Saylor's Market

★★★☆☆
40.1772 -77.39
Map and Directions to Saylor's Market

717-776-7551

37 Carlisle Rd

Newville, PA

17241

Get Directions

About Saylor's Market

Food

Food
More choices in Newville:
Resultset_next

Giant Food Distribution Ctr

1621 Industrial Dr Carlisle, PA

Resultset_next

Deihl's Mini Market

348 Doubling Gap Rd Newville, PA

3.2143 14
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Saylor's Market was?
Write a Review
Reviews 1 - 14 of 14.
.

Being 3 hours short of a 24 hour notice for a veggie tray, the deli manager turned me away. Actually, she was quite rude.However; the front desk and store manager on duty were quite helpful. They called and asked an employee to come in and make up a tray the next day. The employee came in. It was wonderful not to have to worry about cutting all the veggies up myself as I had other pending responsibilities. Her kindness & dedication to customer service was greatly appreciated!

4
★★★★☆

Being 3 hours short of a 24 hour notice for a veggie tray, the deli manager turned me away. Actually, she was quite rude.However; the front desk and store manager on duty were quite helpful. They called and asked an employee to come in and make up a tray the next day. The employee came in. It was wonderful not to have to worry about cutting all the veggies up myself as I had other pending responsibilities. Her kindness & dedication to customer service was greatly appreciated!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I just want to say that I shop at Saylor's regularly and spend a lot of money there, but, some of the people who work there need to take a niceness pill. They could be an excellent store if the store managers would push them to be courteous and friendly and smile. I avoid cashiers lanes that I know are rude and just there for a "job". Prices are competitive and meats are great. The deli needs a new manager and the bakery. And about half the deli staff needs to be relieved of their positions.

4
★★★★☆

I just want to say that I shop at Saylor's regularly and spend a lot of money there, but, some of the people who work there need to take a niceness pill. They could be an excellent store if the store managers would push them to be courteous and friendly and smile. I avoid cashiers lanes that I know are rude and just there for a "job". Prices are competitive and meats are great. The deli needs a new manager and the bakery. And about half the deli staff needs to be relieved of their positions.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Saylor's is wonderful. I find things that I just cannot find anyplace else - particularly baking supplies. I call it the "Vermont Country Store" of Central PA - For a small grocer, there is a lot there and I find the quality to be great. I highly recommend it. Plus, it is nice to shop and see horses/buggies tied outside. The market also supports the local fund raisers and have been very good neighbors to Newville.

5
★★★★★

Saylor's is wonderful. I find things that I just cannot find anyplace else - particularly baking supplies. I call it the "Vermont Country Store" of Central PA - For a small grocer, there is a lot there and I find the quality to be great. I highly recommend it. Plus, it is nice to shop and see horses/buggies tied outside. The market also supports the local fund raisers and have been very good neighbors to Newville.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Reading some of these reviews I am disgusted! Saylor's Market is a great store to shop at. The prices are mostly good and gas prices have been kind of down lately. I am a proud employee of Saylor's. I make the wonderful subs everyone talks about. and Yes..they are renovating and making great changes and parking does suck now...but it will be great and truly wonderful after everything is complete. :) I AM HOME TOWN PROUD!!!

4
★★★★☆

Reading some of these reviews I am disgusted! Saylor's Market is a great store to shop at. The prices are mostly good and gas prices have been kind of down lately. I am a proud employee of Saylor's. I make the wonderful subs everyone talks about. and Yes..they are renovating and making great changes and parking does suck now...but it will be great and truly wonderful after everything is complete. :) I AM HOME TOWN PROUD!!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I have lived in Newville for four years and have watched Saylor's Market decline in all shopping aspects. Today was the final straw and I will never return to make any purchases. I purchased chicken croquets, Spaghetti and a stromboli. I could not find any Chicken what so ever in the croquets, Spaghetti was bland to the taste and stromboli contained very little meat. No only that the meat looked old. I would not recommend this market to anyone. I further would advised other would be customers to beware of their purchases.

1
★☆☆☆☆

I have lived in Newville for four years and have watched Saylor's Market decline in all shopping aspects. Today was the final straw and I will never return to make any purchases. I purchased chicken croquets, Spaghetti and a stromboli. I could not find any Chicken what so ever in the croquets, Spaghetti was bland to the taste and stromboli contained very little meat. No only that the meat looked old. I would not recommend this market to anyone. I further would advised other would be customers to beware of their purchases.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I love Saylor's Market. I used to live in Newville and did all my shopping there. I go now anytime I am in that area. Their prices are competitive, they always have sales, and their meat prices are hard to beat. Their "made to order" and hot bar is one of the best.
If you are spoiled by the big chains then don't try Saylor's, but if you want a good hometown experience then Saylor's is your place. I would recommend Saylor's.

2
★★☆☆☆

I love Saylor's Market. I used to live in Newville and did all my shopping there. I go now anytime I am in that area. Their prices are competitive, they always have sales, and their meat prices are hard to beat. Their "made to order" and hot bar is one of the best.
If you are spoiled by the big chains then don't try Saylor's, but if you want a good hometown experience then Saylor's is your place. I would recommend Saylor's.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I have never shopped at Saylor's, but a work colleague has brought in sandwiches/hoagies made fresh. I must say they are very tasty and very generous with their meat portions on the sandwich. The sandwiches are fully dressed with fresh lettuce and tomatoes. I have read the reviews and cannot comment on employee service or store specials - I will have to take a trip and see for myself. However, I do know that smaller, hometown stores have a tough time competing with larger chain stores. One thing is for certain - I love their sandwiches!! Good job Saylor's!

