Incredible Pizza Co

★★☆☆☆
  • 391 W Main St

    Newark, OH 43055

    Map & Directions
  • 740-345-4455

About Incredible Pizza Co

Hours
Mon. - Sat. 4am - 4pm;Sun. 4am - 2am

Food

Food
More choices in Newark:
Resultset_next

Pizza Pro

1 Redbird Dr Batesville, AR

Resultset_next

Pizza Express

325 S Locust St Newark, AR

2.1667 6
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Incredible Pizza Co was?
Write a Review
.

Bad location, but absolutely great pizza! A pizza that we always order when friends are over and out of town guess ask for too.

5
★★★★★

Bad location, but absolutely great pizza! A pizza that we always order when friends are over and out of town guess ask for too.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The first. Time I went to incredible pizza I was wasted so I thought I would give it a chitance sober, Big mistake it tasted like cardboard and the worker was putting his armpitt on the dough roller. They should change the name to regrettable pizza even if your really hungry it would be better to starve ...

1
★☆☆☆☆

The first. Time I went to incredible pizza I was wasted so I thought I would give it a chitance sober, Big mistake it tasted like cardboard and the worker was putting his armpitt on the dough roller. They should change the name to regrettable pizza even if your really hungry it would be better to starve ...

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS COMPANY!!!

My brother ordered a pizza tonight from this place. An hour later, it had still not arrived. He called to check on it and the woman on the phone (who later claimed to be the manager) told him he had ordered at 9:46 and it was only a little after 10. He hung up and then realized that, no, it was actually almost 11, so he called back. She then proceeds to tell him that they had the address wrong and that the pizza had come back. They hadn't even bothered to call and let him know that. He requests a discount or for them to make new pizzas.

The "manager" says she would have to call him back and hung up. She didn't call back and so he called back ANOTHER time and after a lot of run around on her part, he asks to speak to her boss. He explains the problem to the guy who came on the line and this guy also refused to make any kind of reparation. When asked why he wasn't contacted about the address, the guy tries to tell him they ALSO GOT HIS NUMBER WRONG.

So there were two mistakes (allegedly) by the company and they didn't offer so much as an apology for such poor service.

1
★☆☆☆☆

DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS COMPANY!!!

My brother ordered a pizza tonight from this place. An hour later, it had still not arrived. He called to check on it and the woman on the phone (who later claimed to be the manager) told him he had ordered at 9:46 and it was only a little after 10. He hung up and then realized that, no, it was actually almost 11, so he called back. She then proceeds to tell him that they had the address wrong and that the pizza had come back. They hadn't even bothered to call and let him know that. He requests a discount or for them to make new pizzas.

The "manager" says she would have to call him back and hung up. She didn't call back and so he called back ANOTHER time and after a lot of run around on her part, he asks to speak to her boss. He explains the problem to the guy who came on the line and this guy also refused to make any kind of reparation. When asked why he wasn't contacted about the address, the guy tries to tell him they ALSO GOT HIS NUMBER WRONG.

So there were two mistakes (allegedly) by the company and they didn't offer so much as an apology for such poor service.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I ORDERED pizza from INCREDIBLE PIZZA 01/18/11 AND THAT WAS THE FIRST TIME IN YEARS SINCE IVE ORDERED FROM THERE BECAUSE THE FOOD WAS HORRIBLE!!! BUT IT CAME HIGHLY RECOMMENDED SO WE TRIED IT AND IT WAS VERY GOOD SO WE ORDERED AGAIN ON 01/28/11 AND IT WAS COLD AND NOT MADE WITH THE EXTRA CHEESE LIKE WE ORDERED AND IT WAS NOT VERY HOT LIKE IT SHOULD OF BEEN I WAS VERY DISAPPOINTED SO I CALLED IN AND THE MAN THAT I TALKED TO WAS VERY NICE AND SAID HE WAS SORRY AND AND WOULD GET A REPLACEMENT SENT OUT RIGHT AWAY WELL ONE HR AND 45 MIN WENT BY SO I CALLED BACK TO CHECK ON THE STATUS OF OUR REPLACEMENT AND I SPOKE WITH THE SO CALLED MANAGER FOR THE NIGHT HIS NAME WAS TRACY HE WAS VERY VERY RUDE AND CALLED ME A LAIR COMPLETELY UNPROFESSIONAL AND REFUSED TO EVEN REALLY LISTEN SO I ASKED FOR HIS BOSSES NAME AND HE DIDNT WANT TO GIVE IT TO ME I ASKED 3 TIMES AND HE FINALLY GAVE ME HIS NAME AND IT CURT HE ALSO SAID THE HE WAS NOT GOING TO MAKE IT RIGHT AND HUNG UP ON ME!! I KNOW IF THAT WAS MY BUSINESS AND ONE OF MY MANAGERS TALKED TO A CUSTOMER THE WAY HE TALKED TO ME HE WOULD SEE DISCIPLINARY ACTION MAYBE EVEN LOSE HIS JOB TITLE OR JOB ITS SELF BECAUSE IF IT WASNT FOR THE CUSTOMERS NO ONE WOULD HAVE A JOB!!I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THEM AGAIN BECAUSE OF HOW I WAS TREATED AND I DO INTEND TO FILE A COMPLAINT AGAINST TRACY WITH THE BETTER BUSINESS BEAU FIRST THING MONDAY I DO ADMIT THE MY CHILDREN WENT AHEAD AND ATE AND THINK GOD THAT THEY DID BECAUSE TWO HOURS WE WAITED AND HEARD NOT ONE WORD FROM THEM I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND THEM TO ANTONE UNLESS THEY LIKE DEALING WITH A RUDE AND DISRESPECTFUL ENVIRONMENT!!!

