Horsefeathers

★★★★☆
  • 94 North Broadway

    Tarrytown, NY 10591

    Map & Directions
  • 914-631-6606

About Horsefeathers

Hours
Mon - Sat, 11:30am - 9:45pm; Sun, 11:30am - 9pm

Food

Food
More choices in Tarrytown:
Resultset_next

Diner Restaurant

US Hwy 29 Soperton, GA

Resultset_next

Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

120 E Spring St Mount Vernon, GA

3.625 8
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Horsefeathers was?
Write a Review
.

On another adventure searching for the best burger, my friend and I headed to horsefeathers.

The first thing we noticed was that the beer menu was longer then the food. After finally deciding on what beer we were going to drink. We had a

3
★★★★★

On another adventure searching for the best burger, my friend and I headed to horsefeathers.

The first thing we noticed was that the beer menu was longer then the food. After finally deciding on what beer we were going to drink. We had a

.

If you are in the area, you have to go to Horsefeathers for lunch or dinner. The burgers are the best in Westchester - my favorite's the Old English (traditional cheddar and bacon on an english muff). All the other dishes (try Gracie's Meatloaf) are superb, as is the staff. And don't forget to have a beer, tho you may have to ask for a taste or a little guidance due to their wide selection of imports. Say hi to Fran. Two thumbs WAY UP !

5
★★★★★

If you are in the area, you have to go to Horsefeathers for lunch or dinner. The burgers are the best in Westchester - my favorite's the Old English (traditional cheddar and bacon on an english muff). All the other dishes (try Gracie's Meatloaf) are superb, as is the staff. And don't forget to have a beer, tho you may have to ask for a taste or a little guidance due to their wide selection of imports. Say hi to Fran. Two thumbs WAY UP !

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

During the warm seasons this place is great. You can sit outside and they have such a huge beer list you are sure to find something. Oh yeah and did i mention that the burgers are out of this world!

5
★★★★★

During the warm seasons this place is great. You can sit outside and they have such a huge beer list you are sure to find something. Oh yeah and did i mention that the burgers are out of this world!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

GREAT burgers! This restaurant has a great atmosphere and is a great place for lunch or dinner. The service is fast and friendly and the burgers to die for.

4
★★★★☆

GREAT burgers! This restaurant has a great atmosphere and is a great place for lunch or dinner. The service is fast and friendly and the burgers to die for.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I've been to Horsefeathers twice now. The food is always pretty decent; it's mostly pub fare, burgers, sandwiches, etc. Nothing unique or out of this world, but pretty decent. The first time I went to Horsefeathers, the service was moderate. The server would come when we asked them to, but nothing beyond that. The second time I went, besides getting my order and delivering my check, I never saw the server (and there were only four tables in the entire restaurant). Tried flagging someone down; the only time I could get anyone was the busboy. Asked for refills from him; they came seven minutes later with the check. No one checked on me or asked how the food was. The servers (they pool their tips) said that they repeatedly walked by and I didn't flag them. They saw empty glasses but yet didn't ask if a refill was wanted, how the food was, nothing. Yet, when I did flag them, they didn't respond. Then, when I gave an above average tip for that service (14%), I was called a loser and verbally accosted in the restaurant. I waited tables for five years and never did I do any of this. Nor have I ever seen this.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I've been to Horsefeathers twice now. The food is always pretty decent; it's mostly pub fare, burgers, sandwiches, etc. Nothing unique or out of this world, but pretty decent. The first time I went to Horsefeathers, the service was moderate. The server would come when we asked them to, but nothing beyond that. The second time I went, besides getting my order and delivering my check, I never saw the server (and there were only four tables in the entire restaurant). Tried flagging someone down; the only time I could get anyone was the busboy. Asked for refills from him; they came seven minutes later with the check. No one checked on me or asked how the food was. The servers (they pool their tips) said that they repeatedly walked by and I didn't flag them. They saw empty glasses but yet didn't ask if a refill was wanted, how the food was, nothing. Yet, when I did flag them, they didn't respond. Then, when I gave an above average tip for that service (14%), I was called a loser and verbally accosted in the restaurant. I waited tables for five years and never did I do any of this. Nor have I ever seen this.

Pros: pretty decent pub fare

Cons: bad service

.

I've been to Horsefeathers close to 5 times. I really enjoy their burgers, but at the end of the day the minuses out weigh the positives

Positives-
good burgers- a selection of burgers that make it hard to decide what to order
good sweat potato fries

Negatives-
Awful service. 90% of the time I've experienced very poor service at horsefeathers. Servers consistently forget that you exist. Refills of water are rare and most of the time the only interaction you have with the server is ordering your food, getting your food and getting your check. One day we were refused outside seating during lunch because they were "reserved." They remained open the entire time we were there.

Price. As this has mentioned with other comments the price is outlandish, even more higher than Manhattan prices. Burgers fall into the $12-13 range. Granted these are good burgers, but their is room for improvement...(lets see a bun that isn't purchased in bulk from costco!!!)

I really enjoy burgers and this is why I come back. However, each time I eat there I leave thinking this is the last time I go here. Not something a patron should think after a meal.

1
★★☆☆☆

I've been to Horsefeathers close to 5 times. I really enjoy their burgers, but at the end of the day the minuses out weigh the positives

Positives-
good burgers- a selection of burgers that make it hard to decide what to order
good sweat potato fries

Negatives-
Awful service. 90% of the time I've experienced very poor service at horsefeathers. Servers consistently forget that you exist. Refills of water are rare and most of the time the only interaction you have with the server is ordering your food, getting your food and getting your check. One day we were refused outside seating during lunch because they were "reserved." They remained open the entire time we were there.

Price. As this has mentioned with other comments the price is outlandish, even more higher than Manhattan prices. Burgers fall into the $12-13 range. Granted these are good burgers, but their is room for improvement...(lets see a bun that isn't purchased in bulk from costco!!!)

I really enjoy burgers and this is why I come back. However, each time I eat there I leave thinking this is the last time I go here. Not something a patron should think after a meal.

Pros: burgers

Cons: price, service

.

You wouldn't know it by the name, but Horsefeathers boasts the best burger in the state! An unassuming little place, Horsefeathers is a great place to bring the family, with classic grill fare, and of course those great burgers! Give their special mustard a try for an even better experience.

5
★★★★★

You wouldn't know it by the name, but Horsefeathers boasts the best burger in the state! An unassuming little place, Horsefeathers is a great place to bring the family, with classic grill fare, and of course those great burgers! Give their special mustard a try for an even better experience.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The service very slow, we saw more of our busboy than we did the server. The food was not that great either. I was expecting the place to use very fresh ingredients for the price we were paying. Instead, we had limp salads, chewy squid, small burgers and pasta that was so over cooked that that it looked like bloated worms. I have had better burgers at Wendy's than at this place. Overall, the two other couples I was with decided that this was one place we would strike from our list.

0
★☆☆☆☆

The service very slow, we saw more of our busboy than we did the server. The food was not that great either. I was expecting the place to use very fresh ingredients for the price we were paying. Instead, we had limp salads, chewy squid, small burgers and pasta that was so over cooked that that it looked like bloated worms. I have had better burgers at Wendy's than at this place. Overall, the two other couples I was with decided that this was one place we would strike from our list.

Pros: busboys

Cons: waitress, seating, Price

Editorial from

The "drink your meal" mentality associated with most pubs doesn't apply at this Tarrytown establishment, with its decor bearing more than a few artifacts in homage to the Legend of Sleepy Hollow and the headless horseman. Any appetite can…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Horsefeathers, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review