Columbus Fish Market

★★★★☆
  • 1245 Olentangy River Rd

    Columbus, OH 43212

    Map & Directions
  • 614-291-3474

About Columbus Fish Market

Categories
  • Restaurants
  • Seafood Restaurants
  • Fine Dining
  • Steakhouse Restaurants
Details
  • $$$$
  • Dine At The Bar
  • Group Dining
  • Notable Wine List
Hours
M-Th 11am-10pm, F-Sa 11am-11pm, Su 11am-9pm
Reservations
Make A Reservation
Emails
  • micg@ldry.com
Year Established
  • 1998
Keywords
  • seafood restaurant
  • best seafood restaurant in columbus
  • best restaurant
  • happy hour
Products
  • Seafood Restaurant
  • Fresh Fish
  • Fresh Seafood
  • Cocktails
Specialties
  • Sam Adams Beer Seafood Specialities
  • Shellfish
  • Specialty FIsh
  • Fresh Fish
  • Seafood Combos
  • Crab Cakes
  • Oysters
Payment Options
  • American Express
  • Discover
  • Visa
  • Cash
  • MasterCard
  • Diners Club

Food

Food
More choices in Columbus:
Resultset_next

Seafood Fresh Limited

3589 Refugee Rd Columbus, OH

Resultset_next

Tenkai Seafood Restaurant

1159 Old Henderson Rd. Columbus, OH

4.4286 14
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Columbus Fish Market was?
Write a Review
.

Not worth one star. Food was awful. Sent one steak back that was under cooked, it came back over cooked. Another steak that was 'medium' was so rare it was rubbery and raw. Scallops were over done and tasted like rubber. Hamburger was dry

3
★★★★★

Not worth one star. Food was awful. Sent one steak back that was under cooked, it came back over cooked. Another steak that was 'medium' was so rare it was rubbery and raw. Scallops were over done and tasted like rubber. Hamburger was dry

.

i used to visit the fish market alot when i lived in columbus, but that was years ago. the other day i chose to have dinner there and was really disapointed the fish was not very fresh at all, and i really cant say that anybodys plate at

3
★★★★★

i used to visit the fish market alot when i lived in columbus, but that was years ago. the other day i chose to have dinner there and was really disapointed the fish was not very fresh at all, and i really cant say that anybodys plate at

.

Good seafood, all fresh water fish, very tasty, very exotic. The most exotic fish you'll find in columbus! Don't come here with half-hearted pockets! You pay for what you want here, real good stuff!

4
★★★★☆

Good seafood, all fresh water fish, very tasty, very exotic. The most exotic fish you'll find in columbus! Don't come here with half-hearted pockets! You pay for what you want here, real good stuff!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This is your typical Cameron Mitchell restaurant. High profile, trendy atmosphere, pricey food - poor service, bland meals - even the dessert lacked! I don't mind paying a lot for a dinner, but the value/quality for your money is just not there. I went at lunch time, it was not busy and my service was still terrible. My fish came out lukewarm, hushpuppies were mushy/raw-like, I could not get anyones attention to fix the problems, so I left most of my meal and hoped for a filling dessert. My dessert was not at all worth the calories, so I left it - the server didn't even notice it was untouched. I later emailed the restaurant to voice my disappointment and got NO followup email or phone call to even apologize for my experience.

0
★☆☆☆☆

This is your typical Cameron Mitchell restaurant. High profile, trendy atmosphere, pricey food - poor service, bland meals - even the dessert lacked! I don't mind paying a lot for a dinner, but the value/quality for your money is just not there. I went at lunch time, it was not busy and my service was still terrible. My fish came out lukewarm, hushpuppies were mushy/raw-like, I could not get anyones attention to fix the problems, so I left most of my meal and hoped for a filling dessert. My dessert was not at all worth the calories, so I left it - the server didn't even notice it was untouched. I later emailed the restaurant to voice my disappointment and got NO followup email or phone call to even apologize for my experience.

Pros: Good for name-dropping, I suppose.

Cons: Cold food, bland food, poor service.

.

The staff was friendly, the food delicious, and I will definitely be making another trip. I recommend the appetizer shrimp. They are wrapped in bacon with barbecue sauce and rice. Yum! Add this place to your list of "must visit" places in Columbus!

2
★★★★★

The staff was friendly, the food delicious, and I will definitely be making another trip. I recommend the appetizer shrimp. They are wrapped in bacon with barbecue sauce and rice. Yum! Add this place to your list of "must visit" places in Columbus!

Pros: Delicious food, prompt service

Cons: None!

.

I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!

2
★★★★★

I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!I love Seafood!

Pros: Good Seafood

Cons: Not Enough Seafood

.

