful food, it was a pleasant place for a date with girlfriends.

5 Stars: Delectable specialty cocktails (by hsiaomeic)

hsiaomeic — Wed, 21 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

This cafe serves up some of the most original and creative interpretations of Tex-Mex favorites. Not usually a huge fan of this type of cuisine, I was definitely blown away by the innovative use of unexpected ingredients, such as papaya with grilled shrimp and a calamari salad with a citrus dressing. Completely mouth-watering. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, and the waitstaff is extremely knowledgeable and efficient. A perfect place for amazing food, good friends, and delectable cocktails that won't break the bank.

5 Stars: Best Margarita's in town (by pheonix2003)

pheonix2003 — Tue, 20 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I went to the Rocking horse for the first time over four years ago, since then it has been one of my favorite places to dine at. I have to honestly say I have never been disappointed. Being a vegetarian can make it difficult to find restaurants that will go out of there way to accommodate the vegetarian lifestyle, I have never had that problem at the rocking horse, not only do they offer vegetarian plates , on many occasions they have adjusted certain entrees to suit my needs. The margarita's are Delicious.... The staff always willing to go that extra yard. So I can say without hesitation, go to the rocking horse, you won't be disappointed.

5 Stars: Bright colored cozy night (by lauraazul22)

lauraazul22 — Mon, 19 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

My visit to Rocking Horse Cafe was outstanding. This was my second or third visit and each time I go I walk away having had a great meal in a friendly fun setting. Our waiter, Diego was very helpful in explaining the specials and offering suggestions His attention to detail throughout the meal couldn't have been better. Something for everybody can be found on the menu. We all decided to get different things and do a bit of sharing, so I got a taste of it all. My favorites are the azteca budin which is an appetizer that is the perfect blend of cheesy ,spicy, chicken goodness and the tuna. The tuna steak which I had med rare is over a chorizo rice and it is out of this world. Not to forget the desserts. Tres Leches and the lemon tart!!!
The great thing about the Rocking Horse to me is if you are in the mood to sit and watch the eighth ave crowd you can sit and do so in the front, but if you want something cozy the back is where to go. I love this place and would recommend you go and see for yourself. Ask for Diego.

5 Stars: best margaritas by far.. (by willt9000)

willt9000 — Tue, 13 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

This place is definitely one of our favorites in Chelsea as far as Mexican goes. By far the best Margaritas in the neighborhood and the food is a great twist on the everyday Mexican. The last time we were there we had a super tasty appetizer of a hanger steak Sope (first time I've had this). It was a sort of thick version of tortilla placed flat with the steak on top. Yum. And my main course was free range chicken breast on mushroom-jalpeno rice. Yum-Yum. Overall the meal was great as usual. And the vibe is always very fun. Especially on the weekends.

5 Stars: The Best service in town...... (by db105)

db105 — Tue, 13 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

I come into the Rocking Horse about every other week. The best place to enjoy great food, and get the best service. I always make sure I say Hi to the bartenders Duane , Samantha , Sergio , and the russian guy V... They always welcome me as soon as walk in... that's a great feeling. Most times I stay at the bar eat with them, however last week , I sat at a table and Ayashi was my waiter... She was amazing...I had the usual Steak Burrito and Tres Leche. My cocktail was this Tangy Plum cosmo. Rocking horse will always be the place for Mexican food for me.

5 Stars: Great vibe! (by jon9000)

jon9000 — Tue, 13 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

A really fun place with great Margaritas. The staff is attentive and makes you feel at home. The food was excellent. I had the Sope de Res, which is grilled hanger steak on a masa cake. Delicious! The Lime tart is excellent.

5 Stars: Friendly Service, Good Food (by kgrayson)

kgrayson — Sun, 11 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

We went to Rocking Horse at about 10pm on a Friday night, and found the restaurant to be busy, yet the service was friendly and prompt. We had reservations and were seated immediately, and the maitre d' was extremely friendly. Our waitress got our drink orders immediately, and we really enjoyed our passion fruit cosmos. The food was fresh, creative, very tasty.

