Castrillo's Pizza

★★★★☆

About Castrillo's Pizza

Categories
  • Pizza Restaurants

Food

Food
More choices in Nashville:
Resultset_next

Pizza Hut

200 Highway 27 S Nashville, AR

Resultset_next

Wing Street

1716 S 4th St # 6 Nashville, AR

4.2857 14
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Castrillo's Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

I called Castrillo's one evening at 4:30 to order; got voicemail stating "we are closed from 2-4 p.m." Called again at 5:00 to get same recording. At 5:30, I ordered elsewhere. Later that evening, I emailed Castrillo's to let their

3
★★★★★

I called Castrillo's one evening at 4:30 to order; got voicemail stating "we are closed from 2-4 p.m." Called again at 5:00 to get same recording. At 5:30, I ordered elsewhere. Later that evening, I emailed Castrillo's to let their

.

We will NEVER use this business again! EXTREMELY BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE! We have had our order messed up the LAST 3 TIMES we have used them. We like to support local companies instead of chains, but their customer service could take a few

3
★★★★★

We will NEVER use this business again! EXTREMELY BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE! We have had our order messed up the LAST 3 TIMES we have used them. We like to support local companies instead of chains, but their customer service could take a few

.

DO NOT ORDER PIZZA FROM THIS UNPROFESSIONAL PIZZA JOINT! Tonight was the last time we will ever EVER order form here. The customer service SUCKS! We support our local businesses but tonight was the last straw. We ALWAYS ask for our

3
★★★★★

DO NOT ORDER PIZZA FROM THIS UNPROFESSIONAL PIZZA JOINT! Tonight was the last time we will ever EVER order form here. The customer service SUCKS! We support our local businesses but tonight was the last straw. We ALWAYS ask for our

.

Got a pizza from Castrillo's and I must admit I was surprised by how good it was. The crust was tasty and held up pretty well with the toppings. We ordered wings too...I had to put them back under the broiler because they werent brown enough for me but they were tasty as well. I wil l def return. My husband and I are on a search for the best pie in nashville.

2
★★★★☆

Got a pizza from Castrillo's and I must admit I was surprised by how good it was. The crust was tasty and held up pretty well with the toppings. We ordered wings too...I had to put them back under the broiler because they werent brown enough for me but they were tasty as well. I wil l def return. My husband and I are on a search for the best pie in nashville.

Pros: Great cust...flavorful toppings...wings rock

Cons: Parking...

.

We went to Castrillos last night for the first time, and were very happy with our pizzas. Their hand tossed crust had a great flavor, and the cheese tasted fresh. (They were a little light on the sauce for my preference, but I will just ask them for extra next time.) We're glad to have another great locally-owned eatery in East Nashville; Castrillos is our new favorite pizza!

2
★★★★★

We went to Castrillos last night for the first time, and were very happy with our pizzas. Their hand tossed crust had a great flavor, and the cheese tasted fresh. (They were a little light on the sauce for my preference, but I will just ask them for extra next time.) We're glad to have another great locally-owned eatery in East Nashville; Castrillos is our new favorite pizza!

Pros: Great food, delivery available, cute patio

Cons: Longer cook-times, be sure to call ahead

.

I went to Castrillo's Pizza tonight and ordered a meat lovers. I was blown away at the quality. I must admit I finished a large by myself! I heard there were new owners and was a bit nervous, but they have proven that Castrillos still has the best pizza in Nashville. That pizza was made just right, I was very pleased.
I was also suprised to see that the lobby was updated to a nice green and black decor. Overall, I was very pleased with this change... Keep it up Castrillos.

2
★★★★★

I went to Castrillo's Pizza tonight and ordered a meat lovers. I was blown away at the quality. I must admit I finished a large by myself! I heard there were new owners and was a bit nervous, but they have proven that Castrillos still has the best pizza in Nashville. That pizza was made just right, I was very pleased.
I was also suprised to see that the lobby was updated to a nice green and black decor. Overall, I was very pleased with this change... Keep it up Castrillos.

Pros: Great pizza for your dinner table.

Cons: Lack of parking

.

I used to be such a fan of Castrillo's. They certainly had the best pizza on this side of town--fresh crust that tasted as if it was made daily, excellent quality cheese and ingredients, and the perfect texture. Now there are new owners and the pizza is just not the same. Tonight my pizza was burned on the bottom, overdone on top, and too salty. I ordered thin crust, but it was much thicker than usual. The crust and the cheese both tasted old. The new owners told me they weren't going to change a thing, but I was very disappointed with my pizza tonight as it seems they've lowered their standards.

