Sutton Wine Shop

★★★★★
Staff at this long-standing cellar guide patrons through hundreds of wines, champagnes and spirits, all available for delivery.
  • 403 E 57th St A

    New York, NY 10022

    Cross street: 1st Avenue

    Map & Directions
  • 212-755-6626

About Sutton Wine Shop

Hours
Mon-Sat 9:30-10pm Sun 12pm-8am

Food

Food
More choices in New York:
Resultset_next

Trader Joe's

138 E 14th St New York, NY

Resultset_next

Xicala Wine and Tapas Bar

151B Elizabeth St New York, NY

4.8571 7
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Sutton Wine Shop was?
Write a Review
.

I used to walk past this shop all the time, always eyeing a bottle of 100 yr. old Grand Marnier displayed in the front window. One day I finally went in and while I didn't come out with the bottle of cognac, I did come out with four assorted bottles of really great French wine. They had a very nice selection of Bordeaux, particularly, and with their 50% off the second bottle deal I felt I'd actually come out having paid decent prices per bottle.

Since then I've gone in a number of times, usually to browse their wine on sale. Depending on the original price of the wine, bottles will be marked down anywhere from one to six dollars.

Service is excellent, I felt comfortable asking questions and for recommendations. Continuing their great service: they've got a good selection of wine on their website and you can order online (or phone in) and they'll deliver if you're on the Upper East side.

I'd recommend that if you walk by Sutton Wine shop, stop in like I did. You most likely have a satisfying visit and be happy you did!

5
★★★★★

I used to walk past this shop all the time, always eyeing a bottle of 100 yr. old Grand Marnier displayed in the front window. One day I finally went in and while I didn't come out with the bottle of cognac, I did come out with four assorted bottles of really great French wine. They had a very nice selection of Bordeaux, particularly, and with their 50% off the second bottle deal I felt I'd actually come out having paid decent prices per bottle.

Since then I've gone in a number of times, usually to browse their wine on sale. Depending on the original price of the wine, bottles will be marked down anywhere from one to six dollars.

Service is excellent, I felt comfortable asking questions and for recommendations. Continuing their great service: they've got a good selection of wine on their website and you can order online (or phone in) and they'll deliver if you're on the Upper East side.

I'd recommend that if you walk by Sutton Wine shop, stop in like I did. You most likely have a satisfying visit and be happy you did!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I used to walk past this shop all the time, always eyeing a bottle of 100 yr. old Grand Marnier displayed in the front window. One day I finally went in and while I didn't come out with the bottle of cognac, I did come out with four

3
★★★★★

I used to walk past this shop all the time, always eyeing a bottle of 100 yr. old Grand Marnier displayed in the front window. One day I finally went in and while I didn't come out with the bottle of cognac, I did come out with four

.

Sutton Wine shop is one of the few wine stores I've found to have an amazing selection. They try to represent a little bit of everything, so harder to find items stand a better chance of being found here than at many other places I've shopped at. In the event they don't have a specific item you were looking for they're knowledgeable and quick to recomend something else in that same style, or they always offer to look into ordering it for you. With the weekly tastings I've tried quite a few new wines and varietals I've never heard of and learned a fair amount about the wine too. Overall this place really has the most well rounded approach to retail service. Great customer service, vast varieties of wine and spirits and a pleasant environment to shop in, they deliver too in case you dont want to stop in and browse around, and be it over the phone or in person I always receive really great help.

2
★★★★★

Sutton Wine shop is one of the few wine stores I've found to have an amazing selection. They try to represent a little bit of everything, so harder to find items stand a better chance of being found here than at many other places I've shopped at. In the event they don't have a specific item you were looking for they're knowledgeable and quick to recomend something else in that same style, or they always offer to look into ordering it for you. With the weekly tastings I've tried quite a few new wines and varietals I've never heard of and learned a fair amount about the wine too. Overall this place really has the most well rounded approach to retail service. Great customer service, vast varieties of wine and spirits and a pleasant environment to shop in, they deliver too in case you dont want to stop in and browse around, and be it over the phone or in person I always receive really great help.

.

Sutton Wine is now my only place for great wine. The selection is amazing and the wine tasting is very enjoyable. Sutton Wine also delivers, but I still enjoy going to the store. Try the wine tasting they have, its such an enjoyable experience.

2
★★★★★

Sutton Wine is now my only place for great wine. The selection is amazing and the wine tasting is very enjoyable. Sutton Wine also delivers, but I still enjoy going to the store. Try the wine tasting they have, its such an enjoyable experience.

Pros: Selection, Wine Tasting, Service

Cons: none

.

Not sure what the previous guy is talking about but the selection is amazing! It is not a big place but they really load up the choices. Even when I can't find what I am looking for, they can always recommend something that is right on or special order it for me. What else can you ask for? The prices are fair which is expected since they are not a big box store but there are always monthly sales that are fun and great for those of us that might want to save a little money. But ultimately you can't beat the service. Really great people working there!

5
★★★★★

Not sure what the previous guy is talking about but the selection is amazing! It is not a big place but they really load up the choices. Even when I can't find what I am looking for, they can always recommend something that is right on or special order it for me. What else can you ask for? The prices are fair which is expected since they are not a big box store but there are always monthly sales that are fun and great for those of us that might want to save a little money. But ultimately you can't beat the service. Really great people working there!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The staff at the store are extremely friendly and knowledgeable. They really know their stuff. They have a large selection of wines, liquor, and champagne and they can always recommend something perfect! They also offer delivery so it is very convenient for those occasions when you don't feel like going out.

2
★★★★★

The staff at the store are extremely friendly and knowledgeable. They really know their stuff. They have a large selection of wines, liquor, and champagne and they can always recommend something perfect! They also offer delivery so it is very convenient for those occasions when you don't feel like going out.

.

The Sutton wine shop is actually pretty nice looking; however, I was not so impressed with the selection or prices. Overall, I believe this is a good place to go for a bottle if you need one right away but otherwise, save you money and find a better bottle elsewhere. Again, it is a nice place but is New York City overpriced in my opinion

3
★★★☆☆

The Sutton wine shop is actually pretty nice looking; however, I was not so impressed with the selection or prices. Overall, I believe this is a good place to go for a bottle if you need one right away but otherwise, save you money and find a better bottle elsewhere. Again, it is a nice place but is New York City overpriced in my opinion

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Sutton Wine Shop, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review