4
★★★★☆

I have never shopped at Saylor's, but a work colleague has brought in sandwiches/hoagies made fresh. I must say they are very tasty and very generous with their meat portions on the sandwich. The sandwiches are fully dressed with fresh lettuce and tomatoes. I have read the reviews and cannot comment on employee service or store specials - I will have to take a trip and see for myself. However, I do know that smaller, hometown stores have a tough time competing with larger chain stores. One thing is for certain - I love their sandwiches!! Good job Saylor's!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

For a small town, this store has a great selection and lots of friendly employees. I have never had a price ring up incorrectly, however, once I mis-read a sales ad and they treated me with respect and offered me what was on sale. The recent poor reviews of Saylor's are way off base and probably reflect the views of people with unrealistic expectations. This isn't Carlisle, it's Newville and I love it here!

4
★★★★☆

For a small town, this store has a great selection and lots of friendly employees. I have never had a price ring up incorrectly, however, once I mis-read a sales ad and they treated me with respect and offered me what was on sale. The recent poor reviews of Saylor's are way off base and probably reflect the views of people with unrealistic expectations. This isn't Carlisle, it's Newville and I love it here!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I love Saylor's market! I have lived all over the world and really enjoy the hometown atmosphere that Saylor's provides. They hire many local high school students,who are young, but polite and helpful. They may not be the most experienced workers and may not bag your groceries perfectly, but always are friendly! Occasionally they have to deal with extremely rude customers ( there are alot of rude people lately..), but keep their cool and maintain politeness! Saylors has an old time atmoshere with beats these big chains anytime. Prices are fantastic considering they are not one of those huge, fancy chains and they have excellent sales. I love saylor's and am happy to have a local grocery store which also supports the community and would recommend it to anyone! Best subs around!

4
★★★★☆

I love Saylor's market! I have lived all over the world and really enjoy the hometown atmosphere that Saylor's provides. They hire many local high school students,who are young, but polite and helpful. They may not be the most experienced workers and may not bag your groceries perfectly, but always are friendly! Occasionally they have to deal with extremely rude customers ( there are alot of rude people lately..), but keep their cool and maintain politeness! Saylors has an old time atmoshere with beats these big chains anytime. Prices are fantastic considering they are not one of those huge, fancy chains and they have excellent sales. I love saylor's and am happy to have a local grocery store which also supports the community and would recommend it to anyone! Best subs around!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Every time i go to Saylor's, which i vowed never to go again, the cashiers are rude, and seem to put all of my items in one bag... including 16 cans of formula which always causes the bag to break. I know Newville is small and therefore there are not a lot of people to choose from to employ, but I swear they picked the rudest people they could find.

1
★☆☆☆☆

Every time i go to Saylor's, which i vowed never to go again, the cashiers are rude, and seem to put all of my items in one bag... including 16 cans of formula which always causes the bag to break. I know Newville is small and therefore there are not a lot of people to choose from to employ, but I swear they picked the rudest people they could find.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

It seems that every other time I buy something on sale at Saylors they charge me full price. The cashier has always been very accomodating, but the has happened so often than I now shop elsewhere.

1
★☆☆☆☆

It seems that every other time I buy something on sale at Saylors they charge me full price. The cashier has always been very accomodating, but the has happened so often than I now shop elsewhere.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I shop at Saylor's as much as I can, their prices are just as good as the big chain markets and the employees are friendly and helpful. Their deli items are all fresh and delicious. They have the best store made items on their hot food bar, and have very convienent hours.

5
★★★★★

I shop at Saylor's as much as I can, their prices are just as good as the big chain markets and the employees are friendly and helpful. Their deli items are all fresh and delicious. They have the best store made items on their hot food bar, and have very convienent hours.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Saylors Market is a good place to get a few things, but not to buy a whole order. They are more expensive then the bigger chains, and their selection is not very good. But customer service is great.

3
★★★☆☆

Saylors Market is a good place to get a few things, but not to buy a whole order. They are more expensive then the bigger chains, and their selection is not very good. But customer service is great.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Saylors Market is by no means my favorite grocery store. They are ok for the basic necessities, but fall way behind in selection. They only carry a few brands of each product and most times we cannot find things we use on a regular basis. And when new products come out, 9 times out of 10 they don't have them. Their prices are also not comparable to other grocery stores in the area. Their sales usually aren't that great either. Generally, we only shop there for bread and milk.

PROS: Gas prices lately have been good
CONS: Parking lot is terrible

3
★★★☆☆

Saylors Market is by no means my favorite grocery store. They are ok for the basic necessities, but fall way behind in selection. They only carry a few brands of each product and most times we cannot find things we use on a regular basis. And when new products come out, 9 times out of 10 they don't have them. Their prices are also not comparable to other grocery stores in the area. Their sales usually aren't that great either. Generally, we only shop there for bread and milk.

PROS: Gas prices lately have been good
CONS: Parking lot is terrible

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

Similar Nearby

Similar Nearby

  1. 1
    Deli C
    5% ★★★★★ 1 review
    0.20 mi