5 Stars: Incredible Mexican food with a lively atmosphere (by minolis)

minolis — Sun, 11 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

My experience at Rocking Horse Cafe was positive right from the start with a delicious pinapple frozen margarita & only got better from there. The menu is very diverse with many traditional Mexican items as well as very upscale cuisine such as seafood. Our server, Diego, was very friendly, knowledgable & attentive. The food was not only delicious, but artfully presented. The "happening atmosphere is enhanced by funky decor, a hip crowd & great music. Overall, I was very pleased with my meal, service & surroundings & would recommend Rocking Horse Cafe to all.

5 Stars: Can't miss food (by slimjimroy)

slimjimroy — Mon, 05 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The Rocking Horse is a can't miss great meal. We started going there about 9 months ago and have been there maybe 5 times now. Each time the food is excellent. My wife usually gets a special and I do the regular menu and we share. The Pork dish on the regular menu is maybe the best pork I have ever tasted. Try it! The other thing about this place that is better than pther restaurants is the level of service. The wait staff is amazing. Very unassuming yet informative and friendly. This is a can't miss place!

5 Stars: Fresh Mexican (by atiboni)

atiboni — Sun, 04 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

The Rocking Horse is wonderfully conducive to being out with friends. From the Calamari salad through the Shrimp with Papaya to the sorbet sampler, the food was excellent. The service was friendly, helpful and timely. I heartily recommend it!

5 Stars: A Great Choice (by eformica)

eformica — Sun, 04 Feb 2007 09:00:00 GMT

My husband and I were visiting in New York this past weekend and happened upon the Rocking Horse Cafe. What a charming place!! The decor is inviting and we felt comfortable from the time we stepped in the door to the time we left. The service was great.....attentive but not overbearing. The food was well prepared and you could tell that the ingredients were fresh. The salad greens glistened a bright green with a light dressing. I had scallops and my husband had shrimp. Each were uniquely done ...not your traditional fare. The desserts...well suffice it to say that not a morsel was left. We will absolutely go back when we come to the City and recommend it highly.

5 Stars: Chelsea's Best Mex (by chelseaite)

chelseaite — Wed, 03 Jan 2007 09:00:00 GMT

Had brunch and dinner at Rocking Horse Cafe in December - and both meals were fantastic. The vibe in the room is fun and the service is friendly and efficient. And the food: perhaps the best Mex-inspired food in Chelsea. Even the staples (freshly baked/fried chips, quac and frozen margharitas) are wonderful. Definitely worth a visit.

4 Stars: Great food, not so great service (by vespico)

vespico — Fri, 10 Nov 2006 09:00:00 GMT

Just had brunch there. Food was great when we finally got it. Our waiter took our order and didn't check in again until he brought the bill. Restaurant was empty and I think our order was not submitted because we had to ask the manager about it a couple times. Notice another table having issues (they were smart and left). We stayed and the food was great, but there was never an acknowledgment of a mistake or an apology for the delay. The bus boy did say he was sorry, neither the waiter nor the manager did. I hate that I have to tip in these situations so I tipped exactly 15% on the bill prior to tax to make a point. I am sure it was lost on the waiter, but I did leave him a note. Shame that the food is so good.

5 Stars: Love the Horse! (by brightyellow)

brightyellow — Fri, 07 Jul 2006 09:00:00 GMT

Whenever I am in the Chelsea area for gallery meetings I always make a point to stop by and have dinner or a drink at the Rocking Horse Cafe. I have been going to the Rocking Horse Cafe for the last four years now. They are known for their margaritas but I always try their drink special or have a glass of wine. The tuna dish is to die for and I cannot get enough of their lemon tart dessert. I dream of it sometimes. The nice part of the whole experience is the staff. The staff is friendly, they get it and are always on top of things. I will be back soon. Thanks!

5 Stars: Really diverse, delicious flavors. (by nycmusicdoll)

nycmusicdoll — Wed, 05 Jul 2006 09:00:00 GMT

After my experience earlier in the week at another Mexican restaurant, I was thrilled to have delicious food and attentive service at Rocking Horse. Every member of the waitstaff - from the host and bartender to our server and their assistants- were helpful, quick, and gracious. The food and drinks were all so flavorful - nothing ordinary here. My friend's passion fruit margarita was delicious, and my mojito was refreshing and yummy. Highlights of the entrees were the tuna with wild rice, (order it medium rare), the quesadilla - never greasy, the shrimp with papaya, and the key lime pie....amazingly tangy yet not overpowering, with a rum (!) whipped cream. I definitely recommend it.

