Insider Pages Reviews for Players On Madison

3 Stars: Not Best pizza... (by by playersplaying at Citysearch)

by playersplaying at Citysearch — Sun, 05 Oct 2008 04:11:41 GMT

I just ordered a pizza from Player's on Madison it was hot a fresh just out of the oven. I have to say that the selection of toppings is impressive, and they are fresh. They did however skimp on the basil which annoyed me because it was my only topping; considering the hostess didn't hear that I ordered tomato as well. the crust is below par. It is not what I would consider gourmet, my mother makes a similiar dough herself. If you want to try a nice pizza that I would consider perfect, try Pier W. They make a perfect Margherita pizza.

4 Stars: One of Lakewood's best restaurants (by by ltrempe at Citysearch)

by ltrempe at Citysearch — Sat, 20 Sep 2008 20:05:38 GMT

Having lived around Lakewood for over four years I've found that Player's is one of the best local restaurants. Although I've only ever gotten carry-out (generally assorted apps), the food has been fantastic. There's also a very nice patio in the back.\r
\r
The hosts have always been nice, but there was once a bartender with a very condescending attitude.\r
\r
Best recommendation: \r
Crab and Rock Shrimp Cakes with corn-avocado salsa.

2 Stars: Over Rated (by by pamdane at Citysearch)

by pamdane at Citysearch — Mon, 11 Aug 2008 22:37:26 GMT

Service is Ok, Hostess is pleasant. There is nothing outstanding here. Has a Van Gough atmosphere IMO.\r
\r
Order to table time is atrocious. Appetizers and salads were served at the time meal should have been. \r
\r
No idea how mac and cheese deserves $17 with no sides? It didnt appear to be made with any type of above average cheese. \r
\r
There is nothing ""wrong"" with the restaurant or service, it just is not my idea of a star rated place. \r
\r

4 Stars: great grapeitmis (by Janell W.)

Janell W. — Thu, 08 May 2008 12:06:00 GMT

great food, classy decor, and great staff. but it's also a great place friday after work for happy hour with your girlfriends. the grapetini is like eating grape ape from hanna barbara. except grape ape talks like a neanderthal. and the grapetinis, given enough time, will make you do the same.

3 Stars: Avoid at all cost$$ (by by proados at Citysearch)

by proados at Citysearch — Fri, 16 Feb 2007 21:16:42 GMT

Food is NOT that great and the prices are HIGH. Hostess is ANYTHING BUT FRIENDLY. Been there twice. First time for take-out pizza, which was just OK. I don't know why everyone thinks this is so fantastic. Apparently their pizza tastes aren't high. Second time we ate in, encountered the surly hostess once again and had dinner for two, each with a cocktail. Dinner came to $85. That's a price you don't mind paying at a fancy place with great atmosphere and terrific food. Players ain't that place. Would not recommend.

5 Stars: Great Place for Pizza & Quality Service (by by roman95 at Citysearch)

by roman95 at Citysearch — Mon, 20 Mar 2006 09:00:00 GMT

Don't mistake Player's for your typical pizza and pasta joint. Although their pizza is fantastic (I highly recommend the pollo pesto), Player's has quickly become my favorite restaurant for many other reasons. With such a great variety of appetizers, I struggle to make a decision (calamari, stuffed banana peppers, and brie are a few of my favorites). Their entrees are incredible and combine some unique flavors that go perfectly together. The chicken and pork tenderloin are two great examples that I recommend, and the seafood specials are always intriguing. A different flavored creme brulee every week is the dessert of choice, but the fried banana split is a close second. You can also order food for take-out and the pollo pesto pizza is a perfect choice. Service is remarkable.

1 Stars: Terrible dinner (by by tggobucks at Citysearch)

by tggobucks at Citysearch — Wed, 15 Mar 2006 19:28:51 GMT

we had terrible service, pizza was undercooked and when we mentioned it, the server acted as if we put them out. Will not go back.

5 Stars: A Perfect Place for all (by by pporowski at Citysearch)

by pporowski at Citysearch — Tue, 12 Jul 2005 16:05:18 GMT

Players on Madison is a favorite. My girlfriend and I go about once a month and have never had anything but a wondeful experience. The modern styling is refreshing in an aging area of Lakewood, and the new patio is great for those who enjoy eating outdoors in nice weather. The price is more than reasonable, even ""cheap"" for the service and food received, although there is nothing cheap about this diamond in the rough.

5 Stars: Great Variety and Always Good (by by biscuits at Citysearch)

by biscuits at Citysearch — Wed, 06 Jul 2005 09:00:00 GMT

5 Stars: Always Pleases! (by by mjarail at Citysearch)

by mjarail at Citysearch — Fri, 06 Dec 2002 21:08:07 GMT

My wife and I have been fans of Players on Madison for years. It is amazing that they maintain high standards consistantly. The selection of single malt scotches and small batch bourbons is first rate!

5 Stars: Very impressed!! (by by jandesantis at Citysearch)

by jandesantis at Citysearch — Mon, 28 Oct 2002 15:15:48 GMT

Six of us went last night. I was very impressed. The service was wonderful, decor was beautiful and the food presentation was awesome.

5 Stars: The best gourmet food (by by tomaz at Citysearch)

by tomaz at Citysearch — Mon, 28 Oct 2002 02:58:51 GMT

The best food without the expensiveness. comfortabe, relaxing, service is the best. A great night out. a diverse gathering where you can take anyone. The boss, wife, freind, family, or couples out for the evening.

5 Stars: Great food with Heart & Soul (by by takacst at Citysearch)

by takacst at Citysearch — Fri, 16 Aug 2002 03:12:10 GMT

The staff at Players is wonderful. Natural friendliness and attention to detail to make your dining experience special. Most importantly, the food is fantastic, the chef being especially innovative with seafood.

5 Stars: The Best (by by ritaberg at Citysearch)

by ritaberg at Citysearch — Thu, 08 Aug 2002 18:12:34 GMT

I love Players. I live right around the corner and frequent it often. The service is great and so is the food..

5 Stars: From Tues Date Night Crew (by by amjurey at Citysearch)

by amjurey at Citysearch — Thu, 08 Aug 2002 17:37:19 GMT

Player's is a wonderful restaurant to go to any night of the week. The staff is wonderful and extremely friendly. Tony does an amazing job in coming up with exciting, tasty creations.

I highly recommend the roasted red pepper bisque and Pollo Pesto pizza.