Jimmy's Pizza

★★★★★
  • 1484 Oakland Park Ave

    Columbus, OH 43224

    Map & Directions
  • 614-263-2678

About Jimmy's Pizza

Food

Food
More choices in Columbus:
Resultset_next

Pizza Hut

1716 S 4th St. Nashville, AR

Resultset_next

Domino's Pizza

1002 S Main St Hope, AR

4.8333 12
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Jimmy's Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

Place is closed

3
★★★★★

Place is closed

.

Me and my family have been trying local pizza shops since moving here, Jimmies is the best we've had so far. Very good sauce and pepperoni. Fast friendly and clean service. Highly recommend it

2
★★★★☆

Me and my family have been trying local pizza shops since moving here, Jimmies is the best we've had so far. Very good sauce and pepperoni. Fast friendly and clean service. Highly recommend it

Pros: Very good pizza

.

This place has been a dream for our family, timing was everything..We all appreciate all your kind words and know that we put our special brand on "Every" pizza.. thank you for eating Jimmy's.. see or talk to you soon!

2
★★★★★

This place has been a dream for our family, timing was everything..We all appreciate all your kind words and know that we put our special brand on "Every" pizza.. thank you for eating Jimmy's.. see or talk to you soon!

Pros: we love you too

.

After having your delicious pizza I am spell bound and have to come again. I would also like to thank you for the excellent customer service.I have told all my friends and coworkers.

3
★★★☆☆

After having your delicious pizza I am spell bound and have to come again. I would also like to thank you for the excellent customer service.I have told all my friends and coworkers.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

For years I have lived very close and drove past Jimmy's wondering if I should check it out. All the mediocre pizza I have had from other places when I could have been eating this instead! As Homer S. would say ... DOH!
Seriously, If you live anywhere on the north end it is worth the short drive. Very comparable to Rotolos in Grandview. Chain places like to say what high quality ingredients they use but this place proves it. You don't get this at a chain restaurant.

2
★★★★★

For years I have lived very close and drove past Jimmy's wondering if I should check it out. All the mediocre pizza I have had from other places when I could have been eating this instead! As Homer S. would say ... DOH!
Seriously, If you live anywhere on the north end it is worth the short drive. Very comparable to Rotolos in Grandview. Chain places like to say what high quality ingredients they use but this place proves it. You don't get this at a chain restaurant.

Pros: Delivery, High Quality, Friendly

Cons: Small, Busy

.

I hadn't heard of Jimmy's till I met my significant other 3 years ago; Now, I won't go anywhere else. When I go to another pizza restaurant, the bar is set high at JImmy's and I haven't found a single place to beat it yet. The subs are delicious; the pizza is perfection (especially the Meaty Pie) and the people are great.

2
★★★★★

I hadn't heard of Jimmy's till I met my significant other 3 years ago; Now, I won't go anywhere else. When I go to another pizza restaurant, the bar is set high at JImmy's and I haven't found a single place to beat it yet. The subs are delicious; the pizza is perfection (especially the Meaty Pie) and the people are great.

.

I've lived in Columbus since 1985 & I've finally found the promised land. Jimmy's provides a thin, crisp crust, wonderfully spicy but not too spicy pepperoni & a sauce that sings with layers of flavor. A delivery pizza that tasted like it just came out of the pizza oven.

2
★★★★★

I've lived in Columbus since 1985 & I've finally found the promised land. Jimmy's provides a thin, crisp crust, wonderfully spicy but not too spicy pepperoni & a sauce that sings with layers of flavor. A delivery pizza that tasted like it just came out of the pizza oven.

.

Jimmy's Pies are by far the absolute best pizza you can find in the Mid-West. How do I know? Before moving to Columbus (to go to school) I spent 10 years in the family pizza business on the East Coast. My families pizza shop has been in business since 1956 and still uses coal fired ovens. Whenever my family visits they insist on eating pies at Jimmys. My family and I are very picky about our Pizza and Jimmys exceeds our expectations everytime. Our Hats Are Off!!!

2
★★★★★

Jimmy's Pies are by far the absolute best pizza you can find in the Mid-West. How do I know? Before moving to Columbus (to go to school) I spent 10 years in the family pizza business on the East Coast. My families pizza shop has been in business since 1956 and still uses coal fired ovens. Whenever my family visits they insist on eating pies at Jimmys. My family and I are very picky about our Pizza and Jimmys exceeds our expectations everytime. Our Hats Are Off!!!

.

Diamond in the rough. Drive right by the generic Donatos, and enjoy a made by scratch pizza pie at Jimmy's. My family and I have dined there twice, and both experiences were very positive. The thin, crunchy crust is complimented nicely by a slightly sweet sauce (there's a Sicilian influence somewhere in there). Good cheese (not too greasy) and the right kind of pepperoni...not the large, plastic kind, but the thick spicy kind that curls up when it cooks. Subs are good, and the Nova buffalo wings very tasty. The place is immaculate. I think that they are open for lunch too. Great stuff!!

2
★★★★★

Diamond in the rough. Drive right by the generic Donatos, and enjoy a made by scratch pizza pie at Jimmy's. My family and I have dined there twice, and both experiences were very positive. The thin, crunchy crust is complimented nicely by a slightly sweet sauce (there's a Sicilian influence somewhere in there). Good cheese (not too greasy) and the right kind of pepperoni...not the large, plastic kind, but the thick spicy kind that curls up when it cooks. Subs are good, and the Nova buffalo wings very tasty. The place is immaculate. I think that they are open for lunch too. Great stuff!!

Pros: Clean, Friendly, Quality Ingredients

.

I used to live in Columbus. Now I live in West Palm Beach, Florida. There's good pizza here but not as good as Jimmy's Pizza. I crave their pizza. If you like their pizza try their subs, excellent !!!

2
★★★★★

I used to live in Columbus. Now I live in West Palm Beach, Florida. There's good pizza here but not as good as Jimmy's Pizza. I crave their pizza. If you like their pizza try their subs, excellent !!!

Pros: Excellent pizza, great tasting subs, family environment

.

Jimmy's has a butt kicking pie. The sause is kinda sweet with a real spicy pep. The crust is thin and yummy. They are addicting especially the dessert pizza. I have gained 10 pounds since I found Jimmy's. The dining room is small but quaint. I live on the east side but drive to Jimmy's often. This place is the best kept secret in town.

2
★★★★★

Jimmy's has a butt kicking pie. The sause is kinda sweet with a real spicy pep. The crust is thin and yummy. They are addicting especially the dessert pizza. I have gained 10 pounds since I found Jimmy's. The dining room is small but quaint. I live on the east side but drive to Jimmy's often. This place is the best kept secret in town.

Pros: Inexpensive, Lots of toppings, cheesy

.

Jimmy's has the best pizza in Columbus. Very clean with plenty of sports memorabilia. The staff is pleasant, the subs are also very good. Worth the drive.

2
★★★★★

Jimmy's has the best pizza in Columbus. Very clean with plenty of sports memorabilia. The staff is pleasant, the subs are also very good. Worth the drive.

Pros: Quality, Clean, Fast

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Jimmy's Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review