Insider Pages Reviews for Gaetano's Pizzeria

4 Stars: Gaetano's Pizzeria is Unique (by Marie R.)

Marie R. — Thu, 13 Aug 2009 02:13:00 GMT

Gaetano's has really good pizza with a unique taste.
The sauce is chunky but filled with tomatoe flavor.
I don't get Gaetano's alot but when I do I trly enjoy it.
Give it a try.

5 Stars: Gaetano's Pizzeria is a treasure found (by J S.)

J S. — Sun, 28 Jun 2009 16:03:00 GMT

I found it by accident not by word of mouth, but it is the best pizza I ever had (and I have discriminating taste buds.) It happens to be on my way to work, needed something to eat and now I order it often. I LOVE THIS PIZZA! It is ALWAYS FRESH and tastes as great as it looks! You won''t be disappointed

5 Stars: Best Pizza in PA (by Jim C.)

Jim C. — Wed, 26 Nov 2008 13:12:00 GMT

I lived in Collingdale when Gaetano's first opened on Springfield Rd in the 80's. Probably bought a pizza once a week. Carol, the owner at that time, knew my voice as soon as she answered the phone. In 1990 I moved to Old Forge,Pa, which is known in northeast Pa as "The Pizza capital of the World". There's pizza places everywhere. NOTHING compares to Gaetano's!! When I come down to visit my family in Drexel Hill I always load up with pies to take home. Sure do miss it.

5 Stars: mare (by martianne c.)

martianne c. — Fri, 03 Oct 2008 13:46:00 GMT

this place is the best,everything is fresh.
I tell people the three cheese is a meal,not just a pizza.
Kinda glad they dont deliver I would be 1000 lbs...

5 Stars: Best Pizza (by Lauren L.)

Lauren L. — Tue, 09 Sep 2008 17:35:00 GMT

Hadn't had a Gaetano's Pizza in so long, so last Friday my husband brought one home for dinner. It was delicious. I love their gravy & their pizza crust is so fresh. Definitely try it & you'll be back!

5 Stars: The Family Favorite (by Jane M.)

Jane M. — Fri, 01 Feb 2008 17:52:00 GMT

We have been ordering from here for over 16 years and have never been disappointed with the food or the service. My oldest son now resides in southwest Philadelphia and drives to Clifton Heights just for their upside down pizza! My personal favorite is the three cheese!

5 Stars: ONE OF A KIND PIZZA! (by DINA S.)

DINA S. — Mon, 07 Nov 2005 09:34:00 GMT

GAETANOS PIZZA IS THE BEST PIZZA IN TOWN. OR ANY OTHER TOWN FOR THAT MATTER. THE TASTES IS LIKE NO OTHER. THEY PUT THEIR CHEESE ON BOTTOM SO SAUCE GOES ON TOP. EVERY BODY I KNOW LOVES THAT PIZZA!

4 Stars: Gaetanos is a bit unique... (by Dana G.)

Dana G. — Sun, 11 Sep 2005 18:09:00 GMT

Originally I didnt like Gaetanos because the sauce is on top of the cheese I like the cheese best, so I didnt like how the sauce taste stands out; however, it was something different, so I guess it grew on me. We still dont order from this place much as they dont take credit cards or deliver.

PROS: Different than regular pizza, but not the best either.
CONS: Bring cash, for Gaetanos doesn't take credit card or deliver.