Hickory House Restaurant

★★★★★
  • 7051 E Main St

    Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

    Map & Directions
  • 614-861-5962

About Hickory House Restaurant

Categories
Hours
Sun 1pm-9pm, Mon-Thu 11am-10pm, Fri-Sat 11am-12am

Food

Food
More choices in Reynoldsburg:
Resultset_next

Asian Star China Buffet

2770 Brice Rd Reynoldsburg, OH

Resultset_next

Vick's Pizza

7333 E Main St Reynoldsburg, OH

5.0 20
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Hickory House Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

The Hickory House is a great rib and steak house!

3
★★★★★

The Hickory House is a great rib and steak house!

.

The Hickory House is one of my favorite restaurants! They have great steaks and ribs. Also, some really good new Happy Hour specials! I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a great meal with their family or

3
★★★★★

The Hickory House is one of my favorite restaurants! They have great steaks and ribs. Also, some really good new Happy Hour specials! I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a great meal with their family or

.

I love the family atmosphere of the Hickory House! Their ribs are amazing - the meat falls off the bone. I love their homemade BBQ sauce. The staff is always so friendly and helpful. Having a 2 yr old, we always have extra requests and

3
★★★★★

I love the family atmosphere of the Hickory House! Their ribs are amazing - the meat falls off the bone. I love their homemade BBQ sauce. The staff is always so friendly and helpful. Having a 2 yr old, we always have extra requests and

.

I called to make reservations recently and they told me they don't take reservations at all. It's strictly "first come, first served".\r
\r
Expect to wait no matter when you go there. It might not be long or it could be.\r
\r
The parking

3
★★★★★

I called to make reservations recently and they told me they don't take reservations at all. It's strictly "first come, first served".\r
\r
Expect to wait no matter when you go there. It might not be long or it could be.\r
\r
The parking

.

A group of friends and I do a monthly dinner always trying to find that great new place. Someone within our group came upon a $10.00 coupon for the Hickory House Reynoldsburg. Our decision was made and decided to go on Monday 9-18. It was

3
★★★★★

A group of friends and I do a monthly dinner always trying to find that great new place. Someone within our group came upon a $10.00 coupon for the Hickory House Reynoldsburg. Our decision was made and decided to go on Monday 9-18. It was

.

II am new to Columbus and this forum. I moved from Kansas, and have been looking for a good BBQ joint since our arrival. I found a $10 coupon for the Hickory House and went Friday night to check it out. Boy was I disappointed. Terrible

3
★★★★★

II am new to Columbus and this forum. I moved from Kansas, and have been looking for a good BBQ joint since our arrival. I found a $10 coupon for the Hickory House and went Friday night to check it out. Boy was I disappointed. Terrible

.

After noticing their $10 coupon in the Weekender, we decided to try it. What a great choice! We were disappointed that the coupon did not include the Porterhouse Special - but no big deal - he tried the BBQ ribs instead and LOVED them. I

3
★★★★★

After noticing their $10 coupon in the Weekender, we decided to try it. What a great choice! We were disappointed that the coupon did not include the Porterhouse Special - but no big deal - he tried the BBQ ribs instead and LOVED them. I

.

where to start. seated next to the kitchen entrance when there were many other seats available. salads were warm, brown and wilted, like they were made hours ago. the rolls were cold and hard. the bbq itself was smothered in sauce and

3
★★★★★

where to start. seated next to the kitchen entrance when there were many other seats available. salads were warm, brown and wilted, like they were made hours ago. the rolls were cold and hard. the bbq itself was smothered in sauce and

.

I've been a regular for a very long time at the Hickory House. I've been watching the new improvements since I've heard that Tony's Son-In- law, and Daughter are taking the family business over soon. I love it, they have painted the

3
★★★★★

I've been a regular for a very long time at the Hickory House. I've been watching the new improvements since I've heard that Tony's Son-In- law, and Daughter are taking the family business over soon. I love it, they have painted the

.

We have been regulars at this restaurant for years but something is going on at this location and it isn't good. We ordered take out on one visit and the steak fries were burnt and the salad barely had a handful in the container and what

3
★★★★★

We have been regulars at this restaurant for years but something is going on at this location and it isn't good. We ordered take out on one visit and the steak fries were burnt and the salad barely had a handful in the container and what

.