Nice fresh raw bar, the oyesters are great. You can order fish just about any way you like it or a predefined entree that they've perfected. One suggestion is to get multiple appetizers and split an entree.

PROS: Great raw bar
CONS: Pricey

4
★★★★☆

Nice fresh raw bar, the oyesters are great. You can order fish just about any way you like it or a predefined entree that they've perfected. One suggestion is to get multiple appetizers and split an entree.

PROS: Great raw bar
CONS: Pricey

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I tried the platter where you could choose 3 different types of fish cooked any way you want - it was difficult to decide a favorite. I typically only eat shell-fish, but the fish I received was even better. My favorite was the grilled Tilapia - excellent!

2
★★★★★

I tried the platter where you could choose 3 different types of fish cooked any way you want - it was difficult to decide a favorite. I typically only eat shell-fish, but the fish I received was even better. My favorite was the grilled Tilapia - excellent!

.

The drinks were great. I had the Ciroc Vodka drink they had, my husband and our friend had margarita's and bloody marys. They said they were great as well. I had the Chilean Sea Bass which was so good, I want to go back for more. Even driving 2 hours to get there. Service was exceptional, all 5 of us were very impressed. We love dining out and Cameron Mitchell has it down pat. A little noisy in room we were in, but there are other tables you can go to get the ambiance if you need it. Quieter areas for those romantic, and areas good for families. Place was packed, recommend reservations.

2
★★★★★

The drinks were great. I had the Ciroc Vodka drink they had, my husband and our friend had margarita's and bloody marys. They said they were great as well. I had the Chilean Sea Bass which was so good, I want to go back for more. Even driving 2 hours to get there. Service was exceptional, all 5 of us were very impressed. We love dining out and Cameron Mitchell has it down pat. A little noisy in room we were in, but there are other tables you can go to get the ambiance if you need it. Quieter areas for those romantic, and areas good for families. Place was packed, recommend reservations.

Pros: Food, Service, Drinks

Cons: Noise

.

I liked everything about the place except the food. I really thought it was nothing exceptional at all. Despite requesting that my tuna be well done, it arrived pink in the center. The veggie sides were virtually raw also. I wouldn't go back.

1
★★★☆☆

I liked everything about the place except the food. I really thought it was nothing exceptional at all. Despite requesting that my tuna be well done, it arrived pink in the center. The veggie sides were virtually raw also. I wouldn't go back.

Pros: Nice location

Cons: Average food

.

This restaurant has consistently had great food. The seafood is fresh and well prepared. The service is very accomadating to switching side dishes. I would recomment this restaurant for special occasions, because the servers are very attentive and it is expensive.

5
★★★★★

This restaurant has consistently had great food. The seafood is fresh and well prepared. The service is very accomadating to switching side dishes. I would recomment this restaurant for special occasions, because the servers are very attentive and it is expensive.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The food at Columbus Fish Market is fabulous!! They have several different ways to order the fish you like. For instance if you like Halibut, you can have it grilled, broiled, etc. and then you get to choose the type of flavor you would like, smoked, tropical, peppered, etc. They have wonderful desserts also. Their service is great! This is one of my favorite places to eat, however expect to go there and spend app. $20-30 a meal, it is completely worth it.

5
★★★★★

The food at Columbus Fish Market is fabulous!! They have several different ways to order the fish you like. For instance if you like Halibut, you can have it grilled, broiled, etc. and then you get to choose the type of flavor you would like, smoked, tropical, peppered, etc. They have wonderful desserts also. Their service is great! This is one of my favorite places to eat, however expect to go there and spend app. $20-30 a meal, it is completely worth it.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I'm from the East Coast and I've never tasted seafood like this in the Midwest~! I have to eat there once a week or I start to have withdrawals@! The servers are extremely knowledgeable and help tremendously.

2
★★★★★

I'm from the East Coast and I've never tasted seafood like this in the Midwest~! I have to eat there once a week or I start to have withdrawals@! The servers are extremely knowledgeable and help tremendously.

.

I went here several times and I don't think that their quality of the food is good. It just taste like an average seafood. If you want the real seafood, Fisherman's Wharf is your choice. It's way better that Fish Market.

1
★★★☆☆

I went here several times and I don't think that their quality of the food is good. It just taste like an average seafood. If you want the real seafood, Fisherman's Wharf is your choice. It's way better that Fish Market.

Message from Columbus Fish Market

Columbus Fish Market is an upscale-casual seafood restaurant concept featuring fresh seafood specialties. Columbus Fish Market has a raw bar, open kitchen, retail fish case displaying today’s catch for purchase and a customized cutting room and offers a variety of seafood options including grilled or broiled, blackened, cooked Shanghai style or prepared to your taste. Gluten free and kids menus are also available.

Yext PowerListings

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Columbus Fish Market, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review