5 Stars: Excellent Brunch (by benji1774)

benji1774 — Mon, 26 Jun 2006 09:00:00 GMT

Best Huevos Rancheros in town. Chips & salsa were exceptional. OJ fresh, just the way we like it. Polite waiters and great atmosphere.

1 Stars: What is the rush (by amsams14)

amsams14 — Thu, 20 Oct 2005 09:00:00 GMT

I went there a couple of months ago with some friends. As other people have noted, the food is nothing special. I did however like the drinks and the chips. The worst part was that they rushed us through the meal from beginning to end. They started clearing the appetizers away in less then 10 minutes while people were still eating them. We were actually told after an hour and a half that they needed our table and they asked us to leave. We were a large group and everyone ordered an appetizer, main course, dessert, and several rounds of drinks. I am surprised they didnt just give us our meals to go. There are much better restaurants in the price range who appreciate your business. I recommend you go somewhere else.

3 Stars: My opinion: an average mexican restaurant (by macandmac)

macandmac — Wed, 07 Sep 2005 09:00:00 GMT

We had dinner here last week... we were seated right away so that was good. The service was adequate...but I think they were more concerned about taking the order quickly to get us in and out. The chips that were brought to the table at the start of the meal were good. But I thought the rest of the meal was ok. I thought the lobster emp. were dry and flavorless. I had the prawn main dish and it was adequate. My wife had a pork dish, but I don't remember anything about it.

4 Stars: Great Food! (by meg2005)

meg2005 — Mon, 04 Apr 2005 09:00:00 GMT

The food here is delicious and slightly different from the standard Mexican fare! The MARGARITAS ARE GREAT- stick to a regular Margarita, on the rocks and use Silver Tequila! The place is small, quaint and yes, it does get noisy at times - but thats part of its ambience. Have found the staff very accomodating, adjusting our Margarita if we did not like it (we ordered 2 different kinds of Tequila). All in all, its a great place and I would go for the food! We've never been rushed out of there and that could be because we have ended up at Rocking Horse at non-peak dinner hours.

4 Stars: Unusual treat (by elsimons)

elsimons — Sat, 20 Mar 2004 09:00:00 GMT

Nuevo Mexican food and good drinks make this a fun place. A far cry for Tex-Mex fare. Only complaints were the noise level. When a crowd is that loud, loud music only makes everyone talk louder. A truly undesireable effect.

4 Stars: Bang for your buck! (by mcberry3)

mcberry3 — Mon, 22 Dec 2003 09:00:00 GMT

I went to Rocking Horse with a bunch of ladies for a night on the town. The food was really good, the margaritas were smoking! And the service was pretty good, until they asked us to leave (little frustrating, but I understand). And the total bill was only $41/ head. Awesome! I would definitely go back!

4 Stars: Loved it (by allaboutfiling)

allaboutfiling — Tue, 28 Oct 2003 09:00:00 GMT

The host was horrendous and insisted I didn't have a reservation when in fact I did, but the manager and the waitstaff were completely accomadating and professional, with a sense of humor. The food was terrific, everyone in my party enjoyed themselves and the atmosphere leaves little room for improvement. I highly recommend it.

2 Stars: don't believe the hype... (by chandelier)

chandelier — Thu, 11 Sep 2003 09:00:00 GMT

margaritas...poor, though strawberry was better than raz. cosmos- absolutely awful and green, on purpose?!! best to do a beer, as the bartenders can't mess that up! food was decent, service was not attentive. overall, not even close to impressed... try zarela's for the best mexican (and margaritas) this far north of the border!!

5 Stars: better than ever (by mirabellecity)

mirabellecity — Sat, 19 Jul 2003 09:00:00 GMT

jan mendelson the chef really knows authentic mexican cuisine.what a beautiful place

5 Stars: Yummy, yummy (by dmm531)

dmm531 — Tue, 27 May 2003 09:00:00 GMT

The best Strawberry maragritas this far north of the border. The food was fresh, authentic and not too heavy. The staff was very attentive and quick. Great place for lunch.

