Stone Mill Bbq

★★★★☆
  • 2000 W Reno St

    Broken Arrow, OK 74012

    Map & Directions
  • 918-258-4227

About Stone Mill Bbq

Categories
Hours
Mon. - Sun. 11am - 8:30pm

Food

Food
More choices in Broken Arrow:
Resultset_next

Smokey Bones Barbeque & Grill

9111 E 71st St Tulsa, OK

Resultset_next

Homeland

708 S Aspen Ave Broken Arrow, OK

4.3333 6
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Stone Mill Bbq was?
Write a Review
.

In a city that's being overrun with mediocre chain restaurants, its nice to know you can come to Stone Mill BBQ for some originality. This has been my favorite restaurant in Broken Arrow since it opened, and all the new chains opening have only reaffirmed that.

The BBQ is really fantastic??especially the brisket. It has a very nice flavor with just the right amount of smoke. They have great steaks too. I usually get the filet, though occasionally I go for the sirloin, and I've been really pleased with both. Sometimes I add fried shrimp to my meal, and they are quite tasty too.

The salads are surprisingly good too. Huge portions!

2
★★★★★

In a city that's being overrun with mediocre chain restaurants, its nice to know you can come to Stone Mill BBQ for some originality. This has been my favorite restaurant in Broken Arrow since it opened, and all the new chains opening have only reaffirmed that.

The BBQ is really fantastic??especially the brisket. It has a very nice flavor with just the right amount of smoke. They have great steaks too. I usually get the filet, though occasionally I go for the sirloin, and I've been really pleased with both. Sometimes I add fried shrimp to my meal, and they are quite tasty too.

The salads are surprisingly good too. Huge portions!

Pros: Great steaks, BBQ

Cons: Closed Sunday nights

.

I was expecting a BBQ joint, esp. with all the decor plastered everywhere; nope, just another steakplace serving some lame BBQ; problem is (even in OK) most people don't know good BBQ even if it smacked them n' the face; they offer decnt sauces to make up for their lack of any substancial smoke ring on the meat; oh just to make a good show for bbq they throw the only brother in the joint behind a window in the kitchen cutting the bbq; what a joke!

0
★☆☆☆☆

I was expecting a BBQ joint, esp. with all the decor plastered everywhere; nope, just another steakplace serving some lame BBQ; problem is (even in OK) most people don't know good BBQ even if it smacked them n' the face; they offer decnt sauces to make up for their lack of any substancial smoke ring on the meat; oh just to make a good show for bbq they throw the only brother in the joint behind a window in the kitchen cutting the bbq; what a joke!

.

There are so many ways to eat and serve BBQ. Stone Mill makes BBQ a pleasent experience!
The portions are generous, the flavors are excellent, and the service has left me with a smile each time I am there.
You will be happy leaving here. No risks eating here at all!
ENJOY! :)

5
★★★★★

There are so many ways to eat and serve BBQ. Stone Mill makes BBQ a pleasent experience!
The portions are generous, the flavors are excellent, and the service has left me with a smile each time I am there.
You will be happy leaving here. No risks eating here at all!
ENJOY! :)

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This is not just a BBQ restaurant - they offer a delicious variety of grilled and fried shrimp along with a delectable salmon dish. There spinach dip is out of this world - its not like the usual fare you get at chains - its made fresh everyday from a secret recipe - it has a nice little kick to it - Be sure to ask to sit in the lounge (if you are over 21) it has the best atmosphere of the whole place, esp since you dont have to dine with screaming kids. If you go after 5, you get great service in the bar - both servers have been there since the place opened 5 years ago - they make really good drinks too (nice n strong) My favorite menu item is the fillet - it by far is one of the best steaks in tulsa - other than the Ribeye though - most of the steaks are mediocre. The BBQ is some of the best around, not just in Broken Arrow, but in Tulsa, - Im not big on BBQ but when I get it I'm always pleased when I order it. My favorite are the ribs, brisket and pulled pork. The sauce is also fantastic, comes in Mild n Spicy. Another nice thing is if something doesnt come out to my liking they are very accommodating and pleasant and will fix whatever is wrong and they definitely take care of you.
The decor is very interesting and very fun to look at, many different styles and lots of antiques and stuffed animals etc...It is locally owned by a husband and wife and its nice to go to a quite atmosphere along with supporting small businesses - All of the surrounding hotels recommend it as a great place to eat - plus its in walking distance of the hotels if you want to have a few drinks after a long business trip.

2
★★★★★

This is not just a BBQ restaurant - they offer a delicious variety of grilled and fried shrimp along with a delectable salmon dish. There spinach dip is out of this world - its not like the usual fare you get at chains - its made fresh everyday from a secret recipe - it has a nice little kick to it - Be sure to ask to sit in the lounge (if you are over 21) it has the best atmosphere of the whole place, esp since you dont have to dine with screaming kids. If you go after 5, you get great service in the bar - both servers have been there since the place opened 5 years ago - they make really good drinks too (nice n strong) My favorite menu item is the fillet - it by far is one of the best steaks in tulsa - other than the Ribeye though - most of the steaks are mediocre. The BBQ is some of the best around, not just in Broken Arrow, but in Tulsa, - Im not big on BBQ but when I get it I'm always pleased when I order it. My favorite are the ribs, brisket and pulled pork. The sauce is also fantastic, comes in Mild n Spicy. Another nice thing is if something doesnt come out to my liking they are very accommodating and pleasant and will fix whatever is wrong and they definitely take care of you.
The decor is very interesting and very fun to look at, many different styles and lots of antiques and stuffed animals etc...It is locally owned by a husband and wife and its nice to go to a quite atmosphere along with supporting small businesses - All of the surrounding hotels recommend it as a great place to eat - plus its in walking distance of the hotels if you want to have a few drinks after a long business trip.

Pros: Lounge, Fillet, Atmoshpere

Cons: Not super cheap, but fair, closes a bit early

.

I can't imagine anywhere else I would rather eat. If BBQ isn't your thing, (even though i've NEVER had BBQ like this anywhere - it's unbelieveable!) they have everything else you could imagine. Best burger in town! Their fish is awesome! Spinach and artichoke dip to die for. Awesome atmosphere and the best staff in town. They treat you like family. Huge menu with something to please everyone and delicious homemade pies!

KC

5
★★★★★

I can't imagine anywhere else I would rather eat. If BBQ isn't your thing, (even though i've NEVER had BBQ like this anywhere - it's unbelieveable!) they have everything else you could imagine. Best burger in town! Their fish is awesome! Spinach and artichoke dip to die for. Awesome atmosphere and the best staff in town. They treat you like family. Huge menu with something to please everyone and delicious homemade pies!

KC

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This is by far the best bbq hands down! You will throw rocks at the RIB CRIB.

I take all my clients to this location and first thing they want is this bbq.

5
★★★★★

This is by far the best bbq hands down! You will throw rocks at the RIB CRIB.

I take all my clients to this location and first thing they want is this bbq.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Stone Mill Bbq, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review