Columbus Fish Market - CLOSED

★★★★★
  • 40 Hutchinson Ave

    Columbus, OH 43235

    Map & Directions
  • 614-410-3474

About Columbus Fish Market

Hours
Mon. - Fri. 11:30am - 10pm;Sat. 4pm - 11pm;Sun. 4pm - 9pm

Food

Food
More choices in Columbus:
Resultset_next

Fisherman's Cove

1433 Mine St Nashville, AR

Resultset_next

Catfish Den

2504 N Hazel St Hope, AK

4.8333 12
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Columbus Fish Market was?
Write a Review
.

My wife and I try to go here everytime we are in Columbus. The food is execellent and never disappointing. When your travels can't take you to either coast, this is the best alternative hands down.

2
★★★★★

My wife and I try to go here everytime we are in Columbus. The food is execellent and never disappointing. When your travels can't take you to either coast, this is the best alternative hands down.

.

My wife and I always have a very good meal while here. We are on the south beach diet and the servers were greatly accomodating to us with changing to veggies versus potatoes.
Always make a reservation (opentable dot com takes 2 minutes) because they have alot of walk ins. Atmosphere is busy, but not loud.

2
★★★★★

My wife and I always have a very good meal while here. We are on the south beach diet and the servers were greatly accomodating to us with changing to veggies versus potatoes.
Always make a reservation (opentable dot com takes 2 minutes) because they have alot of walk ins. Atmosphere is busy, but not loud.

Pros: great fish and large selection of seafood,quick service but not rushed

Cons: pricey

.

Had heard about the Columbus Fish Market but got the chance to try it out during lunch with a friend recently. The ambience was great, fish was fresh and cooked as requested. The waiteress was very attentive to detail and hospitable. Would recommend it highly if you are in the mood for fish.

The one thing that I would change if possible is the ability to control the volume of the music being played.

2
★★★★★

Had heard about the Columbus Fish Market but got the chance to try it out during lunch with a friend recently. The ambience was great, fish was fresh and cooked as requested. The waiteress was very attentive to detail and hospitable. Would recommend it highly if you are in the mood for fish.

The one thing that I would change if possible is the ability to control the volume of the music being played.

.

Given the fact that the Fish Market is a Mitchell restaurant you know right off the bat that you are in for a good experience. As a person not inclined to like seafood, I absolutely love this place. It is right near the top of my list of places to go on a special occasion.

The food (surf and turf) is top notch, there is a great beer and wine list and the atmosphere is excellent. It is on the pricey side but well worth it. The menu changes daily as do the specials because the restaurant gets fresh shipments every day.

Unlike the other Columbus location, it is a little easier to get reservations here.

All in all this place is highly recommended,

2
★★★★★

Given the fact that the Fish Market is a Mitchell restaurant you know right off the bat that you are in for a good experience. As a person not inclined to like seafood, I absolutely love this place. It is right near the top of my list of places to go on a special occasion.

The food (surf and turf) is top notch, there is a great beer and wine list and the atmosphere is excellent. It is on the pricey side but well worth it. The menu changes daily as do the specials because the restaurant gets fresh shipments every day.

Unlike the other Columbus location, it is a little easier to get reservations here.

All in all this place is highly recommended,

Pros: Excellent seafood

.

I think this is one of the better places to get seafood considering we are land locked (and I don't think of Lake Erie as anything close to a major water source). You can get fairly fresh seafood from the Fish Market and it's a good sized portion of it too!

2
★★★★★

I think this is one of the better places to get seafood considering we are land locked (and I don't think of Lake Erie as anything close to a major water source). You can get fairly fresh seafood from the Fish Market and it's a good sized portion of it too!

Pros: Good for Columbus

Cons: Seafood always tastes better by the ocean

.

The food is consistently tasty and the presetnation is wonderful. There are tasty daily specials offered at a good value. The portions are great. This is a favorite.

5
★★★★★

The food is consistently tasty and the presetnation is wonderful. There are tasty daily specials offered at a good value. The portions are great. This is a favorite.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The seafood at Columbus Fish Market is as fresh as you will find! It is just like being on the east coast! When I want a nice dinner out - FIsh Market is always my first choice!

5
★★★★★

The seafood at Columbus Fish Market is as fresh as you will find! It is just like being on the east coast! When I want a nice dinner out - FIsh Market is always my first choice!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The Ocean Club is one of my favorite places to stop at on date nights with my husband. The food is delicious and the menu offers a nice variety of different seafoods and appetizers. They are on the pricey side, but as a once in a while place, it's definitely worth the money.

The Columbus FIsh Market also has a counter inside the restaurant where you can purchase fresh fishes and seasonings if you wish to take it home and cook yourself.