We got lost and were hungry, saw the building and it looked busy from the outside, (which is usually a good sign that the food should be good, right?). We were seated literally at the door. My husband really resents this in resturants

3
★★★★★

We got lost and were hungry, saw the building and it looked busy from the outside, (which is usually a good sign that the food should be good, right?). We were seated literally at the door. My husband really resents this in resturants

.

OK, so maybe it's me. But, the new manager of the Hickory House, "Hanging" Chad, doesn't like to talk to customers! Really in the Hospitality Business? He does EVERYTHING to avoid making eye contact and not say "HELLO" to customers. Is this for real? No "Hi, Hello" no "Goodbye, Thanks for coming". Really nothing, although he does like to talk to his hostess, a lot!

0
★☆☆☆☆

OK, so maybe it's me. But, the new manager of the Hickory House, "Hanging" Chad, doesn't like to talk to customers! Really in the Hospitality Business? He does EVERYTHING to avoid making eye contact and not say "HELLO" to customers. Is this for real? No "Hi, Hello" no "Goodbye, Thanks for coming". Really nothing, although he does like to talk to his hostess, a lot!

.

BBQ Fanatic. Own my own smoker, and have done competition. While the fare is good, it is not true BBQ. I dont know hows its prepared, but its not smoked. The sauce is good...Im not sure why a "BBQ Joint" wouldnt do true BBQ, especially with good meats and sauce.

Also, the head bartender is a rude jerk.

1
★★☆☆☆

BBQ Fanatic. Own my own smoker, and have done competition. While the fare is good, it is not true BBQ. I dont know hows its prepared, but its not smoked. The sauce is good...Im not sure why a "BBQ Joint" wouldnt do true BBQ, especially with good meats and sauce.

Also, the head bartender is a rude jerk.

Pros: Good eats for being fake

Cons: Not truely smoked

.

Love this place. I would never eat ribs or steak for that matter anywhere else. This place has the best servers, the best bartenders, and the best food!!! Took some friends there and they drive here at least once a month to eat here. They won't go anywhere else for ribs or steak.. My best friend loves the smelt there and no place else. Thanks for being in town. Love you guys.

2
★★★★★

Love this place. I would never eat ribs or steak for that matter anywhere else. This place has the best servers, the best bartenders, and the best food!!! Took some friends there and they drive here at least once a month to eat here. They won't go anywhere else for ribs or steak.. My best friend loves the smelt there and no place else. Thanks for being in town. Love you guys.

Pros: everything

Cons: not enough seating on friday and saturday nights.

.

Love the steak!!!!!!!The ribs are YUM!!!!!!!The service is outstanding!!!!!!!!!The location is o.k. This is by far one of the best places to eat in central Ohio!!!!!!!!!

2
★★★★★

Love the steak!!!!!!!The ribs are YUM!!!!!!!The service is outstanding!!!!!!!!!The location is o.k. This is by far one of the best places to eat in central Ohio!!!!!!!!!

Pros: Tasty!

Cons: NONE

.

The first few bites of anything with the barbeque sauce are delicious, until a few moments later, when I am overwhelmed by the amount of liquid smoke which seems to permeate everything. Unfortunately, these ribs are not SMOKED, they are steamed then grilled, and the smoke flavor you taste is artificial and from a bottle, and it is way over done. Avoid this place and just go to City Barbeque or Hoggy's. You wont be burping liquid smoke for a week at those places.

0
★☆☆☆☆

The first few bites of anything with the barbeque sauce are delicious, until a few moments later, when I am overwhelmed by the amount of liquid smoke which seems to permeate everything. Unfortunately, these ribs are not SMOKED, they are steamed then grilled, and the smoke flavor you taste is artificial and from a bottle, and it is way over done. Avoid this place and just go to City Barbeque or Hoggy's. You wont be burping liquid smoke for a week at those places.

Pros: Friendly service

Cons: Crazy amounts of liquid smoke

.