1
★☆☆☆☆

I ORDERED pizza from INCREDIBLE PIZZA 01/18/11 AND THAT WAS THE FIRST TIME IN YEARS SINCE IVE ORDERED FROM THERE BECAUSE THE FOOD WAS HORRIBLE!!! BUT IT CAME HIGHLY RECOMMENDED SO WE TRIED IT AND IT WAS VERY GOOD SO WE ORDERED AGAIN ON 01/28/11 AND IT WAS COLD AND NOT MADE WITH THE EXTRA CHEESE LIKE WE ORDERED AND IT WAS NOT VERY HOT LIKE IT SHOULD OF BEEN I WAS VERY DISAPPOINTED SO I CALLED IN AND THE MAN THAT I TALKED TO WAS VERY NICE AND SAID HE WAS SORRY AND AND WOULD GET A REPLACEMENT SENT OUT RIGHT AWAY WELL ONE HR AND 45 MIN WENT BY SO I CALLED BACK TO CHECK ON THE STATUS OF OUR REPLACEMENT AND I SPOKE WITH THE SO CALLED MANAGER FOR THE NIGHT HIS NAME WAS TRACY HE WAS VERY VERY RUDE AND CALLED ME A LAIR COMPLETELY UNPROFESSIONAL AND REFUSED TO EVEN REALLY LISTEN SO I ASKED FOR HIS BOSSES NAME AND HE DIDNT WANT TO GIVE IT TO ME I ASKED 3 TIMES AND HE FINALLY GAVE ME HIS NAME AND IT CURT HE ALSO SAID THE HE WAS NOT GOING TO MAKE IT RIGHT AND HUNG UP ON ME!! I KNOW IF THAT WAS MY BUSINESS AND ONE OF MY MANAGERS TALKED TO A CUSTOMER THE WAY HE TALKED TO ME HE WOULD SEE DISCIPLINARY ACTION MAYBE EVEN LOSE HIS JOB TITLE OR JOB ITS SELF BECAUSE IF IT WASNT FOR THE CUSTOMERS NO ONE WOULD HAVE A JOB!!I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THEM AGAIN BECAUSE OF HOW I WAS TREATED AND I DO INTEND TO FILE A COMPLAINT AGAINST TRACY WITH THE BETTER BUSINESS BEAU FIRST THING MONDAY I DO ADMIT THE MY CHILDREN WENT AHEAD AND ATE AND THINK GOD THAT THEY DID BECAUSE TWO HOURS WE WAITED AND HEARD NOT ONE WORD FROM THEM I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND THEM TO ANTONE UNLESS THEY LIKE DEALING WITH A RUDE AND DISRESPECTFUL ENVIRONMENT!!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

They're open until 4:00am and say they do most of their business between Midnight and 4:00am. It's pretty darned tasty, and the late-night availability brings it up a notch in our book. It's a 2-for-1 place, so you get a good bit for the money, too.

They're reviewed twice here - I had one under Incredible Pizza Co. The reviews need to be consolidated and the Insider Pages search feature revamped. It didn't find this record when I did my review. I had to find it again via Google.

PROS: Open late
CONS: Not as good as Christy's, but I don't think it's their mission. ;)

3
★★★☆☆

They're open until 4:00am and say they do most of their business between Midnight and 4:00am. It's pretty darned tasty, and the late-night availability brings it up a notch in our book. It's a 2-for-1 place, so you get a good bit for the money, too.

They're reviewed twice here - I had one under Incredible Pizza Co. The reviews need to be consolidated and the Insider Pages search feature revamped. It didn't find this record when I did my review. I had to find it again via Google.

PROS: Open late
CONS: Not as good as Christy's, but I don't think it's their mission. ;)

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

well if your not really drunk or something i would not recommend going anywhere near this stuff. if your arleady smashed though man dig in. its cheap and theyre open until 4 in the morning for a reason you know what im saying haha. used to be erics two for one pizza i dont know if they still got the twofer deal or what.

2
★★☆☆☆

well if your not really drunk or something i would not recommend going anywhere near this stuff. if your arleady smashed though man dig in. its cheap and theyre open until 4 in the morning for a reason you know what im saying haha. used to be erics two for one pizza i dont know if they still got the twofer deal or what.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Incredible Pizza Co, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review