Mitchell's Steakhouse was extremely disappointing. Save the money and go to Longhorn.

PROS: Comfortable atmosphere, great for trying to impress.
CONS: Can be difficult to get seats without reservations, pricey.

4
★★★★☆

The Ocean Club is one of my favorite places to stop at on date nights with my husband. The food is delicious and the menu offers a nice variety of different seafoods and appetizers. They are on the pricey side, but as a once in a while place, it's definitely worth the money.

The Columbus FIsh Market also has a counter inside the restaurant where you can purchase fresh fishes and seasonings if you wish to take it home and cook yourself.

Mitchell's Steakhouse was extremely disappointing. Save the money and go to Longhorn.

PROS: Comfortable atmosphere, great for trying to impress.
CONS: Can be difficult to get seats without reservations, pricey.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

living in central Ohio I miss the ocean!!! . .I live by the rule "can I see an ocean?" - -meaing if i can't then why would i order seafood - - -well this resturant is the best seafood I have had not being near an ocean . . it is all freash and very well prepared!! . . .no salt air - - -but a great seafood dinner!! . .their swordfish is stellar!!!!!! . .and the lump meat crab is an outstanding appetizer!!!

2
★★★★★

living in central Ohio I miss the ocean!!! . .I live by the rule "can I see an ocean?" - -meaing if i can't then why would i order seafood - - -well this resturant is the best seafood I have had not being near an ocean . . it is all freash and very well prepared!! . . .no salt air - - -but a great seafood dinner!! . .their swordfish is stellar!!!!!! . .and the lump meat crab is an outstanding appetizer!!!

.

If you're thinking about dining at Columbus Fish Market on the weekend, make reservations! This bustling seafood restaurant is busy for a reason..Fresh fish are flown in daily to be prepared to your liking for dinner, or to take home from their "fish market" counter.

We've dined here on numerous occasions (on a weeknight and have even risked getting rejected on a Saturday night) and brought family and friends who were visiting from out of town. The preparation and freshness of the food have consistently been top notch.

There is a diverse selection of offerings from fresh malpeque oysters to the best crab cakes in town to a variety of fresh and saltwater fish, which may be prepared blackened, asian style, grilled, whatever suits your fancy. The wine list is actually quite good and offers several good coastal wines which certainly compliment the delicious seafood! P.S. Save room for dessert!

2
★★★★☆

If you're thinking about dining at Columbus Fish Market on the weekend, make reservations! This bustling seafood restaurant is busy for a reason..Fresh fish are flown in daily to be prepared to your liking for dinner, or to take home from their "fish market" counter.

We've dined here on numerous occasions (on a weeknight and have even risked getting rejected on a Saturday night) and brought family and friends who were visiting from out of town. The preparation and freshness of the food have consistently been top notch.

There is a diverse selection of offerings from fresh malpeque oysters to the best crab cakes in town to a variety of fresh and saltwater fish, which may be prepared blackened, asian style, grilled, whatever suits your fancy. The wine list is actually quite good and offers several good coastal wines which certainly compliment the delicious seafood! P.S. Save room for dessert!

Pros: Freshly flown fish, Diverse menu, Good wine list

Cons: , Need Reservations!, Sit far from party rm

.

When I am in the mood for great seafood this is my first choice. The seafood is fresh tasting and delicious. Appetizer salad of tomato's and mozzarella is fantastic. Desserts are also delicious. Staff of the restaurant are always friendly and attentive.

2
★★★★★

When I am in the mood for great seafood this is my first choice. The seafood is fresh tasting and delicious. Appetizer salad of tomato's and mozzarella is fantastic. Desserts are also delicious. Staff of the restaurant are always friendly and attentive.

Pros: Good Parking

.

Columbus Fish Market is my first choice whenever I'm craving seafood. The fish is fresh and you can really taste the difference. My favorite is the Shang Hai Salmon - which is steamed and served over sticky rice and spinach. Very yummy and it's actually good for you too. The servers are always extremely friendly and make me feel right at home. It's a great place!

2
★★★★★

Columbus Fish Market is my first choice whenever I'm craving seafood. The fish is fresh and you can really taste the difference. My favorite is the Shang Hai Salmon - which is steamed and served over sticky rice and spinach. Very yummy and it's actually good for you too. The servers are always extremely friendly and make me feel right at home. It's a great place!

Editorial from

The name doesn't quite do the Columbus Fish Market justice; rather, it recollects the noisy, smelly coastal places where you score freshly caught fish to prepare at home. By contrast, this Cameron Mitchell property is loud---and that's…

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Columbus Fish Market, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review