4 Stars: Good but (by genine810)

genine810 — Tue, 13 May 2003 09:00:00 GMT

I was not thrilled with the resturant. It seemed to gourmet for Mexican and it was pricey. The combination of flavors used in their dishes was amazing - I just wish there was more there for the price. The mango sorbet is good and the avacado sorbet is great.
The service was top - notch. So I would go back.

4 Stars: chelsea mexican? (by alacutin)

alacutin — Sat, 22 Feb 2003 09:00:00 GMT

good buritos and nice interesting salsa made with bean sauce? consistant service do not expect great mexican artistry

3 Stars: Pretty good... (by kirbyko3)

kirbyko3 — Wed, 25 Dec 2002 09:00:00 GMT

... but a little inconsistent. Decent food, great neigborhood staple, but lunch there is better than dinner. Dinnertime brings you small portions for high prices, unfortunately.

The food here used to be spectacular, but a year or two ago it slipped to the "just pretty good" spot on my food-o-meter. I wonder if it changed chefs or something, because it suddenly stopped being as consistently fabulous as it used to be. Still, a decent place to grab a bite, but not worth waiting more than 10 minutes for a table if you get there at peak time.

5 Stars: Your basic YUM! (by agapantha)

agapantha — Sun, 17 Nov 2002 09:00:00 GMT

Low key, fun atmosphere, friendly service and scrumptious Mexican-inspired food. The dishes were creative without venturing into that dreaded territory of so-precious-we-forgot-you-would-want-to-eat-it.

Weekday lunch is less crowded and the staff cheerfully tolerated a 3-year-old. (He was pretty darn well-behaved.)

5 Stars: Terrific (by mwkka1)

mwkka1 — Tue, 13 Aug 2002 09:00:00 GMT

The staff is wonderful! They were very nice and extremely accommodating to a large group. I have never seen such great service in New York. In addition, the decor is cute and the food was good too. A group of 12 of us went and did not pay very much for a good meal and great service.

4 Stars: Mexican chic (by KerryAnn)

KerryAnn — Thu, 27 Jun 2002 09:00:00 GMT

I went here for lunch and enjoyed their spicy salmon burger and fries, as well as a mango margarita. The atmosphere was colorful and relaxing. The prices could have been cheaper though. All in all a nice place to eat.

5 Stars: Potent Margs! (by Lauranal)

Lauranal — Thu, 27 Jun 2002 09:00:00 GMT

The mango margs are great and the food is always tasty! Great outdoor seating and people watching too!

4 Stars: margaritas (by diane02)

diane02 — Fri, 21 Jun 2002 09:00:00 GMT

This place has the potential to be great. The chips and salsa are different than your average chip. But they are good. And so are the margaritas. Try the Mango Margarita. Try the glazed tuna.

3 Stars: Good that could be Great (by djceat)

djceat — Fri, 14 Jun 2002 09:00:00 GMT

Rocking Horse is a good restaraunt. We've been going for many years. The food is usually very good...you could never go wrong with the chicken or steak burrito. The chips and salsa...one of the best in the city! Some of the special dishes are excellent too. Rocking Horse could be an excellent restaraunt all around. However, it is a bit pricey for what it is and the staff could try to remember their clientele. Margaritas are delicious and the sidewalk cafe is great for people watching along 8th avenue.

4 Stars: Fabulous (by alsmez)

alsmez — Thu, 30 May 2002 09:00:00 GMT

This is a great little spot for drinks, dinner and dessert....especially if you're a gay man and want to look at the cute but flamboyant waitstaff. The steak burrito is killer, the mussels appetizer is delicious and large enough for a meal. Great guac and salsa as well. The desserts were the real highlight, though...the key lime napolean is to die for. Drawback: tiny, crowded, noisy and you may have to wait.

4 Stars: happy hours (by jasonclampet_citysearch)

jasonclampet_citysearch — Mon, 20 May 2002 09:00:00 GMT

Dinner's nothing to scream about (although there are a few winners on the menu), but solid margaritas and appetizers are well-suited for a summer evening.