Mario's New York Pizzeria

★★★★☆
36.0897 -95.9389
Map and Directions to Mario's Pizzeria

918-743-7761

3350 E 51st

Tulsa, OK

74135

Get Directions

About Mario's New York Pizzeria

Hours
Sat: 11am-9pm, Sun: 4:30pm-8:30pm, Mon-Fri: 11am-2pm, 4pm-9pm

Food

Food
More choices in Tulsa:
Resultset_next

Hideaway Pizza

1419 E 15th St Tulsa, OK

Resultset_next

Hungry Howie's

6703 E 81st St # B Tulsa, OK

4.111111 9
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Mario's New York Pizzeria was?
Write a Review
Reviews 1 - 9 of 9.
.

Me and my husband just walked in and saw there pizza ordered and it was the best we have ever had. We can never get enough. You can order a Med. and You get a pizza that is bigger than a chain store Large. And everything is fresh. The meatballs and homemade and Beef and they are soooo yummmyy. This is a must have

5
★★★★★

Me and my husband just walked in and saw there pizza ordered and it was the best we have ever had. We can never get enough. You can order a Med. and You get a pizza that is bigger than a chain store Large. And everything is fresh. The meatballs and homemade and Beef and they are soooo yummmyy. This is a must have

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I've been eating at Mario's for about two years and I love it. In fact I just took the family there last night. Some friends turned me on to it a couple of years ago and I just can't eat at any of the big chain pizza parlors anymore. Mario's has a great family atmosphere and the feel of a small town pizza hangout. I can't wait till my next trip.

5
★★★★★

I've been eating at Mario's for about two years and I love it. In fact I just took the family there last night. Some friends turned me on to it a couple of years ago and I just can't eat at any of the big chain pizza parlors anymore. Mario's has a great family atmosphere and the feel of a small town pizza hangout. I can't wait till my next trip.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

Latest reviews from Citysearch.

.

you can't beat mario's when it comes to NY style pizza, try it once and your hooked.

5
★★★★★

you can't beat mario's when it comes to NY style pizza, try it once and your hooked.

.

This place is not known for it's delivery service. If you're in the mood to try NY style pizza, this is one of the best places to go. If you like greasy on the bottom type pizzas, keep ordering from Mazzio's.

5
★★★★★

This place is not known for it's delivery service. If you're in the mood to try NY style pizza, this is one of the best places to go. If you like greasy on the bottom type pizzas, keep ordering from Mazzio's.

Pros: Excellent taste, even better the next day re-heated in the oven.

Cons: Busy on Friday nights - but that's a "pro" for business.

.

They said 20 minutes...1 hour later we called to find out they closed and just didn't even bother to deliver the pizza or call. They were open for another hour after we ordered. The pizza is good but Mazzios is better. And when you're really tired and hungry this is quite aggravating. We will never order from them again. Stomach growling.....grrrrrrrrrrrrrr. We ended up calling Pizza Hut. At least we know they will deliver and are professional. So, if you're not dining in, don't count on a delivery.

1
★☆☆☆☆

They said 20 minutes...1 hour later we called to find out they closed and just didn't even bother to deliver the pizza or call. They were open for another hour after we ordered. The pizza is good but Mazzios is better. And when you're really tired and hungry this is quite aggravating. We will never order from them again. Stomach growling.....grrrrrrrrrrrrrr. We ended up calling Pizza Hut. At least we know they will deliver and are professional. So, if you're not dining in, don't count on a delivery.

Pros: they have artichokes for the vegetarian pizza but you have to ask for them

Cons: they may or may not deliver

.

Read the reviews and thought I would have one delivered. Can't say anything about the pizza because after an hour and a half (after being told it would b 45 minutes) I finally called (for the second time) and said they could "fuggitaboudit". Shame I will never get a chance to try it...I only hope the pizza is better than their delivery.

1
★☆☆☆☆

Read the reviews and thought I would have one delivered. Can't say anything about the pizza because after an hour and a half (after being told it would b 45 minutes) I finally called (for the second time) and said they could "fuggitaboudit". Shame I will never get a chance to try it...I only hope the pizza is better than their delivery.

.

Another of my Tulsa favorites. It compares to pizza on Worcester St. in New Haven, Ct (where pizza was invented). Out of travel to almost 100 countries, my top 3 choices for pizza are: Italy, Worcester St, and Mario's in Tulsa.

If you're a Pizza Hut or Mazzio's pizza person, this is not your pizza. Stick to the fast food joints.

5
★★★★★

Another of my Tulsa favorites. It compares to pizza on Worcester St. in New Haven, Ct (where pizza was invented). Out of travel to almost 100 countries, my top 3 choices for pizza are: Italy, Worcester St, and Mario's in Tulsa.

If you're a Pizza Hut or Mazzio's pizza person, this is not your pizza. Stick to the fast food joints.

.

Having been born and rasied a yankee from New York, I often crave "the real thing". Mario's is th only pizza I have had in Tulsa that I would say is New York Style. The best.

5
★★★★★

Having been born and rasied a yankee from New York, I often crave "the real thing". Mario's is th only pizza I have had in Tulsa that I would say is New York Style. The best.

Pros: New York Style, Good Olive Oil, Great Dough

Cons: It's nit in NY

.

This is the absolute BEST pizza I have eaten since I was in New York City. The owners are from that area so they know EXACTLY how to prepare it, make it and serve it. Nothing fancy about their shop. Small and simple and just enough room to make the pizza and to seat a small number of patrons. I'd stand in line outside to wait for a seat to get another one of their pizzas. If you're wanting great New York style pizza then this is THE place for you!

5
★★★★★

This is the absolute BEST pizza I have eaten since I was in New York City. The owners are from that area so they know EXACTLY how to prepare it, make it and serve it. Nothing fancy about their shop. Small and simple and just enough room to make the pizza and to seat a small number of patrons. I'd stand in line outside to wait for a seat to get another one of their pizzas. If you're wanting great New York style pizza then this is THE place for you!

Similar Nearby

Similar Nearby

  1. 1
    Papa John's Pizza
    No reviews
    0.06 mi
  2. 2
    0.28 mi
  3. 3
    Mary Jane's Pizza
    4% ★★★★☆ 1 review
    0.30 mi
  4. 4
    Nyc Pizza
    No reviews
    0.30 mi