Hickory House in Reynoldsburg, Ohio is my favorite place to go.
The food is always the same. AWESOME!
The menu, drinks and service are also the greatest. It's easy to sum
Hickory House up in one word. AWESOME!

One of the other reasons my friends and I go there is that we can still smoke if we want.
It's one of the few areas left in Ohio where smokers are welcome.
It will be a sad day for all of us when the no smoking ban goes state wide.

2
★★★★★

Hickory House in Reynoldsburg, Ohio is my favorite place to go.
The food is always the same. AWESOME!
The menu, drinks and service are also the greatest. It's easy to sum
Hickory House up in one word. AWESOME!

One of the other reasons my friends and I go there is that we can still smoke if we want.
It's one of the few areas left in Ohio where smokers are welcome.
It will be a sad day for all of us when the no smoking ban goes state wide.

Pros: Everything!

Cons: None

.

This is where I go when I want good ribs! In fact, I go to Hickory House for my birthday dinner every year, and a few times between b-days too. My family just loves the food, from my 74 yr old grandparents to my 4 yr old son. There's something for everyone- I love the ribs & shrimp, my husband loves the steak & the french onion soup is a favorite for the entire family. They serve a basic iceberg salad, but add chinese noodles instead of croutons for a twist. The fresh-baked bread is mouth watering, and the desserts are delicous! Great service, low lighting, good for a quiet night out, or a large gathering- they have room for all!!!! Hickory House is a must if you like ribs! Forget about Montgomery Inn in Cincy- it's not even close!!

2
★★★★★

This is where I go when I want good ribs! In fact, I go to Hickory House for my birthday dinner every year, and a few times between b-days too. My family just loves the food, from my 74 yr old grandparents to my 4 yr old son. There's something for everyone- I love the ribs & shrimp, my husband loves the steak & the french onion soup is a favorite for the entire family. They serve a basic iceberg salad, but add chinese noodles instead of croutons for a twist. The fresh-baked bread is mouth watering, and the desserts are delicous! Great service, low lighting, good for a quiet night out, or a large gathering- they have room for all!!!! Hickory House is a must if you like ribs! Forget about Montgomery Inn in Cincy- it's not even close!!

Pros: great food

Cons: a little pricey, avoid Fri/Sat

.

We first tried this place a year ago. Dont know why we waited so long...have been here no less than 10 times. ALWAYS the service is superb, and the steaks divine. The bread is the best in town...And the crab stuffed mushrooms are awesome. This place has never let me down. The only thing I have not cared for is their ceasar dressing. Too oily for me. Everything else is always great, but the service is tops.

2
★★★★★

We first tried this place a year ago. Dont know why we waited so long...have been here no less than 10 times. ALWAYS the service is superb, and the steaks divine. The bread is the best in town...And the crab stuffed mushrooms are awesome. This place has never let me down. The only thing I have not cared for is their ceasar dressing. Too oily for me. Everything else is always great, but the service is tops.

Pros: great food, great service

Cons: long waits at times, Bar is small

.

Forget about all those high price places. This is the place for steaks and ribs. The top in FranklinCounty.

2
★★★★★

Forget about all those high price places. This is the place for steaks and ribs. The top in FranklinCounty.

Pros: food, quality, people

Cons: none

Message from Hickory House Restaurant

Our customers enter our doors as our guests and leave as our family. We are truly a family owned and operated business. The founder's daughter/son-in-law(Reynoldsburg), and nephew(Gahanna) are now carrying on that family tradition. We are three decades strong and the tradition continues. Thank you J.D., dreams do come true.

More about Hickory House Restaurant

In 1978 two wacky bartenders decided to go into the restaurant business. Why not? How hard could it be? Restaurants were crowded; people would wait in line for hours to get good food. Well, hard it was! After a few years of falling all over themselves, they discovered the magic, QUALITY. All great products are built on it, and quality it would be. Right then and there they vowed that everything they sold would be made from the absolute best products available. That one decision has been the true success of this restaurant. Quality caused employees to stay and become good at their jobs. Quality caused customers to come back again and again. Quality is why the Hickory House has been in business since 1979. That high level of quality and family tradition, are what keep us going.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Hickory House Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review