Papa Joe's Italian Eatery

★★★★★
  • 485 Spencerport Rd

    Rochester, NY 14606

    Cross street: 485 Spencerport Rd., Gates - In the CVS Plaza

    Map & Directions
  • 585-247-7920

About Papa Joe's Italian Eatery

Hours
MON 11:30-2:30 ; TUE-THUR 11:30-2:30 & 4:30-8 ; FRI 11:30-2:30 & 4:30-9 ; SAT 4:30-9 ; SUN AVAILABLE FOR CAT

Food

Food
More choices in Rochester:
Resultset_next

Luca Pizza

2937 W Iles Av Springfield, IL

Resultset_next

Saputo's Italian Foods

801 east monroe street Springfield, IL

5.0 3
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Papa Joe's Italian Eatery was?
Write a Review
.

I love this restaurant! Its a cozy and classy atmosphere but not stuffy. Their homemade gnocchi is so good! The kids menu is pretty good too, one of the only restaurants Ive been to that has a kids size ravioli. For 2 adults and 2 small children it costs about 60.00 plus tax and tip.

5
★★★★★

I love this restaurant! Its a cozy and classy atmosphere but not stuffy. Their homemade gnocchi is so good! The kids menu is pretty good too, one of the only restaurants Ive been to that has a kids size ravioli. For 2 adults and 2 small children it costs about 60.00 plus tax and tip.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

For $11 I ordered the largest portion of lasagna I had ever seen. It tasted fantastic. They have my favorite tasting sauce in the city and I am very particular. Service is always great. The staff is very friendly and professional. They specials that they offer are quite amazing. Two people can go and eat a full meal with a glasses of wine for under $30. I have never found a better value. Order the homemade oil with garlic and spices for your bread. Most people can make three meals out of one order at this place. I really don't think that we could make the food ourselves any cheaper. We certainly could never touch the quality. Another favorite is the Cannelloni. On a side note I am not a big fan of salads but I always finish my plate here. I don't know where they get their blue cheese from or if they make it themselves but it is really good. I always get creamy and crumbly blue cheese. \r\n\r\nThe only problem I can mention is that I think that we may have told too many people about the place. It used to be relatively empty when we would visit but now it's packed almost every night of the week. Agetina's has to be sorry they let the two chefs go that run the place because Agetina's is not the same. Well at least I have a new favorite and its right down the street. \r\n\r\nIf you like the place, please don't tell anybody about it. ;-)

2
★★★★★

For $11 I ordered the largest portion of lasagna I had ever seen. It tasted fantastic. They have my favorite tasting sauce in the city and I am very particular. Service is always great. The staff is very friendly and professional. They specials that they offer are quite amazing. Two people can go and eat a full meal with a glasses of wine for under $30. I have never found a better value. Order the homemade oil with garlic and spices for your bread. Most people can make three meals out of one order at this place. I really don't think that we could make the food ourselves any cheaper. We certainly could never touch the quality. Another favorite is the Cannelloni. On a side note I am not a big fan of salads but I always finish my plate here. I don't know where they get their blue cheese from or if they make it themselves but it is really good. I always get creamy and crumbly blue cheese. \r\n\r\nThe only problem I can mention is that I think that we may have told too many people about the place. It used to be relatively empty when we would visit but now it's packed almost every night of the week. Agetina's has to be sorry they let the two chefs go that run the place because Agetina's is not the same. Well at least I have a new favorite and its right down the street. \r\n\r\nIf you like the place, please don't tell anybody about it. ;-)

Pros: Everything about the place

Cons: Getting too busy to easily get a table

.

Last night was our first visit. Decor was very nice. Waitress and staff were excellent. Portions are unbelievably large. The bread was served warmed and delicious, everyplace should do this. Salad was great, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, banana peppers, black olives, chick peas, shredded carrots, and croutons with a good tasting Italian dressing. Also it was served cold and crispy,very fresh. Not one who is particularly fond of salad I cleaned my plate. I ordered an appetizer of steamed clams for a very reasonable price. The bus staff was unbelievable, the restaurant was full, whenever I moved a dish to the side of the table it was gone. They were very mannerly and must have been trained well. I watched when customers left their tables were cleaned off and reset in a minute (I should have timed them). I ordered chicken French which was very good and plentiful with a side if linguini. The sauce was good but not the best to me. I add this because I believe that tomato sauce is very subjective. Everyone likes the taste of a different pasta sauce. I could go on about this but characters are limited here. My wife had chicken Parmesan which was fantastic along with a side of penne with a meatball. Waitress was very nice and experienced. I recommend this restaurant highly. The menu has a lot of items that I would have liked to try. I will have to go back.

2
★★★★★

Last night was our first visit. Decor was very nice. Waitress and staff were excellent. Portions are unbelievably large. The bread was served warmed and delicious, everyplace should do this. Salad was great, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, banana peppers, black olives, chick peas, shredded carrots, and croutons with a good tasting Italian dressing. Also it was served cold and crispy,very fresh. Not one who is particularly fond of salad I cleaned my plate. I ordered an appetizer of steamed clams for a very reasonable price. The bus staff was unbelievable, the restaurant was full, whenever I moved a dish to the side of the table it was gone. They were very mannerly and must have been trained well. I watched when customers left their tables were cleaned off and reset in a minute (I should have timed them). I ordered chicken French which was very good and plentiful with a side if linguini. The sauce was good but not the best to me. I add this because I believe that tomato sauce is very subjective. Everyone likes the taste of a different pasta sauce. I could go on about this but characters are limited here. My wife had chicken Parmesan which was fantastic along with a side of penne with a meatball. Waitress was very nice and experienced. I recommend this restaurant highly. The menu has a lot of items that I would have liked to try. I will have to go back.

Pros: Staff, food

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Papa Joe's Italian Eatery, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review