1
★★☆☆☆

I used to be such a fan of Castrillo's. They certainly had the best pizza on this side of town--fresh crust that tasted as if it was made daily, excellent quality cheese and ingredients, and the perfect texture. Now there are new owners and the pizza is just not the same. Tonight my pizza was burned on the bottom, overdone on top, and too salty. I ordered thin crust, but it was much thicker than usual. The crust and the cheese both tasted old. The new owners told me they weren't going to change a thing, but I was very disappointed with my pizza tonight as it seems they've lowered their standards.

Pros: Location

Cons: Pizza has lost its quality.

.

New to East End but found this great joint. The food is always fresh and tastes great. The service is prompt and I have never had any problems with take out or delivery.

2
★★★★★

New to East End but found this great joint. The food is always fresh and tastes great. The service is prompt and I have never had any problems with take out or delivery.

.

Bought my E Nash home in 2004 - ordered Castrillo's for delivery in 2005. The owner delivered quickly and graciously. Since then I've met people who have very happily used Castrillo's to provide food for their gatherings. And it's a great place for meetings. I've ordered on the way home and taken the hot food home with me. And I have never had a bad experience. I love their wings, their pizza, stromboli, and sandwiches - yumm all the way!

Just for reference, I also enjoy the Eastland Cafe, Margot's and her new place Marche, and The Red Wagon in E Nash. Outside of E Nash I recommend Mama Mia's and Ichiban (restaurants of the independently owned variety)

2
★★★★★

Bought my E Nash home in 2004 - ordered Castrillo's for delivery in 2005. The owner delivered quickly and graciously. Since then I've met people who have very happily used Castrillo's to provide food for their gatherings. And it's a great place for meetings. I've ordered on the way home and taken the hot food home with me. And I have never had a bad experience. I love their wings, their pizza, stromboli, and sandwiches - yumm all the way!

Just for reference, I also enjoy the Eastland Cafe, Margot's and her new place Marche, and The Red Wagon in E Nash. Outside of E Nash I recommend Mama Mia's and Ichiban (restaurants of the independently owned variety)

Pros: Service, Price

.

Since moving to Inglewood almost 2 years ago, I was delighted to find that the closest pizza delivery place was also the best! Our favorite is the Jordan's with spinach, peppers, olives, garlic and feta. Delivery is always prompt and there's usually a special which includes a 2 liter soda and either wings (also good) or cinnamon breadsticks (with frosting!). Highly recommended!

2
★★★★★

Since moving to Inglewood almost 2 years ago, I was delighted to find that the closest pizza delivery place was also the best! Our favorite is the Jordan's with spinach, peppers, olives, garlic and feta. Delivery is always prompt and there's usually a special which includes a 2 liter soda and either wings (also good) or cinnamon breadsticks (with frosting!). Highly recommended!

.

WOW! That is what I love about the east side -- so many different opinions. We had about 80 people for dinner over two evenings and Castrillos provided the pizza. The pizza was great, everyone loved it, the crew at castrillos did a great job in taking care of the order and they were awesome to work with....we will definetly eat there again. I say give it a try.

2
★★★★☆

WOW! That is what I love about the east side -- so many different opinions. We had about 80 people for dinner over two evenings and Castrillos provided the pizza. The pizza was great, everyone loved it, the crew at castrillos did a great job in taking care of the order and they were awesome to work with....we will definetly eat there again. I say give it a try.

Pros: great flavor, inexpensive, good service

.

Excellent pizza, fast delivery.

I've never had a bad experience with Castillo's!

2
★★★★★

Excellent pizza, fast delivery.

I've never had a bad experience with Castillo's!

.

I have used castrillo's several times in the past for delivery. I will never use them again. I can only say it would be a waist of anyones time to call there for a delivery order. There is a young lady answering the phone who is rude, and down right nasty. I was put on hold and after enduring a long hold I was not helped but only yelled out and ridiculed. I am writing the owner of the compnay.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I have used castrillo's several times in the past for delivery. I will never use them again. I can only say it would be a waist of anyones time to call there for a delivery order. There is a young lady answering the phone who is rude, and down right nasty. I was put on hold and after enduring a long hold I was not helped but only yelled out and ridiculed. I am writing the owner of the compnay.

.

This was (as in used to be) the best pizza not only deliverable in East Nashville but REALLY the best.
But something has changed. Thin and crispy crust is not thick and gooey. Fresh mushrooms are now canned. AND and this is unforgivable for my pizza they sprinkled dried herbs over the whole thing. NASTY is now the word.
I hate this I really do. Used to be the best

0
★☆☆☆☆

This was (as in used to be) the best pizza not only deliverable in East Nashville but REALLY the best.
But something has changed. Thin and crispy crust is not thick and gooey. Fresh mushrooms are now canned. AND and this is unforgivable for my pizza they sprinkled dried herbs over the whole thing. NASTY is now the word.
I hate this I really do. Used to be the best

Pros: Used to be best

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Castrillo's Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review